The most baffling part is that this sort of content was already falling out of style TEN FUCKING YEARS AGO when they first started Arin's vanity project. The fact that most of the songs were the most surface-level jokes imaginable stretched for three to five minutes only helped the songs age like milk. Who could forget eternal classics like "What if Luigi wanted to be the star??" or "What if [POPULAR GAME] and sex jokes????"? Really creative stuff.
Part of me can't help but feel a bit sad that 10 years after he started making songs and five years after their last album dropped, the best he can do is still "What if [POPULAR GAME] and sex jokes????". This is the end result of a manchild with impossibly thin skin completely rejecting any kind of criticism and surrounding himself with yes men for over a decade.