The issue with splitting threads like this and Jim's into Fan Threads and On-Topic Threads is that the Fan side never respects this distinction and just raids the On-Topic thread anyways, creating the exact same issue where people just derail the thread for 40 pages to argue about the same shit. It's called the Heckler's Veto: when someone bring's up something you don't like, just shit up the place until nobody can extract anything useful from it.
Anally, too, and then made a video laughing about it. It's really hard to be like "well he's funny".