Prison time for Florida teen who beat teacher over Nintendo Switch would be ‘death sentence’: tearful mom - Mom playing the autism card. But will it work?

1701454633395.jpeg


Article / Archive

The mother of the hulking Florida teen who beat his female teacher unconscious over a Nintendo Switch video game claimed prison time would be a “death sentence” for her convicted son.

Leanne Depa pleaded for leniency for the now-18-year-old Brendan Depa, who faces up to 30 years behind bars for slamming Matanzas High School paraprofessional Joan Naydich to the floor before kicking and punching her in the back and head more than a dozen times.

In her first public appearance since the February beatdown, the grieving mother Wednesday begged Naydich to request that the 6-foot-6 teenager be handed a lighter punishment.

“I am so sorry for what my son did and nobody should ever have to go through that,” Leanna Depa said on an appearance on NewsNation’s “Banfield” through tears.

“But at the same time, please consider that my son has had a hard life and he’s gone through so much trauma in his life. He has autism. Please show mercy to him.”

Brendan Depa pleaded guilty last month to beating Naydich over the video game when he was just 17, leaving her with five broken ribs, hearing loss and what she claims are ongoing cognitive problems.

The disturbing incident — and teachers’ futile attempts to stop the attack — was captured on the school’s surveillance footage.

Brendan Depa faces up to 30 years in prison for the brutal attack. Nigel Cook/News-Journal / USA TODAY NETWORK
Naydich has previously told NewsNation that she wants her attacker sentenced to the maximum of 30 years behind bars.

“I feel like if he gets sentenced to prison, it’s a death sentence for him. He’s scared. And to have your child call and cry and say, ‘I don’t want to die’ — it’s awful,” Leanne Depa said.

The mourning mom blamed a laundry list of mental disabilities and a history of childhood trauma for her son’s behavior — and questioned why he was even permitted inside the Florida public school.

Leanne Depa pleaded for leniency for her son during a NewsNation interview. NewsNation

Leanne Depa claimed that jail time would be a “death sentence” for her autistic teenager. Leanne Depa
Brendan Depa — who grapples with severe autism, ADHD, oppositional defiance disorder and reactive explosive disorder — was placed in the school by his intensive behavioral group home despite his time at an autism behavioral hospital just two years earlier, she said.

“I had always homeschooled him because he didn’t handle the school environment. I asked the group home, ‘Did he have to go to public school? Could he not do school online?’ And I was assured by them that all of their clients went to public school,” Leanne Depa said.

“I never thought he belonged in public school. I didn’t have a choice.”

Leanne Depa added that he should have never been near the Nintendo Switch during school hours and that a crisis team is typically called before professionals take the game away.

Naydich said she had never taken the game away from the teenager, but that he lashed out after another faculty member prohibited him from playing with it.

Brendan Depa’s behavioral issues, particularly his autism, do not constitute a defense in Florida, according to the mother.

Victim Joan Naydich said she wants her attacker to receive the maximum sentence of 30 years behind bars. David Tucker\News Journal / USA TODAY NETWORK
The teenager was initially charged as a juvenile before the federal raps were upgraded.

The troubled teen had three prior battery arrests before the assault on Naydich and was reportedly involved in a jail fight in September.

Brendan Depa is being held on a $1 million bond. His sentencing hearing will begin in January.

Here's a bonus for you, sick bastards.

 
Apologies for no archive, the site isnt working for some reason
FLAGLER COUNTY, Fla. — A student with autism who attacked his teacher's aid was in court on Wednesday for his sentencing hearing.

The attack on paraprofessional Joan Naydich by then-17-year-old Brendan Depa was caught on video inside Flagler County's Matanzas High School and has ignited a national debate over what punishment a student with special needs should receive.
The video showed Depa pushing Naydich, who was knocked unconscious, then kicking and punching her before others rushed in to help. The trigger was said to be talk of taking away his Nintendo Switch.

Depa, now 18 years old, has pleaded no contest.

Naydich said in Wednesday's hearing that she suffered five broken ribs, a concussion, hearing and vision loss, and was diagnosed with PTSD.

“My life will never be what it was before," she said.

Naydich said because of Depa's actions, she lost a job she had for almost 19 years.


"Everything was taken away from me that morning. At 10:00 that morning, everything was taken away," she said at the sentencing hearing. “I think that Brendan should pay for what he did. There are consequences in life to bad actions, bad choices. He made the choice that day to come after me."

The state then called Dr. Greg Prichard, a psychologist, to speak, along with other experts and witnesses.

When asked if he believes Depa is dangerous, he said, "Yes."

As for the attack on Naydich, Prichard said, “I would say it very likely was a manifestation of his emotional behavioral disability and his tendency to overreact aggressively to perceived slights.”

By Monday, a second date is anticipated to continue the sentencing hearing. That is when we expect to hear from Depa's mother and a special education teacher who has been working with him in jail.


“I just want people to know that I am so sorry for what had happened," Depa's mother, Leanne, told the ABC Action New I-Team earlier this year. "I’m just torn. I feel so bad for Joan, but at the same time, I don’t think my son belongs — going through what he’s going through right now. That, yeah, he did something horrible. But he has a disability."

In the sentencing hearing, the state asked Naydich if there was anything she wanted to tell the judge regarding what she thinks should happen to Depa.

“Life is about rules and responsibilities, and nobody is above that. Including Brendan," Naydich said.

-

I totally believe the allegations of PTSD here will be long term and I wanted to put a personal anecdote in here because I recently interviewed a teacher who was brutally assaulted by a sped. The teacher worked one on one with this student for months and out of nowhere he just snapped, punching her in the face and chest multiple times. She is fine physically outside of some black eyes, but the emotional damage is intense. "I just dont know how to process this, I thought we had a connection, I trusted him" She broke down in tears and I had to pause the interview to let her compose herself to finish the story. The breach of trust was harder then the pain.

This is such a common occurrence I am learning. Not the extent that nintendo switch kid did, but constant assaults by speds to young women in the field. They have to learn many types of holds and escalations as part of the job but it seems like its never enough, I've taken reports of 6 year old kids overpowering grown women. If you are curious about where these speds actually are, just google "Autism therapy centers near me" I bet you have half a dozen within driving distance you didnt even know about.
 
I forgot about this case. I will forever stand by my opinion that this hulking nigger should be in prison for a long time because just taking him back isn't OK anymore and they his adoptive mother should have to sit in the stocks and be publicly tomatoed.
Retards like that are coddled spoiled brats that need to absolutely have negative consequences for their actions without random third parties jumping in to enable them.
 
"I just dont know how to process this, I thought we had a connection, I trusted him" She broke down in tears and I had to pause the interview to let her compose herself to finish the story. The breach of trust was harder then the pain.
Emotions are painful for autists, especially if there are cognitive impairments on top of that. The connection they had was exactly why he lashed out. I really feel for your teacher. Friendships for, and with autists are very much The Hedgehog's Dilemma.
 
Brendan Depa — who grapples with severe autism, ADHD, oppositional defiance disorder and reactive explosive disorder

"Reactive explosive disorder" sounds like a diagnosis a vet would give to a dog. Lmao

In all honesty, he just needs to be sent to a mental hospital and drugged out drooling in a chair for the rest of his life. He seems to be a lower functioning autist. I wonder if he would even understand prison.

Also lol at doing school online. I saw during the lockdowns, even the best students had problems with the format. There was no chance for this sped ever to succeed like that. He just needs 24/7 tard wrangling. He needs the mental institution.
Why put him in a mental institution? Put him in a zoo or circus.
 

Special sentencing requirements.

I know it's nice to go yea fucker isn't functional throw him in prison, BUT there are grades of prison for the manageability of inmates - This guy while mentally handicapped would get fucked up in GenPop so to prevent issues going ahead it needs some assessment, for his sake let alone other inmates or the custodians.

Historically people like him would have been thrown into a deep level of a prison an just left to sort its own thing out, the problem with the modern world is we think people with problem can become normal people with assistance, it will work for some but not all an that's what institutions used to be for, in the past it became a wild west but killing it off wasnt the answer some people are just too far gone or too far outside of normal that they need a special environment life long, and this guy is clearly one of them.

He can't be a normal functioning person, he can't exist without a lot of assistance and is of a size to be considered a threat to most people (I'm the same size or close to it an weight as this guy and if he rocked up to me I'd consider it a serious threat). let alone an average person, he needs active management.
 
Mainstreaming tards has been a disaster for education. I heard about this one case where a tard who was 9 years old but already sexually mature and physically imposing repeatedly raped another sped boy anally because the wranglers were too busy fucking around on their phones to properly supervise their charges. The poor victim had to drop out of school because everyone knew about it, and he and his grandma had to take the settlement the school district gave them and move out of town, because they were in public housing and the kid literally couldn't go outside without being tormented about what happened to him. I don't know what ever happened to him, but the rapist graduated to adults and raped a couple of elderly women during break-ins. It turned out that Mommy's boyfriend had been raping him for years and he was obviously acting out what had happened to him.
 
I don't know how US mental institutions are, but I expect them to be soy and house innocent retards, too, with various restrictions on what personnel can do, to protect patient dignity.
You would be wrong. They tranquilize any violent patients like zoo animals and there are a shocking number of rapes there. It's society's refuse, nobody is paying attention to what happens there. And nobody listens to crazy people anyway.
 
Back