Paramedics in Illinois charged with murder after patient dies


Two paramedics in Illinois are facing murder charges after a patient died of positional asphyxiation shortly after he was taken to a hospital in December, court documents say.

Peggy Finley, 44, and Peter Cadigan, 50, responded to a home in Springfield on December 18 after police requested medical assistance for a 911 caller who “was suffering hallucinations due to alcohol withdrawal,” according to a news release from the Springfield Police Department.

Body camera footage released by police shows Finley entering the home’s rear bedroom as one of the officers briefs her on the patient, Earl L. Moore, Jr.

Finley is heard yelling at Moore to get up and walk out to the ambulance. “You’re gonna have to walk ‘cause we ain’t carrying you!” she says. “I am seriously not in the mood for this dumb sh*t.”

Two of the officers can be seen helping Moore outside and onto the gurney. Cadigan helps position Moore and both paramedics strap him onto the stretcher in a prone position.

“The Springfield Police Department was later notified the patient had passed after arriving at the hospital,” the police department news release says.

According to the coroner’s autopsy report, Moore died of “compressional and positional asphyxia due to prone facedown restraint on a paramedic transportation cot/stretcher by tightened straps across back and lower body in the setting of lethargy and underlying chronic alcoholism.”

Finley and Cadigan were arrested on January 9 and charged with first-degree murder, court documents show.

They’re being held at the Sangamon County Detention Facility on $1 million bond each.

Both are scheduled to be back in court on January 19.

CNN has reached out to the attorney for Finley and Cadigan for comment and has not yet received a reply.

Alcohol withdrawal is a medical issue that occurs when a person accustomed to regular alcohol consumption either decreases their intake or cuts it off entirely, according to information from the National Institutes of Health.

Symptoms of alcohol withdrawal vary widely among people experiencing it, and can include anything from insomnia, anxiety, or agitation in mild cases, to delirium tremens, seizures, or hallucinations in severe cases, the agency says.

Lifestar Ambulance Service, which employed the paramedics, declined to comment on the case, citing the ongoing investigation.

CNN has also reached out to the county’s executive chairperson for the Office of Emergency Management regarding its ambulance service contracts and has not yet received a response.

Link Archive
 

Attachments

  • 230113133027-il-paramedics-charged-finley-cadigan-split.jpg
    230113133027-il-paramedics-charged-finley-cadigan-split.jpg
    56.4 KB · Views: 8
Hrm. Couldn't get the Archive link to work, damn it. Sorry. Also it seems I fucked up the image. My bad.

The Bodycam Footage:

The number of ways that Finley managed to fuck up is pretty shocking. She didn't bother to assess the PT, and with his inability to speak, he could have been having a stroke or be a diabetic with dangerously low ( below 40) levels of blood sugar. She didn't put on gloves, she dragged him, and then tried to make him walk when the guy was clearly incapable - The worst part is that she HAD the tools to do her job properly. A stair chair or a backboard stretcher are what you need to use on PTs when you can't get a Cot (The fucking things weigh 200 lbs) inside,

What killed him though was being strapped prone (face down) into the stretcher instead of supine (face up, how every EMS personnel is taught, by the way) and the man suffocated.

Anyhow, I ended up seeing the bodycam footage, and I have to say that it was pretty shocking to see how badly they treated the PT. I get that the guy is obviously a frequent flyer but as an EMS worker you have a duty to provide care, one that they didn't.

I do find it strange that they're being charged with 1st Degree Murder, since I doubt what happened was pre-meditated - I have a suspicion that they're charging them with first degree murder since the PT was black and they don't want to deal with BLM goons showing up and burning the city to the ground.

Anyhow, as an EMT - Yeah, I know, Powerlevel - It was horrifying to watch the bodycam footage and the abuse they put on the guy when he clearly was sick and most likely also mentally ill.
 
I do find it strange that they're being charged with 1st Degree Murder, since I doubt what happened was pre-meditated - I have a suspicion that they're charging them with first degree murder since the PT was black and they don't want to deal with BLM goons showing up and burning the city to the ground.
They're charging them with that because they know it won't stick.
 
I do find it strange that they're being charged with 1st Degree Murder, since I doubt what happened was pre-meditated - I have a suspicion that they're charging them with first degree murder since the PT was black and they don't want to deal with BLM goons showing up and burning the city to the ground.
The strategy is probably to get them to plea for a less severe murder charge. Which is retarded because they will almost certainly never be able to prove pre-meditated murder and all the defense has to do is go forward with that charge to get the murder charges out of the way. The DA can't just move the murder charge down to 2nd, they have to go with whatever murder charge they originally went with and stick with it until the accused plea or the jury gives their verdict.

Maybe they are hoping the fear of the social backlash of walking from a first degree murder charge on a nigger will get them to plea or the Judge is a lefty social justice nutjob, but that is a pretty shaky gambit from the DA.
 
They're charging them with that because they know it won't stick.
Do you think they're either trying to force a plea deal, or they're trying to get them off? I doubt the last option, honestly, since EMS don't have the level of institutional protection that the pigs have in general. I.E. no "An internal investigation said they dindu nuffin" that you see from PD departments when they execute some dude
The strategy is probably to get them to plea for a less severe murder charge. Which is retarded because they will almost certainly never be able to prove pre-meditated murder and all the defense has to do is go forward with that charge to get the murder charges out of the way. The DA can't just move the murder charge down to 2nd, they have to go with whatever murder charge they originally went with and stick with it until the accused plea or the jury gives their verdict.

Maybe they are hoping the fear of the social backlash of walking from a first degree murder charge on a nigger will get them to plea or the Judge is a nigger lover, but that is a pretty shaky gambit from the DA.
Yeah I figured something like that. But honestly all they have to do is put a reasonable doubt they didn't intend to kill him and BOOM, not guilty of 1st degree murder.
Holy shit that's a rough 44 and 50, do they inject liquid depression into their face every day?
I have met a bunch of old timers who have been on the job since the '90s and I've never seen anyone look that bad, so I wouldn't doubt it.
IANAL, but that sounds like manslaughter at worst. Alas, what else do you expect from the dominion of Jabba the Pritzker?
Neither am I but IIRC 3rd Degree Murder is "Unintentional killing through acts of malice" and the way they treated him was pretty malicious, IMHO.
 
The question becomes, when does professional negligence cross the boundary into depraved indifference? I would say this case meets that very high burden. This was professional negligence, but they have the training to know that the unsafe position they left him in could be deadly, and they didn't care. That is depraved indifference. They could claim incompetence, which would mitigate depraved indifference, but that would be a hard one to sell unless they have a shitty record of making mistakes.
 
I do find it strange that they're being charged with 1st Degree Murder, since I doubt what happened was pre-meditated - I have a suspicion that they're charging them with first degree murder since the PT was black and they don't want to deal with BLM goons showing up and burning the city to the ground.
I'm not a lawyer but any stretch of the imagination but if the PT was, as you said, a "frequent flyer" there could be an element of premeditation there.

As an EMT with training you could easily think "I'm so sick of going this guys house I wish he would die / I'm going to let him die next time" and actually enact it. If these EMTs wrote anything like this in previous reports (which given their level of professionalism..), mentioned it to any friends, or indicated as much on social media there's going to be a case there.

Some of the actions (I'm not a medic either but...) are also baffling and are pretty unexplainable outside of malice and contempt. They're going to have a hell of a time explaining why he was loaded and strapped in face down for one on top of every other "we probably don't do this on other cases" decisions they made.

Murder 1 is probably the only way you could possibly explain it. Manslaughter usually has an element of something outside of your control (industrial accidents, car accidents, etc). There was no real "you didn't know what you were doing" with most of the actions they took.
 
If you lay a patient face down on your stretcher for transport, there had damn well better be 2' of steel rebar sticking out of his back. Or something similar

I don't know that this rises to murder, certainly not first degree murder? It fails several tests regarding was death the clearly expected outcome? I would have fired them on the spot. And this is certainly criminal negligence leading to or contributing to a death.
 
I came in here expecting to side with the EMS, but they were inappropriate and failed to meet the standard of care in just about every way.

Frequently fliers are a pain in the ass but even the most heinous individuals should be treated according to the guidelines. You have to care for pedophiles, prisoners, wife beaters, all kinds of trash when you choose a career in healthcare. It’s part of the job. We’re not Cloudflare, we can’t leave people to die because they’re annoying or we don’t like them.

First degree murder charges seem extreme though. While they need to be held accountable, the possibility of prison time for things like this may discourage people from entering healthcare. It could worsen existing healthcare personnel shortages.
 
yah...

As a former Para I can say these two dun fucked up big time. Pretty much ignored every policy in the book and just tossed this dude onto the stretcher and strapped him down so he wouldn't be an issue while they transported him to the local hospital.

Like Mango said, they 100% neglected their patient and maybe even deliberately fucked with him for reasons we'll never know. Yes, some patients can be a royal pain in the ass, some can be rude, aggressive and even dangerous but your duty is still the same no matter what. I've have patients I would have love to strangle right there in the back of the rig but you don't take your frustration out on your patients ever.

However;

1st degree seems a bit steep as I highly doubt these two set out to murder this man but manslaughter for sure. And of course having their licenses and certs revoked. These two should never work with patients ever again.

Holy shit that's a rough 44 and 50, do they inject liquid depression into their face every day?

The EMS life can be pretty rough on you. Long 12/24 hour shifts. Stress like you would not believe unless you've been there. Horrible diet and if your assigned to a shitty district you can quickly burn out and start to hate the very people your there to save. All of this ages you like crazy and turns you into a misanthropic mess.

When I came back to Canada from working in Japan I needed to log some hours in as a trainee (despite being a fucking CAF SARtech for 8 years and 4 more in the JSDF, (yah 40+ years later and I'm still pissy about it)) so they sent me to work in a Native Reservation because, well no one else but raw scrubs would ever voluntarily go and over the year I spent working there I grew to hate the native population so much, so very much, due to what I saw every single fucking shift.

Now I've lost a lot of my venom towards natives as I aged and grew more mellow but at the time all that was keeping me from "accidentally overlooking" a serious issue or two with some of the dirt bags I was treating on an almost nightly basis was my sense of duty and the adherence to the oath I took.

It's easy to lose your ability to empathize when your dealing with shitty people day in and day out. It's why so many LEOs and EMT's turn into massive assholes as that's all the humanity they see. If you deal solely with junkies, bums and criminals time after time after time you too would grow to see humanity as scum and lose your ability to give a fuck.

Now I'm not offering this as an excuse for what these two did. It was clearly malicious intent to neglect a patient in their charge and they should be punished for it. Buuuut I can understand what they were feeling at the time.




If your interested in what life as a big city EMT is like check out the movie "Bring Out your Dead" with good ole Nick Cage. It's still very Hollywoody but it does actually show how overworked, under geared and stressfull life for these EMT's can be. Plus it's a really decent movie overall. Go watch. I give it 4 Rich Evans out of 5.
 
Watched the footage, and comments here cover charges, etc., but look at homegirls booking photo...hands crossed against chest, defiant.

She needs some prison time. Man outside does too with going along and just dumping him face first on the stretcher.

That vid was painful too watch, aside from her absolute shit attitude.
 
I know first degree is going to be nearly impossible to prove unless there's secret cam footage showing them saying "hope he dies" or whatever, but strapping someone face-down when they should have some basic medical knowledge doesn't help their case.
This is kinda scary, tbh. EMTs like this and nurses as careless as this are what I fear when worrying about an emergency situation.
 
To make murder stick, you'd have to prove she intended to kill the patient instead of just being so fed up with him (apparently) that she just didn't care.

Not caring someone to death is manslaughter, easy, but, not murder.
 
First degree murder charges seem extreme though. While they need to be held accountable, the possibility of prison time for things like this may discourage people from entering healthcare. It could worsen existing healthcare personnel shortages.
To be honest the type of people who would be concerned about murder charges aren't the kind of people I'd want in health care to begin with. These two probably never should have been allowed to become EMTs.
 
The question becomes, when does professional negligence cross the boundary into depraved indifference? I would say this case meets that very high burden. This was professional negligence, but they have the training to know that the unsafe position they left him in could be deadly, and they didn't care. That is depraved indifference. They could claim incompetence, which would mitigate depraved indifference, but that would be a hard one to sell unless they have a shitty record of making mistakes.
Yeah, I have to agree with you here, so I guess 2nd Degree Murder would be the best charge to hit them with.
I'm not a lawyer but any stretch of the imagination but if the PT was, as you said, a "frequent flyer" there could be an element of premeditation there.

As an EMT with training you could easily think "I'm so sick of going this guys house I wish he would die / I'm going to let him die next time" and actually enact it. If these EMTs wrote anything like this in previous reports (which given their level of professionalism..), mentioned it to any friends, or indicated as much on social media there's going to be a case there.

Some of the actions (I'm not a medic either but...) are also baffling and are pretty unexplainable outside of malice and contempt. They're going to have a hell of a time explaining why he was loaded and strapped in face down for one on top of every other "we probably don't do this on other cases" decisions they made.

Murder 1 is probably the only way you could possibly explain it. Manslaughter usually has an element of something outside of your control (industrial accidents, car accidents, etc). There was no real "you didn't know what you were doing" with most of the actions they took.
Yeah that's a good point, and I couldn't hear what she said to the police officer, so she very well could have said something similar to "I hate him I hope he dies" - With her horrific attitude I can see her saying that.
Both of you guys 100% nailed what I was trying to say. I'm pretty new to the field, and I'm glad that my take wasn't pants-on-head retarded.

This is kinda scary, tbh. EMTs like this and nurses as careless as this are what I fear when worrying about an emergency situation.
That's another massive problem, tbh. It's already bad enought that we wear uniforms - More than one EMT / AEMT / Para has been shot at by some section 12 nutjob because they saw flashing lights and uniforms and thought they were cops - But there should NEVER be fear of EMS workers, we're literally just here to save you.

That's why the majority of EMS workers vehemently oppose any suggestions that we should carry firearms for self defense, because the moment we stop being seen as "People here to save your sorry ass" its game-fucking-over for EMS,
 
Back