TGWTG Nostalgia Chick / Lindsay Ellis / TheDudette - aka Hotdogs in face girl

Hey, so I'm back. And against better judgement, I read Apostles of Mercy.

Well, tried to read it. Honestly, this book is so poorly written and stupid I genuinely cannot be bothered to make a full summary of the plot. Mostly because there isn't any plot to speak of; it's just a bunch of random loosely connected scenes of things happening, and Cora just kinda standing around slack-jawed while said things eventually resolve themselves. You could replace Cora with a blind chihuahua and the plot would probably still play out exactly the same.

I'll just give you guys the highlights (mostly in chronological order). Spoilers ahead, in case anyone here was genuinely planning on reading it:


There's an approximately 2 year time skip from the end of the last book.

Cora is so traumatized by the death of her Iranian spy fuckbuddy at the end of the second book, that she has sworn off men and became a pillow princess (on the topic of princess, Cora's black girlfriend's description sounds an awful lot like Princess Weekes...) So alas, no sex/intimacy scenes with Ampersand. Heck, Ampersand barely shows up in the book. Also Ampersand lives in Japan now, because Japan thinks Ampersand's psychic space chicken alien race is "neat" and grants his entire race Japanese citizenship.

The baby eating Reptilians from the first book, the ones from the first book who are off-handedly implied to have caused the medieval black plague (that conveniently spared Jews) finally show up. Its confirmed in-story, the Reptilians did indeed invent the Black Plague and spread it to humans. Also the race still has that weird dogwhistle government code name that alludes to Jews: "Sloop John B." (the Hebrew shabbat folk song Dror Yikra is often sung to the tune of Sloop John B.)

The Reptilians live in multiple secret hidden underground cities, David Icke-style, while working on their new plan to eradicate the humans the goyim : Super Ebola. The Reptilians claim they don't want to kill all humans on Earth, just the majority of humanity, in order to save the planet's biodiversity because something something global warming (don't worry, they'll leave at least 16 million humans alive. Like, they literally mention they want to keep a small number of humans alive). They plan to release the Super Ebola virus after they get around to wiping out all the non-Reptilian aliens hiding out on Earth. So plot wise, not anytime soon - since the first book implies there's thousands of hidden alien races currently operating on Earth. (Presumably races infinitely smarter & more competent than Ampersand's race of Giant Psychic Chickens).

A bunch of dumb stuff happens, & suddenly Cora is assigned the job of helping Sol (the Jewish CIA guy) track down Reptilians in their underground cities. Lindsay continues to imply that Sol had prior interaction/a rapport with Reptilians, but doesn't explain what kind of interaction. Lindsay assumes her audience has enough knowledge of antisemitic blood libel to put the pieces together (i.e. Jews are shapeshifting lizard people that eat babies). We also find out Sol survived 9/11 because he didn't go to work that day (because Lindsay can't help alluding to the conspiracy that no Jews died on 9/11).

Despite President Cheney averting the financial crisis via the powers of racism in the second book, the failing American economy is suddenly an in-universe problem. The new (?) financial crisis is triggered by America's new libertarian tea party candidate president Julian Todd, who was elected into office after Cheney. Due to everyone being terrified of evil aliens after learning of their existence in book 1, the new presidential administration/congress is spending way too much on space weapons/defense, and had to astronomically raise corporate and personal income taxes. You know, the sorta policies you'd expect from the very first libertarian presidential administration - drastic increases in both government spending & taxes 🤦‍♀️

A strong thread in the series, & this book in particular, is that liberals (in universe) think its racist to want to defend Earth from evil space aliens (I.e. space aliens that wish to destroy humanity and colonize the Earth). Like, in between multiple chapters is random excerpts from talk shows of conservative politicians being grilled by MSM liberal talking heads who call them out the politicians their "racism" against aliens. This plot thread unintentionally reads like satire, because tankies are portrayed as being so invested in identity politics they'd rather risk planetary annihilation than be accused of xenophobia.

So anyway, more stupid stuff happens that I can't be bothered to explain; they go to the Philippines at one point because someone emailed Cora a photo of a Reptilian.
While on a plane Cora's girlfriend randomly gets abducted by the Reptilians and taken to one of their secret underground bases, because the Reptilians were curious (no, seriously - this is the in-book explanation for her abduction). I guess they needed a lesbian to explain scissoring to them. After hanging out with Cora's gf for a bit, the Reptilian scientists are like "yeah nah, she sucks" and infect her Super Ebola as a test subject. Don't worry, Cora, Sol, Nikola, and Ampersand conveniently teleport over to the secret base, eviscerate a few of the baby eating Reptilians, than force the Reptilian scientist at glass shard-point to heal Cora's GF of Super Ebola. Cora's GF gets better. I forgot what happened after this, pretty sure they just threw their hands up in the air and decided to leave the Reptilians be for the time being. They were prolly worried about the Jewish space lasers

When they all make it back to America, the Libertarian Neo-Con President pardons Cora's thinly veiled Alex Jones-parody dad because he's a huge fan of his work. Cora says goodbye to Sol, and thanks him for helping her/calls him the only good CIA officer she knows the only good Jew she knows. If you squint (heh) you could argue said scene implies they were fucking off screen, on the down-low.

The tankie MSM invites Cora to accept a posthumous award being given to Kaveh. Because even two years after his death, they're still all just so blown away by how stunning and brave Kaveh was for violating the Espionage Act of 1917 (18 U.S.C. § 794). Cora, being the future ISIS-bride that she is, gives a long-winded speech about how post-9/11 national security agencies are big racist meanies that use the Patriot Act as an excuse to pick on poor 'lil innocent Muslim Americans like Kaveh. Because according to Lindsay, it was Islamophobic for the post-9/11 feds to monitor and prosecute Muslim Americans who leak top secret classified intelligence documents to hostile foreign entities. Cora's all "blah blah, Kaveh only committed crimes against the state to raise awareness of CIA human rights violations, blah blah Al Qaeda terrorists didn't do anything wrong it was actually the sneaky lizard Jews, blah blah...."

After the award ceremony, Ampersand tells Cora that his home planet's forces will prolly come to Earth soon and kill everyone. The book ends with the implication that there will be an all-out alien war on Earth at some point in the near-ish future, but Cora and Ampersand will be doing absolutely nothing to stop it because they're accelerations and plan to take advantage of the invasion chaos to enact their own day of the rope. I'm not even joking, the book literally ends with them planning to go full Turner Diaries, and take over America because *checks notes* its secretly controlled by evil militant Jew lizard people from out space - the true masterminds of 9/11 and most world conflicts :story:

I guess its possible Lindsay could write another book about the invasion, but considering that Ampersand's race is weak to metal shovels, & the new Neo-Con Libertarian President just bankrupted America to stockpile nukes (not to mention, the cave dwelling baby eating Jewish Reptilians prolly have some space lasers) humanity will absolutely win said war.
 
That actually makes me want to read Apostles of Mercy now. I read Axiom's End, mostly out of a desire to hate it, but it's just bland enough that I can't. The writing's not good, but not so bad that it becomes fun to catalogue the bad sentences and weird similes. The plot's not good, but in a pedestrian way rather than an unhinged way. The characters aren't good, but they're not schizo, they're just dull. But if I can read a novel by a performatively turbo-woke author that somehow sounds like the themes were chosen by an actual Nazi that sounds like it might be fun.

(I got partway into Truth of the Divine and just kind of gave up on it due to it being a slog.)
 
@Eventide that summary was jaw dropping. I was NOT expecting this to basically become what I can only describe as an attempt to write a parody of an author inserting their political views into their story every chance they get.

Awkwardly shoehorned-in author politics is par for the course for a Lindsay Ellis book. So many chapters of the second book featured Lindsay 'sperging about how the CIA waterboarding Al Qaeda terrorists in Guantanamo Bay is pure evil, so Ampersand's planet of psychic space chickens is clearly justified for wanting to eradicate humanity. Also, since the CIA torturing Muslims terrorists is such an unparalleled act of evil, releasing stolen classified CIA documents is the moral thing to do (....anyone else here disturbed by Lindsay's weird treason kink?)

That actually makes me want to read Apostles of Mercy now. [...] if I can read a novel by a performatively turbo-woke author that somehow sounds like the themes were chosen by an actual Nazi that sounds like it might be fun.

Lindsay is a performatively turbo-woke author that vehemently despises Jews. Which I guess isn't an uncommon sentiment among her ilk (woke lefties for the most part, view American Jews as a class of highly privileged whites who use the memory of the Holocaust to suppress brown people) - but its weird Lindsay takes this rhetoric a step further by mentioning blood libel (ex. her whole "Passover is a celebration of mass baby slaughter" tweet kerfuffle), David Icke Jewish reptoids, American Jews being dual loyal and secretly working against American interests/stirring civil unrest/causing wars, Jews having pre-knowledge of 9/11, & implying the only hope for world peace & a clean environment is a Turner Diaries-style day of the rope to remove corrupt Jew controlled puppet leaders.


(I got partway into Truth of the Divine and just kind of gave up on it due to it being a slog.)

Writing wise, Apostles of Mercy is objectively worse than Truth of the Divine. It's all over the place, and things just happen to the characters; like they have no agency? They go here, than they go there, than a reptoid Jew pops up from the subterranean depths to scare Goyim so everyone has to go to Cambodia to investigate.


@Boston Brand:

So uh, do publishers normally check submitted manuscripts for problematic hateful antisemitic content/radical subversive content glamorizing anti-government terrorism? Because I'm genuinely baffled a mainstream publisher would allow a YA scifi romance series that's supposed to be about a slutty cluster b college student banging a knock-off Starscream, to completely abandon said romantic subplot and ultimately veer into Timothy McVeigh territory....? Like, this book is just so awful & off fucking the rails I'm shocked it was printed onto paper.


....upon further thought, maybe it'll be a good thing for Lindsay's writing career when she's inevitably dropped by St. Martins Press because she lost them millions by penning this deranged garbage trilogy about when Bush era politics meets giant psychic chickens from outer space. It's obvious Lindsay's true literary passion isn't mainstream scifi. Clearly she's meant to be writing those batshit self-published Neo Nazi conspiracy books that always seem to be for sale at gun shows. You know, the ones about secret breakaway Nazi societies hidden in Antarctica and/or the moon, or how the globalist medical establishment is actively hiding the fact that a simple bleach enema is the cure for nearly all know human disease. Be free, Lindsay, go write your magnum opus about how Jews worship an evil baby genociding death God.
 
Last edited:
So @Eventide

First, okay, glad all the anti-Semitism wasn't just me. I'm Jewish, so when that ol' sense starts to to tingle, a lot of times I worry it may be just me.

Aside from maybe NK Jemisin, this may be my least favorite of the times a scifi/fantasy trilogy has essentially been "The Turner Diaries if written by an intolerable leftie".

At least I don't have to publicly pretend Ellis is some great talent they'll keep throwing Hugos at and putting the books on required reading lists to boost her sales in order to keep my job.

Sorry for the tangent. NK Jemisin is a talentless cunt. Rant over. (Ahem)

To answer your question though, yes, an editor or publisher SHOULD have caught all that stuff, to say nothing of the flacid characters, lack of a consistent plot or direction, and general aimlessness - this was supposed to be book 3 of a trilogy remember, and there isn't a single consistent overarching plot of character beat across all three books.

Of course, all of that implies that St. Martin's cared in the first place about the quality of Lindsay Ellis' work to begin with. I was abundantly clear that had Axiom's End crossed my desk, it would have been tossed in my recycling bin and form rejected.

We all know Lindsay Ellis didn't get a book deal because of quality though.

St. Martin's Press took one look at her YouTube and social media following, held thier noses and hoped her blind moronic sheep of an audience would gobble up these turds like they were chocolate éclairs.

Sales numbers though they'll pretend she's some brilliant wit, they'll watch her videos, hell, they'll subsidize her box wine and vacations for years.

But even the biggest of Lindsay's simps won't spend $25 bucks to help Lindsay pretend she's a successful, popular author.

If they were literate and intelligent enough to read, they wouldn't be Lindsay Ellis fans.

When St. Martin's stops taking your calls Lindsay, I hope that knowing you're a failure stings.
 
Last edited:
First, okay, glad all the anti-Semitism wasn't just me. I'm Jewish, so when that ol' sense starts to to tingle, a lot of times I worry it may be just me.

No, it's not you. Lindsay's antisemitism has always been very blatant and obvious. Lindsay clearly doesn't care about being called out on her Jewish hatred because A: her simp soyboy fans lack scruples, and B: her fellow Breadtubers over on Nebula are just as virulently antisemitic. For example, last week Nebula creator Jessie Gender (who, I shall point out, is not Jewish) released a 4 hour video on the topic of antisemitism. TLDR, in the video she claimed Zionist Jews are inherently racists because *checks notes* they reject Black Hebrew Israelites (i.e. members of the American founded black supremacist antisemitic hate group) claim of Israeli indignity.

On the topic of Nebula, anyone else get a hinky feeling about it? Like, for a streaming service that professes to focus on educational content, the majority of its videos are chock full of horrific inaccuracies that often come across as intentional. IDK, I can't help but wonder if the entire platform is a thinly veiled foreign funded disinformation campaign meant to sow discord among the braindead leftists who believe literally anything as long as it's presented in a colorful slideshow format.

answer your question though, yes, an editor or publisher SHOULD have caught all that stuff, to say nothing of the flacid characters, lack of a consistent plot or direction, and general aimlessness - this was supposed to be book 3 of a trilogy remember, and there isn't a single consistent overarching plot of character beat across all three books.

Wait, are you suggesting they just published the third book without glancing at the manuscript? ....could it be possible the higher ups aren't aware they published a YA novel chock full of antisemitic blood libel?

But even the biggest of Lindsay's simps won't spend $25 bucks to help Lindsay pretend she's a successful, popular author.

Good news for her simps - Lindsay's first 2 novels (hardcover editions) have hit the Dollar Tree! 1.25 each! Maybe her sales figures will finally start to pick up (....or do dollar store closeout books not count towards actual sales?)
 
On the topic of Nebula, anyone else get a hinky feeling about it? Like, for a streaming service that professes to focus on educational content, the majority of its videos are chock full of horrific inaccuracies that often come across as intentional. IDK, I can't help but wonder if the entire platform is a thinly veiled foreign funded disinformation campaign meant to sow discord among the braindead leftists who believe literally anything as long as it's presented in a colorful slideshow format.
Nebula has a thread! And it was Nebula that brought me to the Kiwi Farms in the first place. It's ostensibly a good idea--creator owned and operated platform, alt-tech to break the iron grip of YouTube--but it sets off every alarm bell in my brain.

And Lindsay totally has a token Jewish friend: Big Joel. If wet toilet paper were a human, he'd be it.
 
And Lindsay totally has a token Jewish friend: Big Joel. If wet toilet paper were a human, he'd be it.
Longform media analysis content is my go-to for when I need background noise but am not near a TV, but I think I made it through two Big Joel videos before I realized that the terminal levels of soy leaking through the screen would short out my phone's components. He's one of those men who I just know harbors some fucked-up fantasies that they hide behind a soppy uber-beta facade.
 
Hey, so I'm back. And against better judgement, I read Apostles of Mercy.

Well, tried to read it. Honestly, this book is so poorly written and stupid I genuinely cannot be bothered to make a full summary of the plot. Mostly because there isn't any plot to speak of; it's just a bunch of random loosely connected scenes of things happening, and Cora just kinda standing around slack-jawed while said things eventually resolve themselves. You could replace Cora with a blind chihuahua and the plot would probably still play out exactly the same.
You'd think after the low sales of the first two, she'd want to double her efforts and improve herself as a writer. But this is Lindsay we're talking about. This was probably trash she threw together, doubling down on the aspects readers don't give a shit about, cutting off her own nose to spite her face. But she still thinks she's getting a fourth and even fifth book despite the contract being for three. Either she's fucking someone at St Martin's, she's planning on self-publishing the sequels, or she's so delusional she believes this will sell.

The last one is likely. The alternate theory is she's going harder on the politics to pander to the crowd, but here's the thing about wokies: They don't read books. They retweet comic panels that share their beliefs, but don't buy the actual comics. They'll praise an author for being woke, but they won't actually pay money to buy it, even digitally. And actual readers just want a story.
 
It took her a long time to pinch out her third book. I thought it was because she wanted to prolong her contract as long as possible so she could continue to feel proud of herself for being signed to a major publisher but the truth may be that she ran out of ideas and struggled to get something out the door.
 
The last one is likely. The alternate theory is she's going harder on the politics to pander to the crowd, but here's the thing about wokies: They don't read books. They retweet comic panels that share their beliefs, but don't buy the actual comics. They'll praise an author for being woke, but they won't actually pay money to buy it, even digitally. And actual readers just want a story.

It's probably a combination of her being an incompetent/untalented writer, and thinking her weird antisemitic 'sperging would appeal to her woke tankie cohorts that are boycotting Starbucks and Mcdonalds for Palestine. Alas, Lindsay forgot said demographic is also currently boycotting St. Martin's Press books for Palestine because *checks notes*....I actually have no clue? I just know a significant portion of Booktube currently believes St. Martin's Press is run by evil Israel controlled Jewz so they refuse to review or purchase any St. Martin's Press book 🤷‍♀️ TLDR, lefties eat their own, as is tradition.

It took her a long time to pinch out her third book. I thought it was because she wanted to prolong her contract as long as possible so she could continue to feel proud of herself for being signed to a major publisher but the truth may be that she ran out of ideas and struggled to get something out the door.

But how could she run out of ideas? Like, literally all Lindsay had to do was write shitty smut. Just have knock-off Starscream rail her obnoxious BPD self-insert. They fall in love, maybe conceive some abomination psychic chicken/human baby hybrids, the end. Instead she wasted 3 books 'sperging about Bush-era "War on Terror" politics and Jewish reptoids.
 
Don't worry, she's hard at work on book 4 which even has a working title: For We Shall Not Repeat This Evil. As her #2 Simp JohnTheMod (Todd is #1) accurately points out, it's from the inscription of the cenotaph at Hiroshima because Lindsay is deep and smarter than us. (And I would usually avoid baby pics because the kid didn't choose Wine Aunt as her mom but here you go)
LE_IG_240808_1.png
And a random Instagram assortment of pics from the book tour and other public gatherings. She's fat and looks like shit, but hey, recent baby.
LE_IG_240808_2.png
LE_IG_240808_3.png
LE_IG_240808_4.png
Someone tell me why far-left guys make this face so often.
 
Don't worry, she's hard at work on book 4 which even has a working title: For We Shall Not Repeat This Evil. As her #2 Simp JohnTheMod (Todd is #1) accurately points out, it's from the inscription of the cenotaph at Hiroshima because Lindsay is deep and smarter than us.

4th book? Well, isn't she optimistic delusional.

With the Hiroshima reference in its title, I guess the 4th book will be about how the Manhattan project scientists were actually disguised Jewish reptoids scheming to destroy the goyim. That guess isn't a joke - like, her books are genuinely that antisemitic.

...is Lindsay still considered canceled? 'because you'd think she'd be worried about getting canceled again for writing a trilogy featuring evil Jewish reptoids.
 
4th book? Well, isn't she optimistic delusional.

With the Hiroshima reference in its title, I guess the 4th book will be about how the Manhattan project scientists were actually disguised Jewish reptoids scheming to destroy the goyim. That guess isn't a joke - like, her books are genuinely that antisemitic.

...is Lindsay still considered canceled? 'because you'd think she'd be worried about getting canceled again for writing a trilogy featuring evil Jewish reptoids.
Knowing how the left is, I don’t think she’d be canceled as long as she does the thing of “I don’t hate Jews, I hate zionists. Total difference.”
 
Knowing how the left is, I don’t think she’d be canceled as long as she does the thing of “I don’t hate Jews, I hate zionists. Total difference.”
Thing I can't stand about this whole new anti-zionism thing is that it is completely surface level. Years ago when asked about my stance on Israel and I mentioned the apartheid, the killing of civilians, the human rights abuses, the religious violence against non-Jews and the state sponsored pedophilia of goyim children (Epstein being the most famous case of it), I got rail-roaded by SJWs online for using "Nazi Dogwhistles" and told I was the problem. When I told people to listen to Norman Finkelstein and other non-zionists Jews I was told these anti-zionist jews weren't "real Jews" and they were "self hating white supremacists". Now suddenly these same fucking people suddenly hate Israel and go about it with more venom and fervour than I ever have, and none of it is based on the reasons I stated before. Sure these people will state the above reasons but the truth is they are taking that position because it is popular in leftist circles. That is how deep the reasoning is.

My position against Israel is I want rogue states brought into line and either dissolved or reformed, along with war criminals charged and sentenced (I hold the same opinion on Iran and Venezuela) really not extreme positions. But people like Lindsay, they'll turn their opinion on a dime for social status and lynch your family for instagram likes.
 
Lindsay cutting out the alien to focus on a human love interest is perhaps the most stereotypical thing she could do, and also one of the biggest things that'd alienate her core readers. They're reading for the alien romance, they don't want Cora to date human guys. How could you misunderstand it that badly?
Hasn't it been established that Lindsay is mostly writing for her own ego at this point? I'm not sure where "her readers" fit into that equation.
 
T
Don't worry, she's hard at work on book 4 which even has a working title: For We Shall Not Repeat This Evil. As her #2 Simp JohnTheMod (Todd is #1) accurately points out, it's from the inscription of the cenotaph at Hiroshima because Lindsay is deep and smarter than us. (And I would usually avoid baby pics because the kid didn't choose Wine Aunt as her mom but here you go)
View attachment 6287856
And a random Instagram assortment of pics from the book tour and other public gatherings. She's fat and looks like shit, but hey, recent baby.
View attachment 6287858
View attachment 6287859
View attachment 6287860
Someone tell me why far-left guys make this face so often.
The baby has FAS doesn't he1642664995_Alcohol_big_450.jpg
 
Back