Outwith Quiddany
kiwifarms.net
- Joined
- Jul 9, 2021
Looks like she had a Luna-but-worse situation. Good thing it's over for her.
Quoted from the appeal response (attached):
Quoted from the appeal response (attached):
Alta’s parents are Hasidic Jews and Israeli citizens. They moved to the UK in 2014. They have an older child now aged 8. Alta was born on 23 December 2018, eight weeks premature. During her birth, she suffered a severe hypoxic ischaemic brain injury. It is accepted that this will inevitably result in early death. Estimates of her future life expectancy range from six months to two years.
Alta is an inpatient at a hospital run by the Manchester University NHS Foundation Trust. The details of her medical history and treatment are set out in MacDonald J’s judgment. In summary, much of her brain structure has been lost. She has extensive multicystic encephalomalacia, although elements of her cerebral cortex remain, together with a limited amount of her thalami and a small area of her cerebellum. There is also damage to her brain stem. At paragraph 9 of his judgment, the judge summarised her current symptoms as follows:
“i) An inability to maintain an open airway and adequate ventilation to sustain life for any significant period of time without support.
ii) An inability to protect her airway.
iii) An inability to maintain core body temperature.
iv) An inability to blink and protect the corneal surface of the eyes, optic atrophy, an inability to perceive light and darkness and repeated ulceration of the corneas.
v) An inability to perceive sound due to injury to the auditory cortex.
vi) Sustained severe spasticity (stiffness from constant contraction of muscles) of the whole body which will increasingly lead to more permanent joint contractures (joints stuck in same position as they are always stiffly held that way by the damaged brain) and scoliosis (a bent spine).
vii) Spinal clonus (contracting jerks of the body triggered by the spine that is not modulated by a brain).
viii) Severe spasticity (requiring medication, positioning for comfort and prevention of contractures, which have already developed in some of the joints of her hands).
ix) An inability to swallow.
x) Seizures.
xi) Global development delay.”
There is a medical consensus that Alta has no conscious awareness, although her parents contend that she responds to their touch. A central feature of the case before the judge was whether she was able to experience pain.