@Alexander Thaut
My problem is that we really need a halfway competent editor to just pick the runs and go with them.
Oh definitely. And Editors are far too often making political decisions rather than commercial ones.
I mean, even the Gail Simone Birds of Prey wouldn't be the worst idea. . .
Start with Dixon and you could have forty volumes.
I think DC's best Silver Age stuff's probably worthwhile. Otherwise the rest can be notable introductions and events compiled thematically. Like, the Zatanna Quest could be a fun single volume.
Some of it in other formats. But that's more like Marvel's epic line, which I'm a big fan of. Not that I don't have my gripes about how that line is managed.
Yeah I feel like if they really want to do that then they may as well make a Shonen Jump style magazine where they just have a mainline guaranteed draw headline the book and try out different ongoings to see what sticks. The issue is that the DEI crybabies won't like finding out that their shit does not sell.
Speaking of which, I'd bet that the Birds of Prey brand's probably a little damaged at this point. Maybe a Simone Birds of Prey run could be put into tankobon volumes. The BoP were a B-tier IP that got seriously screwed by the movie's mediocrity. At least Green Lantern's kind of an evergreen IP for DC that's usually A-list now. And yet somehow we wind up almost always reverted to Hal, John, Guy, Kyle, and Alan. Out of all the nu-lanterns, the only intriguing one is Jessica.
Well, they did actually. Those Wal-Mart magazines. There was a BoP 'Giant' with a brand new BoP story by Gail and....no one even remembered it. Because Gail didn't create or popularize BoP and the damage in large sense was the result of DC editorials misunderstanding.
You talk to the guys in the shop, what material sells? The 90s. The 80s. The 70s and the 60s do to, but those are more comic guys. Nobody is nostalgic for DCyou and very few for the Nu52. Gail is the problem. Start with the 90s, take Dixon's five years of material that could fill ten or more volumes and start there. Once you do Chuck, Terry Moore, and Gil Hernandez; Gail can do what she did originally coasting on other actual talents.
post-crisis Flash is interesting. I'd probably also throw in Perez Wonder Woman if we have to pick a run.
TBH I'd also put down Young Justice as the original run was pretty coherent.
I feel like Perez's Wondy really trails off after he stops drawing it? Don't remember.
Yes to YJ, double yes to Karl Kessel Superboy, Impulse, and Robin.
What do you think about making long tankbon series about some events and tie-ins? Like the Imperiex Worlds at War one was pretty big and it's just a big messy heroic story that wouldn't be halfway bad. It's got big ups and downs for all the iconic heroes. It's all a big disaster event and the atmosphere is ultimately a big rally for everyone to come together.
I'd say collapse into a series called Superman 2K, with Volume 1 being Jeph and Joe picking up Superman and Action (as well as any necessary issues from the other two.). Fold Imperiex, Lex 2000, and Emperor Joker all into that.
It's probably a better pick than some DEI horsewash.
Bat books are usually a safe bet tbh. Not so sure about Wonder Woman.
If DC really wants to push some heroines to be more prominent, why not Zatanna or Black Canary? Zee is just right there and has a great backstory. She's got a lot of potential and is treated as a major power within the DCU's heroes.
Different people have tried. Scott Snyder REALLY pushed Harper Row for years getting more pathetic with every attempt. Punchline, same story. Then there are others. DC pushed Batlesbian like nothing else. JH Williams? Why the fuck would you put someone like him on that character for a decade? Notice once he wasn't drawing her shit, the books didn't sell?
They've tried with Black Canary but they insist she has to be written by a woman/DEI now, so that was DOA because there isn't a woman in comics today who has the talent to pull that off except maybe Amanda Conner and she sure as fuck isn't gonna draw a monthly for three or four years while her and her husband are tard wrangled.
Paul Dini has been pushing Zatanna for years. He put out a Vertigo one shot with unnecessary buggery in it. It's good except for that. He shoe horned Z into his 'Tec run which is pretty damn good. Then he managed to get an awesome ongoing that kindof got murdered by Dan Didio. Finally, he wrote a hard book teaming her with BC. IT's all solid material and....none of it seems to have drawn any attention?