🐟 Fishtank Sam Hyde's Fishtank.live General - Jet Neptune's Little House of Horrors

Official KF Fishtank livechat here!

Is it over?

  • Yes, I am sad and need a Ben backrub :(

    Votes: 331 31.8%
  • No, we will be back, autism too strong

    Votes: 528 50.7%
  • Cams down until we roll into Bloodgames 2

    Votes: 183 17.6%

  • Total voters
    1,042
He was done for pretty much the moment Luke came back, he was just in the background seething about him. I honestly don't think he would've provided that much more content in the RV part, if any at all.
He didn't even have a chance though because he was voted out immediately. Had he had a few days I guarantee there would have been good content involving Signal and Luke, it's just wrong to think otherwise. You really think we were going to get more content out of Payton rather than Signal who was one of the main drivers of content and who's biggest enemy just walked back into the tank? SIMBAL WAS THE FUCKING LION!
 
He was done for pretty much the moment Luke came back, he was just in the background seething about him. I honestly don't think he would've provided that much more content in the RV part, if any at all.
He'd probably try to murder Luke in his sleep.
The jeet was extra slimy whenever he thought that nobody was watching him.
 
They could have rigged it to vote off any of the new fish instead.
I honestly think they should start rigging the votes and eliminations, because the fans and the fish almost universally choose the wrong person. They always choose the most hated person, which is bad for the show, because the most hated person creates a lot of content. They should be picking the most nontent people, but they never do, because the nontent person doesn't inspire strong feelings because they do nothing.
 
So these are the redditors who have been calling Binx and Mizzy ugly for the last 6 weeks?
1733523576817.png
1733523596167.png
1733523639492.png
1733523659181.png
1733523723877.png
1733523754431.png
1733523789593.png
 
I honestly think they should start rigging the votes and eliminations, because the fans and the fish almost universally choose the wrong person. They always choose the most hated person, which is bad for the show, because the most hated person creates a lot of content. They should be picking the most nontent people, but they never do, because the nontent person doesn't inspire strong feelings because they do nothing.
I suspect s1 and 2 they did rig a lot of the eliminations but they always tried to hide it a lot. For example, the PSAT test challenge could have easily been rigged against Sylvia because we never actually got to see the results, Sam just came up and said Sylvia lost. Sylvia was also most certainly the right choice to go home though regardless of what the real results were which is why I strongly suspect they were rigged.

Sometimes fans demanding a fish be kicked from the show is a good thing too, like in s2 with Brian. The wiggers made it very clear that Brian was their favorite of the s2 contestants post-Cole and didn't want to kick him, yet the fans ALL demanded he get kicked (seemingly no one in the s2 audience wanted Brian around anymore in a literal sense) and the wiggers fully obliged surprisingly. Brian was a good character to have around while Cole was in the tank because they were the main enemies of each other but without Cole, Brian made the show insufferable to watch. So it was actually a good thing they kicked Brian for no other reason than the fans hated his guts.

I think having more fluid eliminations like the first 2 seasons works better for the chaotic nature of the show and it can help safeguard against people like Binx, Payton, Sylvia, or Brian overstaying their welcome while making sure people like Mizzy, Simbal, or Letty aren't punished for acting outside of the group mentality and being competitive
 
I suspect s1 and 2 they did rig a lot of the eliminations but they always tried to hide it a lot. For example, the PSAT test challenge could have easily been rigged against Sylvia because we never actually got to see the results, Sam just came up and said Sylvia lost. Sylvia was also most certainly the right choice to go home though regardless of what the real results were which is why I strongly suspect they were rigged.
I always thought this about the PSAT test too. It felt like production knew Sylvia was the weakest of the remaining cast and the test was just kind of window dressing for her getting kicked off. It was never going to be Letty, Josie or Vance. Sidenote: I think Sylvia did really well on the show and is underrated as a fish. She was generally a good sport and put up with a ton of hassling both from TTS and Frank. When she did freakout it was good content too. The season 1 cast was just filled with people who were in it to win. Four people who were completely down to go to the end.
 
I suspect s1 and 2 they did rig a lot of the eliminations but they always tried to hide it a lot. For example, the PSAT test challenge could have easily been rigged against Sylvia because we never actually got to see the results, Sam just came up and said Sylvia lost. Sylvia was also most certainly the right choice to go home though regardless of what the real results were which is why I strongly suspect they were rigged.

Sometimes fans demanding a fish be kicked from the show is a good thing too, like in s2 with Brian. The wiggers made it very clear that Brian was their favorite of the s2 contestants post-Cole and didn't want to kick him, yet the fans ALL demanded he get kicked (seemingly no one in the s2 audience wanted Brian around anymore in a literal sense) and the wiggers fully obliged surprisingly. Brian was a good character to have around while Cole was in the tank because they were the main enemies of each other but without Cole, Brian made the show insufferable to watch. So it was actually a good thing they kicked Brian for no other reason than the fans hated his guts.

I think having more fluid eliminations like the first 2 seasons works better for the chaotic nature of the show and it can help safeguard against people like Binx, Payton, Sylvia, or Brian overstaying their welcome while making sure people like Mizzy, Simbal, or Letty aren't punished for acting outside of the group mentality and being competitive
For S1 and S2 it makes a lot of sense. But for S3 they invited people who didn't know about FT in the first place and used the FH as a cover. As soon as FT started, they should've gone harder on them and eliminated the ones who didn't provide content/drama. Out of the people you mentioned, Binx actually did create drama to fuck with the other contestants. But she needed a push and it shouldn't have happened in the first place. However, she still did deliver.
Payton instead should've been gone weeks ago.
 
Last edited:
For S1 and S2 it makes a lot of sense. But for S3 they invited people who didn't know about FT in the first place and used the FH as a cover. As soon as FT started, they should've gone harder on them and eliminated the ones who didn't provide content/drama.
For sure, Ian should have been the only one voted out. They should have set up a fake voting elimination after the Fishtank reveal that rubs in their face that it's rigged to prove a point to them of what kind of show they're on and throw out the voting eliminations as a whole after that.

And I still think that Famous House 2.0 should have been styled after s2 and made up of fans with more hardcore challenges right off the bat.
 
The only good reason to ever eliminate someone is if they actively make the show worse or if they provide so little content that it's not worth feeding them. Trish clearly wasn't the winner but she contributed enough to be worth having her there, so they eliminated her when she was the only option left and let her stay anyway. That's the best way to do the eliminations in my opinion.

During Famous House there has to be some kind of "game" that the fish think they're playing, (rigged) elimination votes make sense for that, but depending on how hard it's rigged and when the timing of the elimination is it could break the illusion to fast. Ian being voted would have been harder to rig since very few people voted against him, but the 2.0 elimination would have been incredibly easy if the rug pull was the very next day.

The final two this season had to be Burt and Binx: Burt was most entertaining, and Binx made the most money on plushies. Simbal was a huge mistake, and Mizzy was probably also a mistake. The Simbal elimination should have been rigged, and the Mizzy elimination just shouldn't have happened.

The problem with the Simbal elimination was that they were trying to run the show in two directions simultaneously: Jet and the fish thought the game was to eliminate the other fish, and that's the game Binx played. It's a good idea for a game, but it's a completely different game than Fishtank. Sam and the audience thought the goal was to eliminate the new fish by forcing them to quit before they have the time and numbers to vote out the old fish, which is exactly the sort of game Fishtank is, and could also work well, but it doesn't work if the fish were directly told they were trying to be low profile and vote each other out via manipulation.
 
Back