I watched Mufasa [Spoilers]

GeorgeWashingtoff

kiwifarms.net
Joined
Jan 4, 2025
I chose to grab it from the pirate bay instead of pay to see it at the cinema. I think that was the best idea, it's watchable but not worth paying for unless you're a hardcore fan who must see these endless remakes/story additions on the big screen.

Quick rundown- Simba's daughter Kiara is scared of storms, so Rafiki tells a story about Mufasa. Timon and Pumbaa are there for comic relief for the little kids when scary parts happen. Like when Taka's pride was slaughtered by the outsiders, although any scariness there was already heavily diluted by the outsider King singing a happy jingle with the line "I'll make you go byebye". Mufasa is seperated from his parents and makes his way to the paradise he was told about, and the story is about how he got there and met the major characters we saw in the OG movie.

Since we've all seen the 1994 OG movie we know what happens so the movie is almost void of any mystery. Mufasa becomes king, is the one to bonk Sarabi, is then resented by Taka etc. It's supposed to be a twist/revelation that Taka is Scar but it's obvious from the beginning e.g. Taka is given an English accent to match his 1994 equivalent while most others have African accents (was it just me or did one of the white female lions sound Jamaican?). The movie lacked the feeling of threat too since we all know Mufasa would survive everything.

The movie seemed to force in a little too many "reverse foreshadowing" tropes. e.g. there's a stampede, not 1 but 2 times Mufasa is holding onto an edge with Scar grabbing him , Scar manipulating the good guys and befriending the bad guys etc. Stuff that happened in the 1994 the writers thought should also happen here to give us that fuzzy nostaliga feeling, or whatever.

Also the trope about "animals on journey to find paradise" feels overdone. The Land Before Time and the T&P movie did it too. It's just lazy writing and an easy excuse to have the characters go on a journey.

Also Mufasa's super smell powers are inconsistent throughout, at one point he could detect the outsiders approaching half a day away. Yet other times were unable to tell when they were just 1 min behind them. At the end he turns superhero using his smell to detect a large rock falling underwater.

And now that I've seen this movie given that it's canon, I can see why Scar was so pissed with life in the 1994 movie. Apart from having to watch Sarabi fall for Mufasa instead of him, his entire pride was mauled to death. Going back to that, I know little kids will watch this and the writers have to tell them what would happen in the gentliest way possible, but it did seem a little insensitive that Scar's entire family was killed to cheerful singing of "I'll make you go byebye" and immediately followed by Timon and Pumbaa fart jokes. Doesn't quite hit the tears as much as Mufasa's death in 1994 does it?

I hope this is the last one. I really don't give a fuck about what Kiara does. Isn't this movie #5 now including the 2019 remake and the T&P spin off?
 
I ain't reading all that. I'm happy for you, or sorry that happened
tl dr The movie is watchable but don't spend any money to see it.

I really don't give a fuck about what Kiara does
I just realised Lion King 2 is about Kiara's story. Hopefully now we've heard the Lion King story from all 3 generations and from Timon and Pumbaa that will finally be the fucking end of it. Unless they release Zazu in 2035 which wouldn't surprise me.
 
Mufasa's story could have been entirely avoided if Mufasa had simply decided to walk upriver to find his parents after the flood.

Editors could have easily cut out the entirety of Timon and Pumbaa's scenes and the story would have been unchanged, but I guess Disney needed to use those characters to appeal to kids. Their scenes are actually quite distracting and kill the little momentum the story has.

I can see why Scar was so pissed with life in the 1994 movie
Not to mention that according to this movie, Mufasa stole Scar's birthright to be the next king.

Also Mufasa's super smell powers are inconsistent throughout
Mufasa also wasn't able to smell Kiros' scent on Taka/Scar, after Taka went to fraternize with him in the mountains and Kiros brushed up against him.
 
Some very baffling decisions like making Mufasa and Scar unrelated, and the whole Mufasa was raised by females thing. Its like, they're expending effort to actively try to make it worse. Wouldn't it be easier to phone it in?

One insight I've heard thats being overlooked a lot is they actually took advice from reviews for the last movie and made the characters more expressive. The problem is they made them more expressive as if they were humans which gives it an even more uncanny valley look, It didn't cross their minds that animals have their own unique way of showing emotion making a little effort to understand this could have added a lot.

I got entertainment by watching the reviews so it was good for that at least.
 
Just checked the voice cast. A lot of black actors but only Rafiki had an African voice actor. That explains why a lot of characters had "all over the place" accents that kept slipping between American/British and African.


False cat narrative. In real life, cat's voices come from their toxoplasmid colonies. they would have all been part of the hive mind and sound exactly the same.
 
Mufasa also wasn't able to smell Kiros' scent on Taka/Scar, after Taka went to fraternize with him in the mountains and Kiros brushed up against him.
I picked up on that too. Here's how the conversation should have gone:

M: Where have you been?

T: I was hunting for food

M: No you weren't. I smelled you approach the outsiders and you spent 5 mins with them. Are you plotting something with them because you're mad I did it with Sarabi?

T: I'm not mad, why would you think that?

M: Because we heard you sing an entire song about it

The outsiders couldn't smell Mufasa and co either here, does smell just stop working in the snow?

I also noticed after this point the voice actor was trying to make him sound like 1994 Scar too, as if it was part of the transformation.
 
I'd rather just watch The Lion Guard.
 
Back