Erin Reed / Anthony Reed II / @ErinInTheMorn / @ErinInTheMorning / @ErinInTheNight / _supernovasky_ / beholderseye / realitybias / AnonymousRabbit - post-op transbian Twitter/TikTok "activist" with bad fashion, giant Reddit tattoo. Former drug dealer with felony. Married to Zooey Simone Zephyr / Zachary Todd Raasch.

  • 🐕 I am attempting to get the site runnning as fast as possible. If you are experiencing slow page load times, please report it.
tony1.jpg
Thread.
 
Last edited:
As opposed to right now, where none of this is true and things like this NEVER happen!

View attachment 5763149
What the fuck is this shirt?? Looks like it's this one. Right now it's on sale for $18, has he ever worn this before or did he just buy it recently? It would be hilarious if he only got it because it's cheap and ~queer~ .
loving that dirty tile crack gray at the tips of his hair, and his ever growing roots! such a goregous color, can't believe more women aren't using cheap 2 in 1 shampoo to hit this same color 🥰🥰🥰
 
What the fuck is this shirt?? Looks like it's this one. Right now it's on sale for $18, has he ever worn this before or did he just buy it recently? It would be hilarious if he only got it because it's cheap and ~queer~ .
Seattle Sounders (association) football shirt. Zac's a supporter; he grew up in Washington and went to UW for his undergrad degree. There's a video where both Tony and Zac are waving from the pitch to fans.
 
Seattle Sounders (association) football shirt. Zac's a supporter; he grew up in Washington and went to UW for his undergrad degree. There's a video where both Tony and Zac are waving from the pitch to fans.
Seattle keeps getting worse. No wonders trannies love the city most commonly associated junkies and suicide
 
Since Tony claims to get several calls from trans people,parents of trans kids,etc I wonder how long until he starts tweeting about how he's getting several calls from parents of trans kids that are considering suicide because of the ban?Or will it be another case like Ohio where nothing happens?You'd think Tony will be massively reporting on all of these suicides if this stuff really cause thousands of kids to kill themselves.
 
You'd think Tony will be massively reporting on all of these suicides if this stuff really cause thousands of kids to kill themselves.
Tony keeps stomping his foot insisting that the Finnish and German papers are dead wrong. However, child troonery has been banned in half the country and there are no corresponding bodies in the street to back Tone's views. In fact, the best they have is a "non binary" kid who started a fight in a bathroom and then died from something unrelated to that fight.
 
Tony and Vanessa Urquhart are on public radio.
Missouri influence on trans bans with Erin Reed, Evan Urquhart | STLPR (archive; archive via Tor)

Usual stuff, but with plenty of smearing of Jamie Reed because it's St Louis.

Audio (40 minutes):

(Edit: The right audio this time.)

AI-generated transcript:
[00:00:02]
Elaine Cha: This is St. Louis on the air. From St. Louis public Radio, I'm Elaine Cha. It is a scary time to be trans in Missouri. In the last year on our show, we've featured the voices of trans people, their families, their doctors, their supporters. They describe for us what it feels like to have their lives, their most personal decisions labeled as a problem in need of legislative correction. Trans people in Missouri are once again watching the legislature as it considers dozens of bills that could further restrict their lives. But there's a larger story here, and Missouri plays a key role in it on the national stage. Our producer, Danny Wicentowski has been exploring that story.

[00:00:50]
Danny Wicentowski: Here's Danny in the Missouri legislature, 2023 was the year that the state went in on laws that target transgender people, from student sports to medical care. The wave of bills led to new laws, restrictions on gender affirming care, and included efforts to close the very clinics that provided that care. It's a new year, but this is happening again. Last month, lawmakers spent over 8 hours debating bills that would go even further than the ones they passed in 2023. But there is a bigger picture here. What happens in Missouri isn't just about Missouri. For observers of the national landscape, Missouri is a bellwether and a trendsetter. Republican leaders like the state's attorney general, Andrew Bailey, are setting that tone for how to attack ideas about gender identity and gender transition. And other states are taking notice. To talk about Missouri's place in this movement and this moment, I'm joined by two trans journalists who have spent a lot of time looking at what's happening in our state and how it fits in the national landscape. Erin Reed is a journalist based in Washington, D. C. She is the author of the newsletter Erin in the Morning, and she's published numerous pieces covering Missouri's legislation and politics. Erin Reed, welcome to our show.

[00:02:11]
Tony: Hi. Thank you so much for having me on.

[00:02:13]
Danny Wicentowski: And connecting. From Charlottesville, Virginia, is Evan Urquhart. Evan is the founder of Assigned Media, a news site dedicated to daily coverage of the people and organizations who are trying to restrict the lives of trans people. Evan, it is great to have you here.

[00:02:27]
Vanessa: It's good to be here.

[00:02:29]
Danny Wicentowski: I want to start looking back at the year it was. Now, Aaron, you wrote a recent column in the Guardian, and you called Missouri ground zero for the fire hose of anti-trans legislation. Now, you were describing this current year of 2024, but it was last year when Missouri started passing bills that targeted trans people at school and in the doctor's office and in sports fields and in the bathroom. Now, to start us off, looking back at 2023, was there a moment or a bill when you realized that Missouri wasn't just following these trends, but was a major actor in it?

[00:03:06]
Tony: Yes, of course. And you did mention several bills that were passed last year, bills that target trans people in bathrooms and sports, as well as their medical care. But it was the gender affirming care ban in Missouri that very clearly showed that Missouri would be a trendsetter because its ban went further than most other states. For instance, Missouri was, I believe, the first state to ban gender affirming care for incarcerated trans adults. Basically going into targeting adults as well as transgender youth in their bill.

[00:03:38]
Danny Wicentowski: Did something change, I guess, in the national landscape? Did that send a signal to other states?

[00:03:44]
Tony: Yeah, it did send a signal to other states, and something did know. I don't know if you remember, but whenever that bill was being debated, Attorney General Andrew Bailey announced that he would start to restrict trans adults by saying that trans adults no longer could get gender affirming care if they didn't have two years of psych evaluations, or that trans adults had to cure depression and anxiety before getting gender affirming care, even if gender dysphoria was the cause of that depression or anxiety. Essentially banning gender affirming care for many trans adults in the state. And the reason why I mentioned this is because it was a very important moment, because after that, we started to see a few other states take similar actions. We saw this in Florida, and very recently, we saw this in Ohio, where they also targeted trans adults with essentially rule changes.

[00:04:38]
Danny Wicentowski: Evan, I wanted to ask you about this as well, because you started assigned media. Last year was when it really got off the ground. And I'm wondering, what was it about last year and the actions of legislatures like Missouri that made you want to cover this in a more overt way?

[00:04:58]
Vanessa: Yeah. So last September, October, I was very frustrated that I felt there was this wave of propagandistic, sort of right wing news coverage of trans issues, including trans women in sports, gender affirming care, particularly for youth, a few other kind of styles of story. And it was just all day, every day on right wing media. I once timed listening to right wing media to see kind of at the height, how long it took for them to mention trans issues. I think it was less than ten minutes. And then there was this sort of on the other side, in terms of the mainstream media or the left leaning media, which aren't exactly the same thing, there was this sort of gulf of lack of information, lack of news. And I just felt that if one of the two major parties in the United States has made attacking trans people their primary focus and their primary legislative focus, that really needs a lot more news coverage than it was getting now, of course, when it came to Missouri, it was certainly a pathbreaker in terms of anti trans propaganda because of, as you know, and I know you've covered the allegations of Jamie Reed, who was a former clinic.

[00:06:29]
Danny Wicentowski: Right. And let's get into that, because I think in terms of what made Missouri especially impactful and influential last year, this story that involved a former case worker who had worked at the Washington University Transgender center at St. Louis Children's Hospital, she released a whistleblower complaint, first through a website called the free press and later through a legal affidavit. This was almost exactly one year ago, in February of 2023. And so this former caseworker, Jamie Reed, she claimed that the clinic was pressuring kids into transitioning, that doctors are permanently harming them by allowing them to medically transition. Now, an internal investigation by the university found her allegations unsubstantiated, but she has stood by her story. Last month, Reed actually testified in favor of proposed bills restricting gender affirming care for kids. She insists that it is not compassionate to medically transition a child. Evan, you covered this very deeply. Tell us a bit of a summary of who is Jamie Reed, and why did her allegations create such an immediate impact?

[00:07:42]
Vanessa: Well, Jamie Reed was a former, mostly front office staff member at this clinic, this very high reputation clinic that served transgender youth. And when I first came aware of her allegations, I didn't know anything about St. Louis Children's Hospital. I didn't know anything about the transgender center. So on the surface of it, her allegations seemed quite plausible and something to take very seriously. But it was actually the same day, I believe, that she went public with her essay in the Free Press that I wrote the first of many stories, sort of trying to provide context and clarity around these allegations. And the first thing that I noticed was just that a lot of her medical and scientific facts were just completely not correct. This isn't to say that she necessarily lied. I mean, she just may have been misinformed about a lot of the kind of basic science around pediatric transgender health care. It became clear that whatever this was, it wasn't really someone who was providing completely factual information in the affidavit. And then, of course, extensive reporting in Missouri and in the national press has sort of only deepened the picture of how inaccurate and misleading that affidavit was.

[00:09:16]
Danny Wicentowski: You actually did a lot of original reporting after the Jamie Reed allegations were released. And I should note that Jamie Reed stands by her allegations. She has repeatedly said that she blew the whistle because she believed it to be correct. And despite a lot of the evidence that has come out later and that is what you were part of, you actually talked to patients, to families. What started becoming apparent as you talked to the people who had direct experience with this clinic in St. Louis?

[00:09:49]
Vanessa: Well, I absolutely want to tell you about that, but I will just say that I have spoken via Twitter with Jamie Reed, and I did ask her directly about the one allegation that was shown to have been incorrect by one of the families who came forward. And I asked her, now, what she says is that that incorrect information actually originally came from a colleague. And so I asked her, why did you include information in your affidavit that you didn't know to be correct? And what she told me was that her concern was to draw attention to the practices of the center that she disagreed with. So while she has stood by her allegations in the sense that she has never admitted to having intentionally lied, and I wouldn't dream of accusing her of that, she is aware that there was false information in the affidavit, and she has told me that she didn't think that that was the most important thing, that the most important thing was drawing attention to the practices of the center that were lawful, that she disagreed with, but that were not necessarily against the law or indications of wrongdoing.

[00:11:10]
Tony: Yeah.

[00:11:12]
Danny Wicentowski: When you talked to the patients and the families to try to fact check what Jamie Reed is saying, what did you find?

[00:11:18]
Vanessa: Yeah, there were families that were reaching out to me fairly early just because I was doing a lot of kind of basic fact checking of what are these allegations? How many of them have been confirmed? What does the science say? And so I think that gave people some trust to feel that they could reach out to me. And what I found out was that these were families who were devastated at having been included. Sometimes specifically, I talked to the family of a transgender girl, now woman, who was included in the affidavit because she had an adverse reaction to one of the medications. It's actually a little bit more complicated than that, but we don't need to go into the details. So both families that were specifically named and families that were more sort of generally named were devastated that this treatment that they found life changing for their children, that they were reliant on, that they were grateful to, and this center that they had really trusted, was being misrepresented, was being presented as if it was damaging their children when they knew that their children were thriving and their children were trans and that they had not in any know, felt angry at the transgender center or felt like they had been harmed, which was the opposite of what Jamie Reed was saying.

[00:12:50]
Tony: I would like to actually jump in here now because I think that's a really important point. Whenever we imagine whistleblowers and we imagine the role of whistleblowers, it's to expose harm. And it's so critically important to recognize that none of the patients so far have come forward to state that they were harmed. We haven't had any allegations from people treated at that clinic that they were harmed. And in fact, many of those patients have had to flee the state of Missouri after laws were passed targeting their care. Whenever it comes to Jamie Reed in know, I think it's really important to recognize, and this was whenever I had first read the Jamie Reed story, I very clearly saw all of the hallmarks of all of the different sort of well coordinated anti trans campaigning that we've seen over the last three or four years that I've been following. And in an article that I wrote, I covered many of those hallmarks, misinformation and basic facts that were wrong about what care actually is. But also, I think it's extremely telling that the lawyer who Jamie Reed tapped to represent her was Vernadette Broyles, who heads the child and parental rights campaign. This is the same group that worked to pass the don't say gay legislation in Florida. This is the same person who is coordinated with several different organizations, like the Alliance Defending Freedom, who write the anti trans laws. And so it's hard to divorce the sort of claims of being a whistleblower from the very well coordinated political attacks on trans and queer people that we've seen over the last several years.

[00:14:40]
Danny Wicentowski: We are talking today about the ways that Missouri's embrace of anti trans legislation is having an impact on the national stage. I'm here with journalist Aaron Reed, author of the Aaron in the Morning Newsletter, and Evan Urquhart, founder of Assigned Media. Aaron, you draw these connections of folks that are outside of the state who were helping Jamie Reed here. What was the impact in other states? If you could describe, to have this whistleblower in Missouri stand up and say trans care for kids is dangerous and I'm speaking out, did that have an impact around the country?

[00:15:17]
Tony: Absolutely. Within days, if not weeks, we saw Jamie Reed's article cited in court briefings. We saw it cited in legislative hearings to ban care in other states. It very, very quickly was sort of handed off to all of the different Republicans in various states that were working on trying to ban care. And again, the way in which the information disseminates, the way in which we live in a system now to where these kinds of things can be said, and it takes longer to fact check them than it does for the legislators to pick them up and run with them, makes it so that we are very prone to moral panics. We are very prone to disinformation, driving negative legislation targeting trans people. And so, yeah, we saw that with the Jamie Reed story. It wasn't even strictly held within the United States. We saw it cited by people in the United Kingdom who were targeting care there. And again, the same networks that sort of amplify this stuff. We're talking about the alliance defending freedom, the Heritage Foundation, SEGM. These are groups that specifically are organized with this goal in mind. And just recently I reported on Representative Gary Clique in Ohio, who is the author of the trans ban in that state. And he, when talking to other Republicans, specifically said that the end goal, the end game was to ban care for everyone. That's the goal of all of this.

[00:16:58]
Danny Wicentowski: And, Aaron, have you seen any kind of copycats or any other similar whistleblowers who have taken the Jamie Reed model in other states?

[00:17:07]
Tony: They have attempted to bring out a couple more whistleblowers. One of them, I think, worked at a hospital in Washington state for maybe a few months in terms of working in the gender affirming care clinic there. And another one had allegedly released private and confidential information in Texas. Neither of those two have really caught on. Jamie Reed is the only one who they appear to be successfully getting into the information ecosystem.

[00:17:38]
Danny Wicentowski: Now, I had a chance to actually speak with a patient at the Washington University clinic, and his name is Joey Borelli. And he said that Reed's descriptions just did not match with the clinic that he knew. When reading it, I'm kind of reeling thinking not a single one of these things is true. Would you talk to one trans person? It's baffling. It leaves me reeling, but it also makes me want to throw up because of the power that it has. That was Joey Borelli who spoke with me last year about being a patient at the Washington University Transgender center. That was in the wake of Jamie Reed writing that whistleblower report. Evan, the patients and folks that you spoke with, is that kind of what you heard, this sense of bafflement of, what was it that she was describing, but also a sense of how fearful this could be.

[00:18:34]
Vanessa: Yeah. These were families who had been fighting against gender affirming care bans, you know, for, for quite a long time already. They were a fairly close knit group, many of them, who would go to the legislature and speak on behalf of their children. Sometimes their children would speak, and they really felt that they were able to make their voices heard and to get some empathy from the legislators. And there was just a feeling that all of that collapsed after the Jamie Reed allegations. And there was so much frustration and hurt that their stories were being overshadowed by this person who they knew because they'd been there, because this was treatment that they'd had and experienced. They knew it wasn't true, or at least it wasn't true to their experience at all. And I don't believe anyone has ever really found a patient or a parent who has substantiated the allegations of wrongdoing.

[00:19:47]
Danny Wicentowski: Now, there is kind of an aftermath to what had happened at that specific clinic. And following the Missouri legislature banning care for transgender minors, both that clinic and another one in Missouri, they affirmatively decided to stop offering that care. The law had given some kind of grandfather clause. There was some space there. But we had two clinics essentially say even though the law doesn't force us specifically to close and to stop offering this care, there is a legal danger. Aaron, I'm wondering, what did that tell you about the impact of some of these laws? And is that something that other states are also pursuing?

[00:20:30]
Tony: Yeah. And actually, I want to note that you specifically just noted what they cited. They cited the law. They cited the legal danger in the know whenever this bill was being debated in Missouri, they claimed that trans people would be grandfathered in to care, that they would, if you were already getting care before your care was not going to be interrupted. But all of the people that follow this legislation, myself included, knew that was a lie because there was a provision within the legislation that said that you could be sued for the rest of your life if you provided care. You did not have a statute of limitations. You did not even need to show negligence. So you could literally sue for any reason your doctor if they provided you care. And unfortunately, it's impossible to practice medicine under those constraints. No doctor is going to do it because no liability insurer is going to provide you with malpractice insurance. You don't even have to show malpractice under the Missouri law. And so to give your listeners an example of what this would a comparison to this, imagine, if you will that tomorrow we decided that knee surgery, if you regret your knee surgery 20 years from now, and you had to get your knee surgery replaced 20 years from now, which knee surgeries need to be replaced. Sometimes you could sue your doctor 20 years from now. It doesn't even matter if they did the care perfectly. No doctor would do it. No surgeon would be able to actually do knee surgery. And so that's what they did. They did this specifically because they knew that they could backdoor a ban that way. And in fact, since we're talking about Missouri being a sort of leader in this kind of legislation, this legislation was then used in other states. And now we're seeing in a place like New Hampshire, that these liability laws are not only targeting youth, they're targeting trans people at any age. And if they pass, it would essentially be a backdoor ban on all trans care. The perfect analog to this is the target restrictions on abortion providers laws, the trap laws that many of your listeners are going to understand and remember. These are bills that stated that a hospital had to have admitting or an abortion clinic had to have admitting privileges at a hospital, or that an abortion clinic had to have extremely high malpractice insurance rates. And what that does is it doesn't outright ban abortion, sure, but it does make it to where nobody can actually practice it. And we saw that in Missouri, just like we're seeing it around the country right now.

[00:23:04]
Elaine Cha: We need to take a quick break, but we'll be back shortly to continue our conversation with trans journalists Erin Reed and Evan Urquhart. This is St. Louis on the air on St. Louis public Radio. Welcome back. I'm Elaine Cha. Let's return to St. Louis on the air producer Danny Wicentowski's conversation with trans journalists Erin Reed and Evan Urquhart.

[00:23:33]
Danny Wicentowski: Erin, you manage a map on your website and your newsletter that shows states based on the intensity of their anti trans laws, the degree to which things are unsafe for trans people living there, you do not rank Missouri as the worst state or the most danger. That's for Florida, from my understanding. But it is one that you rate at high risk for the next two years. Why is.

[00:24:01]
Tony: I have actually, it's actually two maps. One of them is for adults and one of them is for trans youth. For trans youth, Missouri is listed as one of the states with the worst laws passed for trans adults. It is not yet at that level. Florida is the worst currently because they are saying that if you are, quote unquote, misrepresenting your driver's license gender for instance, you could be charged with criminal fraud, or if you're found in a bathroom that doesn't match your gender identity, or you're assigned sex at birth, you could be thrown in jail for up to a year under criminal trespassing laws. So Florida is a very difficult place to be in right now. Missouri is tough. Missouri is extremely tough, especially for trans youth, with the bills that ban their care. But Missouri still has a little ways to go. They can still do more, and, in fact, legislators are looking at doing more in Missouri. Very recently, we heard bills in Missouri that completely struck that grandfather clause out. For example, there's also a bill in Missouri that passed committee that would allow for healthcare practitioners to legally discriminate against LGBTQ people, and specifically trans people. So we heard in that hearing that if I as a trans person went to a clinic in Missouri as an adult and my doctor signed off on care, and the nurse signed off on care, and I went through all of the steps, and then I went to the pharmacist, and even the pharmacists signed off on care, but the cashier was religious and didn't believe that I deserved to get my care. That cashier could mix. The entire process could say, nope, I'm not going to sell you your hormones. And so that's what this law would do. These are the kinds of laws that make it very hard to navigate society because the rules keep changing for trans people.

[00:25:54]
Danny Wicentowski: Aaron, you spent many, many hours live tweeting a January 17 Missouri House and Senate committee hearings that went very late into the night. You talked about these new bills, one that would allow pharmacists, desk workers, nurses, and more to discriminate against trans people. What else stood out to you from that marathon hearing?

[00:26:20]
Tony: I'm glad that you mentioned that it was a marathon hearing, because it was. It was one of the longer ones that I've covered. And, in fact, there were nine bills heard in a single day, which is the most from all of my hundreds of hours of tracking these bills. It's the most bills that have been heard in a single day targeting trans people in a single state. And these bills ranged from, as you mentioned, the legal right to discriminate against trans people in medical care to bills that would forcibly out trans students to their parents, ban trans people from bathrooms. We even saw one bill that would essentially say that the Missouri Commission on human Rights had to target trans people in bathrooms, basically stating that trans people in a bathroom are a violation of the rights of cisgender. You know, it was hard. It was hard to listen to. It was hard to watch, and I have to because this is my job. I report on these bills. But we saw that barely anybody came up to speak in favor of this legislation, and yet they still advanced a good bit of it. They combined some of the bills, they pushed it forward, and the other bills are still alive. They're still sitting there and could come out at any moment. And so, yeah, that was a long hearing.

[00:27:43]
Vanessa: I'd like to jump in just for a moment to talk about some of this legislation that's proposed, legislation that's debated. And I think often people think, well, it's not going to pass or it's not that likely to pass. So why is it important to talk about it, and why is it important to monitor it the way Aaron does? And the reason is that last year or two years ago was way too far right, was the absolute fringe. No one would do it. Trans people have been hearing for years that no one was going to ban gender affirming care, that no one was going to come after gender affirming care for adults. So the proposed legislation this year know, very plausibly the legislation that passes next year. And I do think Aaron's work is so important in tracking know, both of.

[00:28:40]
Danny Wicentowski: Your points involve the subject of what is gender affirming care and how is it communicated by political parties, by organizations. Evan, you have done a lot of writing about trying to address misconceptions, trying to address propaganda, as you mentioned. And you actually had a recent piece titled your bad faith questions about gender identity answered. And this was actually a response to a letter in the St. Louis Post Dispatch from someone who was raising questions, as you mentioned, in sort of a bad faith way. And I'm wondering, could you describe, how do you know with a question of, like, how is gender dysphoria diagnosed? And this was a question you kind of unpacked in your piece. How do you know when someone's coming at this with bad faith? And why is gender affirming care attracting this type of energy?

[00:29:35]
Vanessa: Right. Something that is very common among people who are either opposed to transgender rights or who are very severely skeptical of trans people's right to be who we are. They often present questions as if they are unanswerable, and they kind of trust that the invisibility of trans people and the inability of trans people to kind of have an equal microphone will cement in the public's mind the idea that, for example, that gender dysphoria in youth is self diagnosed. Now, it is not self diagnosed. It's sort of like a headache. If you go to your doctor and you have a headache, they're going to ask you some questions, and they may diagnose a migraine, but it isn't you self diagnosing migraine. It is you reporting on what's going on in terms of how much pain you're feeling in your head. So gender dysphoria is a little bit like that. There are questions that professional asks, and it does have to do with how the trans person, and if it's a young person, how the young trans person is feeling and thinking about their body and about gender, but it's not that child diagnosing themselves. Another one of the questions that I called bad faith was, is gender dysphoria simply an unwillingness to conform to gender stereotypes? Now, that's a question that's implying that it is and is kind of relying on the fact that there's no one there to answer and to say, well, as a matter of fact, trans people are very likely not to be very strictly gender conforming after they transition. There are a lot of trans men who are gay men, and there are a lot of trans men who are not deeply macho, deeply, perhaps, myself included, kind of doubling down on macho stereotypes. And the same, of course, is true for trans women, who often break stereotypes in many ways. But so by asking the question, is that what gender dysphoria is? It's sort of implying that the answer is yes, and the answer is actually no. I like to do a lot of that, kind of just letting people know that there is an answer and that the kind of stereotype, I think, often is that trans people are sort of irrational or kind of unable to answer these basic questions. And so just kind of breaking it down and saying, no. These are the answers, I hope, is something that can kind of dispel that in people's mind.

[00:32:14]
Tony: And that would be bad enough if that were it. But we're seeing even further now. We're seeing people with very large platforms, essentially not only just ask the questions and assume that no trans person is going to be able to have the platform to answer them, but also they're going to go and find the one cherry picked person who meets their criteria, who meets their definition. We have this know very recently in the New York Times with the Pamela Paul article, where Pamela Paul said that, oh, well, trans people are really just gay people. That transition is transing away the gay or something like that. And we saw that she found one person who said that they were just internally repressed and gay. And yet, whenever you look at the community, whenever you look at the trans community, by and large, something like 80% of us identify as LG or B after transition as well. And so it lifts up that point that Evan just made, that essentially, so much of this relies on the idea that we, as trans people, often do not have these platforms to be able to answer back. We don't have the New York Times. We don't have big columns that we can constantly write out on. And that's why Evan and I do the work that we do. We're here able to actually report on these.

[00:33:39]
Danny Wicentowski: Know, I wanted to ask both of you, as journalists who are trans, who are covering this issue that involves laws that if you were living in Missouri, might very much directly affect your life and your own medical care. If you could just tell us a bit of what this is like for you as journalists and how you maintain that professionalism and that energy, even while these laws and these figures are talking about things that are really, really personal.

[00:34:14]
Tony: Yeah, this is the hardest but most important job that I've ever had. And I think that I recognize that every day there are places right now that are unsafe for me to travel to. I was invited to go speak at a college in Florida, the new college of Florida, which, by the way, was taken over by a De Santis handpicked person. And I know that if I had gone to the bathroom there, easily, somebody could target me. And it's hard to be able to report on these bills. It's hard to be able to write on these topics while also knowing that you could be next. You could be targeted next. And I'm in a relatively safe place. I'm in Maryland, and Maryland has taken steps to protect trans people. And I want to be clear that there are many states right now that are going in the opposite direction, that are taking steps to protect trans people in their borders. But as it stands right now, I have to answer these questions from trans people in Missouri who ask me, am I safe here? Is it safe to stay here? And I have to tell them the truth. I don't know. There are ways that you can be targeted right now in many of these states that can last a lifetime. And so, yeah, it's difficult, but it's important.

[00:35:34]
Vanessa: I would say that being a journalist is sort of the great passion of my life. And I have always just believed so strongly in truth as a fix, as a spur towards good actions, towards good policy, towards understanding one another. And so I do see it as just the greatest privilege to be able to do journalism, to be able to bring people real information, particularly people in my community, the trans community, but the mainstream as well. When I get that chance. Is it hard? In some ways, yes. But I would also say that it's harder to feel like you don't have anything you can do. And so I have something I can do. I have my job. I go out, I report every know that that's a great privilege and something that I value. Very.

[00:36:34]
Danny Wicentowski: Guess. Lastly, you know, looking at Missouri in this next year, from what you've know, is Missouri going to be leading this trend yet again, or is there another state that we should be looking at to wonder is Missouri going to look like this in a know?

[00:36:50]
Tony: I think that Missouri is going to continue to be one of the first to do things, and I have not seen any indication that that is going to slow down. Other states like Florida, Texas, have also sort of taken that front step, the first step to do things. And my eyes are on Missouri. I know that Attorney General Andrew Bailey has repeatedly targeted the community. Right now, he very recently signed on to a letter stating that he should be able to go after people who are getting gender affirming care in other states. So people who are leaving Missouri to go get care, as if he has some sort of ownership over Missouri, citizens who are traveling to other states. And so, yeah, I think that Missouri is absolutely going to be one of the states that we need to continue to watch. And I also want to state that we've been talking a lot about trans people, but these same rulings, these same policies are targeted against other people as well, people that are seeking abortions, immigrants. We see that this is not going to be limited just to us. And I think that we need to watch Missouri for more than one reason because of that.

[00:38:01]
Danny Wicentowski: Erin Reed is a trans journalist who tracks legislation around the US in her subscription newsletter, Erin in the morning. She has covered Missouri's legislation numerous times, and she recently published a column in the Guardian titled Missouri is Ground Zero for the fire hose of anti trans legislation. Aaron, thank you so much for being with us today.

[00:38:22]
Tony: Thank you so much for having me.

[00:38:23]
Danny Wicentowski: And Evan Urquhart is the founder of Assigned Media, a news site dedicated to daily coverage of anti-trans propaganda and its effects. He covered the Jamie Reed case very deeply in the last year, and he recently wrote on January 23, a piece responding to a letter published in the Post Dispatch titled your bad faith questions about gender identity answered. Evan, thank you so much for being here today.

[00:38:48]
Vanessa: Thank you.

[00:38:53]
Elaine Cha: This episode was produced by Danny Wicentowski.

[00:38:56]
Danny Wicentowski: Audio engineering and podcast design by Aaron Doerr. Our executive producer is Alex Heuer.

[00:39:06]
Danny Wicentowski: St. Louis on the air is a production of St. Louis Public Radio. Understanding starts here. St. Louis on the air proudly supports local artists by using music from Life Creative group.

[00:39:23]
Elaine Cha: Do you find yourself regularly listening to episodes of St. Louis on the air? Suggest us to a friend you think might enjoy our conversations and leave us a review and rating on Apple Podcasts on the App Store. It's the simplest way to help people discover our show. Thank you.

[00:39:42]
Danny Wicentowski: St. Louis Public Radio is a member supported service of the University of Missouri St. Louis. St. Louis Public Radio is the gate way gives you the day's news first thing every weekday morning, from the ever evolving relationship between St. Louis City and county to developments in the Missouri and Illinois state capitals, and reports from our correspondents in Rala and the Metro east. We put it all in a roughly ten minute package with clarity and context. Download the gateway wherever you get podcasts.
 
Last edited:
As opposed to right now, where none of this is true and things like this NEVER happen!

View attachment 5763149
What the fuck is this shirt?? Looks like it's this one. Right now it's on sale for $18, has he ever worn this before or did he just buy it recently? It would be hilarious if he only got it because it's cheap and ~queer~ .
I misread the shirt and thought it said “LOVE UNIT,” which is totally what pre-transition Tony would have called his penis.
 
Man, it's terrible when the law can go after you for the rest of your life because you did a thing twenty or more years ago, isn't it?

I mean, there's no statute of limitations on killing people, for crying out loud!! Or raping someone in a lot of states. Hell, even California will get their panties in an uproar if you commit massive fraud that carries a huge sentence.

But it's not just the states. Get this....the feds have this hate boner for "terrorism" so much, that even if no one died during your "protest" but was merely injured, they will still prosecute you for it, even if you are now a "peaceful" senior citizen!!

Gosh darn it, it's been so long ago. Shouldn't those alleged "victims" get over it already?
 
So for instance, a young very feminine boy might be diagnosed with gender identity disorder.

This is such Tranny logic. "In the past under DSM 4 they were mistakenly identifying feminine boys and masculine girls as having gender identity issues, now under the DSM 5 the criteria will weed out such cases. Subsequently we're so good at weeding out those cases today that the number of children being diagnosed has increased ten fold"
 
Tony keeps stomping his foot insisting that the Finnish and German papers are dead wrong. However, child troonery has been banned in half the country and there are no corresponding bodies in the street to back Tone's views. In fact, the best they have is a "non binary" kid who started a fight in a bathroom and then died from something unrelated to that fight.
If anyone tries to ask him where all the bodies are then he'll use the old trans excuse of "Their deaths are being underreported!" which is the most unfalsifiable claim someone can make.
 
Last edited:
If I were to guess, Erin Reed likely holds similar opinions to Brianna Wu: trans people are people looking to go from one point to the other with medical intervention and anything that doesn't involve medical transitioning is half assing it and aren't true trans.
I can't find it in thread, but I'm 99.9% certain he's said at some point that he had dysphoria, but also you don't need to be dysphoric to be trans. He's never explained how one reconciles that notion with the claim that transitioning is lifesaving medically necessary treatment, of course.

Bold words coming from someone who didn't even finish his degree, if I remember correctly.

Someone took it on the chin again.
Pretty easy to do when you've got a chin that size.
 
I can't find it in thread, but I'm 99.9% certain he's said at some point that he had dysphoria, but also you don't need to be dysphoric to be trans. He's never explained how one reconciles that notion with the claim that transitioning is lifesaving medically necessary treatment, of course.
Yep. Here you go:
Funny he mentions "dysphoria" because he has said previously that his dysphoria started after he decided to troon out, and that people didn't need to feel dysphoria to be ✨Stunning and Valid✨ trans.
Same post in which I first mentioned, off-hand, that Tony had confessed to being a drug dealer. :story: Feels like a lifetime ago.

Bold words coming from someone who didn't even finish his degree, if I remember correctly.
Well, he completed his bachelors and masters degrees, but dropped out of his PhD.

Tony's made an appearance on the "Freedom over Fascism" (lol) podcast:


44. Erin Reed, Independent Journalist, Trans Activist, Author of Erin in the Morning (archive; archive via Tor)

AI-generated transcript:
[00:00:00]
Stephanie Wilson: I'm Stephanie Wilson, and you're listening to freedom over fascism.

[00:00:08]
Unknown: It's important to find the room that you can do the most good in. And maybe that room is a legislative meeting, but maybe it's the boardroom. Maybe it's an appearance reading group. And I think that just identifying those rooms is the biggest thing that anybody can do. You.

[00:00:28]
Stephanie Wilson: Hi, friends. As I'm recording this, it's February 27, and I've just returned from an amazing multigenerational vacation, refreshed and ready to dive back into the fight for freedom. All of us need time to refresh ourselves in this never ending fight, and if you need some time away, please take it so that you can return stronger and more energized as well. I returned and learned that yesterday the Arizona legislature defeated a measure to put anti trans questions on the ballot in November. I also came back to the news of the killing of next Benedict, a trans teen in Oklahoma, though details are still emerging, next was beaten in a bathroom and died the next day after months of persistent bullying. Today I'm talking to Erin Reed, who writes a newsletter called Aaron in the Morning about anti trans laws across this country and about events like Nexus murder. As in many of my conversations, we talked about the importance of acting locally or in whatever room you can make the most difference, whether it's running for school board, changing policies where you work, or educating people you know in real life. About books and shows featuring trans people. Erin is the of Zoe Zephyr, whom we talked to a couple weeks ago. They're a power couple for sure. In the fight for trans rights and freedoms, Erin and I discussed the importance of local action, running candidates for state and local office, which can generate votes up ballot to change the entire balance of power in a state. I recommend following her work, if you don't already. She's at erininthemorning.com, on substack and at all major social media platforms. I ask you as well to spread the word about this podcast to other people you know who are interested in finding the truth, learning how to frame it so people can hear it, finding ways of reaching people, and meeting candidates and officials who are on the front lines of fighting for freedom in this country. Please support us on Patreon or substack and find us anywhere you listen to your podcasts and at freedomoverfascism us. Erin Reed, welcome to freedom over fascism. Hi.

[00:02:57]
Tony: Thank you so much for having me.

[00:02:59]
Stephanie Wilson: I'm so glad you're here. I've been thinking about your work for a really long time last week. The last week has been really heartbreaking, although there's new heartbreak every day. That's shocking but not surprising. And last week, I was on vacation, a much needed, multigenerational vacation in the middle of nowhere, which was amazing. And if anybody has the opportunity to take a few days to reset, I highly recommend it. But I came back to this tsunami of news. In your introduction, I talked a little bit about what you do, but would you mind taking a moment to introducing yourself to our listeners? Who are you? What do you do? What do you believe your impact is on laws affecting trans people in the United States today?

[00:03:48]
Tony: Of course. So I am a transgender journalist. I cover all of the legislation, the cultural issues, the biggest news on the topic of LGBTQ rights, with a special focus on transgender rights across the United States and across the world. Increasingly. I write for my subscription newsletter, errand in the morning, as well as report on platforms like TikTok, Twitter, Instagram. I try to make sure that everybody has the information about what's going on wherever they are, and I try to meet people wherever they are. And as we know, we've been watching bills move across the United States for the better part of the last four years, and I try to make them digestible so that people understand the impact of those bills.

[00:04:32]
Stephanie Wilson: I think people like you and independent journalism these days is so important. I'd love to talk to you more about that because the mainstream media is not doing its job. But first, I want to talk about last week and the murder of next Benedict, a high schooler who was murdered by their peers in Oklahoma high school after months or years of bullying. Can you tell us anything? Our listeners are high information people. Anything that's going on that's new. I know that some of what Judd Luggam reported has moved things along, as he has in other investigations, but do you mind updating us on what's going on and anything new?

[00:05:23]
Tony: Absolutely. So you got the very basics of what know we saw next. Benedict, a trans teen in Oklahoma, was allegedly being bullied, had a confrontation in a bathroom, where they alleged that they were teased for their clothing that they wear. And I'm also going to, before we continue, I'm going to actually switch pronouns to he him just because we did learn. One of the new pieces of information we learned yesterday from Joe Yerkaba's reporting was that he used he him pronouns, and those were the ones that he preferred the most, although we do know that in varying social situations, he used other pronouns as well. One of the I think greatest tragedies of this is that his life was taken before he was able to truly, completely come out to everybody. And so the loss of a young person's life in the middle of their identity development is just an extra sad part of what happened. But in the bathroom, it appears that he was attacked by three people, had concussion or some sort of a head injury, went to the hospital, and eventually passed the next day. And there's been a lot of information that's come out since then. We know that, for instance, the police officers stated that the autopsy report showed that his death had nothing to do with trauma. That was later sort of backtracked whenever Judd reported and asked them about the case. And it sounds like they had released that statement just to get national attention off of the case and that they were still investigating next Benedict's killers. And so that's about all the information. We had. Vigils all weekend. We saw vigils in Oklahoma City, Tulsa, Washington, DC, Minneapolis, and dozens of other places. We also know that in Oklahoma, Superintendent Ryan Walters, basically the person in charge of education in Oklahoma, has repeatedly spread fear about transgender people in bathrooms, stating that trans people in bathrooms are an assault on truth. He hired libs of TikTok. Chaya Raichicks lives, a TikTok creator. Assumingly, he stated that the reason why he was hiring her was to make schools safer. And of course, that account has been associated with bomb threats that often come after she posts targeting various individuals. One of the individuals we also learned that she targeted very early on in the Lindsay TikTok account was a teacher of Nats, was one of Nax's former teachers, and a great mentor of theirs. And so I think know this is a tragedy all around. And we've got a young trans person's life who is no longer with us. And the situation is still developing in Oklahoma.

[00:08:26]
Stephanie Wilson: With the superintendent bringing on lives of TikTok. It seems like there's a couple of different streams. There's the laws that states and municipalities and school districts are passing against trans youth, and more often this year, trans adult. But then there's the fear and the permission structure they seem to create for violence. Do you think that has made a difference in the communities where they are active? Or do you think just the change of laws is what has precipitated violence like this?

[00:09:13]
Tony: I think that it's intricately connected, and I think that it's sort of a two pronged attack on trans people. You have sort of this extrajudicial violence that's going on against trans people, by people, by organizations like Proud Boys and all of your other sort of proto fascist orgs that are out there, that target trans people wherever they are, that send threats, that do this harm. And then you have legislative and legal violence done towards trans people. And it may sound like these things are sort of not connected, but they're intricately connected. And in fact, whenever we talk about people like Chaya Raichek and libs of TikTok, we know that the legislators in Oklahoma are citing libs of TikTok and citing Chaya Reichik for the passing of the laws. Those same chaya and libs of TikTok and all of your anti trans far right influencers also are directly followed and inspiring the people who are doing harm. And in fact, we learned from one of the news stories that some interviews with trans and queer students in the school state that they are routinely bullied by people who watch libs of TikTok and Chaya Raiche. And so this is all interconnected. It's all very closely linked to each other. And this fear campaign, it touches everywhere. It doesn't just sit in the legislature. It doesn't just sit in the meeting groups of the Proud Boys and all of the other sort of far right organizations. It also lives in our schools. It sort of permeates the medical systems in some of these more right leaning places. And it very much impacts trans people's lives on a daily basis.

[00:10:58]
Stephanie Wilson: Do you think that there's anything that we, as activists and not electeds, can do to help? Not just defeat laws in MAGa controlled legislatures, but also in the popular culture or online? Are we making any progress? How do you see that? You're a major influencer. When I told people I was going to interview you, I had a lot of people fangirling and boying over me talking to you. But what do you think the best ways of fighting against this fear mongering would be?

[00:11:45]
Tony: Yes. Education is always important. And I think that for a long time, we've recognized that education is one of the ways in which you can combat extremism. It's one of the ways that you can combat hate and bigotry. And we've got examples of this in the past. We know that the more people learned about lesbian, gay, bisexual people, the more acceptance. In this way, we were able to get marriage equality over time. And I think that there's a lag time whenever it comes to trans people. I think that a lot of people have not necessarily had as much time to learn about trans people and we have started coming out more recently in greater numbers. Whereas 20 years ago, even while gay people were openly gay and coming out, trans people were very heavily still stigmatized. And so I think that the very first thing to do before anything else, is just learn. Get educated, read information, follow trans journalists, read trans authors, and not just on theory and on activism, but also in other non related contexts. There are incredible trans musicians out there. There are people who are writing works of fiction. There are people who are creating video games. There are people who are doing art, who are trans and queer. And a big part of how we move the needle forward is by including those people in your consumption of media, because all of us, even trans people, include it, have to sort of deprogram from the years of hate and abuse we got in the popular media. There's a really good documentary out there that I would highly suggest called disclosure. And it's all about how the media history of representation of trans people has played such a huge role in sort of the negative perceptions that still persist and permeate, even among sometimes left leaning groups. And so you have to sort of realize everything's gone inside. Now, once you have education, then you can start looking at the other ways you can contribute. Maybe you have local trans organizations or queer organizations in your community that you can help either with volunteering or with donations, or just with spreading the word and being on their mailing list. Maybe it means showing up to the legislatures. Maybe it means making a change in your professional society or company. There are still a lot of companies that don't offer good, inclusive health care benefits. And so I think that I'm going to borrow something from my fiance and say that it's important to find the room that you can do the most good in. And maybe that room is a legislative meeting, but maybe it's the boardroom. Maybe it's an appearance reading group. And I think that just identifying those rooms is the biggest thing that anybody can do.

[00:14:40]
Stephanie Wilson: Wow, that is a really nice way to say that as we try to figure out where we can make an impact. I live in Massachusetts, and you talk about our laws being good, and they're good. And I have a teenager who is cis, but has many genderqueer friends. I venture to say a majority of his friends are genderqueer. And still there's work to do here. It's not all good. And I think that, as you were saying, people take some time to understand what it is to be trans or genderqueer or non binary. And I think our brains also take time to catch up. Like a lot of people my age, which is older than you, have trouble. And our children correct us very quickly with they them, the binary trans, male to female, female to male. Easy, right? You are she. I am she. You are she. That. That's easy. The. The gender queerness is something that's harder to wrap brains around. But I also think that even in places like this, where there are a lot of kids and adults coming out, there are a lot of places where we can contribute knowledge, or even if it's recommending a tv show that has trans characters and hopefully trans actors playing those trans characters. So, shifting a little bit from how can people make the most difference? One of your latest risk assessments on your newsletter, Aaron, in the morning, you talk about how the anti trans laws are moving from targeting kids to targeting adults. And the more than 400 bills this year alone, and it's only February 27 when we're recording this, that MAGA is trying to pass. Can you talk a little bit more about what is the state of being like? Where are the states where people are mostly safe, super safe, very endangered? Mostly. Can you talk about the different gradations and how you come to these assessments?

[00:17:17]
Tony: Yeah, absolutely. So you're referring to my antitrans legislative risk assessment map. This is something that I have produced for a good two years now. And two years ago, whenever I first worked on this map, it was only targeting, or it was only focused on the risk for transgender youth. And that isn't because I was ignoring adults. It's because those were the only kinds of bills that we saw. We saw bills that were targeting trans youth only. That has changed. We have seen more and more bills that have expanded their focus to target adults. And also for trans youth, a lot of the worst bills have already passed. They've already done almost everything they can do to make the lives of trans youth harder, to ban medical care, to ban them from bathrooms, to ban them from sports, and more. And so whenever it comes to looking at risk, there's a few things that I keep in mind. Number one is what laws are already on the books and which ones are being advanced. And for adults that might look like bans, that target pride. That ban pride. Basically, a lot of times they're sold as bands on drag, but they're actually, whenever you read the bills, they say that it applies to anybody wearing makeup or clothing that signifies a gender that is not of your assigned sex at birth and performs. And so that basically targets trans people who are dancing or who are wearing elaborate costumes, that are walking down pride marches, which you see at prides very often. I'll also note that these drag bands, as they're called, the very first person that a drag band was used against was not somebody doing drag. It was a trans person in a library in Montana who was a trans public speaker speaking about transgender. So, you know, these bills, they target trans adults in a myriad of ways. They would prevent, for instance, Kim Petrus from singing in that state. Kim Petrus being a Grammy award winning transgender musician. And so we see this with adult restrictions and pride. We also see this with medical bans. Florida has been a big state for targeting adults. They also have a bill, or they have a law now that could put trans people in jail for a year for using the bathroom, the same bathroom I've been using for five years. I cannot travel through Florida safely. Florida is currently also looking at revoking trans driver's licenses if they have incorrect gender markers and stating that any trans person misrepresenting their gender identity or their gender at birth is potentially guilty of fraud, criminal. So, you know, we are seeing an escalation in targeting transgender people. Medical care. We see bans in medical care in Florida for many trans adults as well. We've seen this advanced in places like Ohio, Missouri, and even this morning, I'm reading a bill in Kansas that would do similar. And so this is how I kind of look at things, like which laws I'm looking at whenever I'm developing the risk map for adults. I also speak to activists in every state. I've got a contact list of three to five people in every state that I can always just message if there's something that comes up in that state. And I want to get a better understanding of, hey, what do you see the picture on the ground as right now? Are you seeing this being a priority this year? I go through all the states, and essentially, I've got sort of a rubric that I use, a scoring rubric that I say, is this kind of bill being proposed? How far did it get? What do the activists say? And then I stratify the risk. I say that there are some states where it's so bad that it's hard to travel in. There are some states where it's really bad and likely going to get worse. There are some states where things are actually really okay right now, and even states where they are going the extra mile in protecting the trans people that live there for trans youth, it's very similar. Instead of looking at some of the things that I mentioned, I also add in things like medical care bans for youth, which are present in, like, 21 states right now.

[00:21:16]
Stephanie Wilson: So in these states that are at higher risk or in the middle of all sorts of trans bans, this is a broad, broad, broad question. How are people, trans people, parents of trans kids, how are people dealing? I know some are moving and some are fighting, but how do they do their daily life with so much of a target on them?

[00:21:45]
Tony: Each person is sort of right now, sort of fighting their own fight, and that looks different for each person. Some people I know, many people have fled their home state. In fact, recent surveys show that 130 to 260,000 people who are trans have already left their home state, many of them coming from Florida, Alabama, Texas. I see those very often. And people who are fleeing, they're showing up in your local communities. I know here in Maryland, where I live, I'm part of a local parents group, and I regularly see posts on Facebook of like, hey, I just got here from Texas. Got a non binary kid or a trans kid. Is it? So, you know, that's happening. We also see people who are stuck in their home states who are forced off their medication or who have to travel up to 1000 miles to get to the nearest clinic every month or every few months. And it sounds extremely difficult, and it is. There are people that don't have the resources to do that. There are people that are pulled off medication right now that are being forced to medically detransition. There are transgender girls who are being forced to grow facial hair right now. Like that's happening in front of their peers. They've probably identified as trans for years, and yet this is what they're dealing with. Some people are. Some trans youth are young enough to where this is not a concern yet. For instance, if you're 8910 years old and your gender nonconforming, non binary, trans, anything like that, those kids have not gone through puberty yet. And so they're sort of crossing their fingers and hoping that they get a court decision. There are people being investigated for child abuse. This is still happening in some places, and so it's going to be a different situation wherever you're at. I know some trans people are staying, inviting. That's important to recognize as well is that this is their home. Many people are not going to just give up and leave. So every person is fighting their invite right now.

[00:23:46]
Stephanie Wilson: It's one of my biggest problems with how we do things in America is individuals are expected to solve systemic problems, and it doesn't work that way. Are there places where people are successfully fighting against some of these antitrans laws, or at least communities within the states that are badly off, that are safer for trans kids and adults.

[00:24:19]
Tony: Yes to both. There are still victories that are happening. For instance, something that I'm going to be writing on today is the fact that SCR 100:13 in Arizona was beaten by a single vote. And this actually is a huge victory for trans people in Arizona, because in Arizona, there is a democratic governor who's been vetoing all of the anti trans legislation. However, Arizona Republicans realized that they could vote for a bill that puts it directly on the ballot, that would bypass a governor's veto, that failed by a single vote just last. So, you know, that was huge. There were a lot of people that came out. That bill was specifically why I upped the risk in Arizona, because that bill could potentially have gone into effect. Thankfully, it doesn't look like that's going to happen. And Arizona will actually reduce in risk because of that for trans use. It's a huge victory there. We see even in places where things are difficult, like in Missouri, we just saw, I believe it was Kansas City pass a ordinance that declares Kansas City a refugee sanctuary city for trans people in Missouri, stating that Kansas City will not enforce anti trans laws if they can get around it. And of course, in Virginia, where Governor Glenn Youngkin has demanded that every school conform to a new set of executive branch policies that ban trans people from sports, that ban trans youth from bathrooms, that forcibly out trans youths to their parents. And it does a dozen more things targeting them. This was a major issue given that thousands, tens of thousands of kids walked out of their high schools in Virginia in protest of these laws. And instead, we saw in Virginia that a good number of school districts basically just said, no. They said, we're not going to adopt it. You can try to make us, but we're not going to do it. And that's where we stand right now. So there are stories of resistance happening everywhere, even where my fiance is from in Montana. She's the first trans legislator in Montana. Montana has been tremendously targeting trans people in that state. And yet we saw one of the best stories of resistance last year in that state, where she demanded her right to be heard after being silenced in a legislature. And as a result, the world knew about what was going on and the cruelty that was going on there in the state. So, yeah, resistance is still happening. It will always happen. And the people there that want to continue fighting and have that ability and that willpower to do so, are going to hold up the tradition that the LGBTQ community has had for generations now.

[00:27:03]
Stephanie Wilson: So I often think about and talk about your fiance, Zoe Zephyr, as an example of how you can demand to be heard and as activists and candidates and officials, how we need to find a way to demand to be heard. And I'm glad to hear that some places are refusing to implement some of these horrible laws. So what I also wanted to say is, with one vote difference in the Arizona legislature, that means that the more people who run in down ballot races where their seat was previously uncontested by a Democrat, or the more people that you get out to vote in rural areas or urban that haven't voted in the past, that right there is the difference. And we had last week on two women who have this rural organizing initiative in Arizona, where they have registered thousands of people to vote and have been responsible for several of those legislative seats that Democrats have taken. That work is incredibly important as it filters up. Right. Some of those races were decided by 12, 10, 15 votes, and this measure was defeated by one vote. So I want to remind people that activism isn't just picking a topic. It's also working on ways to engage and mobilize more voters at every single level.

[00:29:03]
Tony: Yeah, I absolutely agree. I think that voting at every single level is really important, and I really want to emphasize at every level, we need to go down to the local level. And, in fact, I think a lot of the energy is spent on the left with the presidential election. And while that is an important election for sure, it's also important to note that Republicans have realized and anti trans people have realized the impact that can be made in your school board races, the impact that can be made in your city council races, in your state legislatures. And that's where all of these bills are happening. And a lot of times, whenever you can make the impact those local levels, they filter about, they start to grow. That's where we get the idea of grassroots from. And so, thankfully, looking at 2022 and 2023, I have seen and reported on an increased participation in local elections over this topic. And just recently, in the big 2023 school board elections across the United States, we saw 70% of moms for Liberty candidates lose their races. And specifically, they were running primarily on anti trans issues. That was their big topic in Bucks County, Pennsylvania. In Loudoun County, Virginia, we're talking about bellwether counties for the entire nation. Whenever you watch on 2020 four's election night, you're going to hear them talk about Bucks county. You're going to hear them talk about Loudoun county and Virginia. These are the swing counties that determine presidential elections. And the anti trans horses lost heavily there. The new school board members swore in on banned books. And in fact, we just saw in Democrats, you know, won almost all the seats. There were two seats they did not win there that were still held by monster liberty members. Those two, they resigned just a couple of weeks ago. They resigned their post. And that shows that this was never about making schools better or working for the kids. They literally had one topic that they wanted to focus on. They wanted to target trans people. And the second that they lost their power to do so, they wanted nothing to do with kids anymore. It's all about that. And so I think local participation is important. And also, if you are a person who cares about this issue, you can win in these elections. You can go and win at a school board race. It might sound unfathomable to you, but we're not talking about tens of thousands of voters here. In many cases, we're talking about getting in there and doing work and making change where you can.

[00:31:51]
Stephanie Wilson: Exactly. A friend of mine called me up just a couple of weeks ago and said, hey, I'm running for school board. Can you help me? And it's not somebody who'd ever gotten involved in politics really at all. And things were not going well in their school district, and she decided to jump in and run. And I think the more people who feel empowered to do that, the more places there are to train them, the more of a permission structure to say anybody can run for office, you don't have to have some special magical protein in your tongues. I don't know. But that we are all capable of doing action in our localities that can have ripples across the country is really important. And even if it doesn't ripple across the country, if it ripples across your town and one kid gets treated better or many kids get treated better or more books are on the shelves or people understand that moms for Hitler are really there to control. I don't let them have the name. They don't deserve to be called liberty. That it's all about controlling other people. And as we see now, and it's all interconnected, right? So this whole, we've got anti trans, anti abortion, and now we're targeting embryos, fertilized embryos and IVF. And it's so easy to see how it's really about controlling people and having tree that looks like them.

[00:33:37]
Tony: Yeah. And unless your listeners think the moms are Hitler comparison is weird. They literally had a Hitler quote on one of their pamphlets that they passed out and then had to pull a big Maya culpa. So it's a very apt comparison. But I think that you're entirely correct. And I think that we do have the ability to make an impact, and I want to make that clear. We can change things. We can do things that will make this world better. And going back to kind of like what we said at the very beginning, it's that finding that room, finding what room you belong in, and for some people, for that person that you spoke about, like going for a school board race, maybe that's the room where they can do good in. And I think that if we continue to do that, if we continue to look for those spaces and work to get in those spaces, we know, I think intuitively, where our voices can make the most difference, it's just a matter of jumping and doing it. It seems scary. Whenever you're looking out, you're thinking, oh, can I do it? But the people that are in these positions, the people that are in these state legislatures that are in these school boards or the teachers or the people that are in the boardrooms, they often have to make that same decision. And I think everybody can find their own space where they can make difference.

[00:34:52]
Stephanie Wilson: I think that is a really important idea and a great place to end. Is there anything else that you would like our listeners to know? And if you want to let them know how they can find you, please do.

[00:35:04]
Tony: Yeah, of course. Nothing. In addition to this, this was very thorough. But I will say that if anybody wants to read my work, it's erininthemorning.com or on virtually any of the major social media platforms. You can follow me at erininthemorn or at Erin in the morning, depending on the platform. Other than that, though, thank you so much. I'm going to keep reporting on this and I'm going to make sure that I keep everybody informed as things develop.

[00:35:29]
Stephanie Wilson: Well, you're one of my biggest go tos for understanding what's going on all across the country. So thank you for that.

[00:35:36]
Tony: Thank you so much.

[00:35:41]
Stephanie Wilson: Thank you for listening to freedom over fascism. And thank you to our editor, Benji Wilson. Please join our patreon at freedom overfascism. Subscribe wherever you listen to your podcasts, and please drop us a rating or review on Apple Podcasts. We thank you for choosing freedom over fascism.

He's also giving a presentation about men in women's sports to Yarmouth, MA, libraries via Zoom on Tuesday March 5 at 7pm UTC-5 (ie next Tuesday).
GHYCGCwXcAEubXO.jpg
Here's the link to join without having to register. I should be able to join & record.
 
Last edited:
Back