Supreme Court Watch

Status
Not open for further replies.
Poll after poll has shown that people think Roe v. Wade shouldn't be overturned, but that also abortions should have limits earlier in the pregnancy than Roe allows. Suggesting that most American have no idea what Roe actually said, but thats another issue.

That poll doesn't appear to be very granular, other polls show a clear favor for "legal under certain circumstances" or similar.
This is why you can't argue with shitlibs, they don't understand ANY nuance. All refugees are welcome, all guns should be banned, all abortions are good. There's zero thought to any of shit they spew, it's always going 100% in one direction and everything less than what they demand at the time is fascism.
 
TIL not wanting to kill innocent babies makes you a death cult
Huh? No, the people killing babies, mostly unknowingly for Moloch, are the death cult. Roe V Wade was not the start, it's just one permutation of human sacrifice to obtain earthly desires.
 
no one has provided any evidence of their assertions

i have provided mine. Good luck in fantasy land

only the population of 6 states supports "illegal in most cases", and in those states it's only by a hair (1-5% more)
If what you're saying is true they'll vote to change the law. What the fuck are you whining about?
 
the only way democrats ever win anything federally is by the skin of their teeth
while I've never voted Dem or Repub, Dems have won the popular vote of the last 5/6 presidential elections, with Republicans near threatening to destroy any pretense of democracy or their own sense of sanity to accept being a minority party most of the time
 
Ill just lay it out, are the majority of people here are pro abortion? Anti abortion? I honestly don’t know, If you are anti abortion, is it for religious reasons? Do you have fundamentalist religious reasons for why people shouldn’t abort a life no matter what or is it based on just sheer moral convictions that lives shouldn’t be stopped no matter what? Not trying to judge or be a dick, just wanna know why you think in the way you do since the vast majority of normie women are enraged (rightfully so) right now.
 
>hate on the white males for ages because oppression
>get some black males and females
>they're worse and more oppressive
1656162762486s.jpg
kek i love this shit
 
I don't trust those polls. They no doubt called the most pozzed regions, and asked chalked up retard/rape babies only for "yes in some cases" or such shit.

Why I support this? To hurt liberals, the enemy.

Coloureds with anger management extra classes, strict police, no gibsmuh, can become productive members of society. It takes a shitton of effort but it is doable.

Liberals will never be anything but cancer, and for them it was a choice, not something decided by parents' genes.

A black janitor who doesn't do crimes but works honestly is more valuable then a white liberal who just tries to jew it.
 
Ill just lay it out, are the majority of people here are pro abortion? Anti abortion? I honestly don’t know, If you are anti abortion, is it for religious reasons? Do you have fundamentalist religious reasons for why people shouldn’t abort a life no matter what or is it based on just sheer moral convictions that lives shouldn’t be stopped no matter what? Not trying to judge or be a dick, just wanna know why you think in the way you do since the vast majority of normie women are enraged (rightfully so) right now.
I'm pro-abortion because I know who gets the most abortions. I'm anti-abortion because it makes the most irritating demographic of women extremely upset.
 
Well, the problem is we can't have an honest discussion about it. And if I believe abortion is a women's right to control her body putting that on an open ballot is the equivalent of putting "Should we let slavery be legal or not in our state".

For the pro-lifers the question is literally "Should we let murder of the baby variety be legal in our state"

It would be nice to live in a society where we could have that discussion. An even better one if we could talk openly to agree on what abortion even is. But we don't. Because the people are retarded.
The issue I've seen people discuss the most is "when does life actually begin?". That seems to be what drives either side of the argument, with one side believing it's when the child is actually ready to be born or whether it's directly at conception. Personally, I don't equate a fetus with an actual baby. The two are just too different to be counted as equals.
 
people in here pretending a majority of America supports the Roe decision is *almost* as delusional as when people made a 600 page thread about how Trump was going to win Georgia, Pennsylvania, Arizona etc
Someone would fail high school civics if it were actually taught in any meaningful manner. The role of the judiciary, especially SCOTUS, is not to cater to opinion polls. There are limits to that of course (if popular opinion gets too strong).
As I and others have already written, it is clear much of the other side has not or will not read Dobbs, let alone the cases it rightly overturned. I doubt many are even capable of articulating the tenuous "legal reasoning" of Roe/Casey or engage the lucid arguments set forth by Alito in Dobbs.
In that way Alito and Kavanaugh are right that Roe did real damage to the country in warping how many perceive what SCOTUS is or what it should do.
Right, most Americans support some degree of legality where they live
Insofar as we live in a democratic republic, engage the democratic process to get the abortion laws you want in your jurisdiction. Easy-peasy.

I have noticed some of your other inane postings. Others have ably addressed your ongoing screed. Ich muß auch sagen, Kleine Jen bist du gar nicht so stark, wie Du denkst.
 
I think the SC ruling explicitly says this is a state issue and not federal. Congress can't do anything that would be considered Constitutional by this court so it's up to the state legislatures.
I read the entire decision yesterday and I think this is still unclear. The Federal government has dabbled in healthcare successfully before (cf. California v. Texas, 2021). Since there was never a federal abortion law, neither Roe nor Casey addresses whether the Federal government has the power to impose restrictions on the States in this matter, and therefore, neither does Dobbs.

@AnOminous , thoughts?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back