YouTube Historians/HistoryTube/PopHistory

View attachment 2736076

Apparently the Historytube Slack has also been giving him alot of hate for his Rittenhouse commentary.
I gotta admit he's holding out a lot longer then I expected. Tell us if some of his actual closser left leaning friends like Tigerstar, step back, or the cynical historian gets pissed off with him.
Was wondering what's your guys opinion Drachinifel? He does naval history about certain ships(mostly after ww1 and some age of sail) ,evolution of navies and events around it. I think he does good job around it the only negative thing i can say that his Discord is a janny shithole, i have been warned 5 times for the most mundane shit.
I have not watched much of his content but from what I've seen he seems to be one of the better ones. As for the jannies on his discord, can you talk about what they went after you for?
 
I have not watched much of his content but from what I've seen he seems to be one of the better ones. As for the jannies on his discord, can you talk about what they went after you for?
i got 3 warnings for posting "memes" in a non meme channel environment and 2 "NSFW" these 2 where "damn bitch you live like this" memes where you could see minuscule amount of cleavage on the pics.
 
I gotta admit he's holding out a lot longer then I expected. Tell us if some of his actual closser left leaning friends like Tigerstar, step back, or the cynical historian gets pissed off with him.
1637453373036.png


Comment deleted. No information on why from my sources.
 
View attachment 2736076

Apparently the Historytube Slack has also been giving him alot of hate for his Rittenhouse commentary.
How long until we get a althist vid of a timeline where Floyd didn't OD?
Was wondering what's your guys opinion Drachinifel? He does naval history about certain ships(mostly after ww1 and some age of sail) ,evolution of navies and events around it. I think he does good job around it the only negative thing i can say that his Discord is a janny shithole, i have been warned 5 times for the most mundane shit.
Pretty good and non-partisan. He is what Historytube should strive for, no tismo politics, no forcing modern bullshit into the past, just passionate talk about the subject you love.
 
Ok the farms is shitting up and not letting me quote but what's the context for above? I'm guessing they are doing a shitty series on the cotton gin and how it actually was going to help slavery, not make it untenable.
 
  • Like
Reactions: DeeDee Megadoodoo
Youtube decided to recommend me this pile of shit again


The channel isn't strictly about history, but a lot of the videos are as the maker has taught history in school

Of course as typical of history teachers there's a lot of wild claims being thrown around. For example Jordan Peterson gets accused of nazi dog whistling by using his experience in psychology to infer that Hitler had a obsession with cleanliness, and that it didn't take much to go from wanting to clean the streets to seeking to cleanse society. For some reason Knowing Better thinks this is making excuses for the holocaust and puts it in the same category as holocaust denial. This is what happens when you got ideologues talking about history.

He also makes a lot of wrong statements like claiming that the Auschwitz prisoner orchestra stemmed from the other prisoners at the camp, like the political prisoners, and were not connected to the victims of the jewish extermination. But this is just blatantly false as the orchestra was all jewish, instead the correct statement would be that the orchestra was the result of the early years of the camp before people started dying on mass, but I guess one doesn't want to approach the issue this way as it opens up for discussion of why and how the concentration camps went from having leisure activities and temporary release even for jewish prisoners to mass casualties

The video is from 2018 so you could probably see it as a product of the mass hysteria about nazis around the time because of the events in Charleston Virginia
 
Youtube decided to recommend me this pile of shit again


The channel isn't strictly about history, but a lot of the videos are as the maker has taught history in school

Of course as typical of history teachers there's a lot of wild claims being thrown around. For example Jordan Peterson gets accused of nazi dog whistling by using his experience in psychology to infer that Hitler had a obsession with cleanliness, and that it didn't take much to go from wanting to clean the streets to seeking to cleanse society. For some reason Knowing Better thinks this is making excuses for the holocaust and puts it in the same category as holocaust denial. This is what happens when you got ideologues talking about history.

He also makes a lot of wrong statements like claiming that the Auschwitz prisoner orchestra stemmed from the other prisoners at the camp, like the political prisoners, and were not connected to the victims of the jewish extermination. But this is just blatantly false as the orchestra was all jewish, instead the correct statement would be that the orchestra was the result of the early years of the camp before people started dying on mass, but I guess one doesn't want to approach the issue this way as it opens up for discussion of why and how the concentration camps went from having leisure activities and temporary release even for jewish prisoners to mass casualties

The video is from 2018 so you could probably see it as a product of the mass hysteria about nazis around the time because of the events in Charleston Virginia
That guy is both breadtuber lite and hated by breadtubers for his Colombus video where he basically calls out a lot of the claims of what Colombus did for what they were, English propaganda.
 
That guy is both breadtuber lite and hated by breadtubers for his Colombus video where he basically calls out a lot of the claims of what Colombus did for what they were, English propaganda.
Yeah, I remember seeing the Colombus video, shows he can show some historical nuance, but it's clear that when it comes to modern politics the ideology blinders are worn

Honestly seems more egregious to make Jordan Peterson your poster boy for historical revisionism and holocaust denial than whatever anyone thinks of a long dead Italian explorer
 
That guy is both breadtuber lite and hated by breadtubers for his Colombus video where he basically calls out a lot of the claims of what Colombus did for what they were, English propaganda.
They love that he occasionally cites their favorite breadtubers like contrapoints.

This is from the grapevine, but apparently he's like Beau and CH in that he's trying to use his more respectable historical/objective content to lure people into political content. Kinda going for a "well, this guy is clearly not partisan so I should take his word for it more".
 
Yeah, I remember seeing the Colombus video, shows he can show some historical nuance, but it's clear that when it comes to modern politics the ideology blinders are worn

Honestly seems more egregious to make Jordan Peterson your poster boy for historical revisionism and holocaust denial than whatever anyone thinks of a long dead Italian explorer
You should see his video on Hawaii, it's loaded with white guilt for white elite the Hawaiian monarchy invited overthrowing the government.
 
Anyone's thoughts on History Debunked?
He's more of a British political channel then a history channel.
but you have to feel bad for old british men like him that has live long
to see their country to be turned to what it is today.
British deboonked is an interesting one. He's essentially Sargon of Akaad talking points filtered through a lense of respectability. One of his videos was essentially: "Yes black people are dumber than us, less in control of their emotions than us, less productive than us, more violent than us, and in general worse than us. But, we shouldn't judge." He's the most classical liberal bloke out there.
 
Back