Anime/Manga - Discuss Japanese cartoons and comics here; NO CULTURE WAR DOOMPOSTING!

Little_Busters!_game_cover.jpg
I'm over 3 hours into little busters the VN. Thing is I watched 10 episodes of the anime a year ago. This is one of the times the book is better. It didn't adapt well. The anime missed a lot of what makes the game special, and when it tried adapting some of the goofy shit like the fight mechanics, it was a mess. Short review, read the VN.
 
Is El Hazard good? The animation looks beautiful.
I am going to keep this vague enough to not spoil you if you decide to watch everything. It has been a while since I have watched the animes so I may get a few details wrong.

The first OVA is pretty good, but kind of falls apart at the end (The "protag" goes from being just there to kind of being a gary stu). Not in a way that leaves a bad taste in your mouth, but it could have been better. Fucking amazing animation and moments throughout. Questionable writing at times is its biggest flaw, but a lot makes up for it. The ending is also satisfying enough that you can just stop here and not really miss much.
It is by the same studio that did the Tenchi OVAs(A few writers too), so if you like that you will like El Hazard as well. Its almost too good considering the gag its based around...

What comes after it is... interesting. The second OVA downgrades the animation, music, and especially the writing (particularly flanderizes some characters). I'd recommend watching it only because of how uniquely bad it is. I don't think I have seen an anime where it was clear everyone involved had no idea what the wanted to do with the setting. I like the villain's design, but her motivation practically non-existent. Apparently she was based on a character from a game-tie in that used geomancy (You see this in the intro) as well as other important factors, but that was all clearly scrapped early in production. There had to be some sort of development hell for the second OVA, but that sorry is likely behind a language barrier if it exists.

The third OVA solves the problem of not knowing what to do with the setting by simply taking everyone to a completely different one. The art style changed, but it isn't has bad as the second OVA got at times. Think tv animation quality. Its mid at best, and got its episode count cut in half midway through production. I have no idea what was originally planned considering how little was actually there. It has a really thin plot and drags on till the second half. It has been a while but I found the second half fun (May have been Stockholm at that point). It would have worked better maybe as a 6 episode max series. Some characters get flanderized even harder, and there is a lot of missed opportunity.

Wanderers is one of the worst animes I have seen in my life. Not in a fun bad way, but in an extremely by the books bland bad. They turn the protagonists into an extremely annoying gary stu. It feels like at times he is written to be almost aware the universe will just bend over backwards for him at times. Not in a self aware way, in a "oh he is totally cool you gotta love him right audience!?!?" kind of way. All the fun and mystery of the setting is completely non-existent, and the writing is insanely weak in comparison. Every episode feels like a filler episode. It would almost be completely unnoteworthy if not what the writers tried near the end of the series. Perhaps someone on the writing team actually noticed the protagonist was a gary stu. I say they because they just start pretending he had character development. Not actually retconning anything, but just have dialog/visual moments suggesting that he was a more cowardly character that grew into hero. I could go on in more detail. There is ONE good episode about two side characters (practically the protags in the original) that is fun though. If you just really like bland 90s cheap tv anime, Wanderers is that in its most distilled form.

TL;DR El Hazard's first OVA is fun and much better than it should be. The second is interesting bad. The Third is boring. Wanderers is just.. bad.
 
I can’t understand the appeal of Gintama. I read a good bit of it, but I can’t get into it. It just seems like the mangaka couldn’t settle on an idea. The serious moments are cliche, the parody moments feel like the same three jokes, and the culture jokes feel like he stole posts off of 2chan.
 
View attachment 5976048
I'm over 3 hours into little busters the VN. Thing is I watched 10 episodes of the anime a year ago. This is one of the times the book is better. It didn't adapt well. The anime missed a lot of what makes the game special, and when it tried adapting some of the goofy shit like the fight mechanics, it was a mess. Short review, read the VN.
Which version are you playing? I found a copy on the Switch for a nice price and I'm thinking about trading for it. Is this the one with the weird girl that has a German sounding name that speaks random English?
 
It didn't adapt well. The anime missed a lot of what makes the game special, and when it tried adapting some of the goofy shit like the fight mechanics, it was a mess.
It was J.C. Staff, what'd you expect? It was putting me to sleep.

When there's a sale going on and I have some pocket change, I'll grab it on Steam.
 
Frieren was the first weebshit in a while that respected not only the characters and story, but most importantly the viewer.
You say that but I don't think any arc has ever been as much filler as the Mage Exam arc. Granted I am only watching the anime and have not picked up the manga yet so my opinion is limited in that regard, but from an anime only experience thus far, the Mage Arc feels entirely like a waste of time.

We know Frieren is going to ace every test that happens because she's the most powerful living mage and its probably not even going to be difficult, which means that the arc is actually about Fern, but the story doesn't really follow Fern so what character development she is probably having we're not getting to see.

So what we're actually getting is a slow, plodding storyline of Frieren helping randos that we just met while characters we care about like Stark are sidelined, and I actually could not care less. I really liked everything leading up to the Mage Exams because it fleshed out the world, developed the characters etc. The Mage exams just feel like a very slow excuse for a tournament arc of sorts.
 
You say that but I don't think any arc has ever been as much filler as the Mage Exam arc. Granted I am only watching the anime and have not picked up the manga yet so my opinion is limited in that regard, but from an anime only experience thus far, the Mage Arc feels entirely like a waste of time.
If it helps, like I mentioned a few pages back, it turns out to be important setup for new characters and plot leads that kicks off the overarching story seeds in the manga (but then it goes back to the pattern of travel episodes with only occasional major arc sections).

I think everyone agrees it feels out of place in the show though. You don't get the context for why it isn't a waste of time until later, but I guess they wanted to end on a major event.
Nothing like that happens again, thankfully. Future arc sections go back to being more like the Aura thing.
 
Which version are you playing? I found a copy on the Switch for a nice price and I'm thinking about trading for it. Is this the one with the weird girl that has a German sounding name that speaks random English?
It's the steam version and yes.
It was J.C. Staff, what'd you expect? It was putting me to sleep.

When there's a sale going on and I have some pocket change, I'll grab it on Steam.
I have a love hate relationship with J.C. Staff. When they go all out like with raildex, it's good shit. When they don't, it's a lot of pretty still frames with not much animation going on. But yeah, check it out when you can. It's on sale now btw.
 
  • Like
Reactions: The Token Ethnic
It has made grown men cry apparently. It seems to be a lot of peoples top pick for best anime of the season
I'd say it really makes you reflect on the past. Wishing that you appreciated those fleeting moments and thinking back to those instances where you didn't do or say what you wanted to. It's definitely well done and quite the mid-life crisis anime lol (but it's not for everyone)
 
  • Like
Reactions: 56 others
You say that but I don't think any arc has ever been as much filler as the Mage Exam arc. Granted I am only watching the anime and have not picked up the manga yet so my opinion is limited in that regard, but from an anime only experience thus far, the Mage Arc feels entirely like a waste of time.

We know Frieren is going to ace every test that happens because she's the most powerful living mage and its probably not even going to be difficult, which means that the arc is actually about Fern, but the story doesn't really follow Fern so what character development she is probably having we're not getting to see.

So what we're actually getting is a slow, plodding storyline of Frieren helping randos that we just met while characters we care about like Stark are sidelined, and I actually could not care less. I really liked everything leading up to the Mage Exams because it fleshed out the world, developed the characters etc. The Mage exams just feel like a very slow excuse for a tournament arc of sorts.
I agree, and add that I feel like in some way it made the world building worse by turning magic from something that can be studied and improved into glorified Jojo stands. None of the new characters got enough spotlight to make a reappearance meaningful since they are all walking tropes. And the whole setup is lazy - "you need to be a god tier mage (which there are only 5 of) to advance beyond this line", maybe if it was the final stretch of the journey but I guess there are still villages they'll meet there that somehow exist despite the blockade.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Lone MacReady II
I'd say it really makes you reflect on the past. Wishing that you appreciated those fleeting moments and thinking back to those instances where you didn't do or say what you wanted to. It's definitely well done and quite the mid-life crisis anime lol (but it's not for everyone)
I tried to watch Neo Ranga and it was super annoying how they kept getting 1 good shot in at the opponent and then wouldn't shut the fuck up about how they just won every battle from now until the end of time. It became a lot more enjoyable when I realized the pilots were lolcows in giant mecha suits coping about losing WW2. Definitely an anime deserving of a comedic fandub where they just talk mad shit at each other the whole time like its a MW2 lobby.

Also found it retarded that they kept putting infantry within splatter range of the giant mechs and seems to be a giant oversight by the writer that they never squashed anyone even by accident. Evangelion at least put them at a distance with armored units or didn't have them fighting the giant doomsday machine of the week at all. At least there's always Patlabor that did that aspect right.
 
  • Like
Reactions: The Token Ethnic
Frieren was the first weebshit in a while that respected not only the characters and story, but most importantly the viewer.
Maybe because it was the first fantasy anime in forever to actually take LOTR tropes seriously, like the issues that come with mortals and immortals loving each other... It isn't overly edgy and it focused more on world building than you expected, with places/people often having relevant Germanic names (staying faithful to the European myths that Tolkien adapted). They even use the Prußen "ß". There isn't a nigger elf (with caucazoid features) shoved in to be the "dark palette swap" for the actual elf. There's nobles who actually have to lead their people well instead of being modern day vectors for Martin-tier political critique/denigration. Demons - i.e. evil creatures are actually Evil instead of (once again) being used as a vector for Martin-tier faggots to say, "Everyone is actually shit deep down huuuuur".

Frieren was definitely refreshing in that regard.
So what we're actually getting is a slow, plodding storyline of Frieren helping randos that we just met while characters we care about like Stark are sidelined, and I actually could not care less. I really liked everything leading up to the Mage Exams because it fleshed out the world, developed the characters etc. The Mage exams just feel like a very slow excuse for a tournament arc of sorts.
I agree that, future prep aside, the mage arc wasn't as good when compared to the first 18/19 episodes. Unless my memory is as dogshit as Voll's, the last actual demon slaying that "Frieren the slayer" (cliché nickname) does is in episode 10... Episode 10, which has the only meme that anyone seems to remember from the show i.e. "Aura kill yourself", because "Haha Frieren say funny gamer words!". Modern audiences really don't deserve good content that respects them because most are mongoloid retards who don't appreciate the world building anyway.
 
Back