So let’s dig into Andie and see what we can find. Like I said, much of her early internet presence has been wiped out over the years but there’s plenty of scraps remaining and I intend to find them all and preserve them. The oldest I can find is a youtube account dating to December 2008 under the handle jaderoarsbiggestfan. Jade Roars is some youtuber from New Zealand and responded to her first video of her and her friends goofing off in the cafeteria.


Many of her videos are just annoying teen girl fluff, singing or fucking around with her dog. Jade Roars does respond to almost all of them for a while. Weirdly, she refers to Andie as “Emma”.


May 2009. Other than looking a little greasy and ungroomed with droopy eyelids, nothing’s off.
She dances in this one. She’s maybe a little hunched over but it looks more like bad posture and trying to watch the computer screen to follow along or slumping a little to remain in the webcam’s view than a medical problem. She bends back with no issue when the dance demands it around 2:25.
Suddenly, November 2009, she posts a video saying she’s in the hospital
yet again. It’s basically impossible to hear what she’s saying in this. She talks about being on a pain pump and says something about her back.
Then in a back brace, walking with a walker. I am pretty sure this is our fusion surgery. Then there’s no content for a year, which in Andie World does not mean there wasn’t content for a year. We’re going to learn that where there’s a gap, it means she was posting, but has deleted it, and we know 2010 is one of the years people say she was faking cancer.
In December 2009 she made another youtube, xSingingGoddess. There’s only four videos on it as of now, all singing. The first was posted June 2010 and she’s wearing her brace. The girl on her right is named Aubrey. Usually I don’t post minors who just happen to be associated with a munchie, but Aubrey and a few others Andie is associated with are kind of collateral damage by necessity. Andie doesn’t want us to know what happened and we have to use whatever sources are available. This means stalking her friends’ accounts, especially the ones who still run damage control for her as adults.
August she posts clips from some American Idol concert she went to. According to some AI fan site this was filmed days before she posted it. She only films the stage and we never see her.


There’s another old youtube channel called LoveableXDSinger01 that dates back to October 2010. She put a facebook link in the bio, but it’s the same dead one that was in the cancer blog. In the user pic she’s using a powerchair, but that tracks with maybe having a limb-girdle myopathy or some other muscle-melting malfunction going on so let’s not judge yet.
The current oldest public video on it is what looks like a high school choir singing “Old Time Rock n’ Roll” from 2010. Andie might be the person on the far left who is seated for the performance but there’s no description or information available. Andie has younger sisters so it could also be that she’s filming and one of the sisters is performing.
February 2011, we have this video of her singing the Star Spangled Banner. She’s in a powerchair with a head rest that’s doing nothing to support her. Her back is pretty much pin-straight so we can guess that the surgery we saw up there was the spinal fusion she talked about.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EzXtLSvnLOE
This video got cross-posted to the jaderoarsbiggestfan account.
In January 2011, another youtube called AndieLovesSinging is created. There’s nothing interesting in the biography for this one.
First extant video on that channel is from May 2011. It’s another choir video and from this we can guess that yes, in the 2010 video she was on stage and she was the one seated.
April 2011, she posts to the jaderoars account, a cover of the viral song Friday by Rebecca Black. Jade still thinks her name is Emma. The youngins might not know this but it was kind of normal to make up a name to use online back in the pre-Facebook days when we were warned to never ever use your real name. I hesitate to chalk this up to anything other than the advice of the day.

June 2011, with Aubrey again. The AndieLovesSinging account has no content for another year after this.
Here’s one of her dancing in 2011 with someone named Jordan. Again her spine doesn’t move much. There's other people in wheelchairs in this shot and if you look closely you can see the name of the building behind them: Fanning Hall
Fanning Hall is the main dining hall at the Mount Hood Kiwanis Camp, a summer camp for kids with disabilities located in the Mount Hood National Forest outside of Portland.
In October 2011 she posts a news clip where she’s interviewed about bullying she experienced in high school where we can see her very very briefly walking with an extraordinary gait abnormality. Her knees are bent, her thighs are together, her back is straight but she’s pitched forward at the hips, and she almost looks like someone trying to sneak around quietly.
So that clip was posted right after the Lexie vs. Leukemia post where she was accused of faking cancer and it’s the last thing public on her youtube for a long while. But if you search youtube for other videos
about her you land on some interesting things. The person who made this, Ashley Rose Johnson, pretty obviously has capital-A Autism. Per her other videos she also attended Mount Hood Kiwanis Camp. She did not personally meet Andie while she was there since in this video she says she hopes they can meet. She’s making this video singing to Andie telling her “if you can hear me, you can make this through. You’re a fighter.” This is almost an entire year after the Prayers for Andie posts about her being in a coma went up. I looked into Ashley and honestly, she’s great. She’s a Special Olympian and proud to be Miss Salvation Army Dishwashing Queen. With zero sarcasm, Ashley Rose Johnson is my favourite character in this whole thing and her social media was treat. Just a Jesus-lovin, baby-slipper-knittin’ gal living her best life with the support of her family and friends. God bless.
In the comments someone tells Ashley that Andie never had cancer, that yesterday she had blamed the faking on her friends, and that she did it to get free stuff. This account commenting is a dead end. From all this back story we can identify two distinct cancer faking scandals: the Prayers for Andie one in 2010 that may have just been two blog posts by some weirdo who stole her name and made up a character loosely based on her, and the 2011 Andie is my Hero facebook incident that this video and the Lexie vs. Leukemia post are about, which from context we can gather was using a lot of material from Andie’s real socials. Lexie vs. Leukemia specified “singing cancer girl” and we know Andie has the youtube accounts where she posts videos of her singing, but it could be that someone was posting her videos in cancer groups claiming to be her and she was unaware.
I know. Just let me writhe around and try to find any possible way she could be telling the truth. At this point we still can’t totally rule out that Annie or someone else who knows [of] Andie is using her identity to catfish. It’s not much of a thing to catfish for non-monetary reasons in this Tiktok look-at-me age we live in but it used to happen all the time. You’d find someone using stolen pics to claim some wild roleplay /wish fulfillment story and just assume it was an awkward 12 year old girl trying to make herself seem interesting or something of that sort. I imagine if you were a sick kid with a rare illness back then it was just kind of expected this would happen, like Gina Fiorentino stealing photos and videos from cystic fibrosis blogs, facebook pages, and youtube accounts for decades to create this character of the beautiful 23-year-old tragically dying of cystic fibrosis. I’d like a bit more evidence before saying she for-sure was behind the cancer faking.
Also in October 2011 we find this
bizarre comment on a Portland State University post about their forum rules, talking about her experience in the Portland Symphonic Girlchoir and how she went to Mount Hood Kiwanis camp in summer 2011. These are things corroborated by her youtube.


Sometime around here there was another news segment on her, showing her delivering the first of her “smile boxes” to a little girl in the hospital. She posted this to her youtube in October 2016 but it says she’s 19, and later she will say she delivered her first box in 2011. Interesting that after getting accused of faking cancer twice she suddenly has a bunch of campaigns that make her seem like a selfless kindhearted individual. I mean that could be on the level, she really didn't do it and she's trying to redeem herself in the eyes of the local community. Or it could be damage control and call-out insurance, convincing people she couldn’t have possibly done it because she is of good character and/or making them hesitant to criticize her in any way because of the perception the community will have of her based on these deeds and her claimed disabilities?
In January 2012 Andie updates her father’s facebook to say he’s having shoulder surgery. It’s the only public post on his profile.
Her mother has an account but there’s nothing public except a picture of their dog, Noodle. For reasons that are about to be abundantly clear, Andie’s parents have almost no internet footprint.
Also in January 2012, a guy named Chazza Tonner uploads this video about Andie. The kid who made this video lives in Scotland so it’s probably no one that knows her in real life.
The only really interesting thing it contributes is what looks like Andie’s dog and gear with the URL istanduptobullying.com printed on it, which isn’t active anymore. Wayback crawled it one time in the last few years but by then it was a GoDaddy parking page. I don’t know if this was actually affiliated with Andie or if she has just bought merch from them.


And this, her bio from the start of the post and pics of her riding a horse at Mount Hood Kiwanis.

Two months later, someone named Brian Hartwig started a blog called Andie’s Army. The first post is just an upload of Andie’s October 2011 news interview.
Through this we find Andie’s
other other Youtube account, StandingUpToBullying, which started in October 2011 with a backup upload of that news clip. If you haven't guessed yet, Andie has created and deleted dozens of accounts for
some unknown reason.
I looked into Brian but he’s just a weird Jesus-loving dude. If you’re a regular church-goer you know the type. Awkward and doesn’t pick up on social cues easily, probably has a touch of the 'tism, but genuine and always down to volunteer for whatever needs to be done. From what I can tell, he does a lot of work with the blind and sick through a church ministry and still volunteers with Andie on her smile box stuff. He seems to truly believe Andie’s story and think he’s supporting a good cause. And he actually is. While I have a lot to say about Andie and her
motivations for doing this, she really does deliver hundreds or thousands of gifts to Ronald McDonald House and local children’s hospitals every year and donates what’s left over to a shelter for women and children. Abraham with the squinty eyes is his blind friend. They might live together and there’s tons of videos and photos where Abraham has his hand on Brian’s shoulder so Brian can guide him. Brian’s “in a relationship” status is the day he accepted Jesus into his heart. Again I just kind of unironically love the side characters here. The friendship between Brian and Abraham is so wholesome it hurts my teeth. Just two guys eating burgers and goin on
adventures!
Andie’s jaderoars account also comes back to life here with some more singing videos. She’s taken to wearing these beanie hats all the time.


March 2012, another news story, this one about Andie joining a “most beautiful teen” contest and getting hate comments, and how she runs the anti-bullying facebook
Here’s a
Daily Fail article that mentions it in a sidebar.
Also in March 2012, the AndieLovesSinging account uploads a video of her singing and dancing to Santa Baby in a stupid hat and fake glasses.
This one is great and gives us some early insight into the total lack of self-awareness Andie possesses. Walking on a manual (unpowered) treadmill with a support harness at PT in April. Taking the tiniest little shuffling steps like her legs are glued together. A woman in the room remarks that she’s in a harness and the therapist says “by special request,” to which the first woman (presumably her mom) says, “that’s so she can get pictures.” She goes on to say Andie documents everything that happens. The therapist seems thoroughly convinced this is bullshit, by my reckoning, and keeps telling Andie to take larger steps, scooch forward, and kick a foam mat while Andie keeps taking these tiny steps and leaning her upper body forward. The woman I think is her mom asks if it would help if she uses her arms. The therapist says it would help if she stood up straight.
Brian made this strange post in April 2012 about Andie meeting someone named Linda. This video was hosted locally on the blog but the blog is no longer online so the link 404s. I’m working from an archived copy someone made in 2015. I checked Brian's youtube but whatever this was, he never uploaded a copy there.
A few days later the jaderoars account has a flurry of new singing videos with another girl. I guess this is Linda.

On the 9th of May Andie makes a video about getting a package from Linda. Linda lives somewhere tropical and is calling Andie while she opens the box, which contains a plush panda. Most of her videos are hellishly uninteresting, for the record. I have them all downloaded but there is pretty much zero value to uploading them to KF.
May 2012, a blog called
Emu’s Debuts calls her a teen hero for the smile box charity. The link is a redirect to the news outlet’s homepage now, but from context, it was the piece about her giving out her first box from 2011.
