Greer v. Moon, No. 20-cv-00647 (D. Utah Sep. 16, 2020)

[reptile baht spaniard rid]

but its grounds shall be limited to intervening circumstances of a substantial or controlling effect or to other substantial grounds not previously presented

Would transferring the whole fucking case out of the district be an "intervening circumstance"?

Also no need to be too blackpilled about this, as the case hasn't even been decided, all that has been decided is that there MIGHT be a case, get Florida to rule that the 10th was full of shit.

 

[Useful_Mistake]

The docket was just updated:

https://www.supremecourt.gov/search.aspx?filename=/docket/DocketFiles/html/Public/23-958.html

 

[he who has thus come/gone]

This still leaves open the possibility of setting a contradicting precedent in the Eleventh Circuit, and then Greer appealing on the basis of a self-created circuit split to the Supreme Court. That would be even funnier. It's not over yet Kiwisisters.

 

[Useful_Mistake]

Would transferring the whole fucking case out of the district be an "intervening circumstance"?

I don't know, but I wouldn't assume so.

 

[Harvey Danger]

Lawyers also use Circuit rulings as citations in support of their case; suggest that they cite it until SCOTUS is forced to address

I'm only a casual SCOTUS observer, but I've noticed that when they issue opinions necessitated on circuit splits they usually have several different rulings in hand that get cited at the beginning. They seem to care once the split is noticed and apparent. When Obergefell vs Hodges was taken up on the Constitutionality of gay marriage bans, they were dealing with 6 cases in 4 states, and only 1 ruling that upheld a gay marriage ban.

So if I give SCOTUS (clerks) the benefit of the doubt here, they're operating on a historical "show the damage" basis, instead of a "repair all issues" mode. They're waiting to see if this is anything more than a small, acceptable circuit difference. I don't think they understood the case facts, and considered it a meaningless interpretation difference. They want a showing of actual damage to be moved to action, and this case hasn't even progressed to a basic level yet.

Spoiler: political speculation

Reading the tea leaves further (because I despise John Roberts), this is a court that has overturned Roe vs Wade, tossed out affirmative action, and smacked down Colorado for excluding Trump from the ballot. They're currently dealing with multiple gun lawsuits, fundamental abortion/birth control questions (fallout of their own decision), multiple federal overreach cases, plus a big Trump case around core issues of Presidential powers



I think the current Court is looking to only deal with huge transformative issues right now. There's nothing on there that deals with smaller legal errors like this, or any circuit splits that I can tell. Maybe they're in a mood.

Roberts is famously deferential to legislatures and fait accompli situations--he yelled at the court until they refused to deal with the 2020 election--but the Court has been more willing to tackle big issues since 2021. Maybe they're in "fix everything before court packing gets pushed through mode". Or maybe the more recent diversity hire justices hamper their ability to deal with finely detailed legal problems, and they're forced to stick to big issue activism.

 

[Andoxico]

If they're going to take us down they'll have to break the Internet and the law as we know it to do so. It's not over, kiwibros, we have a lot more damage to do!

 

[Null]

If they're going to take us down they'll have to break the Internet and the law as we know it to do so. It's not over, kiwibros, we have a lot more damage to do!

Based and Samson-pilled. It keeps me going, knowing that the world will be so much worse off after I'm through with it.

 

[Rain Team Pepe]

When every possible legal avenue has been exhausted Mod a Killdozer into GTA6 and let off some steam.

 

[BULLY HUNTER_78]

View attachment 5985664

good to know

Kafka remains the only legal expert I trust to predict the outcome of this case.

 

[Pedophobe]

I predict Rekieta will briefly find court reporting interesting again.

 

[reptile baht spaniard rid]

When every possible legal avenue has been exhausted Mod a Killdozer into GTA6 and let off some steam.
View attachment 5985707

Kiwifarms, Killdozer, a website. When all is said and done, the farms will have run through centuries of laws like a killdozer through a shitty building.

 

[not william stenchever]

View attachment 5985664

good to know

Stand upon the ashes of billions sneeded and ask their ghosts if honor is meritorious.

 

[God's strongest milkman]

Based and Samson-pilled. It keeps me going, knowing that the world will be so much worse off after I'm through with it.

The real question is, what is the worst thing you could involve yourself in for the continued health and stability of the U.S social and legal machine? As you are so devoured by the great mouth and it's many teeth, be made of poison and be it's last meal.

 

[BULLY HUNTER_78]

Stand upon the ashes of billions sneeded and ask their ghosts if honor is meritorious.

I like to believe god has a sense of humor. I bet the day these Jewish faggots finish turning the Internet into a perfectly manicured, little walled garden will be the day that we’re hit wit with a massive solar flare that’ll wipe the slate clean. The DEI competency crisis powerbrokers don’t understand how the Internet they manage actually works and I have zero faith in their catastrophe recovery.

Basically, I’m saying Null is the Lot of the Internet.

 

[Useful_Mistake]

I like to believe god has a sense of humor. I bet the day these Jewish faggots finish turning the Internet into a perfectly manicured, little walled garden will be the day that we’re hit wit with a massive solar flare that’ll wipe the slate clean. The DEI competency crisis powerbrokers don’t understand how the Internet they manage actually works and I have zero faith in their catastrophe recovery.

Basically, I’m saying Null is the Lot of the Internet.

>talks about God.
>Minimizes the first letter of God.
>Capitalizes the first letter of the word "Jewish"

 

[BULLY HUNTER_78]

>talks about God.
>Minimizes the first letter of God.
>Capitalizes the first letter of the word "Jewish"

My cope is it was the autocorrect on my phone was programmed by Jews

 

[geckogoy]

I hate jews so much (and so does God)

 

[Your Starter for 10]

Russell Greer just wins and wins.

He can't keep getting away with it!

 

[not william stenchever]

I hate jews so much (and so does God)

God is so over them that he cannot muster the effort to do fire and brimstone or pillars of salt anymore. Not that anyone else is doing much better. Nowadays when you die you get sent to the call center in the sky staffed by sirs doing the needful.

 

[The Un-Clit]

Rule 44.2 I say! What the fuck did we give money to the Lord of Shitposting for if not to be used at the very highest levels so that we can all sneed proudly?