Culture You Can Now Compost Dead People in New York - Gov. Kathy Hochul signed a bill that would legalize composting human bodies after death.

There’s a new option for people in New York trying to figure out what to do with their bodies after they die. Over the weekend, Governor Kathy Hochul signed Assembly Bill A382 into law, which legalizes the process of natural organic reduction—more popularly known as human composting—in New York State.

There are several reasons to choose being composted over alternative end-of-life methods. Burial uses a hefty amount of nasty stuff that’s harmful to the environment. One corpse needs about three gallons of chemicals, including formaldehyde, methanol, and ethanol, which can leach into soil and groundwater; around 5.3 million gallons get buried with dead bodies each year. Meanwhile, cremating bodies takes energy and in the U.S. generates about 360,000 metric tons of carbon dioxide each year from the burning process.

Natural organic reduction works by curing a human corpse with wood chips in a special container for several weeks, where it breaks down into mulch. Each body produces a cubic yard of soil—about what can fit in a pickup truck—that the family of the deceased can then use in gardens or scatter outdoors. Industry estimates show that the process could save around one metric ton of CO2 per body.

The movement around human composting in the U.S. has picked up steam in recent years. In 2019, Washington became the first state to legalize the process; it was quickly followed by Colorado and Oregon in 2021. New York is the third state, following California and Vermont, to legalize human composting in 2022; Delaware, Hawaii, and Maine have all proposed similar legislation. Bills in New York to legalize the process were proposed in 2020 and 2021 but never got traction to come to a vote; this past year, however, the bill sailed nearly unanimously through the House and Senate.

Human composting in the U.S. has been almost entirely spearheaded by a Seattle-based organization called Recompose, which was the first organization to license human composting in the U.S. and whose founder, Katrina Spade, patented the natural organic reduction process.

“Cremation uses fossil fuels and burial uses a lot of land and has a carbon footprint,” Spade told the AP. “For a lot of folks being turned into soil that can be turned to grow into a garden or tree is pretty impactful.”

Not everyone is on board with this new method. The New York State Catholic Conference, a group that represents Catholic bishops, urged Catholics in November to contact Hochul to oppose the bill.

“Composting is something we as a society associate with a sustainable method of eliminating organic trash that otherwise ends up in landfills,” Dennis Poust, the group’s executive director, said in a statement on the bill’s passage. “But human bodies are not household waste, and the bishops do not believe that the process meets the standard of reverent treatment of our earthly remains.”

 
Did crematoriums stop working or what?
Why compost potentially toxic bodies?
Is this sign of clown world to come?
Is this just new York?

I don't know about the next guy, cremation is most cost effective and environmentally friendly solution. Corpses release gases as they rot and bones decompose poorly.
Besides human remains aren't nutrient rich to plant life.

Corpses are biohazard waste for a reason, what's wrong with NY law makers?
 
  • Winner
Reactions: Elim Garak
Is this just new York?
No, it's legal in 5 states so far but there is only one facility in the whole country in Washington.
Ah, now the motivation is clear. This was all one big stealth ad for a process this person has patented, and if you want to use it, you have to license it.
This is a great point. Natural burial grounds decompose corpses for free and protect land from development as well. Patenting something inherent to humans like rotting when we die is kind of scammy. There was a mushroom burial suit that went viral from a TED Talk that is also patented even though it's a basic idea that fungus helps stuff break down. Someone even made a mushroom burial suit ASMR:
It is pretty much a publicity stunt bc there is only one company in one state that does it and they basically use it being legalized as free publicity. The owner of Recompose is affiliated with Caitlin Doughty from the Youtube channel Ask a Mortician. @cuddle striker basically called her the joke of the death industry and not taken seriously.
 
Did crematoriums stop working or what?
Why compost potentially toxic bodies?
Is this sign of clown world to come?
Is this just new York?

I don't know about the next guy, cremation is most cost effective and environmentally friendly solution. Corpses release gases as they rot and bones decompose poorly.
Besides human remains aren't nutrient rich to plant life.

Corpses are biohazard waste for a reason, what's wrong with NY law makers?
There's this other method called "liquid cremation", where they submerge the cadaver in a vat of enzymes that, over the course of a few days, breaks down all the soft tissues and organs to a slurry of protein and lipid, which can go down the drain without any other processing. All that's left is the skeleton, which can still be tossed into a tumbler and broken down into powder to put in an urn or scattered.

Apparently this "liquid cremation" is cheaper than conventional cremation and is also pretty low on environmental impact.
 
There's this other method called "liquid cremation", where they submerge the cadaver in a vat of enzymes that, over the course of a few days, breaks down all the soft tissues and organs to a slurry of protein and lipid, which can go down the drain without any other processing. All that's left is the skeleton, which can still be tossed into a tumbler and broken down into powder to put in an urn or scattered.

Apparently this "liquid cremation" is cheaper than conventional cremation and is also pretty low on environmental impact.
Soylent green somehow was first thing that came to mind. I must be getting crazy, urbanites aren't that desperate that they get their protein intake from predigested corpses.

Yet. Lab grown meat is expensive and there are food shortages.
 
  • Thunk-Provoking
Reactions: Elim Garak
There's this other method called "liquid cremation", where they submerge the cadaver in a vat of enzymes that, over the course of a few days, breaks down all the soft tissues and organs to a slurry of protein and lipid, which can go down the drain without any other processing. All that's left is the skeleton, which can still be tossed into a tumbler and broken down into powder to put in an urn or scattered.

Apparently this "liquid cremation" is cheaper than conventional cremation and is also pretty low on environmental impact.
So if I chose this, my family could make a xylophone out of my skeleton after I die? Hell yeah
 
As another kiwi mention this is already happening in Seattle and I watched a documentary about it and honestly it seems way better than rotting away in a box with mold and shit growing on you for years and years and years.

Also, there are places in Japan that are actually cemetery tree nurseries where are you are put in your own chamber and buried beneath a sapling that becomes a tree sort of like your on living tombstone.
 
No, it's legal in 5 states so far but there is only one facility in the whole country in Washington.
This is somewhat misleading. If you need to bury a corpse six feet under and you haven't pumped it full of all kinds of toxic materials these places cannot accept, it's actually legal to do that in more places in the US than it isn't. Unlike many other laws it generally springs from the local jurisdictional level and not from above. The feds/state don't care if Pop Pop gets buried in the back 40. Cities absolutely do care if you're trying to establish a family plot in your suburban yard. Usually in states that allow it, if you own the property and there aren't zoning conflicts, they'd just really appreciate if you gave them notice of where individuals are interred. Not that surprise skellys are illegal, it's just a nightmare when they find them and they would prefer to know that it's not the result of crime (personal opinion, remain ungovernable, even in death. Get buried with a letter in your pocket explaining how you're gonna haint the shit out of whoever disturbs you).
 
Makes me think a bit of Speaker For the Dead by Orison Scott card. The aliens on the planet would plant a tree in their dead people which provided nutrients for the tree. This honestly seems like not a terrible idea. Plant grandma's petunias in grandma lol.
 
There's this other method called "liquid cremation", where they submerge the cadaver in a vat of enzymes that, over the course of a few days, breaks down all the soft tissues and organs to a slurry of protein and lipid, which can go down the drain without any other processing. All that's left is the skeleton, which can still be tossed into a tumbler and broken down into powder to put in an urn or scattered.

Apparently this "liquid cremation" is cheaper than conventional cremation and is also pretty low on environmental impact.
I think that's the approved way to dispose of lab animal carcasses like rats since it doesn't leave behind edible remains that might get eaten and passed around the environmental food chain, with the added step of being done inside a centrifuge to quickly separate out the bones.
 
There is a bright future ahead.
tumblr_ps87i0FsFD1t67zi3_1280.jpg
 
No, it's legal in 5 states so far but there is only one facility in the whole country in Washington.

This is a great point. Natural burial grounds decompose corpses for free and protect land from development as well. Patenting something inherent to humans like rotting when we die is kind of scammy. There was a mushroom burial suit that went viral from a TED Talk that is also patented even though it's a basic idea that fungus helps stuff break down. Someone even made a mushroom burial suit ASMR:
It is pretty much a publicity stunt bc there is only one company in one state that does it and they basically use it being legalized as free publicity. The owner of Recompose is affiliated with Caitlin Doughty from the Youtube channel Ask a Mortician. @cuddle striker basically called her the joke of the death industry and not taken seriously.
Somehow that doesn't surprise me. Case in point: she wrote a book for kids called will my cat eat my eyeballs


Everything about her screams shes a headcase
 
  • Like
Reactions: Sparkling Yuzu
Back