Crime Neil Gaiman Accused of Sexual Assault, Author Denies Allegations

  • 🐕 I am attempting to get the site runnning as fast as possible. If you are experiencing slow page load times, please report it.
Acclaimed author Neil Gaiman is facing multiple allegations of sexual assault, making him the subject of a police complaint in New Zealand. Gaiman has offered a response as well, refuting the accusations.

Per Tortoise Media, two women have accused Gaiman of sexual assault while in consensual relationships with the author. The allegations go back two decades, but they were first reported on in Tortoise's podcast Master: the allegations against Neil Gaiman, which was released on Wednesday. The women describe allegations of "rough and degrading sex," alleging that these instances were not always consensual.

One of the two accusers, a 23-year-old woman named Scarlett, claims she was sexually assaulted in February 2022 just hours after first meeting Gaiman. According to Scarlett, the assault happened in a bath at Gaiman's New Zealand home where she was hired to work as a nanny for his child. Gaiman says that the two merely "cuddled" and "made out" that day, adding that a three-week sexual relationship ensued, but was entirely consensual. Scarlett insists that Gaiman was "rough and degrading," and reportedly, messages, notes, and accounts from friends support her allegations.

Another accuser, identifying herself as K, says she was an 18-year-old fan when she first met Gaiman at a book signing in Sarasota, Florida, in 2003. K claims that she began a romantic relationship with Gaiman after she turned 20, resulting in engaging in rough sex that she "neither wanted nor enjoyed." It's alleged that one particular incident saw Gaimain forcefully penetrating K despite her objections.

Gaiman has denied this claim as well. The Sandman author maintains that his relationship with K was never unlawful and that he's "disturbed" to be accused of such behavior. According to Gaiman, K's allegations stem from "regret" over the relationship she had when it was over. He also attributed Scarlett's allegations to a condition she has that's associated with false memories, but the Tortoise report noted that this isn't supported by the accuser's medical records.

Additionally, Gaiman has strongly denied all allegations of non-consensual sex at any time with the women accusing him of sexual assault. He also claimed that New Zealand police ignored his offer for assistance with one woman's complaint in 2022, suggesting that shows a lack of substance in the investigation. New Zealand officers have responded by saying they made a "number of attempts to speak to key people as part of this investigation and those efforts remain ongoing." It was added that there are "a number of factors to take into consideration with this case, including location of all parties.”

Gaiman has long been one of pop culture's most revered authors, bringing to life acclaimed stories like The Sandman, Good Omens, and American Gods. Just recently, Netflix has been promoting the upcoming second season of The Sandman, which is based on Gaiman's source material; he also executive produces the series.

Source/Archive

________________________________________________________________________

Honestly while Gaiman was not on the top of my "insufferable and terminally overhyped geek culture retards I cant wait to get outed as sex predators for my own amusement" list (currently being topped by Wil Wheaton followed by Alan Moore) I cannot deny feeling that little bit jollier with the thought I may never have to hear him mentioned again
 
He wasn't the only one who had a big internet footprint, and many of them didn't act like Gaimans.

Douglas Adam's used to spend a lot of time on alt.fan.douglas-adams on USENET. He really liked hanging out with and talking about his stuff with people who saw it the way he did. Like clockwork someone would come along and get weird and he would stop posting for a while and eventually reappear with a new address. He never announced his presence, but if you knew what he wrote like it was pretty easy to see he was back. He was a good dude.

Steve Martin on the pre-box wine and trannies Something Awful forums is kind of another.
J Michael Straszinski is another example of a well regarded nerd facing writer/producer from around the same time as Gaiman's rise, who was fully online with fans since the 90's. But somehow never made it weird. Of course he is also a generation older than Gaiman.
 
“Made her sign a non-disclosure agreement in exchange for $275,000.” The fucking gall of this woman to take an enormous payout, then say she was forced, then fail to honor the NDA anyway.

It’s insane that we are meant to sympathize with her. It’s unbelievable how anti-heterosexual male the world has become, while constantly repeating that straight guys are privileged.

“40 years ago he tried to kiss me too forcefully and stopped when I firmly said no!” The horror. They clearly want to make men herbivores and it’s disgusting. Yeah what he did was bad but it’s not something to malign him with decades later.
 
While Gaiman’s account denied any non-consensual sex with the two women, their allegations raised questions about whether he had reasonable belief in consent for sex with them given their vulnerability. Gaiman asked one of them to sign a non-disclosure agreement, the first of two known NDAs he signed with former sexual partners, suggesting weak confidence that his account would survive public scrutiny.
Bro dated a 20 year old while he was 60 and had another woman sign an NDA over their relationship?

I'll be real, at first I thought these accusations were funny, but false, but after reading this, I've done a 180, the nigga's definitely guilty.
 
“Made her sign a non-disclosure agreement in exchange for $275,000.” The fucking gall of this woman to take an enormous payout, then say she was forced, then fail to honor the NDA anyway.

It’s insane that we are meant to sympathize with her. It’s unbelievable how anti-heterosexual male the world has become, while constantly repeating that straight guys are privileged.

“40 years ago he tried to kiss me too forcefully and stopped when I firmly said no!” The horror. They clearly want to make men herbivores and it’s disgusting. Yeah what he did was bad but it’s not something to malign him with decades later.

“Normal heterosexual males” don’t need to throw exorbitant amounts of money at the women they fuck to keep quiet. If they did, then the so-called pussification of men would be justified. I think we can safely look at most 3rd world and religion of peace countries to see why sometimes the red blooded male needs some ground rules.

That being said, there’s little sympathy for anyone here because of the types of women he curated as fans are exactly the type to betray any man based on even a slight perceived transgression. But hundreds of thousands of dollars? That’s not chump change, he raped them, bro
 
Keanu's in a long-term relationship with an old baby boomer. He's probably just trying to be respectful by not hanging on every whore who wants a picture.
Keanu Reeves is in a long-term relationship with a woman 9 years his junior. (Which is perfectly fine for a 59-year-old, but you make him sound like our resident grannyfucker).
 
But hundreds of thousands of dollars? That’s not chump change, he raped them, bro

One of them sent friendly emails to him for years and continued their relationship for long past the supposed act. It wasn’t rape, it was bad sex — and that’s also assuming the woman is being completely truthful because these cases rarely come with evidence.

The NDA could easily be more about him realizing the public would crucify him over it because they believe all women, even anonymous ones who offer no proof. Your logic is like saying “He plead the fifth? That means he’s guilty!”
 
J Michael Straszinski is another example of a well regarded nerd facing writer/producer from around the same time as Gaiman's rise, who was fully online with fans since the 90's. But somehow never made it weird. Of course he is also a generation older than Gaiman.
That's not to say JMS isn't the same kind of perv, he just didn't do it online. No, he saved it for the actresses that worked on Babylon 5.
 
One of them sent friendly emails to him for years and continued their relationship for long past the supposed act. It wasn’t rape, it was bad sex — and that’s also assuming the woman is being completely truthful because these cases rarely come with evidence.

The NDA could easily be more about him realizing the public would crucify him over it because they believe all women, even anonymous ones who offer no proof. Your logic is like saying “He plead the fifth? That means he’s guilty!”

Pleading the 5th isn’t the same as throwing a fuckton of money at a problem, but I’m not exorbitantly rich, so I wouldn’t know. It’s safe to say most of these women were duplicitous assholes, but again, would you trust this man around your genitalia or anyone you care about?

IMG_2626.jpeg

Truly a victim of post-Gamergate feminism, yes sirree!
 
Pleading the 5th isn’t the same as throwing a fuckton of money at a problem, but I’m not exorbitantly rich, so I wouldn’t know.

I explained that I saw it as a move to counter the "Guilty upon accusation" hysteria of current year. But since you obviously dislike the guy, I realize that you're just going to Believe All Women when someone accuses him of misconduct. Your "Just look at him!" argument is pretty damn weak though and I hope you're not just enjoying seeing someone you dislike being taken down a peg, even on flimsy charges.
 
Last edited:
When I was young and dumb, I wrote a letter to my favorite author and we struck up a years-long correspondence. He sent me original drafts for my favorite book, autographed copies with personalized inscriptions too. At one point I made an obvious awkward advance because when you're young it can be hard to sort out admiration and desire.

You know what he did? Laughed and told me he was old enough to be my grandfather and that I didn't really know what I was saying. He could easily have led me on or been really gross but no, he did what a normal human would do. And we talked for years after that, until his mind was no longer sharp enough for letters. RIP Barry, you were a real one.
 
“Made her sign a non-disclosure agreement in exchange for $275,000.” The fucking gall of this woman to take an enormous payout, then say she was forced, then fail to honor the NDA anyway.

It’s insane that we are meant to sympathize with her. It’s unbelievable how anti-heterosexual male the world has become, while constantly repeating that straight guys are privileged.

“40 years ago he tried to kiss me too forcefully and stopped when I firmly said no!” The horror. They clearly want to make men herbivores and it’s disgusting. Yeah what he did was bad but it’s not something to malign him with decades later.
Who says anyone feels bad for the accusers?

It's a win/win situation from a lolz perspective: deserving target who mistreated victims who probably largely had it coming. Sophocles would be proud.
 
Back