The biggest argument against viewbots I would say is his 24-hour sub-only chat restriction. It's not a room just anyone could pop in and talk so it's (at least somewhat) feasible that he'd have a bunch of viewers that aren't chatting, whether they're newcomers, hatewatchers, or what have you.
And the huge membership is mainly indicative of how submissive his whales are.
That would be the biggest argument. Also how his chat is North Korea and almost anything you say can catch you a LIMB or at the very least an OHMAIGAWD STAHP TALKING ABOUT FOOTBALL, WE TALK ABOUT ME, REE, HERE. I don't think this is intentional on his part to mask the 10 chatters - 360 viewers discrepancy, but it sure is convenient. However, I think there are many more arguments for than against.
- Maintaining a sense of relevance.
- Having an argument to be able to go ultra begmode. If he had 30 viewers, 450 memberships and 200 likes would be completely off the table.
- "THE SILENT MAJORITY." "ALOTTA PEEPUL ARE SAYING." Phil probably wants to believe this, he doesn't, but he wants to.
- Justifying his stalling, droning, monotone gameplay. If it still puts asses in seats, it must be good.
- Maintaining a sense of success for the dentheads. They're not misfits, they're part of a khammunity.
- Safeguarding his ego. Why, no, Phil's not getting assraped daily by even DarkDave's viewercount and his chat's activity by now, thank you very much! He's doing just fine! He DESTROYS that viewership, dood! Almost double! DarkDave getting RAHCKED!
- Being able to call his new gimmicks a roaring success when in reality, Fisting with the Fat was a wet fart and DSP watches youtube to pause and talk over the video on his PS5 is pretty fucking boring, by simply upping his viewercount. This way, he gets to push new, even lazier avenues of content creation. What people want to see from the pigroach hasn't ever changed: Games he sucks at, and him sucking at them. By using low audiences and lack of support as an excuse, he can more conveniently keep his narrative coherent while only cherrypicking snoozefest games, usually kid's games, walksims, and so on.
- Provide a convenient smokescreen for the whales. We know he's got twenty simps top, and he knows that, and they know that, but most normies would be confused by
@JimJimJim 's long list of socks. Maybe he can keep it a secret from his girlfriend from Canada who is totally real.
- Appearing on the first page of youtube and having generally better discoverability. Not that he cares much, but he must know by now that if one of his whales gets run over by a truck, a thing that can totally happen, he's in deep shit. While he doesn't want and couldn't handle popularity any more, he definitely wants to be on the lookout for new sugardaddies.
- It's more likely than not that one of his sugardaddies paid for and set up the whole thing. PlanetJeff's an engineer, and while
@JimJimJim may not work in cybersecurity, he seems competent enough for this to be within his scope. Phil would take this offer in a heartbeat.
- A selling point for memberships. It makes you special, it gives you a crown. If you just slap a crown emoji on, he'll ban you. But if out of the ten dents everyone has a crown, then nobody is special. Having 360 viewers, 400 members, and 10 active chatters is a really weird situation to be in, but out of the 10 chatters, only a handful have crowns.
As for the Against arguments:
- Phil doesn't have the technical know how. (A sugardaddy could have done it)
- Chat is and has been North Korea for ages. (Mods haven't given a fuck since the late twitch days)
- 24 hour sub mode. (Ironically detractors are more diligent about bypassing this and unsubbing later than fans are.)
- It would cost pull money, maybe. This one's admittedly weak since Phil does set money aside to buy the horse's affection with takeaway.
That's all I got in the list, but feel free to add more, of course. Honestly I feel it's clear as day, Phil just couldn't afford to become even more irrelevant and this is a nice little band-aid placed squarely in the middle of the gaping hole at the S.S Pigroach's hull.
EDIT: I'm not saying every chat has to be Max Dood/Aris/Gawr Gura levels of so fast it's impossible to keep up with, but slow chats tend to happen for a reason, and more frequently greasy streamers like our very own Darksy have slower moving chats. You could argue that Amouranth's chat, with 10K viewers moves slow because everyone is too busy pounding it, but I doubt anyone beats their meat to Dark. And he sure as fuck doesn't have a pleasant voice to just run in the background.