I contacted the owner of the anti-Moon site for comment. It is clear they are someone other than they claim to be. A number of semi-coherent posts online have caused people to suspect that the site is operated by former porn star Donny Long, a victim of Moon. However in private the individual is highly eloquent, articulate and sly. Furthermore, when I used (legal) investigative techniques to try to trace the operator I discovered that they were using a VPN in Peru, which subsequently switched to a Japanese address.
The IP address of the Peru endpoint (190.43.98.209) is similar to one I previously identified as being used by Moon himself, (190.81.170.77). Both are in Lima Peru. The impression I have formed is of a member of Kiwi Farms or a rival trolling site familiar with moderately sophisticated counter-forensic techniques, perhaps one of their recommended no-logging VPNs. ‘Candice Potter’, the administrator of the forum also claims to be outside the United States. However their private correspondence shows sophisticated grammar and it is likely this is untrue.
The possible motives vary. It could be a Kiwi engaging in a false flag attack to try to obtain law enforcement sympathy. It could be one of Josh’s many enemies posing as Donny to avoid retaliation. Without further investigation, there is no definitive answer.