There is truth to his analysis, but the issue more has to do with Keemstar being unable of accepting that he himself is also a lolcow, so his bizarre humiliation rituals push competent collaborators away, leaving you with insane paypigs and backstabbers like the thorpes. Furthermore as shamoo points out, the extensive scripting prevents the cows from naturally being cows. They don't naturally produce interesting moments anymore, and even if they did it is now sullied with suspicion.
IMO KC getting first clowned on, and now buried statistically by lolcowlive has more to do with failures by KC than successes or effectiveness of LCL. I will say however that KC's strategy of just never talking about LCL other than to say its fake is the correct response, (it denies keem the oxygen to invent more fake content) and will probably be vindicated in the long term.
In other news I saw
this tweet when pulling the shamoo one. Honestly I think this angle is kino and TRUE AND HONEST. Liana is OUR GIRL! Whether she meant it or not hahaha.