Phalanges Mycologist
kiwifarms.net
- Joined
- Sep 11, 2021
Right on the Subject of Metalworking let's talk about workbenches.
I've been dissatisfied by my small shop bench for a very long time, it was serviceable but got wobbly or was not right in other ways I can't quantify, the main being it was made from Uni Strut and tack welds with Zebidy clips, This morning I tried to do some work on a part and what mattered was breaking a good part of a bad part.
I loaded the only sensible part into a vice with pipe grips took my hands on a a sledge and delivers a good wallop with a hammer covered with leather hide, and I broke the middle leg on my bech under the vice, not just bent it but it broke in half so was unsalvageable.
So today I was in a position to dust off some designs for a 6ft x2.5ft workbench, Now I wanted to build this all from Oak and Beech but that wasn't possible nor was the grade of timber I wanted, I had to settle for Outdoor treated hardwood timber and asked them to cut it to length for me to save time, and I did some assembly work with a loaned nailgun at the timber yard.
1.5 x 3 timber was the order of the day so I had to laminate some parts together I'd rather have solid but thinking about it the lamination may help going forward. (@moop_fogo I did this apart from the initial cuts will all hand tools).
Now it's not finished, I still need to mount a decent vice, and I am going to go a bit modern here and I'm going to bond and screw a 1" bit of marine ply to the top before I do that, I did 3 coats of bitumen paint on the bottoms to the leg to prohibit rot, I've not assembled the center shelf as hard as the others but all joins are secured with Lag Bolts and Glue.
Now I am adding things specifically to this bench for metalwork, the main one is called a Pound through it will look like a dog hole in a woodworkers bench but it will have a metal liner and a steel plate, to allow me to drive bunches or chisels etc through them. But one thing I am going to do is make new Tool box's and a few racks on the wall for my go to tools, Drivers, Pliers hammers, chisels etc.
Now This is where I am a bit stumped, I have a choice in Vices. I have a few available vices I can use and are all really well made and are in great condition.
1) 1880 Forged leg vice, this is a forged Steel leg Vice, 4" jaws and only has one flaw and that's the fact I've had to rebuild the mounting plate, where someone tried driving a few metric bolts into a imperial hole.
2) Record 23A Fitters vice, with jaw options.
It's a lot larger than the picture does it justice, and mine was made in the mid 50's and has been treated very well before I got it, the jaw options I have are Soft, Really Soft, Square and round also in soft or hard jaw options, it has had one repair and that's a replacement handle but it used most of the original handle and a threaded welded end on the handle.
3) A new German made Multi Vice, when I say new this is New Old Stock and it was made in the 80's but it's lived in a box all it's life, it can hold Round stock and flat stock, but the way it works is like a more modern swap head and I don't like them from experiance, but this is more solid than the ones I've used.
Personally I am edging towards the leg vice, but because I have Pinchers which are secondary jaws for the leg vice and made and designed for any stock you can imagine, it's only downside is it's not parralell but the work I do isn't as dependant on it.
I've been dissatisfied by my small shop bench for a very long time, it was serviceable but got wobbly or was not right in other ways I can't quantify, the main being it was made from Uni Strut and tack welds with Zebidy clips, This morning I tried to do some work on a part and what mattered was breaking a good part of a bad part.
I loaded the only sensible part into a vice with pipe grips took my hands on a a sledge and delivers a good wallop with a hammer covered with leather hide, and I broke the middle leg on my bech under the vice, not just bent it but it broke in half so was unsalvageable.
So today I was in a position to dust off some designs for a 6ft x2.5ft workbench, Now I wanted to build this all from Oak and Beech but that wasn't possible nor was the grade of timber I wanted, I had to settle for Outdoor treated hardwood timber and asked them to cut it to length for me to save time, and I did some assembly work with a loaned nailgun at the timber yard.
1.5 x 3 timber was the order of the day so I had to laminate some parts together I'd rather have solid but thinking about it the lamination may help going forward. (@moop_fogo I did this apart from the initial cuts will all hand tools).
Now it's not finished, I still need to mount a decent vice, and I am going to go a bit modern here and I'm going to bond and screw a 1" bit of marine ply to the top before I do that, I did 3 coats of bitumen paint on the bottoms to the leg to prohibit rot, I've not assembled the center shelf as hard as the others but all joins are secured with Lag Bolts and Glue.
Now I am adding things specifically to this bench for metalwork, the main one is called a Pound through it will look like a dog hole in a woodworkers bench but it will have a metal liner and a steel plate, to allow me to drive bunches or chisels etc through them. But one thing I am going to do is make new Tool box's and a few racks on the wall for my go to tools, Drivers, Pliers hammers, chisels etc.
Now This is where I am a bit stumped, I have a choice in Vices. I have a few available vices I can use and are all really well made and are in great condition.
1) 1880 Forged leg vice, this is a forged Steel leg Vice, 4" jaws and only has one flaw and that's the fact I've had to rebuild the mounting plate, where someone tried driving a few metric bolts into a imperial hole.
2) Record 23A Fitters vice, with jaw options.
It's a lot larger than the picture does it justice, and mine was made in the mid 50's and has been treated very well before I got it, the jaw options I have are Soft, Really Soft, Square and round also in soft or hard jaw options, it has had one repair and that's a replacement handle but it used most of the original handle and a threaded welded end on the handle.
3) A new German made Multi Vice, when I say new this is New Old Stock and it was made in the 80's but it's lived in a box all it's life, it can hold Round stock and flat stock, but the way it works is like a more modern swap head and I don't like them from experiance, but this is more solid than the ones I've used.
Personally I am edging towards the leg vice, but because I have Pinchers which are secondary jaws for the leg vice and made and designed for any stock you can imagine, it's only downside is it's not parralell but the work I do isn't as dependant on it.
Last edited: