I think that Jim's near universal appeal in this sector has a lot to do with his ability to not take the internet too seriously, but also because he hasn't been face-doxxed yet. I think that his relative privacy in an increasingly public world gives him this mystique. He's kind of like a character in a novel. It's kind of like the saying "never meet your heroes" in that he will remain cool until a solid video or picture of him is released revealing that he's fat and ugly, in which case it's over for Jim.