Erin Reed / Anthony Reed II / @ErinInTheMorn / @ErinInTheMorning / @ErinInTheNight / _supernovasky_ / beholderseye / realitybias / AnonymousRabbit - post-op transbian Twitter/TikTok "activist" with bad fashion, giant Reddit tattoo. Former drug dealer with felony. Married to Zooey Simone Zephyr / Zachary Todd Raasch.

[luigismanslave]

Zach somehow got an article of his linked on RealClearPolitics
View attachment 6024320
View attachment 6024326
https://thehill.com/opinion/civil-r...ns-are-life-lessons-let-trans-americans-play/
https://archive.fo/NlTcd

welllll they can play, just y'know, with the other members of their sex

 

[Not Dr. Evil]

In addition to not bathing, Tony seems to be opposed to doing laundry.

 

[Sir Chubbis the Turd]

A: “Absolutely. So, first of all, I’m going to be talking about the fact that trans people have a history. We have always been here. We are as old as humanity itself. And I think that that’s important to talk about to start off with, because so often the news around trans people and the reporting around transgender people are that we are somehow this new thing. That we have exploded onto the scene out of nowhere, but the truth is, we are as old as writing itself. The very first human author Enheduanna was writing about the priesthood of Inanna, which is a priesthood of transgender, third gender and gender nonconforming people, so people whose assigned sex at birth did not match their gender identity or presentation. And so the first time that symbols were placed down onto clay tablets and somebody signed their name, they were talking about transgender people. We’ve always been here, [and] we’re part of what it means to be human.

Rather than show a million articles that debunk Tony’s oft repeated statements about the priesthood of Inanna. I beg you to visit this site, it is the full Sumerian lexicon. Literally every word the Sumerians invented in their original cuneiform. It is translated directly from the dictionaries written by the Sumerian scribes themselves. Primary source material translated into English. Search any random word you can think of that has anything to do with trans, transgender, transvestism or third gender, and sift through the zero entries. Search for the word “priest” and find 18 related words. Search the word “house” and see over 50 related words. Don’t take my word for it, take the actual words of the civilization that these priests lived in.
Open a fucking book before you open your mouth Tony.

(Edited to correct spelling)

 

[blue gopher snakes]

In addition to not bathing, Tony seems to be opposed to doing laundry.


View attachment 6024406

View attachment 6024499
View attachment 6024500
View attachment 6024502

Ew can you imagine how disgusting Tony’s rot pocket must be after a few days of sweaty, dirty backpacking? I bet the wildlife was approaching their camp to opportunistically feed on what they assumed, based on smell, was a rotting corpse.

 

[Not Dr. Evil]

Rather than show a million articles that debunk Tony’s oft repeated statements about the priesthood of Inanna. I beg you to visit this site, it is the full Sumerian lexicon. Literally every word the Sumerians invented in their original cuneiform. It is translated directly from the dictionaries written by the Sumerians scribes themselves. Primary source material translated into English. Search any random word you can think of that has anything to do with trans, transgender, transvestism or third gender, and sift through the zero entries. Search for the word “priest” and find 18 related words. Search the word “house” and see over 50 related words. Don’t take my word for it, take the actual words of the civilizations that these priests lived in.
Open a fucking book before you open your mouth Tony.

Not to repeat myself but how does Tony come to the conclusion that troons could have existed before the first troon modalities were invented in the late 1920s?

Harry Benjamin and the birth of transgender medicine

 

[Accept Only Substitutes]

Not to repeat myself but how does Tony come to the conclusion that troons could have existed before the first troon modalities were invented in the late 1920s?

Harry Benjamin and the birth of transgender medicine

Because there was a crazy Roman emperor who was trans. Even though he wasn't, he was just a headcase pervert. They also like claiming the few historical sources of woman cross dressing, without caring that the reason why those women presented themselves as men was because they were unhappy with the strict roles available to women at the time. Basically, they decided society wasn't fair and took advantage of the loophole in that same society that took a person's sex at face value given their style of dress.

 

[Thomas Eugene Paris]

In addition to not bathing, Tony seems to be opposed to doing laundry.


View attachment 6024406

View attachment 6024499
View attachment 6024500
View attachment 6024502

Imagine coming around a corner on the trail and running into these two. You'd start hearing banjos.

 

[Trianon]

What are Tony and Hobbes basis for asserting that "this is a made up number?"

What are Tony and Hobbes basis for claiming certainty about regret and detransition rates?

What are Tony and Hobbes basis for claiming certainty about the number of troons that are happy with their troon out?

View attachment 6021715

Just like Tony, Hobbes deboonks his own claims without realizing it.

View attachment 6021824

Tony makes the same mistake as Hobbes.

View attachment 6021828

View attachment 6021830

Tony makes the same error.

View attachment 6022056
Tony Reed is hardest hit by this finding.

View attachment 6022049

Like Tony, Hobbes cites a document that deliberately excluded detransitioners as "proof" of satisfaction and detransition rates. What a moron!

View attachment 6022375

This is the same thing people do with false rape report statistics. Because the number of cases that can be cleanly adjudicated is so small, they can say, "Less than 2% of reports are false," while handwaving away the huge middle where we can't know what happened or who is telling the truth. Sure, I would hope it's still a really small number, but it's not a slam dunk when you're just taking a smaller and smaller fraction out of the initial group and then claiming it still represents the whole. The number of people who use some kind of gender clinic and then just disappear is huge.

Zach somehow got an article of his linked on RealClearPolitics
View attachment 6024320
View attachment 6024326
https://thehill.com/opinion/civil-r...ns-are-life-lessons-let-trans-americans-play/
https://archive.fo/NlTcd

RCP usually puts point-counterpoint articles together, so let's hope the AMAC "gender equality" article below it is the one they truly wanted to highlight and just searched around for (EDIT a pro-trans article around the same timeframe. (Sorry, message auto-deleted while I was trying to post.)

 

[Trombonista]

What are Tony and Hobbes basis for asserting that "this is a made up number?"

What are Tony and Hobbes basis for claiming certainty about regret and detransition rates?

What are Tony and Hobbes basis for claiming certainty about the number of troons that are happy with their troon out?

View attachment 6021715

Just like Tony, Hobbes deboonks his own claims without realizing it.

View attachment 6021824

Tony makes the same mistake as Hobbes.

View attachment 6021828

View attachment 6021830

Tony makes the same error.

View attachment 6022056
Tony Reed is hardest hit by this finding.

View attachment 6022049

Like Tony, Hobbes cites a document that deliberately excluded detransitioners as "proof" of satisfaction and detransition rates. What a moron!

View attachment 6022375

Holy shit, you have learned nothing. This thread is about Tony/Erin Reed, not Michael Hobbes or other random troon supporters. Stay on topic.

 

[a hapless toad]

In addition to not bathing, Tony seems to be opposed to doing laundry.

That must be why he's wearing his shirt inside out in that last photo.

 

[AirdropShitposts]

A: “Absolutely. So, first of all, I’m going to be talking about the fact that trans people have a history. We have always been here. We are as old as humanity itself. And I think that that’s important to talk about to start off with, because so often the news around trans people and the reporting around transgender people are that we are somehow this new thing. That we have exploded onto the scene out of nowhere, but the truth is, we are as old as writing itself. The very first human author Enheduanna was writing about the priesthood of Inanna, which is a priesthood of transgender, third gender and gender nonconforming people, so people whose assigned sex at birth did not match their gender identity or presentation. And so the first time that symbols were placed down onto clay tablets and somebody signed their name, they were talking about transgender people. We’ve always been here, [and] we’re part of what it means to be human.

So you're saying that both sex and gender have been conceptually fixed for all of human history across all human societies?

Follow up, Dr. Reed, why did the early humans start assigning sexes at birth? And why hasn't this changed at all for tens of thousands of years?

edit: Sorry, sorry, just one more, why has the Patriarchy allowed this, including for the most powerful humans in society, over their many millennia of control if it's such a challenge to them?

 

[AfghanBlue]

So you're saying that both sex and gender have been conceptually fixed for all of human history across all human societies?

Follow up, Dr. Reed, why did the early humans start assigning sexes at birth? And why hasn't this changed at all for tens of thousands of years?

edit: Sorry, sorry, just one more, why has the Patriarchy allowed this, including for the most powerful humans in society, over their many millennia of control if it's such a challenge to them?

And also why on earth should there suddenly be drastic, hyper capitalistic big pharma intervention and surgeries which have proven to lessen life expectancy, added on to this natural incidence of troonism which has existed perfectly fine for so many millenia?

 

[AirdropShitposts]

Tony's conception of trans: just a minor piece of mental paperwork, that also you'll die if you don't get an endless list of "medical" procedures for that nobody is doing to children anyway even though it's proven science with zero downsides that nobody ever regrets.

 

[Your_deadname_here]

Holy shit. Tony's Ted talk. Just reading the transcript in his weird voice, where he's putting on that fake earnest delivery, with that sense of urgency. "Im here to tell you, chernsgengers have always existed. They've found cave paintings in France that date before any recorded history. And you know what? Dr. Cheri Popper, the famous chernsgenger anthropologist has found indisputable proof the hominid that drew it was Cherns. "

Yes Tony, paraphilias have always existed. Nobody is saying all of you appeared out of nowhere. You've pushed this agenda on to the public. Transgender gaslighting is ridiculous.

 

[Not Dr. Evil]

Tony's conception of trans: just a minor piece of mental paperwork, that also you'll die if you don't get an endless list of "medical" procedures for that nobody is doing to children anyway even though it's proven science with zero downsides that nobody ever regrets.

Amazing how there are no learned treatises or PhD holding experts on Mesopotamian culture who concur in Tony's view.

 

[Positron]

Tony's assertion that transsexualism is "as old as writing" is of course absurd, but even if that were true it is still not a reason that we must support transsexualism today. Rape, incest, bestality are all as old as time; no non-LGBTQ people tolerate any of these.

And how did all those "ancient transpeople" stay alive when modern transpeople kill themselves left and right?

 

[Tragi-Chan]

Tony's assertion that transsexualism is "as old as writing" is of course absurd, but even if that were true it is still not a reason that we must support transsexualism today. Rape, incest, bestality are all as old as time; no non-LGBTQ people tolerate any of these.

And how did all those "ancient transpeople" stay alive when modern transpeople kill themselves left and right?

Most of these “trans people have always existed” arguments seem rooted in a form of megalomania. They always emphasise the importance of trans people, with the unspoken implication that you should worship and admire modern trannies for being of the same caste.

The trouble is that Tony rather shoots himself through the foot. It indicates that trans people’s ability to survive and thrive doesn’t require surgery or hormones or even societal acceptance.

If we try to make Tony’s arguments compatible (always a mistake), troons should be the dominant cultural force in society now that they can be out. But they aren’t. Outside of tech, which is more of an autism thing than a gender thing, they barely register.

 

[behindyourightnow]

And also why on earth should there suddenly be drastic, hyper capitalistic big pharma intervention and surgeries which have proven to lessen life expectancy, added on to this natural incidence of troonism which has existed perfectly fine for so many millenia?

The answer to how troons simultaneously need modern medicine to survive, and yet have lived happily and healthily throughout all history without access to modern medicine, is, as always:

SHUT UP, BIGOT.

 

[Jacques1194]

Tony's assertion that transsexualism is "as old as writing" is of course absurd, but even if that were true it is still not a reason that we must support transsexualism today. Rape, incest, bestality are all as old as time; no non-LGBTQ people tolerate any of these.

And how did all those "ancient transpeople" stay alive when modern transpeople kill themselves left and right?

I feel like Tony would make a cognitive dissonance argument where troons back then didn't need HRT to live as their "true selves" and had to only socially transition. Also I'm seeing a lot of cope on trans subreddits that most cultures throughout history have accepted trans people until the "Evil White Christians" showed up and demoralized trans people. Hence why the suicide rates are high today. A lot of arguments I'm noticing are all assumptions that are contradicting where troons had no choice but to commit suicide, or they were some how accepted in a few societies and treated as this rare 3rd sex.

 

[Not Dr. Evil]

"Always been here" and the left handedness trope seem to be at odds with one another too. No need to excuse a sudden spike if you have always been here.