‘We don’t deserve our dogs.’ - A tribute to the best partner a duck hunter could ask for

She was a chocolate lab born to a backyard breeder in Shasta County. I found her in the classified ads for $500 — the best money I ever spent.

We took her home at six weeks. We named her Gaddy. That’s duck-hunter slang for “gadwall,” a type of duck. But we never called her that. She was always Gadders or Gads.

That first night, she slept on my bare chest as I laid on the floor. She whimpered for her mother and her litter mates — all puppy breath, pokey little claws and velvet-soft wiggles. I told her she had a new family now. And she did. She was a fine friend to our two babies who came the next year and the year after.

When she was about 8 months old, we started working with a trainer named Burke Wardall. He was an incredible trainer — of people. He trained me to train her, and we trained her well.

“You’ve got a real winner there,” Burke told me once after watching her make a beeline 200-yard retrieve on some training bumpers he’d set out across a couple of ponds.

She was a missile, single-minded and focused on whatever it was I sent her out to bring back to my outstretched hand.

Not even a year old, she brought me her first Canada goose in Lassen County. She was so small she practically pushed it to me with her nose across a frozen pond, her paws slipping and sliding across the ice. I laughed. I cried a little, too. I was proud. She wanted nothing more than to make me happy. She was a winner, like Burke said.

Oh, I wish you could have seen her in her prime a few years later. I once watched that dog swim and chop with her front paws through yards of ice to get me a namesake duck that had sailed across a half-frozen pond.


She once towed me and my hunting buddy, all our gear and the ducks she retrieved that morning, in my tippy decoy sled across a canal that was too deep for us to wade. She’d just shivered for most of the morning on a icy muskrat lodge waiting for ducks to fall, but her tail was wagging the whole time as she made the three round trips across the canal with us in tow. We don’t deserve our dogs.

In her older years, too many shotgun blasts took her hearing, and she wasn’t as fast across the marsh as she once was, but, boy, she got smart. A younger dog would have jumped into the patch of tules and plowed through the tangle to find the bird. Not Gadders. She would walk around the clump of reeds and stick her nose in every couple of feet and give a sniff. I knew she was on the scent when her tail would start wagging. She’d gingerly wade into the tules and come out with the bird, more often than not.
I retired her a couple of years ago. She spent her days mostly sleeping on her bed in the air conditioning at our home in Antelope. Her favorite times, though, were at my mom and dad’s up in Mt. Shasta. She loved it there. It’s so lovely and cool in the summers. My mom always gave her too many treats. She took long naps under the big cedar. She went on quiet walks with my dad across our property, the smell of deer and jackrabbits everywhere.

Over the last year, she pretended to be annoyed by the dumb, goofy puppy we brought home to be my new hunting partner. The pup wants nothing more but to play and play. Ol’ Gadders gave it a go once in a while, too, even though it was getting harder for her back legs to hold her up if she tried to run and play tug-of-war.

On Father’s Day, she looked at me when I tried to coax her up to go outside. When she pushed herself up off her bed, her eyes said, “Oh, my friend. This hurts. It hurts. I don’t like this.”

The next morning, she couldn’t get up at all, until I put my arms around her belly. She’d been losing a lot of weight. Her tail barely wagged any more, even at meal time. She was covered in fatty tumors.

It was time.

Thirteen years after she slept on my chest that first night, we went on her last hunt.

The wife and kids cried and said their goodbyes before I loaded her up in the old pickup that’s driven me and her across the country and over miles and miles of dusty, rutted refuge roads.

We drove up to my buddy’s ranch in Mt. Shasta. There’s a little stock pond out there, down below a green meadow where my buddy and I used to haul hay bales when we were kids. She liked to swim and fetch there. There are cow pies to roll in and goose turds to gobble. It is dog heaven.

Four mallards jumped up off the pond when I turned past the stock gate and into the meadow.

I got out a camp chair and her bed. I sat and watched as she waded on sore legs into the cool water. She didn’t stay in the pond long before she pulled herself out. She limped over and laid down on the bed next to me. A true lab, always happiest when wet. She was on my left side — the same side she always sat through all those sunrises over frost-covered marshes.

I sometimes like to imagine what it’s like to perceive the world through your nose the way a dog does. Their sense of smell is 40 times more powerful than ours is. I wonder what smells she smelled in those last moments. I know there were ducks, green grass and cows. What else could she perceive drifting on that cool early summer Siskiyou County breeze?

She was looking up at Mount Shasta when she died.

I buried her a few feet away under some cedars.

One of them has a wood duck nesting box hanging on it. I’d like to think that some day there might be little wood duck hatchlings standing on the cairn I built over her. I know those mallards we chased off will be back to keep her company.

It was a good death for a very good girl.

 
Ok this heavily implies the dude fucking shot his dog Ol Yeller style behind the hunting shack. She just passed away normally right?

To be fair, I imagine a well-aimed bullet to the head is a quick enough death for a dog not to feel much pain. Is it really any less humane then driving them over to the cold sterile room of a vets office (a place they likely hate) and having them die on a cold table?

When my dad's beloved hunting dog got old, sick and blind, my dad went to the store and bought a pound of roast beef lunch meat out of the deli, took her out into the field where she grew up and learned to hunt and play. He put out the roast beef, poured part of a bottle of beer into a little dish, and stood off a few paces. Close enough that she knew he was there. It wasn't the first time he had shared a bottle of beer with her... Every once and a while she got a little sip poured into her water bowl. She was the type of dog who would anything she saw her person eat. But it would be the last time.

When she finished her treat, he shot her in the head, and (much like in story here), buried her under a tree.

I know a lot of rural, country folk who put down their own dogs. As you say... They would rather the dog die happy, comfortable, and in a familiar setting. I would question anyone who would suggest that that's somehow sick or barbaric, compared to taking them to a vet to be killed.
 
I rated it horrifying for a reason.

Its possible but improbable that he went with a chemical euthanasia at some point, maybe? I don't know if non-vets can obtain and administer it.

But he knew what she was looking at when she died, that makes it a very specific moment and unlikely to be natural. If it was natural it's awfully convenient it happened on his planned final trip with her, and it's creepy he had his finger on her pulse the whole time so he could identify the moment.

Depending on if it was instantaneous enough, there's a risk she smelled her death.
Even if she understood the concept of a gun, she might not have been able to hear him pull the trigger.

I think a gun death is better than done at the vet. They can smell death at the vet. I have no question about it. Whatever chemical they put off, they can sense it. Like cows being led to a slaughterhouse don't know exactly what's going on but get spooked. My dogs don't mind strangers or needles but if they have to go to the vet, they don't like the experience. You have to train them to look past whatever it is about the place that they can sense. Chemical euthanasia isn't instant either. I had one dog that wanted to try and stay awake and keep eating treats and it took longer than you'd think for him to pass. I think guns are a lot more humane. Most people just don't have the stomach for it and I don't fault them for not being able to.
 
Why are Kiwis pro shooting your dog? The greatest gift you can give your dog is a peaceful, painless death with barbiturates, not tearing its skull apart with a gunshot you're probably too stupid to aim correctly.

Yes, this was the ideal way 50 - 100 years ago, but if you're doing this today odds are you're some white trash hunter who thinks eating the heart of a deer after shooting it for fun is some sort of "spiritual" event. No, sitting in the woods drinking beer and deafening your dog with gunshots so you can murder birds doesn't make you some sort of enlightened gun-owner or American who is "one with nature".

If you can't afford to go to the vet for euthanasia but can somehow afford bullets, start by shooting yourself.

Fuck sake.
 
Chemical euthanasia isn't instant either.
Depends on how the vet does it. My vet uses anaesthetic first, then injects the euthaniser after the animal is asleep.

I think guns are a lot more humane.
Keep in mind that many people do not have access to firearms.
In fact, I would bet that shooting dogs as a form of euthanasia is illegal in a number of countries.
 
  • Agree
Reactions: Fomo Hoire
Ok this heavily implies the dude fucking shot his dog Ol Yeller style behind the hunting shack. She just passed away normally right?
God I hope so but the implication is clear. The dog was a hunting dog, that makes it worse- a regular pet might not know what a gun is or what happens to animals that get hit by a bullet. This dog knew.
Why are Kiwis pro shooting your dog? The greatest gift you can give your dog is a peaceful, painless death with barbiturates, not tearing its skull apart with a gunshot you're probably too stupid to aim correctly.

Yes, this was the ideal way 50 - 100 years ago, but if you're doing this today odds are you're some white trash hunter who thinks eating the heart of a deer after shooting it for fun is some sort of "spiritual" event. No, sitting in the woods drinking beer and deafening your dog with gunshots so you can murder birds doesn't make you some sort of enlightened gun-owner or American who is "one with nature".

If you can't afford to go to the vet for euthanasia but can somehow afford bullets, start by shooting yourself.

Fuck sake.
My granddad was an old school farmer and while he slaughtered animals for meat, ALL pet animals were put down using veterinary medicine, not brute force. They make house calls, especially in rural areas. The animal can die instantly and painlessly in the comfort of home, rather than in shock. The glorification of Old Yeller-ing is zoomer overcompensation.
 
I would question anyone who would suggest that that's somehow sick or barbaric, compared to taking them to a vet to be killed.
I think a gun death is better than done at the vet.
The horror I feel isn't about it being done by gun shot or by doc shot, but more of the weight of the action. Something on the level of being forced to do the Trolley Problem, but with more serious stakes than letting 1488 hitlers get run over by a train to save one jew.

Regardless of method, euthanasia is in direct contradiction to the desire the owner presumably has to make more happy memories with their pet. The entire time, they want just one more day together, just one more minute, just one more moment, but you don't know how many more peaceful moments you can steal before everything goes really badly downhill and you regret not having done it two moments ago.

I would have trouble making that call even if it was for a human whom I discussed euthanasia with previously and who explicitly told me they didn't want to live as a potato hooked up to a machine. And with dogs you can't even have that conversation or level of certainty.

And again thinking of humans... I know there are quality of life concerns with just waiting for a pet to die on its own, but also I know that body pains are a thing people deal with getting old, and we generally don't just go and commit suicide over it. My remaining grandparents aren't very mobile anymore, can't eat what they want anymore, and can't really do much of anything. They're still trying to live however, they want to see what becomes of their families and they want to impart some last minute nuggets of wisdom, they aren't trying to find a perfect way to die because there are things they still value despite their bodies and their diets.

Its a hard decision to make on behalf of another human who has already stated their wishes so you can be 100% certain you're doing what they would have wanted. It's not any easier for another creature that isn't human but is still just as much a part of your family.

Depends on how the vet does it.
Honestly a lot of the description of vet euthanasia can be described by this quote. Talk of dogs being afraid of the vet or of them being able to smell death there confuses me because there are mobile vets here that will come to your home. They'll even do it on the weekend or on a holiday (with advanced notice and an extra after hours fee) if you know when you'll be done giving your pet their going away party.

I figure it must be like what you said about guns. Mobile vets are probably a region dependent phenomena.
 

Usually it's pretty obvious what needs to be done. Going back to one of my dogs, he had such bad arthritis that he would scream in pain if he had to get out of bed and even if he was laying down and had to move slightly. Pain medicine did nothing and also because he could barely stand he began developing something akin to bed sores. I've never been in a 'what if' situation with euthanasia. It's never easy but it takes love to realize when pain needs to end.
 
Usually it's pretty obvious what needs to be done. Going back to one of my dogs, he had such bad arthritis that he would scream in pain if he had to get out of bed and even if he was laying down and had to move slightly. Pain medicine did nothing and also because he could barely stand he began developing something akin to bed sores. I've never been in a 'what if' situation with euthanasia. It's never easy but it takes love to realize when pain needs to end.
I mean minus the screaming part, I feel like that's about comparable to my grandparents. And they aren't asking anyone to just kill them already, even though they have the facilities to do so. There's more to life than pain (or the lack thereof).

And I assume the reason my grandparents don't scream is a mixture of not wanting to show weakness and of my not monitoring them 24/7 anyways.
 
  • Thunk-Provoking
Reactions: KiwiFuzz
I mean minus the screaming part, I feel like that's about comparable to my grandparents. And they aren't asking anyone to just kill them already, even though they have the facilities to do so. There's more to life than pain (or the lack thereof).

A dog who is bed ridden isn't living a comfortable life. I'm sorry but that's it.
 
And again thinking of humans... I know there are quality of life concerns with just waiting for a pet to die on its own, but also I know that body pains are a thing people deal with getting old, and we generally don't just go and commit suicide over it. My remaining grandparents aren't very mobile anymore, can't eat what they want anymore, and can't really do much of anything. They're still trying to live however, they want to see what becomes of their families and they want to impart some last minute nuggets of wisdom, they aren't trying to find a perfect way to die because there are things they still value despite their bodies and their diets.

I've met many elderly folk who have said, more or less, "I've done everything I need to do, nothing in life interests me anymore, and every day I just hurt worse. I'm ready to go. I want to die. Let me die." Most of them don't kill themselves, for various reasons, usually either religious or to spare their loved ones the heartache, but...

Its a hard decision to make on behalf of another human who has already stated their wishes so you can be 100% certain you're doing what they would have wanted. It's not any easier for another creature that isn't human but is still just as much a part of your family.

It's not easy, no. It's not supposed to be easy. But like the article says... At some point, particularly with dogs, a person who has a strong bond with their animal reaches a point where an animal that trusts them to make everything better in life is suffering, the person can't make it better, and the dog doesn't understand. It just knows that it's in misery.
 
I had to put down a cat recently and people acting like being shot in the head is somehow better are daft. She was awake and purring at being held and petted one minute, and literally two seconds after the injection she was completely limp and her eyes empty and doc confirmed no heartbeat. There was no BANG, no confusion of a hunting dog realizing his hunting buddy is aimed at him and he's about to end up as a Dick Cheney anecdote, no likelihood of lingering shock and terror because the bullet didn't sever the brainstem like a guillotine. Just goodnight and that's all.
 
Maybe, but any vet can get in a car and drive to your house. Most will do this, for an extra fee.
I'm not sure what I think of this. This seems factually correct but I can't help if there's legal red tape that might make them only practice in their office.

I know there's laws on letting dogs into ambulances at least.

I've met many elderly folk who have said, more or less, "I've done everything I need to do, nothing in life interests me anymore, and every day I just hurt worse. I'm ready to go. I want to die. Let me die." Most of them don't kill themselves, for various reasons, usually either religious or to spare their loved ones the heartache, but...
I'd feel less conflicted with euthanizing those ones, but still not entirely ok with it.

And, just because some old people reach that end game, it doesn't mean I'd blanket apply it to all old people and subsequently all old animals. I don't want to slippery slope from case specific consentual euthanasia to PETA to WKUK Forever Puppies.

At some point, particularly with dogs, a person who has a strong bond with their animal reaches a point where an animal that trusts them to make everything better in life is suffering, the person can't make it better, and the dog doesn't understand.
And that's the horrifying. I'm trying to point at that situation, but people here just jump to the conclusion that I'm trying to lecture them on what the best way to kill a dog is.
 
Even if she understood the concept of a gun, she might not have been able to hear him pull the trigger.
You never hear the shot that kills you.

I know the feeling of a dog that can't be a dog anymore, they get up in the morning and it does not feel fine at all, it's suddenly worse than ever. Back is fucked, hind legs can't support them and it's no longer something that passes in 5-10 minutes, suddenly yelping in pain and it won't stop... Pissing themselves indoors without noticing it then feeling ashamed... Dogs have a dignity, they don't want to be a burden.
 
Back