So, lets talk a little bit about Amazon, book sales in particular. Yall know by now that there's a lot of info publicly available on Kindle regarding books and their authors, and from that publicly available data you can probably further infer that it might be possible to determine how full of shit Fatrick is regarding his sales acumen (or lack thereof).
I figured this was the case, so I consulted with an actual author (as in, he makes actual money from his writing) and got him to help me understand exactly how much Fat is making and how. First, lets see a nice image:
View attachment 2616589
This is a program called KDSpy, if you're at all interested in metrics relating to Kindle ebooks (or physical copies, or audiobooks) this is one of the programs you can use to investigate them, its generally used for keyword tracking and approximate metric information as shown here. What you're looking at is all of his books, organized by title, length in pages (as far as Amazon knows), sale price as of this morning, estimated monthly sales, revenue in whole dollars, number of total reviews and sales ranking (which Amazon freely displays).
So what can we infer from this?
- As the helpful red box down below indicates, he's making a few hundred bucks from his books on average per month from all sources as far as the program can determine. Please note that the software isn't 100% accurate, I consulted with my author friend and a couple other people to verify this info and was told that programs like KDSpy tend to overestimate actual revenue because they do not have internal access to the algorithms which correlate sales ranking and reviews to actual sales, so these are "best guess" measurements which end up being pretty close anyway. After all, if the books were more popular they'd be higher on the sales ranking list (with a lower actual number), which would directly indicate higher sales. There isn't a publicly available direct correlation between sales rank and actual sales, but the data it does have access to from real life, no bullshit authors does substantiate this (or so I am told).
- Additionally, we can infer that the books themselves aren't popular even if we disregard the sales ranking information because of the length of time they've been out versus the number of reviews they've received. Indie authors (and lets be honest, even if he was on an imprint these are indie numbers) are always begging for 5 star reviews because that drives all sorts of Zon metrics and advertising. The more 4 or 5 star reviews a book receives the more likely Amazon is to show it to you, even with recent changes to how it displays books to potential customers. In The Black has been out for a year on Wednesday and has 143 reviews total, 59% of these being 5 stars, so that infers that the sales are very poor for this particular title. You have to figure that out of 100 readers only a small portion will bother to leave a review, let alone a nice one, so this implies that not many people actually read the fucking thing. You can draw your own conclusions for the rest given that information.
This sort of thing isn't really my forte (obvious, I'm sure) but it does help flesh out what other posters earlier have (correctly) stated regarding his advance. Namely, that he would not be receiving royalty checks until his advance is paid back to Tor. I believe one of two things is true here: either he is lying about a "six figure" advance, or he is lying about continuing to receive any money from it at all because these books haven't yet paid the publisher back. I personally believe its the former, but either way he is definitely lying through his teeth about something here. His previous books obviously didn't sell that well either, so I believe his actual advance was much much less than he has publicly admitted to, perhaps in the neighborhood of $10000, which still wouldn't have been paid back yet judging by the metrics available. Either way he really is the equivalent of a shiftless layabout, but more importantly its obvious that he doesn't care about writing, definitely the more serious of his crimes.