Crime Neil Gaiman Accused of Sexual Assault, Author Denies Allegations

Acclaimed author Neil Gaiman is facing multiple allegations of sexual assault, making him the subject of a police complaint in New Zealand. Gaiman has offered a response as well, refuting the accusations.

Per Tortoise Media, two women have accused Gaiman of sexual assault while in consensual relationships with the author. The allegations go back two decades, but they were first reported on in Tortoise's podcast Master: the allegations against Neil Gaiman, which was released on Wednesday. The women describe allegations of "rough and degrading sex," alleging that these instances were not always consensual.

One of the two accusers, a 23-year-old woman named Scarlett, claims she was sexually assaulted in February 2022 just hours after first meeting Gaiman. According to Scarlett, the assault happened in a bath at Gaiman's New Zealand home where she was hired to work as a nanny for his child. Gaiman says that the two merely "cuddled" and "made out" that day, adding that a three-week sexual relationship ensued, but was entirely consensual. Scarlett insists that Gaiman was "rough and degrading," and reportedly, messages, notes, and accounts from friends support her allegations.

Another accuser, identifying herself as K, says she was an 18-year-old fan when she first met Gaiman at a book signing in Sarasota, Florida, in 2003. K claims that she began a romantic relationship with Gaiman after she turned 20, resulting in engaging in rough sex that she "neither wanted nor enjoyed." It's alleged that one particular incident saw Gaimain forcefully penetrating K despite her objections.

Gaiman has denied this claim as well. The Sandman author maintains that his relationship with K was never unlawful and that he's "disturbed" to be accused of such behavior. According to Gaiman, K's allegations stem from "regret" over the relationship she had when it was over. He also attributed Scarlett's allegations to a condition she has that's associated with false memories, but the Tortoise report noted that this isn't supported by the accuser's medical records.

Additionally, Gaiman has strongly denied all allegations of non-consensual sex at any time with the women accusing him of sexual assault. He also claimed that New Zealand police ignored his offer for assistance with one woman's complaint in 2022, suggesting that shows a lack of substance in the investigation. New Zealand officers have responded by saying they made a "number of attempts to speak to key people as part of this investigation and those efforts remain ongoing." It was added that there are "a number of factors to take into consideration with this case, including location of all parties.”

Gaiman has long been one of pop culture's most revered authors, bringing to life acclaimed stories like The Sandman, Good Omens, and American Gods. Just recently, Netflix has been promoting the upcoming second season of The Sandman, which is based on Gaiman's source material; he also executive produces the series.

Source/Archive

________________________________________________________________________

Honestly while Gaiman was not on the top of my "insufferable and terminally overhyped geek culture retards I cant wait to get outed as sex predators for my own amusement" list (currently being topped by Wil Wheaton followed by Alan Moore) I cannot deny feeling that little bit jollier with the thought I may never have to hear him mentioned again
 
Apparently there's a podcast about the accusations, no idea where or who's doing it, but for what it's worth some twitter lady is live-tweeting as she listens.
Part 1 https://nitter.poast.org/redcoast/status/1808514093323587854
Part 2 https://nitter.poast.org/redcoast/status/1808604076650660238

I was gonna quote notable bits but frankly I got bored.

The general feeling the tweeter gets is that the accusations are bull, and the podcasters are idiots.
Ones I will quote are these:
The way they're setting this up seems very slanted already. The first accuser contacted a journalist with her accusations, but they found messages from her to Gaiman, even after their relationship was over, that explicitly said she consented.
After the alleged incident in which Gaiman supposedly forced her to get into a hot tub naked with him and jerk him off:
She sends Neil some what's-app messages about childcare and then adds, "Thank you for a lovely, lovely night. Wow. Kiss." Okay, she is lying.
There's a bunch of things like these, messages that make it seem she clearly consented and even drove some of the action. Not for my biases but for what's in there, I'm agreeing with this Xeeter that it may all be bullshit.

Someone else, if so inclined, go through more carefully (or look for the podcast I guess) and unearth info.
 
Last edited:
these stories sound like standard "i was a shameless little groupie whore and now i regret it" stuff tbh
don't know or care about the guy, heard he's an annoying libshit, but that's not enough to convince me that he's also a rapist
It wouldn't be enough to convince them if it was someone on the right. Fuck em. Lay in your me too bed faggots.
 
I don't know that I believe he raped either of the accusers, but I hope he gets canceled anyway. Fucking your eighteen year old nanny as a sixty-something year old man is just fucking stupid and creepy, even if it's not illegal. Anyone who tries to fuck people young enough to be their grandchildren deserves every potential consequence that arises from being that retarded.
 
I'm reconsidering some of his stories as the product of a male feminist. Calliope, in Sandman, is pure projection. "How do you get your ideas Mr. Famous and Brilliant Writer?" "I'm glad you asked about my process. I've imprisoned a woman in my attic and I rape her every night." And while I used to think Delirium was intended to represent degeneration from the ideal that was Delight, I now think she's merely one of Gaiman's sexual fantasies, or a past conquest. Red hair; sloppy, damaged club clothes; hangs out fetish club; barely knows where she is half the time; friendly but crazy. The fact that she's a literal child (or at least incarnates as one) makes it all a bit more concerning.

Amateur auteur theorycrafting aside, those messages from the nanny are 100% exculpatory. I hope Gaiman learned a lesson and will be wiser about where he puts his dick in the future--but I doubt it.

He based Death's appearance off an early goth fashion model named Cinnamon Hadley, she was a lesbian. He orbited her to high hell and back before she died, obviously inserted her as a means to cope with the fact he couldn't fuck her. Marrying the Dresden Dolls singer too is just lol.
He wanted Death to look like Nico. Mike Dringenberg modeled her off Hadley and received co-creator credit. I don't think Gaiman knew of her before that.

But this is Death now.
 
I'm reconsidering some of his stories as the product of a male feminist. Calliope, in Sandman, is pure projection. "How do you get your ideas Mr. Famous and Brilliant Writer?" "I'm glad you asked about my process. I've imprisoned a woman in my attic and I rape her every night." And while I used to think Delirium was intended to represent degeneration from the ideal that was Delight, I now think she's merely one of Gaiman's sexual fantasies, or a past conquest. Red hair; sloppy, damaged club clothes; hangs out fetish club; barely knows where she is half the time; friendly but crazy. The fact that she's a literal child (or at least incarnates as one) makes it all a bit more concerning.

Amateur auteur theorycrafting aside, those messages from the nanny are 100% exculpatory. I hope Gaiman learned a lesson and will be wiser about where he puts his dick in the future--but I doubt it.


He wanted Death to look like Nico. Mike Dringenberg modeled her off Hadley and received co-creator credit. I don't think Gaiman knew of her before that.

But this is Death now.
Neil it's called THE Black Death not black Death
 
He based Death's appearance off an early goth fashion model named Cinnamon Hadley, she was a lesbian. He orbited her to high hell and back before she died, obviously inserted her as a means to cope with the fact he couldn't fuck her. Marrying the Dresden Dolls singer too is just lol.

So he's always been close to alternative culture stuff which has plenty of overlap with weird sex stuff and general weird behaviour.

He's still a Jewish progressive cultist regardless. The odds don't look great given those traits lmao. But hey who knows, false accusations aren't underheard of.
He’s a Scientologist. I thought Death was based on someone who’s still alive. It was Deliurim or one of the others who’s based on a dead chick.
 
What? A SSF writer whose victims aren't children?
:optimistic:
"Scarlett" was hired as a nanny for his child in 2022. Give it a few years.


That one urban fantasy book: ok but incompetent and stupid at times
Stardust: bad
American Gods: bad
Niggers: bad

Fucking your eighteen year old nanny as a sixty-something year old man is just fucking stupid and creepy
It should be illegal and he should get raped in prison for it. A nanny is a job like any other, she shouldn't have to choose between having cum dumped into her and getting fired.
 
The women describe allegations of "rough and degrading sex," alleging that these instances were not always consensual.
AKA "I didn't say no and now I regret it".

I have no sympathy for Gaiman though, this is exactly what you get when you open up your relationship and fuck your fans, especially fans of someone like Gaiman. He's too much of a softboi to ever actually rape anyone, but getting crucified for false rape allegations is exactly what he deserves. Fucked around and found out.
 
I thought Death was based on someone who’s still alive. It was Deliurim or one of the others who’s based on a dead chick.
He says she's based on several people, which tends to happen as artists rotate through a book, but Cinnamon Hadley is the original and most important. Several of the early illustrations of Death are based on photographs of her, probably traced.
 
Back