Ukrainian Defensive War against the Russian Invasion - Mark IV: The Partitioning of Discussion

That's one thing I don't get about these western or western-situated pro-Russian commentators (The Duran, Lira, Big Serge, MacGregor, etc.). They think Russia can do no wrong and everything is going according to plan. Ukraine is being destroyed and suffering massive casualties while Russia can't stop winning. The supposed Russian fuck-ups and Ukrainian gains are mere western propaganda (or part of a greater Russian strategy), and Russia has barely suffered any losses and is conducting every operation perfectly.

Yet if you listen to Russian ultranationalists such as Igor Girkin or Russian milbloggers or sometimes even Prigozhin, they'll consistently admit that the entire invasion has been a clusterfuck from the start, that the MoD has made a mess out of every other operation, and that there's pervasive command incompetence with thousands of troops lost in senseless and miscarried attacks. They're under no illusions that it's all going smooth as silk.

In short, these western Putin-loving Russiaboos are even more delusional than the zigger vatniks.
One group creates propaganda intended for Western audience (like pol and 'anti-war socialists' or w/e), and another is simply prodding their regime to do more to actually win the war, instead of playing it safe so you don't get an uprising.
As always, I am very suspicious of who funds these Westerners. It's rather insane that we don't have something a year into the war. No FBI report, no nothing. All we see is some diplomats expelled and the sort, yet these propagandists are just churning out idiocy without anyone going "hmmmmmm".
 
Funnily enough the whole Jews Arabs thing only really kicked off after the British mandate in Palestine, when foreign Jews moved in and started agitating for their own state. Most of the native Jewish population had no issues with the Palestinians as ethnically they were identical and didn’t really get on one another’s nerves. Hindus/Pakis is also pretty much a British thing, funnily enough, it’s almost like the British two state solution plans were terribly thought out and executed concepts.
I'm going to tl;dr on the Jews/Arabs which is the Jews were treated very much like the Jews treat Arabs now. Remember the Ottomans were in charge until about 25 years before and the Ottomans were adamant about two things: Firstly that the state must follow the instructions of Mohammed and protect the capital-J Jews and secondly that capital-J Jews (like any other ethnic minority) have no real power - jewish individuals were sometimes elevated to lofty positions but none of that was allowed to manifest as additional self-determination for Jews as a whole.
Even if you forget the influx of Jews from Europe, the Jews were going to be subject to some pogroms once a leader realized he could pull a Hitler and blame the minority for everything, he just needed a way to get around the prohibition on Jewish persecution by framing them as being in revolt against their rightful Muslim rulers.

Hindus & Pakis are very much not a British thing, that was existing long before. Where Britain did meddle there was by dividing the country during independence.
Muslims and Hindus still routinely beat up and/or kill each other in the places where one or the other is a minority.
The only real bit of skullduggery the British got up to was on the subject of Kashmir.

tl;dr previously All the area that is India, Pakistan, and Bangladesh was part of the "British Raj" - all the local leaders reported to British colonial authority. When giving independence - and one of the issues that had been dragging out the process/an excuse for dragging out the process - was there was a lot of muslims who had no interest in being dominated by Hindus. There was already a lot of ethnic violence that the British would brutally put down and punish both sides. So there was the idea of a "Muslim" and "Hindu" partition, and the British allowed all the local domains to choose which they wanted. They also left the mechanism for decision to the people - lots of people viewed the local royals as divinely granted the right to rule them and democracy was an anathema, so if the people didn't want to vote the Royals were allowed to make the choice. But there was a very heavy slant to democracy when possible.

Kashmir was a Hindu royalty governing a Muslim minority, but it was allowed to go to "Royal Choice" under dubious circumstances. The Brits allowed this to happen because Kashmir is the headwaters of the Indus river, and who ever controls that has the option of damming the river and starving India. If it hadn't gone over to India, within two decades India was going to have to go to war over it.

south asian muslims (in and around the area of what we now call pakistan) had been waging large scale wars of conquest and subjugation against the hindu states of india for centuries before the britbongs even set foot in the region
arabs were 'fine' with jews when those jews (like other non muslim minorities) lived as subjugated second class citizens under the boot of islamic domination, which again was going on for a very long time (like over a thousand years) before the anglos started taking over
Pretty much this.
The reason for all this "ethnic strife" is that these populations are being oppressed and ground underheel anymore. Or in the case of India, ethnic flare ups aren't getting a response from a 3rd party who views both as subhuman and doesn't care who started it.
 

Russian mil bloggers certain the Ukrainian offensive is imminent. Basically an overview of the current battle lines and apart from the strange thumbnails, Paul's coverage is a good quality video.

One group creates propaganda intended for Western audience (like pol and 'anti-war socialists' or w/e), and another is simply prodding their regime to do more to actually win the war, instead of playing it safe so you don't get an uprising.
As always, I am very suspicious of who funds these Westerners. It's rather insane that we don't have something a year into the war. No FBI report, no nothing. All we see is some diplomats expelled and the sort, yet these propagandists are just churning out idiocy without anyone going "hmmmmmm".
A portion of these are tankies who are perceptive enough to see that the Russian Federation is a reflagged (with aircraft and tanks wearing red stars or even flying the Soviet flag) successor state of the Soviet Union following a sort of latter day NEP with characteristics of crony monopoly capitalism. Scott Ritter (still putting out propaganda) Gonzalo Lira and others are morally compromised characters who ofttimes live far beyond their means (I think too of Taylor Marshall, a trad Cath blogger who switched with a month of Feb '22 to putting out regular Russian propaganda and lives a lavish lifestyle his blogging and books are unlikely to support). I imagine the files on these compromised, crooked characters are being held in reserve, because for now anyone shilling for Putin condemns himself out of his own mouth. Kompromat on, say, convicted pedophile Scott Ritter is a few taps on the keyboard away. Anyone inviting Scott Ritter's views discredits himself automatically. Countering his stuff isn't even needed.
 
Another Ka-52 shot down:


Related: another "trophy" for sale. Ron Cole is an aviation artist who includes pieces alleged to be part of the featured airframes; the first was an Su-25, this is his latest.

Kamov-ka-52-1-virtual.jpg
This sort of trophy is probably far more palatable than TA-50 & uniform/insignia with normies; especially if they're boomer types who have donated. It's just surprising that pieces of scrap & surplus sold as Russian battlefield trophies hasn't flooded the gunshow, reenactor, and fleamarket circuits yet.



And speaking of muscovite milbloggers; Rybar & co. helpfully made a video, detailing how to destroy a Challenger.
 
Last edited:
It's just surprising that pieces of scrap & surplus sold as Russian battlefield losses hasn't flooded the gunshow, reenactor, and fleamarket circuits yet.
I think the man issue is what Bart Simpson found with the "Actual cell from itchy and scratchy" - most of the stuff they're parceling out is unidentifiable or unrecognizable. There's no wow factor, and at this point there are too many KA-52 kills for anythign to be 'unique'.

And speaking of muscovite milbloggers; Rybar & co. helpfully made a video, detailing how to destroy a Challenger.
View attachment 4829677
Lol. Anything that isn't "Get a modern ATGM and pray you're a good shot" is pure cope.
 
That's one thing I don't get about these western or western-situated pro-Russian commentators (The Duran, Lira, Big Serge, MacGregor, etc.). They think Russia can do no wrong and everything is going according to plan. Ukraine is being destroyed and suffering massive casualties while Russia can't stop winning. The supposed Russian fuck-ups and Ukrainian gains are mere western propaganda (or part of a greater Russian strategy), and Russia has barely suffered any losses and is conducting every operation perfectly.

In short, these western Putin-loving Russiaboos are even more delusional than the zigger vatniks.
What boggles my mind about these people is that they can look at the map of the frontlines and somehow still think Russia is winning.
Like its been an entire year into the conflict, the army that was supposedly the second-strongest army in the world can barely push the frontline more than 100 miles from territory it already controlled.
If Russia is winning so fucking hard, then why is it failing to make any significant gain?

This is of course, rhetorical, as Ukraine could blitz across Crimea tomorrow and they would still claim its "all part of the plan, bro; just a strategic withdrawl bro, now the hohols are couldron'd in Crimea!" etc.
Lol. Anything that isn't "Get a modern ATGM and pray you're a good shot" is pure cope.
Ehhh, the right explosive dropped from a quadcopter drone (a HEAT/shape-charge) could take one out from the top.

So what is it, a long range attack? A bombing?
I've got people on a Discord server claiming it was suicide drones, but no source has been posted.
 
the army that was supposedly the second-strongest army in the world can barely push the frontline more than 100 miles from territory it already controlled.
Avdiivka is 4km from Russian Controlled Donetsk and is still under Ukrainian control. After an entire year, they couldn't take this small town that's just a stone's throw away from their pseudo-border.
Russia_Controlled_Donetsk_to_Avdiivka_Mar_21_2023.png
 

Russian mil bloggers certain the Ukrainian offensive is imminent. Basically an overview of the current battle lines and apart from the strange thumbnails, Paul's coverage is a good quality video.


A portion of these are tankies who are perceptive enough to see that the Russian Federation is a reflagged (with aircraft and tanks wearing red stars or even flying the Soviet flag) successor state of the Soviet Union following a sort of latter day NEP with characteristics of crony monopoly capitalism. Scott Ritter (still putting out propaganda) Gonzalo Lira and others are morally compromised characters who ofttimes live far beyond their means (I think too of Taylor Marshall, a trad Cath blogger who switched with a month of Feb '22 to putting out regular Russian propaganda and lives a lavish lifestyle his blogging and books are unlikely to support). I imagine the files on these compromised, crooked characters are being held in reserve, because for now anyone shilling for Putin condemns himself out of his own mouth. Kompromat on, say, convicted pedophile Scott Ritter is a few taps on the keyboard away. Anyone inviting Scott Ritter's views discredits himself automatically. Countering his stuff isn't even needed.
Its still really muddy on the Eastern Front from what I am seeing. I think the Ukrainians didn't want to push until mid April, but events may be moving too quickly for them. I've seen telegram videos showing entire convoys of US Made MRAPS moving into the Bakhmut area, so they are clearly massing forces for something. Either a push or just as likely the establishment of a second line of defense in case they have to pull back. Either way, the Battle is clearly not going the way the Russians want, despite their optimistic protestations. Any victory they manage to eke out here will be Pyrric at best. The longer it takes for them to secure it though, the worse their situation becomes.

In other news, I don't think anyone has posted the number 1 new single in Ukraine yet.


View attachment 4835409
Definatly drones and by the looks of it they hit a train full of kalibr missiles in more vital train junctions that supplied the front line and black sea
The drones literally have 4chan memes on them :story:
 
More Monkey Ooks coming from the Kremlin about "unspecified consequences" due to Britain sending Depleted Uranium ammunition along with their challenger tanks.


Its like Putin thinks its still 2014 and he can just get by with unspecified threats. Even though he's literally pushed this mess as far up the escalation ladder as he can. What is he going to do if Britain does not back down? Start a War?
 
More Monkey Ooks coming from the Kremlin about "unspecified consequences" due to Britain sending Depleted Uranium ammunition along with their challenger tanks.


Its like Putin thinks its still 2014 and he can just get by with unspecified threats. Even though he's literally pushed this mess as far up the escalation ladder as he can. What is he going to do if Britain does not back down? Start a War?
Start a nuclear war

At the chimp bar
 
Back