David Steel / LazerPig / Ricewynd / Malquistion - Pathological Liar, Reddit Historian, Femboy Thirster, and Vore Connoisseur

And the same can't be said for the British ships sank by Exocets, also the Neptune is a lot newer. I thought the Chinese could build good quality ships/subs for the PLA because they're held at gunpoint, has that changed now?
A neptune is a Ukrainian copy of a KH 35. Its not new. And I said submarines. You dont need a ship to be able to withstand hundreds of meters of water, it needs to float. Big difference.
Also, one of the Exocets that hit the stark failed to detonate, the other, luckily hit above the waterline, and skilled damage control and a fast rescue response kept them alive.
Point is it did survive. And when they have been used as targets in multiple SINKEXs, the amount of bullshit needed to sink one is insane. American build quality is unique paralleled.
 
A neptune is a Ukrainian copy of a KH 35. Its not new.
I said it's NEWER not new, the KH 35 itself is only from 2003, and it being from 2021 still has it probably being better than the Exocet.
And I said submarines. You dont need a ship to be able to withstand hundreds of meters of water, it needs to float. Big difference.
So they'll produce high quality submarines steel, but not good steel for their ships? Despite being the worlds largest ship builders without incident. Got it.
 
I said it's NEWER not new, the KH 35 itself is only from 2003, and it being from 2021 still has it probably being better than the Exocet.
It started design work in 83. It's old.
So they'll produce high quality submarines steel, but not good steel for their ships? Despite being the worlds largest ship builders without incident. Got it.
Do you know what goes into building a sub? The best shit. The best welds. A ship doesn't require that. It needs to float and not leak. Big difference. Combine that with lesser standards from the start and yes, they probably can't take as many punches.
 
It started design work in 83. It's old.
Ok, we can shift the goalposts however you want, but the Neptune is only based on the KH-35, it's still had nearly 2 decades of improvement, it's not old.
Do you know what goes into building a sub? The best shit. The best welds. A ship doesn't require that. It needs to float and not leak. Big difference. Combine that with lesser standards from the start and yes, they probably can't take as many punches.
I'm sure the PLAN doesn't want high quality craftmanship for their ships, and all of it is the same tier as the cheap export shit you've worked with, being a welder you're obviously the most knowledgeable about all Chinese steel, including what is used in the PLAN.
 
  • Dumb
Reactions: The Foxtrot
Ok, we can shift the goalposts however you want, but the Neptune is only based on the KH-35, it's still had nearly 2 decades of improvement, it's not old.
My nigga Episode 6 of star wars dropped when they thought it up 41 years ago. That's old.
I'm sure the PLAN doesn't want high quality craftmanship for their ships, and all of it is the same tier as the cheap export shit you've worked with, being a welder you're obviously the most knowledgeable about all Chinese steel, including what is used in the PLAN.
I know steel. I know you don't. Unless they have been hiding this ability to not be shit for decades, yeah, I have little faith they can do it for such large a project as a entire fleet not including their subs.
 
Unless they have been hiding this ability to not be shit for decades, yeah, I have little faith they can do it for such large a project as a entire fleet not including their subs.
They do have that ability and have had it, which is why Chinese ships haven't sunk. You have personal experience with bad Chinese steel, you have a bias, that makes you see all of their workmanship as bad, yes you have more expertise than me when it comes to steel, but you don't know the ins and outs of the Chinese MIC (I obviously don't either obviously).
 
Can you two keep your autism in check I really don't want to have to browse 4 threads in order to get my daily militaria autism fix. We simply don't know how well the Chinese Navy(I refuse to call it the PLAN) will perform even the Chinese don't know, and if I remember my reading correctly this is one of the few things preventing them from pulling the trigger on Taiwan.
 
They do have that ability and have had it, which is why Chinese ships haven't sunk. You have personal experience with bad Chinese steel, you have a bias, that makes you see all of their workmanship as bad, yes you have more expertise than me when it comes to steel, but you don't know the ins and outs of the Chinese MIC (I obviously don't either obviously).
Yes I do have a bias that is built on hands on experience. So does every welder and metalworker alive. And the collective agreement is this: it is fucking dogshit in comparison to American steel.

Yes their ships float. That's not the hard part. The hard part is when you get hit by a missile that the structure doesn't immediately collapse in on itself, it gives time for the damage control teams to do their jobs. It must pass muster. Which the Chinese navy lacks: true combat experience. They have no instructional knowledge of ship combat. They barely had a navy in ww2. Their designs are untested and materials shoddy.
 
Can you two keep your autism in check I really don't want to have to browse 4 threads in order to get my daily militaria autism fix. We simply don't know how well the Chinese Navy(I refuse to call it the PLAN) will perform even the Chinese don't know, and if I remember my reading correctly this is one of the few things preventing them from pulling the trigger on Taiwan.
the PLAN is the only arm of the PLA that has real experience tbh, supporting a base in Djibouti and doing anti piracy is a definitely more than just doing drills.

Yes I do have a bias that is built on hands on experience. So does every welder and metalworker alive. And the collective agreement is this: it is fucking dogshit in comparison to American steel.

Yes their ships float. That's not the hard part. The hard part is when you get hit by a missile that the structure doesn't immediately collapse in on itself, it gives time for the damage control teams to do their jobs. It must pass muster. Which the Chinese navy lacks: true combat experience. They have no instructional knowledge of ship combat. They barely had a navy in ww2. Their designs are untested and materials shoddy.
Okay bro, we'll just have to wait and see how they perform if China actually ever decides to go to war, but I'd say the PLAN is the most important arm of the PLA, closely followed by the PLAAF, so it'd only make sense that they invest as much as possible in making sure their ships are actually good.
 
Okay bro, we'll just have to wait and see how they perform if China actually ever decides to go to war, but I'd say the PLAN is the most important arm of the PLA, closely followed by the PLAAF, so it'd only make sense that they invest as much as possible in making sure their ships are actually good.
Bro, I expect to see a invasion of Taiwan by 2030. The entire world does. We shall see indeed.
 
War is a continuation of politics. They know it's only the last resort if they can't get it within their sphere via more sophisticated methods.
Exactly, peaceful reunification is not, and probably will never be off the table. Taiwan isn't Ukraine, and it's population is a lot less likely to actually fight China, vs seeking a diplomatic solution. Ironically the USA would be the main reason Taiwan would actually fight, if it comes to that.
 
Can you two keep your autism in check I really don't want to have to browse 4 threads in order to get my daily militaria autism fix. We simply don't know how well the Chinese Navy(I refuse to call it the PLAN) will perform even the Chinese don't know, and if I remember my reading correctly this is one of the few things preventing them from pulling the trigger on Taiwan.
Agreed, the Chinese Navy is very much an unknown factor at this point.
 
It's a "The Chinese one is probably worse because uhhh it just is okay!?!?" episode. What does the USN need to put up with that the PLAN doesn't? All ships sink when they're hit by ASMs, the Moskva was armoured and 2 Neptunes instantly sank it. The Type 52D is a destroyer, the constellation is a frigate, I see no reason why it'd be more lightly armoured.

Good faith debate about China with Americans challenge: IMPOSSIBLE

Sir it's pronounced " IMMPPOOOSSIBUURRUUUU!!!!!"

A Chinese Type 54A displaces less then an upcoming Constellation class frigate


Ergo it's smaller and lighter

This means there is less stuff making it up unless the PLAN is using an absolute shit load of Carbon fiber reinforced plastics all over that thing.

Let's say the average interior bulkhead in a Constellation is 2 inches thick and the average in a Type 54A is 1.5 inches thick.

That's 25% less steel right there.

And so on.

We'll make for sure if the PLAN donates a few ships to a SINKEX.

Otherwise it's academic and severely autistic 😎🐢

It's called building standards, safety regulations, and steel quality, which are not the same as US standards. And no, not all ships sink. Ever hear of the USS Stark. Oliver Hazard Perry class. Built like a fucking tank. Ate two exocets and made it back home. And got repaired. The moskava can't say the same.

TRUE. The Moskva was also a floating PoS that should have been retired a decade ago....

Even then it actually (probably) sank under tow as there are pictures of it above the water hours after getting hit.

My solution is to ask China to provide a few ships for a SINKEX.
 
TRUE. The Moskva was also a floating PoS that should have been retired a decade ago....

Even then it actually (probably) sank under tow as there are pictures of it above the water hours after getting hit.

My solution is to ask China to provide a few ships for a SINKEX.
The Moskva was a mess when you look at it. In order to get this mountain of fuck off missiles on:
Russian_cruiser_Marshal_Ustinov_MOD_45164874.jpg
They had to cut weight, which meant armor and structure from what I've read. It's a fucking glass cannon compromised from the beginning. This is what I expect of China, because this was the Soviets at their PEAK.
 
The Moskva was a mess when you look at it. In order to get this mountain of fuck off missiles on:
View attachment 5938327
They had to cut weight, which meant armor and structure from what I've read. It's a fucking glass cannon compromised from the beginning. This is what I expect of China, because this was the Soviets at their PEAK.
That, and the Moskva like most Russian Navy vessels had very, *very* little maintenance after the collapse of the USSR. So it sinking hours after it was hit might have been a decision of "Is it even worth trying to tow this scrap heap back to a dock, when it would be cheaper to just let it sink?". Remember, the Admiral Kuznetsov has been nothing but a supreme headache for the Russian Navy for pretty much the entirety of its service history, and they're planning on scrapping most of the Kirov-class ships due to a lack of maintenance on the reactors over the years rendering them no longer safe to operate/sail.
 
You have now idea. Had to work with them when I was in and they are a special special kind.
I think it's related to being light armor. Cav Scouts are the same. Never met a LAV bubba but they have tires so maybe they're normal.
Honestly i just want Total Chink Death. A nation of locusts that suck the land dry and have no human empathy.
Thermonuclear war between India, Pakistan, and China. Imagine it. Imagine what we could have.
 
I think it's related to being light armor. Cav Scouts are the same. Never met a LAV bubba but they have tires so maybe they're normal.
Define retarded. I want details
Thermonuclear war between India, Pakistan, and China. Imagine it. Imagine what we could have.
It would be like that scene in Superman where Lex Luthor splits California from the US, just Asia, much to the relief of all the less spergy slant eyed countries around them.
 
Back