The battle lines of the culture war have shifted so much that the positions of even 15 years ago don’t cleanly map to those of Current Year. The Christian Right is defeated and irrelevant. Censorship is now overwhelmingly the domain of the Left who now controls the media, and the Left of today isn’t the Left of the 1990s and 2000s. The terms of the culture war have changed so fast that it’s created living fossils such as Dawkins. Forget about trying to guess where Carlin would be today, his death year of 2008 is practically an eon ago.
Pretty much. Towards the end of his life, Carlin was drifting away from being a leftist and more into being a bitter edgy nihilist. The "American Dream" bit from 2005 is eerily prescient and would get you in hot water if you did it today.
The same special that had that bit also had a bit where he correctly debunked the fedora atheist talking point of "If we had no religion, there'd be no war", so it's pretty obvious that by the mid-2000's, the guy was becoming a proto-doomer.
Personally, I don't think George Carlin would ever go woke but he'd definitely wind up in the same "living fossil" category that Richard Dawkins and Bill Maher are in.
Howard Stern went full woke partly to stay relevant and also due to his hatred of Joe Rogan, who's pretty much surpassed him in every conceivable way.
Now, Bill Hicks on the other hand would never go full woke at all. If any dead comedian from back in they day would be "based" in this iteration of the culture wars, it'd be him.
While Bill Hicks was an atheist who rightfully hated the fundies and neocons of the Reagan and Bush Sr. regimes, there's a lot of other things that point to him not going woke or becoming a Maher-esque living relic.
For one thing, he despised Bill Clinton with a burning passion and rightfully pointed out how large companies controlled both parties even back then. Hicks also condemned the actions of the ATF at Waco and Ruby Ridge, which got him flak from leftists even back then.
If Bill Hicks were alive today in Current Year, he'd be like Sam Hyde on PCP.