Post Ratings Discussion

Should we have a fish hook rating?

  • Yea

    Votes: 1,032 85.5%
  • Nay

    Votes: 175 14.5%

  • Total voters
    1,207
Would there be a thread, guide, or any indication as to which "ratings" give positive, neutral, and negative score?

I thought Islamic Content was neutral, but just found out it's not. It's one of my favorite buttons, and I always thought its use was facetious in nature. But I guess I will refrain pressing it, lest I want to anger rating whores.

It's also strange that Disagree contributed to the neutral rating score instead of negative.

There's not an official guide, but:

Positive: Like, Agree, Winner, Informative, Feels, DRINK, Semper Fidelis, Press 1, NICE MEME, Achievement
Neutral: Dislike, Disagree, Autistic, Optimistic, Press 2, Horrifying, Powerlevel
Negative: Islamic Content, Off Topic, Late, Dumb, A-Log, Deviant
 
Last edited:
I thought Islamic Content was neutral, but just found out it's not. It's one of my favorite buttons, and I always thought its use was facetious in nature. But I guess I will refrain pressing it, lest I want to anger rating whores.

As-salāmu ʿalaykum my brother, the Islamic Content rating should strictly be used for messages that are used to spread peace as prescribed by the Prophet (PBUH) and not for any other reason, insha'Allah
 
As-salāmu ʿalaykum my brother, the Islamic Content rating should strictly be used for messages that are used to spread peace as prescribed by the Prophet (PBUH) and not for any other reason, insha'Allah

The Islamic Content rating should be automatically applied to every post.
 
We really need a negative "salty" rating. This could be the icon:
1ov1Mri.png
 
My friend, I'm trying to work this with MS Paint. I have no idea what the hell that is :o

Ah. I don't think Paint can actually do transparancy. Get yourself something like GIMP. It's free and it can do more. You go into your channels panel once you've got something like that and you add another one. THEN you save it as a png. Alpha channels are our fancy little friends that let us have transparent images.
 
  • Agree
Reactions: APerson
Now that I am a supporter and have all the ratings I think that it was a terrible idea to implement ratings but they are so essential to the culture of our site that getting rid of them would cause too much damage (I think that just informative, autistic, and dumb would have been sufficient with maybe also drink for shitposts)
 
I obviously know they're both positive ratings, but what's the difference between the Semper Fidelis and Winner ratings in terms of when to use them? Sorry if this has been asked before.
 
I obviously know they're both positive ratings, but what's the difference between the Semper Fidelis and Winner ratings in terms of when to use them? Sorry if this has been asked before.

It's just fluff, really. Semper Fidelis was originally part of the Wounded Marine Charity Drive before all donators got access to it. I guess you could consider it a more "valuable" Winner when receiving it since fewer people have access to it.
 
Back