Ex-CNN reporter says she is 'haunted' after having dinner with 'closeted' Trump supporters who seemed 'normal'

  • Michelle Kosinski, 50, took to social media Sunday to describe the recent dinner
  • The DC-based journalist served as CNN's White House Correspondent until 2020
  • She's also worked at NBC News and has been seen schmoozing with the Obamas
By ALEX HAMMER FOR DAILYMAIL.COM
PUBLISHED: 01:41 EDT, 7 May 2024 | UPDATED: 02:14 EDT, 7 May 2024

A former CNN reporter took to social media Sunday to talk about how she is 'haunted' by a dinner with several Donald Trump supporters who, at first glance, seemed 'normal.'

'All were well-educated and successful in careers,' Michelle Kosinski recalled of the recent dinner party that she described on X.

'They seemed great! On the surface. For like an hour ' the one-time NBC News correspondent continued, categorizing the Trump-leaning guests as 'closeted.'

'But slowly, over a few drinks, they began to let slip their true MAGA natures.'

The 50-year-old who served as CNN's White House Correspondent until 2020 went on to add how she was surprised by the revelation - marveling at how a 'normal' a group of people could support a politician she does not approve of.

84544663-13389955-image-m-120_17.jpg
Former CNN reporter Michelle Kosinski took to social media Sunday to talk about how she is 'haunted' by a dinner with several Donald Trump supporters.
84544661-13389955-image-a-118_17.jpg
The 50-year-old who served as CNN's White House Correspondent until 2020 went on to add how she was surprised by the revelation - marveling at how a 'normal' a group of people could support a politician she does not like. She is seen here with her husband Kimbell Duncan and the Obamas in a photo from her stint as WH correspondent

She proceeded to provide personal details about the party guests, along with some of their children

'One of the couples each attended top Ivy League colleges,' the former CNN staffer wrote in a thread that has since been viewed 3million times.

'But now that it was university time for their own kids, they were adamantly NOT letting them apply to any ivies.

'And were weird about explaining why. Though the kids were double legacies. Okayyy... moving on...'

Pivoting from the subject likely linked to recent protests over the current conflict in Gaza, Kosinski turned to the next group of non-progressive principles.

'The next crew suddenly busted out with air quotes when mentioning climate change,' the onetime Senior Diplomatic Correspondent for famously left-leaning CNN recalled.

'Again, these are otherwise smart people,' she added, insinuating that the millions of Americans who support the current GOP frontrunner are of below-average intelligence.

'Not scientists, clearly,' she sniped. 'But educated. And the dude took seething umbrage when my friend mentioned the damage Trump had done and vowed to continue to do.'

1715086809192.png
1715086820989.png
1715086824566.png
1715086830152.png
1715086843940.png
1715086850124.png
1715086861050.png

'The others,' she added, 'when they realized that a few in their presence came armed with (gasp) actual facts (NO!)-- quickly changed the subject.

'[They] nervously said they don't want to talk politics,' the journalist remembered, adding of her fellow diners: 'They realized they would be eviscerated on all idiotic points, especially on the economy.'

'My friends and I realized we were surrounded by otherwise carefully closeted MAGAts,' she eventually concluded - before describing how the supposed 'ordeal' has already left an emotional toll

'It's funny how the extremist or just wrong beliefs can't help but leak out, even when you least expect them, and from people you least expect. They are out there.'

'This dinner continues to haunt me. They all seemed so... normal.'

Many were quick to mock the anecdote, pointing out the political writer's hesitance to accept other schools of thought as legitimate, as well as her desire to not socialize with those sporting particular views.

84544495-13389955-image-a-121_17.jpg
Kosinski, most recently the host of a left-leaning podcast, has 65.5K followers on X, with whom she regularly shares anti-Trump content
84544801-13389955-image-a-123_17.jpg
Donald Trump is seen leaving Trump Tower on his way to court in Manhattan on Monday
84544803-13389955-image-a-125_17.jpg
Commenters were quick to hone in on the outspoken progressive's apparent desire to put Trump supporters through a process - made popular by several regimes - known as 'reeducation'
84544657-13389955-image-a-124_17.jpg
'[They] nervously said they don't want to talk politics,' the journalist remembered, adding of her fellow diners: 'They realized they would be eviscerated on all idiotic points, especially on the economy'

'Damn, to be haunted by conversations with those you disagree. You have my sympathy,' wrote one such user, in a post that has been like more than 1,500 times.

Jokingly parroting he "This dinner continues to haunt me", someone else sniped" You desperately need to engage with people outside your bubble if divergent views "haunt" you.

Someone else added: 'You live in your bubble.

'People are fed up with self-righteous “progressives” freedom of thought precedes freedom of speech.'

Mark Hemingway of Real Clear Investigations, meanwhile, pointed to how mortgage rates have tripled after three years of Joe Biden.

'It is truly amazing how at a time when mortgage rates have close to tripled in three years, overall consumer prices are up 20 percent (25 for food), and Russia's at war in Eastern Europe and the entire Middle East is a powder keg -- the response is "MAGAs don't know facts!"'

1715086940675.png
1715086928542.png
84545169-13389955-image-a-134_17.jpg
Others online were quick to mock the outspoken progressive's presumptuous anecdote

Others honed in on the outspoken progressive's apparent desire to put Trump supporters through a process made popular by regimes known as 'reeducation.'

'If people don't ever talk about these things as friends and neighbors, and only live in their own warped information silos, how will they ever learn what is true or false?' a post from Koinski in the same threat reads.

'How will the truth ever make them consider alternatives? The allure of bullsh*t is co-opting decent minds.'

Kosinski, most recently the host of a left-leaning podcast, has 65.5K followers on X, with whom she regularly shares anti-Trump content.

In a post published in December 2016, she is seen schmoozing with her husband and the Obamas during her stint as CNN's White House Correspondent.

She has yet to pen a follow-up to her series of posts about the dinner.

Source (Archive)
 
‘MAGAS, she thought, there could be MAGAS here. The warmed over box wine flowed through her veins….’
'My friends and I realized we were surrounded by otherwise carefully closeted MAGAts,' she eventually concluded - before describing how the supposed 'ordeal' has already left an emotional toll

MAGAts.

She was surrounded by "carefully closeted MAGAts".
 
She proceeded to provide personal details about the party guests, along with some of their children
Cunt.
'[They] nervously said they don't want to talk politics,' the journalist remembered, adding of her fellow diners: 'They realized they would be eviscerated on all idiotic points, especially on the economy.'
No, they didn't want to spend the next 30 minutes getting shrieked at by the not-so-secret journoscum harpy that landed at their table.
 
Just wait until she learns what black people think about the gays...

Also it pisses me off to no end how dogmatic these people are over second layer thinking and stats.

Like the idea that a conversation such as:

>The economy is trash
>The economy actually isn't trash, look at these stats that say otherwise
>I don't think we can trust those stats, because it sure doesn't feel like the economy is doing well
>That's just a far right conspiracy, why would our government lie to us?

Is somehow an intellectual own, especially coming from the people that fundamentally believe racism is hiding behind every blade of grass is fucking insane. That somehow they are entirely qualified to parrot main narrative talking points, but the second anyone tries to go a layer deeper and question the legitimacy of the claims being made, they're suddenly an enemy of the state.

All I'm saying is, people can say what they want about other political issues, but when it comes to the economy, the A-political/non-bias take across the board is that the economy is fucked, the data that is being used to prove the contrary is being heavily misinterpreted and once you go through it, it isn't even that complex of an explanation to explain just how wrong all these shills are.
 
That haunting feeling is her realizing on some level that she is completely insane and lives in a pretend reality.

Or a haunting feeling is that in the back of her mind she knows that MAGA is normal stuff that she actually is in favor of and always has been like most people would be but she's scared that some of these thoughts may slip and she gets kicked out of the pretend reality.
 
‘MAGAS, she thought, there could be MAGAS here. The warmed over box wine flowed through her veins….’
I suppose I'll finish:

"MAGAts could be here" she thought, "I've never been in this house before. There could be MAGAts anywhere." The cool air conditioning felt good against her makeup-caked face. "I HATE MAGAts" she thought. The Daily Show highlight videos reverberated her AirPod, making it pulsate even as the $9 wine circulated through her pounding heart and escalated her (merited) fear of Republicans after dark. "With a journalism degree, you can go anywhere you want" she said to herself, out loud.
 
View attachment 5968926
"Those subhuman Neo-Nazis should learn a thing about EMPATHY"
Fuckkk, the "gained empathy" talking point these days is fucking disgusting. The concept that all these people suddenly gained empathy at 30 is fucking clinically psychotic. Like oh yea all these people who were fully grown adults with bills, mortgages, and families just had 0 empathy their entire adult lives. They totally don't mean they saw some career criminal get kneeled on and since that was the closest thing they've ever had to an interaction with a black person they automatically assumed that's the experience of the entire race.
 
If people don't ever talk about these things as friends and neighbors, and only live in their own warped information silos, how will they ever learn what is true or false?' a post from Koinski in the same threat reads.
How the fuck are people supposed to engage "as friends and neighbors" with bargain-bin Stasi? Old bitch immediately went on social media and rang the fucking shame bell at these people as soon as she got a whiff that they're not lockstep in line with her worldview.

The icing on the cake is that there's a decent chance they don't give a shit about and/or actively hate Trump given these people's history.
 
Fuckkk, the "gained empathy" talking point these days is fucking disgusting. The concept that all these people suddenly gained empathy at 30 is fucking clinically psychotic. Like oh yea all these people who were fully grown adults with bills, mortgages, and families just had 0 empathy their entire adult lives. They totally don't mean they saw some career criminal get kneeled on and since that was the closest thing they've ever had to an interaction with a black person they automatically assumed that's the experience of the entire race.

When they say "empathy" just mentally replace it with "learning to shut up and conform to the group".
 
How do we know you're not a closeted trump supporter bitch? Going around saying things like this and ranting about how he's a dictator in waiting would be a pretty good cover story.
I'll take it one step further and say it's a great way to make her "side" look like absurdly stupid lunatics incapable of anything approaching a critical, unbiased thought. It's hard for me to believe she is this stupid so who's to say it isn't calculated to do exactly that?

That's my schizo side talking up there, but it isn't always wrong.
 
One thing I always love about interacting with leftoids is that it's so easy to convince them you're on the same team, even just by showing up at places they hang out at. And then knowing that in an instant I can ramp their paranoia to max by the slightest comment that goes against far-left orthodoxy.

The best is always giving them just a little push back. Play innocent and press them on exactly why they believe what they are saying. Asking them to logically explain their position is anathema to them.
 
I'm surprised she'd be willing to accuse said trump supporters as closeted. You'd think the usual cultists, especially on twitter would jump on her claiming shes using an anti gay slur. Especially in this context. She is after all implying closeted people are bad people, lying about what they really are
 
Back