WhatifAltHist / Rudyard Lynch - History youtuber, galaxy brained, no credentials and no sex

Lindy64 said:
View attachment 6033105
Click to expand...
20th century had it's fair share of whoring, violence, and other negative things. Hell, the 60s is pretty much where the whole "Free Love" movement started out but I guess Rudy didn't think of that while writing the tweet. Also I wouldn't call the early 20th century an innocent time.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: Lowlife Adventures and Cowboy Kim
Lindy64 said:
View attachment 6033105
Click to expand...
What is he on about?
  • Talking stage
    • Is he insinuating this is a bad thing? It's a good idea to get to know a man/woman before you get married, Rudy. And it's nothing new. Courting used to be more common and more structured, but it was still a talking stage. Many many courtships were broken off so I don't see how it's any different today.
  • Rosters
    • I assume this means people who have more than one person they regularly rely on for a bootycall. That is probably way more common that it was in the past but it's definitely not new. People have always had affairs and some have multiple going at the same time. Ever heard the expression 'a girl in every port'? Single (even married men) were often not very stigmatized for sleeping with multiple people as long as they kept it mostly quiet and didn't mess around with women of too high a class.
  • Bodycount
    • There have always been people who have had more than one sexual partner over their lives. Some people, like Lord Byron, Cassanova and Heine, would brag about their bodycount. I'm sure there are plenty of examples from Asia too. Maybe that was more stigmatized back then but I don't see the point. Moreover, virginity has almost always been valued or even required in women. So having a low/0 bodycount certainly mattered.
  • Ghosting
    • This one is also laughable. I imagine it mostly happened to women. There are countless examples of women who never hear back from a man they slept with and go on to kill themselves. There's Kuragin in War and Peace. I'm sure this happened to men too though certainly not as often.
  • The pills
    • Birth control? Yeah, that is pretty new. But abortion and natural remedies that induce miscarriage certainly aren't. I'm sure many people from the past would be very interested if you told them there was a pill women could swallow to prevent pregnancy.
  • Situationships
    • Maybe I don't understand the nuances of the term, but my immediate response is that most marriages and relationships amongst most people across history could be characterized as such. You were less likely to test the waters with dozens of people. You were less interested in true love. So you shacked up with whomever your situation allowed. Definitely the norm, especially outside the elite classes.
  • Chad/Stacy
    • There have always been men and women who are more sexually desirable than the average.
  • The Wall
    • Already addressed. And dumb. Ever heard of spinsters?
  • Hypergamy
    • There have always been men (particularly elites) who slept around. Mistresses were very common in many societies. And guess what? Most elite men wouldn't tolerate their mistresses seeing other men, thereby inevitably creating...
  • Incels
    • There are aspects of this term which I do think are very contemporary. That said, there have always been men who can't get any. Whether that was because of slavery, castration, elites hoarding women, polygamy, or whatever, it's always been around. I would only add that, in most societies for most of history, prostitution was less stigmatized (for men) than it is in the West today. So it was probably easier to get laid. And yeah, if you were lower class you were certainly more likely than to day to get married regardless of your looks/personality/status. Women are pickier now, deal with it. But there have always been men who just couldn't find someone. And women (see spinsters).
Why do I waste so much of my time responding to this sperg?
 
  • Like
  • Winner
  • Autistic
Reactions: CEO of Lurkers, Jacob Schiff, Jondavis2 and 14 others
Mudkipcorn said:
There are aspects of this term which I do think are very contemporary. That said, there have always been men who can't get any. Whether that was because of slavery, castration, elites hoarding women, polygamy
Click to expand...
Even in cultures where polygamy is encouraged, a very very small percentage of population actually practice it. Most likely because in those countries it is actually difficult to feed multiple illiterate and jobless women (and the children you inevitably father).

Oh, and attention. Women don't like having to share attention.
 
  • Like
  • Agree
  • Informative
Reactions: SIMIΔN, Haffhart, Shouldn'tHaveAnAccount and 4 others
I looked at the Mr. Enter thread, and apparently the drama with StarGiant (a troon faggot who did a shitty job editing his videos) is back. I looked up what StarGiant looks like, just because I was curious and...

autismusmaximus.png


This faggot looks eerily similar to Rudy

Whatifalthist trooning coming soon? 🤔
 
Last edited:
  • Informative
  • Horrifying
  • Thunk-Provoking
Reactions: Jacob Schiff, Haffhart, Cowboy Kim and 6 others
KittyGremlin said:
zoomer doomerism
Click to expand...
Rudy’s “doomerisim” is really just autistic cope. His obsessive thinking will continually be fueled through YouTube; Jesus Christ could be born again tomorrow and he’d post some video about its effects on the “ensuing incel uprising” or something like that.

Also does anyone know his steam account? I’m assuming from his map’tism that he’s probably a big paradox interactive fan.
 
  • Agree
  • Thunk-Provoking
  • Winner
Reactions: Haffhart, Bloudwulf, Cowboy Kim and 3 others
Cowboy Kim said:
My sides will go into orbit if its solely because Mexico is in the name.
Click to expand...
In fairness I actually could agree with this dude.
We are like half Mexican at least, it’s whack. Even with White people, especially the poorer ones, their culture can bleed into you. It’s those White hombres you see around, he was the White boy in the Mexican squad or whatever.
 
  • Like
  • Informative
Reactions: Wright and Haffhart
Sorry, people. I can't help myself. More from Xitter:

Rudy has had a brainwave. How can we characterize this messed up society we live in? What philosophical framework might shed light on the exact nature of things? Ask no more as he figured it out.
femmat.png
An interesting notion. But can our great thinker explain himself? What exactly is feminine materialism?
femmat2.png
Apparently not. But if he truly is fixating on this and views it as a real breakthrough, I'm sure it will be properly elucidated in time.

Rudyard also asked his audience what has led them to having foreknowledge of the inevitable Collapse.
gu.png
gu1.png
gu2.png
gu3.png
gu4.png
gu5.png
 
  • Winner
  • Like
Reactions: Jacob Schiff, Nigger Cobson, naffatune and 4 others
Some of Rudyard’s history-related videos are quite informative. His videos on India, Japan, and Russia were pretty well research.

It’s his pseudo-philosophical takes that makes him rather cringe. I doubt Rudyard is an incel but I do think he is somewhat autistic (which he does admit in some videos)
 
  • Agree
  • Informative
  • Like
Reactions: Jacob Schiff, Bloudwulf, Haffhart and 5 others
Laughing Putin said:
Rudyard has a bona-fide alogger on YouTube, Westside Tyler.

Click to expand...
Holy fuck at least Rudy took a year to get on my nerves, the first 30 seconds of this video alone made me want to blow my fucking head off.

"My heckin dude aren't we like past the hecking chungus of a conversation that is incels. Bruh that discussion were like born from cringe my heckin brother in christirino"

Can we make it a law that if you say "my brother in Christ" you have to present what church you attend or you get stoned? I'm so sick of hearing it.

@ Rudy pls read 7 books and destroy this guy with facts and logic.
 
  • Agree
  • Winner
  • Like
Reactions: Jondavis2, L-Block Lurker, Lowlife Adventures and 9 others
Cyberpunk Meta said:
Some of Rudyard’s history-related videos are quite informative. His videos on India, Japan, and Russia were pretty well research.

It’s his pseudo-philosophical takes that makes him rather cringe. I doubt Rudyard is an incel but I do think he is somewhat autistic (which he does admit in some videos)
Click to expand...
The Japan video was dogshit, I even made a summary of it. He makes the same mistakes of overgeneralazing, reading and regurgitating somebody else's point instead of reaching his own conclusion, and leaving various points up in the air

ENDTOPII said:
> twitch
> discord
>" bruh to much text doesn't make sense"
> defends the fallout show

Makes Rudyard look more sane now, what a faggot.
Click to expand...
One fucking hour talking about Rudyard, what the hell
 
  • Like
  • Agree
Reactions: Jacob Schiff and SIMIΔN
Nachos Bell Grande said:
Holy fuck at least Rudy took a year to get on my nerves, the first 30 seconds of this video alone made me want to blow my fucking head off..

@ Rudy pls read 7 books and destroy this guy with facts and logic.
Click to expand...

He is very annoying, isn't he. Tyler puffs himself up as this chad ex-marine (and one-time bouncer) who also thinks he's the smartest guy in the room, and yet he has developed a very unhealthy obsession with bullying poor nerdy Rudyard. Tyler isn't wrong about many of his points, but his arrogance is so off the charts, I have to agree with you, he has me hoping that Rudyard kicks his ass someday.
 
  • Agree
  • Like
Reactions: Local Fed and Nachos Bell Grande
Laughing Putin said:
He is very annoying, isn't he. Tyler puffs himself up as this chad ex-marine (and one-time bouncer) who also thinks he's the smartest guy in the room, and yet he has developed a very unhealthy obsession with bullying poor nerdy Rudyard. Tyler isn't wrong about many of his points, but his arrogance is so off the charts, I have to agree with you, he has me hoping that Rudyard kicks his ass someday.
Click to expand...
General Rudyard will break him during the revolution.

I think that's what annoyed me so much. I wanted to agree with him, but Jesus man you're making Rudy seem humble. My brain couldn't handle two of them at once.
 
  • Like
  • Agree
Reactions: Local Fed, Laughing Putin and Cowboy Kim
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back