Personally I'm thinking about a S&W M&P 2.0 in 40 cal for my 40 cal choice if I don't go the SD40VE route. I'm a Smith fan, they were my first pistol and I like the quality. For 9mm it's a Beretta, it's just a classic, a classy one.
I've shot Glocks, they shoot fine. They are just boring. If I'm shelling out already, I want something that fits me, something with lines, something sexy. Glock isn't me. This is:
View attachment 6201598
I want something that looks like more than a brick, and arguably has some improvements over the Glock design. That and it's not Austrian. It's American. Yes, I am the kind of guy that WILL pay more to support American workers and a American company like Smith and Wesson, that continues to innovate and make new shit. They just came out with a lever action- they haven't done that since the 1800's. What new shit has Glock done?
As a gun Autist, the Glock shares one VERY GOOD thing with the 1911 in common, which is something that other pistol manufacturers SHOULD follow, but rarely don't.
Near toolless disassembly.
You can completely strip a Glock with nothing but a paper clip to move trigger group plastic pin out of the grip, and a small screwdriver to compress the striker a bit to remove the rear plate from the slide.
Glock got this completely correct, and I'm tired of pretending that its not. That fact alone makes the Glock one of the best "McPistols" out there for non-gun people, as a deadlined one can easily be fixed by anyone with basic mechanical skills. If you can fix a sink, you can fix a Glock. The Toyota Corolla of defensive handguns. It's not sexy, it doesn't have the greatest trigger, and unfortunately, due to how polymer and physics work, a poor choice if you have a weak grip despite their size. That being said, just about every other McPistol (Polymer/striker fired gun, you can get one pretty much anywhere, like a good mushroom and swiss...) suffers from similar issues, and fall around the same price range.
I have both a 5946 and a Gen 4 G19 (among other pistols). The 5946 is a precision manufactured chunk of stainless steel, with a slide that glides along the frame like it was on a bearing, and a very nice, short, smooth DA pull that feels a lot like my 586 DA trigger. A very nice gun that is very pleasant to shoot, if a little tricky at first with the DA only trigger.
The Glock 19 does everything the 5946 is suppose to do, better. The 5946, while a beautiful handgun, its primary purpose in life was to be a NYPD carry pistol. All a NYPD carry pistol has to do is launch 9mm reliably and sit in a holster all day, which are two things that the Glock absolutely excels at for a cost significantly less than that 5946.
I had an M&P. I didn't like it enough to keep it. I like my VP9 more.