Anime/Manga - Discuss Japanese cartoons and comics here; NO CULTURE WAR DOOMPOSTING!

Isekai may have the initial premise of "I was reincarnated in X, Y, or Z goofy way" but every single story plays out the exact same way.
Isekai is forever stuck in the western fantasy camp
Isekai designs. As in, character design of the mc. Just making the point that since reincarnation is common, characters have a little more variety when it comes to things like design or race despite the stupid meme about how isekai protagonists all look like Kirito.

As for anime hogwarts shows, there were at least 3-5 last year and one last season.
 
Last edited:
  • Winner
Reactions: AnsemSoD1
Isekai designs. As in, character design of the mc. Just making the point that since reincarnation is common, characters have a little more variety when it comes to things like design or race despite the stupid meme about how isekai protagonists all look like Kirito.

As for anime hogwarts shows, there were at least 3-5 last year and one last season.
If we're going to go with endless black-hair clones, can we at least have them be clones of someone manly like Ace, instead of a pussyboy faggot like Cuckito?
 
Goyslop light novels haven't taken place at Anime Hogwarts for over a decade. You'll only see that setting in the present day when it is itself part of the Generic Isekai Fantasy Setting (Villainess Isekai slop LNs tend to feature this pretty frequently).

To be totally fair, though, in the late 00s and early 10s, Index-ripoff and Maburaho-ripoff Magic School Battle Harems were  the LNslop, even worse than isekai is now.

Off the top of my head (and there are many more examples I know I completely memory holed, I swear to god I've watched one or two episodes of War of the Roses except Anime Hogwarts 2 or 3 times in the past year) Misfit of Demon King Academy and Welcome to Demon School Iruma-kun
Not really, actual comedy is rare and at most is characters talk about tropes. Battle shonens are also rare, an enemy that's actual a roadblock doesn't last long, unlike ye olde battle shonens where an entire season could build up to a single fight. And even the harem is devoid of character interaction.

Adventurer's guild and light fantasy usually come bundled up. Having an explicit MMO mechanics is the biggest red flag that things are going to get shit since it's pure power level/having the exact counter ability bullshit every time.
It's not really important how effective they are at aping the genre they are inspired by (they are pretty bad); you still have a break down between ones trying to be funny (if anime actually had to be funny to be a comedy the only comedy anime are GTO, Cromartie High and maybe Panty and Stocking on a good day), the ones that are trying to appeal to people who want the appearance of crunchy fights, and the ones that are vehicles for attractive character fan service

A lot of those are not isekai in name only. But still have every fault of the original genre.A lot of those are not isekai in name only. But still have every fault of the original genre.
What I'm saying is that's isekai isn't even a genre, it's a plot device. It's a common plot device of fantasy anime and fantasy anime very frequently sucks whether or not it uses that particular plot device. There is nothing about the plot device that makes anime bad on it's own but people in this thread confuse the plot device with the problems of Fantasy Anime in Current Year which are in no way directly related to the actions of Truck-San
 
I am of the strong opinion that Reincarnated as a Sword is one of the few titles that took the modern isekai tropes and did something good with them.
If we're going to go with endless black-hair clones, can we at least have them be clones of someone manly like Ace, instead of a pussyboy faggot like Cuckito?
Cuckito sounds like a demeaning nickname one would give to an emasculated Mexican.
 
Finished Shaman King Marcos.

Man I fucking love Shaman King world and characters so much. There is this feeling that no other series can replicate. I just love it so damn much.

Now I have to finish Super Star and wait for the sequel for the Flower of Maize
 
I would say every Isekai exists on a spectrum between 3 points: Comedy, Battle Shonen, and Harem/Reverse Harem. But as an entirely separate thing the vast majority of Anime Fantasy either takes place at Anime Hogwarts, the Adventurer's Guild, and/or a light fantasy setting with explicit MMO mechanics built into the universe. Most of the time when people in this thread are complaining about Isekai it's just a complaint about how nearly ALL fantasy Anime takes place in those 3 settings not actually isekai. You can find dozens of non Isekai anime in the last 10 years that still take place in those settings because that's what the Nips want, not fish out of water stories with cheat powers explicitly.

It's not Isekai that's shitting up fantasy anime, it's fantasy anime shitting up itself.
Kind of, but that's because isekai is the dominant form of shitty fantasy anime currently. In the early 10s it was shitty anime Hogwarts battle harems, but that genre was slightly better than isekai because it could actually come up with cool shit sometimes like Horizon in the Middle of Nowhere. Isekai has jack and shit. Not a single modern isekai isn't just eyerolling and cringy at best. The only good "isekai" are the ones made pre-2000 like Now and Then, Here and There or Dunbine, but even though they are technically isekai they aren't part of that retarded genre shat out of the slop machine.
 
nearly ALL fantasy Anime takes place in those 3 settings
because they're also a plot device, just like most anime is set in a school setting, isekai is just an extension of it. for a "proper" fantasy or space opera you'd have to dump a lot of exposition and worldbuilding on the audience first, and most normalfags's eyes will just glaze over in that case. game of thrones only kept their attention long because of rape and dragons which was just safe-edgy enough, just like walking dead with drama and violence.

it's also an easy setup for conflict happening the story needs, unless it's CGDCT iyashikei no wants some farmer do his daily chores for half the season. as much as isekai is an obvious escape fantasy it's immediately accessible for almost everyone and allows the pacing jump right into the story.
as @A.P. Hill said lot of nip media has worked this way to get to the conflict/character interactions faster.
 
  • Like
Reactions: A.P. Hill
I wouldn't say isekai is all that accessible when compared to other anime genres, have you seen the reading guides for series like Re:Zero or Slime? That'll keep you tied down for months, at least. Hell, even Mushoku Tensei is actually a prequel.
People just think they are because they don't really care much outside what they see in the anime adaption.
 
Last edited:
I wouldn't say isekai is all that accessible when compared to other anime genres, have you seen the reading guides for series like Re:Zero? That'll keep you tied down for months, at least.
People just think they are because they don't really care much outside what they see in the anime adaption.
ReZero doesn't really count as a traditional isekai since it's somewhat of a subversion of what happens when some bumfuck idiot gets transported to a world with ninja demon maids and his cheat power works actively against him.

Anyways as bad as Battle Harem went, it never went bad enough to have the norm being a literal system manager voice describing in world mechanics as if they were an RPG system.

Like a Battle Harem skill that lets you throw fireballs will be called "Surtr Apocalyptic Destruction", in isekai it will be called "Fire Magic Lvl. 3". It's beyond depressing.
 
The only modern isekai that was good is still a milquetoast rollplay campaign writeup. Handyman Saitou you had so much potential, but it was ogre before it began due to it being a literal twitter comic. Though I suppose "being in the same camp as Lodoss" is not a terrible place to be, all things considered.
 
  • Like
Reactions: A.P. Hill
The point I'm getting at is that you don't have to like modern fantasy anime and it is largely shit but it's largely shit independent of the isekai plot hook. How many good fantasy manga/LNs can you think of that aren't being adapted because the studios are too busy adapting stories beginning with the actions of Truck-san?

Anyways as bad as Battle Harem went, it never went bad enough to have the norm being a literal system manager voice describing in world mechanics as if they were an RPG system.

Like a Battle Harem skill that lets you throw fireballs will be called "Surtr Apocalyptic Destruction", in isekai it will be called "Fire Magic Lvl. 3". It's beyond depressing.
Again, taking RPG/MMO mechanics seriously in-universe isn't an explicitly isekai thing. And hell, it's an OLD trope at this point. I'm not sure at which point it went in-universe but even Rance did this (Rance's super power is that he doesn't have a level cap in a world basically everyone else is limited to 20-40, if I recall my Rance-Lore one of the games he beats the Big Bad by level grinding into the thousands)

I would say it's almost more common among non-isekai at this point, most of the isekai people actually like don't do this (Mushoku Tensai, Re:Zero, No-Game No-Life, Tsukimichi, Faraway Paladin, Eminence in Shadow etc etc)

I think Slime-guy also did this at the begining and immediately stopped. Shield-guy does it but it's mostly heroes having a HUD which is stupid but kind of irrelevant
 
because they're also a plot device, just like most anime is set in a school setting, isekai is just an extension of it. for a "proper" fantasy or space opera you'd have to dump a lot of exposition and worldbuilding on the audience first, and most normalfags's eyes will just glaze over in that case. game of thrones only kept their attention long because of rape and dragons which was just safe-edgy enough, just like walking dead with drama and violence.
Or you know, they could just do the worldbuilding as the story goes along as long as they keep things consistent. Like any competently told story. No one likes exposition dumps.
 
Last edited:
  • Agree
Reactions: LifeAlert
I wouldn't say isekai is all that accessible when compared to other anime genres, have you seen the reading guides for series like Re:Zero or Slime? That'll keep you tied down for months, at least. Hell, even Mushoku Tensei is actually a prequel.
People just think they are because they don't really care much outside what they see in the anime adaption.
If you really have the cravings for a reincarnating protagonist who keeps getting killed but gets stronger every time, just play infinity blade instead. Sirius isnt some chickenshit kid and actually punches above their weight. So when they get their hands on the infinity blade it feels earned and their redemption arc doesn't come out of nowhere as they learn more about how that world works and what the Deathless are. They also had several books that were canon and completely optional and kept things relatively straightforward.

Isekai like re:zero are just bad junk food storytelling thats half assed on purpose. Like for fucks sake kid. Just ask her out already, get your answer, and go from there. Its been several years. At least Konosuba tries to be funny about it.
 
  • Disagree
Reactions: Atatata
Back