Lolcow Melinda Leigh Scott & Marshall Castersen - Sue-happy couple. Flat earth conspiracists. Pretending to be Jewish. Believe Kiwi Farms is protected by the Masonic Order. 0-6 on lawsuits. Marshall is dead.

[Illuminati Order Official]

Melinda's dad was a completed suicide according to her. Definitely something personality-wise going on.

I believe BPDs are more about suicide baiting than actual suicide. If he just did it it was more likely depression \ bipolar disorder.

 

[Dizzyuntildeath]

@TamarYaelBatYah When Andrew gave you all that money, did you ask for it? or did you dangle the hope of a friendship in front of him for it?

 

[Fanny Trucker]

I believe BPDs are more about suicide baiting than actual suicide. If he just did it it was more likely depression \ bipolar disorder.

(Successful) suicide rates among BPDs are very high, especially among men with it. The stats give an estimation that around 10% of actual BPD sufferers die by suicide, and that may well be a conservative estimate, as this rate is higher in men, and there's increasing evidence that BPD in men is more common than previously thought, but rarely diagnosed due to a multitude of factors. Baiting suicide is a habit of BPDs, for sure, but so is pulling it off.

 

[RodgerDodger]

@TamarYaelBatYah When Andrew gave you all that money, did you ask for it? or did you dangle the hope of a friendship in front of him for it?

Did any of it go to the stiffed creditors landlords and judgements she had chasing her since her failed bankruptcy?

 

[Dizzyuntildeath]

Did any of it go to the stiffed creditors landlords and judgements she had chasing her since her failed bankruptcy?

Does Mel admit when she's wrong?

@Anaiah Carlson Annnnnnnndrewwwwwww, we talked about your rating people.

 

[AnOminous]

(Successful) suicide rates among BPDs are very high, especially among men with it. The stats give an estimation that around 10% of actual BPD sufferers die by suicide, and that may well be a conservative estimate, as this rate is higher in men, and there's increasing evidence that BPD in men is more common than previously thought, but rarely diagnosed due to a multitude of factors. Baiting suicide is a habit of BPDs, for sure, but so is pulling it off.

BPD = borderline personality disorder not bipolar disorder.

 

[DSP's Tax Lawyer]

Did any of it go to the stiffed creditors landlords and judgements she had chasing her since her failed bankruptcy?

The money is just as likely to have gone to Josh for attorney fees as it was to her creditors

 

[RodgerDodger]

Melinda's dad completed suicide according to her. Definitely something personality-wise going on. It's too bad, because the kids are at huge risk of their own psychiatric issues and one suspects they aren't getting good guidance.

The only evidence we have of her fathers suicide is Mel herself. Haven’t we all learned by now not to trust anything coming out of a Cluster B nutbag that isn’t backed up by actual third parties or physical evidence?

 

[Illuminati Order Official]

Haven’t we all learned by now not to trust anything coming out of a Cluster B nutbag that isn’t backed up by actual third parties or physical evidence?

If she told us her father died while saving a baby from a burning house - sure, this would call for scrutiny. Suicide in the family is generally not something to brag about so I'm inclined to believe this story.

 

[RodgerDodger]

If she told us her father died while saving a baby from a burning house - sure, this would call for scrutiny. Suicide in the family is generally not something to brag about so I'm inclined to believe this story.

She's a long proven unreliable narrator. Question everything and anything not independently confirmed. This is LOLCOW 101.

 

[Dong-Liquor]

What's everyone's favorite essential oil?

I waver between Jeremiah Weed Sarsaparilla and Jaegermeister

 

[Hyacinth Bucket (Bouquet)]

I believe BPDs are more about suicide baiting than actual suicide. If he just did it it was more likely depression \ bipolar disorder.

Yes, just bringing it up as an example of some pretty deep psychiatric issues in the family.

The only evidence we have of her fathers suicide is Mel herself. Haven’t we all learned by now not to trust anything coming out of a Cluster B nutbag that isn’t backed up by actual third parties or physical evidence?

Definitely not presented for the truth of the statement. Just that this is what she said happened. It would be a weird thing to lie about, but so is pretending to know Hebrew, so this is an odd person.

 

[Anonymus Fluhre]

Her court cases against Mr. Josh C. Moon has alerted normies.

Rhetorical Hyperbole Is Not Defamation — The Virginia Defamation Law Blog — January 30, 2019

Under Virginia law, rhetorical hyperbole is not defamatory. Rhetorical hyperbole refers to statements that--while they may seem at first glance to express — January 30, 2019

www.virginiadefamationlawyer.com

Rhetorical Hyperbole Is Not Defamation — The Virginia Defamation Law …

archived 9 Nov 2021 01:41:10 UTC

archive.md

I was reminded of these principles when I read last week’s opinion (from the Western District of Virginia, Big Stone Gap Division) in Melinda Scott v. Joshua Moon. Joshua Moon is the owner of Lolcow, LLC, which operates the Kiwi Farms internet forum. Ms. Scott’s lawsuit alleges that Mr. Moon published on Kiwi Farms an article containing private facts about her upcoming marriage, her spouse’s prior legal problems and incarceration, and a protective order she had obtained against a New York resident. Her complaint alleges that Mr. Moon posted comments on Kiwi Farms stating that Ms. Scott is “the dumbest person, possibly ever,” “really fucking stupid,” a “moron,” a “slut whore,” that she writes like she uses “crayola magic marker,” and she has “ha[d] like a dozen husbands by age 30.”

The court dismissed the case, finding these statements to amount to nothing more than rhetorical hyperbole:

All of these statements are loose, hyperbolic, and based in opinion. Thus, though they may be insulting and offensive, they are not actionable as defamation.
Another way to look at the issue is this: meaningless insults are not defamatory, no matter how cruel. Actionable defamation requires a statement of fact that causes people hearing the statement to believe certain (untrue) facts about the person described in the statement and consequently hold that person in lower regard.

 

[Mr. Faget]

Her court cases against Mr. Josh C. Moon has alerted normies.

Rhetorical Hyperbole Is Not Defamation — The Virginia Defamation Law Blog — January 30, 2019

Under Virginia law, rhetorical hyperbole is not defamatory. Rhetorical hyperbole refers to statements that--while they may seem at first glance to express — January 30, 2019

www.virginiadefamationlawyer.com

Rhetorical Hyperbole Is Not Defamation — The Virginia Defamation Law …

archived 9 Nov 2021 01:41:10 UTC

archive.md

The sad thing is, nothing anyone says can possibly cast Smelly in a lower light than what she says herself.

 

[Anonymus Fluhre]

The sad thing is, nothing anyone says can possibly cast Smelly in a lower light than what she says herself.

That article is two years old, I'd like to know what they think of the new lawsuit.

 

[super thug]

I wonder if she got herself kicked out, I wonder if that's what the silence is about. We know that their relationship is pretty shit. I figured adding even more stress to the equation by turning the screws on marshall could cause a split.

I'm quite certain that marshall made the slo-mo-bitch video in response to one of my posts. The "my hand stinking like ass for a week if I ever slapped one of them in the face" post. The slo-mo video was a nice surprise, I wasn't expecting it lmao. I wish I could say I did that on purpose, but that wouldn't be honest.

If they split up, THAT'S what I did on purpose. It wasn't just me though, really Null with the lawsuit and everyone else adding to the tension helped. Like the USA in WW2, I just came to mop up. I really can't take any credit, if it worked I'm just fucking glad it worked. Truly, no one deserves more credit for Smelly getting kicked out on her ass than she, herself, does.

I figure if she's able to check the thread, she should be along to tell me how dumb I am, because my nefarious plot didn't work. We'll see what happens.

I really hope those kids get to a decent home soon. When CPS finally separates them from her, I'm sure it'll be hard on them at first. Like Mr. Faget says, children are just hardwired to be loyal. Leave the kids in a stable home, with normal, kind, nurturing people and they'll never want to go back to her after only a month, I can almost guarantee it. A month goes by and when they see her again they're going to grab their new guardian around the leg real tight, not wanting to go back to the mean, weird, stinky, old trash lady.

Not that I'd ever admit this in a real-life or professional setting of course, but quite frankly, the best thing that could ever happen to manlet and the childpack is her disappearance in Minecraft. She is likely beyond help, excepting that her NPD might be "manageable" assuming she cared enough to do so, but history clearly shows this isn't a priority for Smelly.

If we assume for a minute that thug gives Marshall a proper beating, there is a chance he might come away from it with a newfound core identity. Losing the fear of pain or failure from experiencing it will change a lot of people, emboldening them to live their lives more fully and directly. In specific, an ass-beating can't really be seen as "traumatic" in the same way one might be traumatized from (as examples) active combat experience, extreme violence, or other similar triggers. It might traumatize him on some level, but with more of a galvanizing effect than a destructive one.

Then again, he might just re-affirm his manlet status. Seeing as he's a child-killer, I'm personally ambivalent at best about his journey of self-improvement, because he's still a sack of shit.

It's sad but yes, she really would be better off dead. Everyone tied to her would be better off if she just went *POOF* and vanished without a trace. No, that's not something that I'll do, as much as thinking about those poor kids with that lunatic bothers the hell out of me, I'm really not some fucking psycho.

I'm glad that there appears to be some validity to my hypothesis that losing a fight is actually generally a positive experience, so long as you aren't disabled or mutilated in some fashion. It does make a lot of sense when you think about it.


It is kinda funny how Andrew neg rates whatever posts poke his widdle fee-fees, huh? So powerless, lol. He just gotta jab any way he can, which is never in meaningful way. Just a guy who's learned his lot in life is to always be a pest, below the level of an actual annoyance he's just an "almost-annoyance", damned to forever watch everyone else live life around him while he stands perfectly still. So petty and small, like a good cult member, lol. I can't believe I wasted my time trying to help that fucking creep.

We all make mistakes.

 

[Illuminati Order Official]

I figured adding even more stress to the equation by turning the screws on marshall could cause a split.

They split up and reconcile from time to time all by themselves. This summer Melinda was posting a whiteboard on which she counted days to leaving Marshall and that's not the first time one of them was leaving the other.
I suspect the silence is caused by Ashley reaching out to her. Now they can talk about us without us seeing or commenting.

It is kinda funny how Andrew neg rates whatever posts poke his widdle fee-fees, huh? So powerless, lol.

I believe he's banned from posting here. But he's active in his own thread if you want to chat with him. He's not that bad - fella knows and kind-of accepts we see him as a lolcow and while he dislikes being made fun of he doesn't get into fights and doesn't rage over his thread. The only people who should be worried about him (more as a nuisance than a threat) are people he believes owe him friendship.

 

[Mr. Faget]

I'm glad that there appears to be some validity to my hypothesis that losing a fight is actually generally a positive experience, so long as you aren't disabled or mutilated in some fashion. It does make a lot of sense when you think about it.

People usually end up frozen or hamstrung by the fear of something, far more often than the thing itself. Once it's known and familiar, they will typically fear it less. Fights are no different in that regard. Once they move past the duality of "THIS FIGHT WILL BE LIKE X MOVIE" and/or "OMG I MIGHT GET HURT", and see how fights actually work (and end), it gets better. They also tend to get less lippy about them.

I know I'm preaching to the choir (you) about that particular topic, but it might be useful for others.

 

[DSP's Tax Lawyer]

Did they finally cut her internet?

 

[RodgerDodger]

Did they finally cut her internet?

She's probably just feverishly typing out her latest lawsuit that will surely win this time.