I want to seeth about the latest Gotrek novel Verminslayer and since the thread of AoS is dead I'll do it here.
First of all the AoS Gotrek books were so far been at least serviceable. But this one is just bad in many many ways:
First of all, no Tharnquall despite being a Skaven book. What the absolute fuck.
Second thing, the book does the sin of referencing a far better book, the original Gotrek Skaven fight, which just further shows how bad it is in comparison.
This time Gotrek has a new sidekick, a sheboon cavalier, after the previous one (a sheboon sigmarite priest) is unceremoniously dumped off because the author didn't know what to do with her. The new girl is a mary sue with the annoying trend of second guessing herself and comparing herself to others, in a bid to fool the reader to think she isn't a mary sue.
The plot setup is that Gotrek works as a sewer patrol man in generic steampunk city #6379, similar to how he and Felix did it in Nuln. This new fantasy city is horrifically boring despite the author trying really hard to sell it as exciting city of adventure. The main issue is that like every high fantasy shit, things just exist because they look cool. Nothing makes sense because magic, fuck you. The city also has a blatantly vampire countess ruling it despite you'd think that, especially in a high fantasy universe, people besides Gotrek will notice how blatant it is. Another noticeable thing is that the city uses literal health potions as currency, which is just retarded and really takes me out of the book whenever they are referenced.
At the start of the book, Gotrek meets sheboon as they encounter a sign of a skaven plot to do something bad and they team up to stop it. The Skaven are noticeably way more boring that the original Fantasy setting, and their plan is foreshadowed halfway too hard to be the machination of a Vermin Lord that it spoils the twist.
Along the way there are many many characters (they introduce like 8 in the first pages!) that I don't give a shit about because they barely have any distinguishing features beyond their own brand of quipping, plus you know most are going to die.
The final battle is notable that sheboon shows she knows about metallurgy than Gotrek, a fucking dwarf, and she beats the Verminlord by decapitating it with a standard steel sword. Did I mention she was a mary sue? To compare, Felix took like 8 books to kill something big (a dragon), and only did it because he obtained a sword made for the express purpose to slay dragons, that also mind controlled him to fight with disregard for himself.
Gotrek throughout the book just mopes a lot without doing much, being there solely to hype the author's OC (if she even gets another book). The author has absolutely no idea what to do with the character because he keeps changing Gotrek's goal every book.
The book ends on a sequel hook that I don't care for because literally every book in that series ends with those and they never matter.
It's absolute shit.