Opinion Trump repeats ‘51st State’ jab and false trade-deficit claims - Trump’s 51st state jokes a bullying technique, former adviser to Trudeau says

Donald Trump is repeating his contention that the U.S. should annex Canada, ratcheting up his rhetoric amid threats of a continental trade war.

In a social media post at 3.23 am Eastern Time Wednesday, the U.S. President-elect also repeated his false assertion that the U.S. has a US$100-billion trade deficit with Canada.

“No one can answer why we subsidize Canada to the tune of over $100,000,000 a year? Makes no sense! Many Canadians want Canada to become the 51st State,” Mr. Trump wrote on his Truth Social platform. “They would save massively on taxes and military protection. I think it is a great idea. 51st State!!!”

While there is no serious movement in either country for Canada to join the U.S., Mr. Trump has now made variations of the comment several times, seemingly to needle Prime Minister Justin Trudeau.

Mr. Trump is threatening to impose tariffs of 25 per cent on all Canadian and Mexican goods entering the U.S. when he takes office on Jan. 20. The President-elect has said the levies are meant to force the two other North American countries to stop migrants and fentanyl crossing their borders into the U.S.

But Mr. Trump has also repeatedly raised the trade deficit, which most economists dismiss as unimportant but which he views as a scorecard for economic success.
According to U.S. figures, the country’s trade deficit with Canada in 2022, the last year for which it has published numbers, was US$53.5-billion on more than US$900-billion worth of trade.

That deficit is mostly related to crude oil, of which the U.S. imports more than 1.6 billion barrels a year from Canada to make up for its own shortages. Imposing a tariff on it would likely significantly drive up gasoline prices for U.S. consumers.

Mr. Trump first made his “51st state” comment to Mr. Trudeau during their dinner at Mar-a-Lago late last month, saying that Mr. Trudeau could serve as Canada’s governor. The Canadian government dismissed the line as a joke.

The President-Elect has subsequently referenced it several more times in Truth Social posts. Most recently, he used it on Monday in reaction to Chrystia Freeland’s abrupt resignation as deputy prime minister and finance minister.

“The Great State of Canada is stunned as the Finance Minister resigns, or was fired, from her position by Governor Justin Trudeau,” he wrote, before deriding Ms. Freeland as “totally toxic” and “not at all conducive to making deals.”

Ms. Freeland was the point-person on trade negotiations during Mr. Trudeau’s first term, and both Mr. Trump and some of his advisers have previously expressed irritation with her for refusing to make concessions.

 
A large amount of Canada’s laws are incompatible with American laws. It would be a mess integrating the country. The most similar annexation would be Hawaii, as that was the closest thing to America taking over a civilized country.
Just conquer Canada and implement American laws. Who said that they should be respected as equals?
 
I've been unable to find much more on that but Canada's finance minister who resigned last week seemed to imply her suddent departure was about disagreement with Trudeau about tariffs and political ideology. Is he trying to avoid giving Trump the tighter border security Trump wants for some reason? To the point of risking the tariffs?
She's referencing recent "economic relief efforts" (bribes) the Liberals have implemented/attempted to implement. There's a nonsensical two-month pseudo sales tax rebate currently that has a scope nobody really understands and business owners hate. There was also supposed to be a $250 rebate check handed out to everyone in the spring. Freeland objected to both these measures as political stunts, the rebate check proposal has now been quashed but her objections are mainly why she was going to be fired. She doesn't name these measures outright in her resignation letter but it's obvious here that this is what she was referring to. It's related to the tariffs but more in a 'we can't be wasting more money on this stupid bullshit when tariffs are looming' kind of way.
 
A large amount of Canada’s laws are incompatible with American laws. It would be a mess integrating the country. The most similar annexation would be Hawaii, as that was the closest thing to America taking over a civilized country.
Yeah, when they become part of America? The sum total of their old laws become null and void.

Remember that dumbass Hawaiian Judge who tried to say he didn't have to rule in-line with the Constitution if he didn't want to because of "Aloha Spirit" inherit in the fact the islands used to be their own country?

That didn't work.
 
Just conquer Canada and implement American laws. Who said that they should be respected as equals?
Making Canada a state would by definition imply they held an equal status in the union.

It's a retarded idea all around, why are people so eager to effectively add another California to the electoral college?
 
It's working cuz Trudeau's government wants him to resign
It's not working, the Liberals literally have no mechanism to force Trudeau out short of an election loss. He's already been locked out of forwarding legislation for months because of domestic issues and he flat out doesn't give a fuck. If he wants he could prorogue Parliament for the rest of the year and avoid confronting the issue altogether. He's a narcissist addicted to his title, literally nothing else matters.
 
What do you mean? Like can you elaborate?
Every public institution in Canada would cease to function unless explicitly carried over into the new state.

Things like the Canadian senate aren’t Constitutional, so an entirely new government would have to be drafted. Parliament would be completely different in composition and boundaries due to district boundary precedent (it would favor Republicans more).

Every judge and lawyer would need to pass a new bar exam for American law.

The healthcare system will need to become ACA and HIPAA compliant. I have no idea where to even begin with that behemoth.

Measurements would all have to be converted to Imperial (yes, this is Federal law).
 
Every public institution in Canada would cease to function unless explicitly carried over into the new state.

Things like the Canadian senate aren’t Constitutional, so an entirely new government would have to be drafted. Parliament would be completely different in composition and boundaries due to district boundary precedent (it would favor Republicans more).

Every judge and lawyer would need to pass a new bar exam for American law.

The healthcare system will need to become ACA and HIPAA compliant. I have no idea where to even begin with that behemoth.

Measurements would all have to be converted to Imperial (yes, this is Federal law).
I mean yeah but like I really want to see the crown kicked off the continent so...it's worth it.
 
Trump has zero respect for Trudeau and is going to do anything in his power to humiliate him and the country. The best thing for the country would be an election ASAP because at least Trump is likely to show some respect for Poilievre.

Trudeau is going to stay on as long as possible though no matter what consequences that has on the country.
 
In all reality I don't see how adding Canada as a state would benefit America. It'd add 10,000,000+ voters far more left wing than the average Democrat that hate America and would immediately hate their situation

Just making Canada kiss the ring a bit is enough
 
  • Like
Reactions: Core Theorist
He's bullying him! He's gaslighting him! This is psychological abuse! Is there a hotline Justin can call?
Oh no! Mean Tweets! My only weakness!!!!!

Every public institution in Canada would cease to function unless explicitly carried over into the new state.

Things like the Canadian senate aren’t Constitutional, so an entirely new government would have to be drafted. Parliament would be completely different in composition and boundaries due to district boundary precedent (it would favor Republicans more).

Every judge and lawyer would need to pass a new bar exam for American law.

The healthcare system will need to become ACA and HIPAA compliant. I have no idea where to even begin with that behemoth.

Measurements would all have to be converted to Imperial (yes, this is Federal law).
They managed to add new states to the US that had been "their own country" when info still had to travel by horseback, you're really making this out to be far more complicated than it actually would be.

You're making the mistake that they'd be bringing their old healthcare system and parliament with them, they wouldn't. They won't get a parliament, they'll be told and allowed to set up a state government like the US, with a State House and Senate, and to hold elections to popularly vote for National Reps and Senators to go to Washington. For healthcare? They cut up their old insurance cards and sign on with a new provider state side just like the illegal immigrants do. Yes, there will be hiccups and hurdles, but none of this is a divide-by-zero problem that's simply impossible.

Yes, there's far more bureaucracy, but, there's also more bureaucrats and computers to collate and edit the files.

And just to be clear, it won't happen, it's just a thought experiment, but, these things are not deal breakers in any way, shape, or form.
 
Last edited:
In all reality I don't see how adding Canada as a state would benefit America. It'd add 10,000,000+ voters far more left wing than the average Democrat that hate America and would immediately hate their situation

Just making Canada kiss the ring a bit is enough
You would have to deport or disappear half the population or more to start to fix things. We are half scamming Indians, and a quarter Chinese.

It would be a real improvement for most Canadians. Sadly we as a people are retarded and would brag about our failing state the entire time.
 
Back