- Joined
- Apr 1, 2019
>You serious? You go down, HARD. Taking a round to the plates is painful.You serious? You go down, HARD. Taking a round to the plates is painful.
Length
Weight
Manual of Arms
Capacity
Modularity
Ease of Use
All favor a rifle. Shotguns are great for hunting rabbits and phesants
No, you don't. It doesn't feel good but probably 90% of the time when someone was hit in the plate during room clearing, they didn't fully realize it until afterward due to adrenaline. I had a team leader that got hit twice in the plate and he didn't even realize it until they were back on the FOB and he started to drop kit.
Also, nice cherry picking, but you know damn good and well a center mass shot even at 10 yards or less with even a full choke is going to have a higher probability of missing the strike plate, which was the entire point I was making. The shot pattern you posted would have produced impacts around the plate if it was off approximately two inches in either direction. One of the impacts was actually off the strike plate for some of the plates I've seen used.
View attachment 3563131
That's the typical spread of some 00 Buckshot at 10 yards which is farther than you'll shoot in most homes, and probably father than the gas station shooting we watched. You still gotta aim with a shotgun.
Like the picture above shows, you're only lighting one guy up. He's eating all that buckshot and it's not likely to pass though as easily as a rifle round. Also, if you're up against some half-way competent dudes that are running a stack, you're probably not gonna make it.
The effectiveness of a shotgun in a trench was due to the rate of fire and it's wieldability. Keep in mind that a trench is just a long and muddy hallway. Compared to a Mauser 98 or some guy with a Luger and no reload on hand, a shotgun is devastating. Even then, the Strumtruppen had many a guy assault a trench with only a sack full of grenades to great effect.
Yes, and you're only chance of defeating body armor is with speed. Rifles provide that. Gambling on a pellet spreading far enough seems like a really bad gamble. At the distances we're talking about, velocity from most rifles will be brutal.
Shotguns are better than nothing, but compared to a modern pistol with 15 rounds or a semi-auto rifle, you're going to be super hard pressed to find somewhere the shotgun excels beyond their capabilities (aside from breaching).
I am not trying to be an asshole when I point out that the people who make a living out of running up in someone's house and killing people do certain things for a reason and those reasons are worthy studying. A DEVGRU team searching a house operates under some basic principles of CQB. Those principles are the same for you as well.
I never once argued it wouldn't stop them, so I don't really know where you coming from with this. But most militaries now use plate carriers, which offer no protection beyond the plate. Meaning if a shot is off the plate, it is going to have an effect.You're just describing mechanics here, good training and mechanics with a shotgun or rifle will yield results.
Onto your body armor argument, the average bullet proof vest can stop bird and maybe buckshot. You need at least level 3+ (plates with steel inserts) or higher to effectively stop 3100fps nato 556. Effectively stop as in the first round isn't a guessing game of angle and range. Same armor for slug shotgun. Regardless it's a complete moot point. If someone is invading your home with expensive plate armor, you are fucking dead, they aren't there for your TV.