‘Her rise was meteoric’: Pootoogook drawing named one of 21st century’s best works - Art Is Dead.

Link
By Jorge Antunes

A drawing by famed Nunavut artist the late Annie Pootoogook has been named one of the best artworks of the 21st century by ARTNews, a magazine based in New York City.

That shouldn’t come as a surprise, says William Huffman.

“Her rise was meteoric; it was amazing,” said Huffman, arts administrator and curator at the West Baffin Eskimo Co-Operative in Kinngait, where Pootoogook was a member artist.

“Once people started paying attention, everyone started paying attention.”

He said her early art was “quotidian,” or everyday slice of Inuit life. Later, her work became more challenging.

The drawing singled out by ARTNews is titled Man Abusing His Partner. It depicts a man holding a large piece of wood and a woman crying, gripping the bed beneath her as the man approaches.

Huffman said the scene is very modern and something people from all over the world can understand, yet there are also certain elements — parkas hanging on a wall, a sealskin blanket on the bed — that place it very much in an Inuit household.

Inuit art typically has particular motifs, such as seals or polar bears, animals, people and scenes from the Arctic. Pootoogook’s work, while very Inuit, was also very modern and depicted scenes of contemporary Inuit life and culture, Huffman said.

In her magazine article published March 5, Anne Doran — who is an accomplished artist herself — noted that Pootoogook, who comes from a long line of Inuit artists in Cape Dorset, now Kinngait, wasn’t the first Inuit artist to take on modern themes.

“Both Ashoona, Annie Pootoogook’s grandmother, and Napachie Pootoogook, her mother, however, were among the first Inuit artists to create autobiographical artworks,” Doran wrote.

“Following their example, [Annie] Pootoogook likewise based her drawings on personal experience, including her struggles with addiction and —as here — abusive relationships.”

Speaking of the Man Abusing His Partner work by Pootoogook, Huffman said, “The moment that this work was revealed publicly, suddenly it changed what people thought Inuit art could be capable of.”

Pootoogook struggled with drug and alcohol addiction for much of her life, sometimes living on the streets of Ottawa. On Sept. 19, 2016, her body was found near the Rideau River. Though her death was ruled suspicious, no arrests have been made.

A park in Ottawa was posthumously renamed in her honour. She was 47 when she died.

art-books_44_annie-pootoogook-man-abusing-his-partner.webp
 
Why is it whenever there's some brave minority artist the art work inevitably looks like a child drew it? It always reminds me of when a toddler draws something and you make a big deal about how good it is and put it up on your fridge but it's actually just a bunch of fucking scribbles but you put it up on your fridge just to be nice because it makes the kid happy.
The technical term is "outsider art".

While strictly speaking, the term ALSO encapsulates art made by genuinely talented self-taught autist-artists (including minority ones), art fags will almost always limit their praise and visibility-boosting to the most childish examples.

There's a lot of reasons for this; if you wanted to impress a liberal friend, you might say something like "Pootoogook's work boldly rejects the cultural assumptions and normative values of the colonial powerstructure". But really, it comes down to what YHWH says above: it reinforces leftists' view of minorities as helpless children, in need of guidance and largesse.
 
"Art" isn't just an airy sense of ideas that make us have feelings. The word means something. An art is something you practice and become technically proficient in. An artist is someone who obsessively improves at that thing well beyond the point of proficiency. Everyone understands this when they say a craftsman is an "artist" with his tools or whatever. But somehow they forget it when we return to things like illustration. What art has been mastered here exactly? What craftsmanship is in this? You might not like Rothko but he wasn't making childish crayon drawings without composition or quality.

tl;dr "Wow that's a neat idea I resonate with" is not art. Art is doing something well.
 
If anyone is interested in buying my fridge for eleventy zillion dollars, I have 27 one of a kind pictures of felines at various stages of life as done by the greatest artist of the American west, in their “40 crayola” stage. I think “my cat takes over my pillow so I can’t get to bed on time” is easily better than this. It shows the strife of the 21st century youth’s rebellion against patriarchal facism being facilitated by the natural world’s natural inability to abide by human conservership of the planet and its resources.
 
The technical term is "outsider art".

While strictly speaking, the term ALSO encapsulates art made by genuinely talented self-taught autist-artists (including minority ones), art fags will almost always limit their praise and visibility-boosting to the most childish examples.
The art world has always been very strange to me. Art is something basically anyone can do with enough practice and motivation and basic tools that can be purchased very easily worldwide. It's even more accessible than music which has a bit of the weirdness of the art world but a lot less of the strange circle jerking exclusivity bullshit the art world has. I've met a fuckload of artists over the years. A ton of them have been really talented at what they do and produce some really great art. Then I see news stories like this or just see examples of what's considered high quality professional art or whatever the fuck and it's just fucking garbage. I understand there's a lot of money laundering and bullshit that goes on at that level of art but just in general the art world makes my brain hurt and none of it makes sense to me.
 
I understand there's a lot of money laundering and bullshit that goes on at that level of art but just in general the art world makes my brain hurt and none of it makes sense to me.
The art world is entirely captured by ideology and finance. The quality of art is determined by pricing models and the likelihood that it will appeal to political agents. Somehow, it's still less fucked up than what happens in architecture.
 
The art world has always been very strange to me. Art is something basically anyone can do with enough practice and motivation and basic tools that can be purchased very easily worldwide. It's even more accessible than music which has a bit of the weirdness of the art world but a lot less of the strange circle jerking exclusivity bullshit the art world has. I've met a fuckload of artists over the years. A ton of them have been really talented at what they do and produce some really great art. Then I see news stories like this or just see examples of what's considered high quality professional art or whatever the fuck and it's just fucking garbage. I understand there's a lot of money laundering and bullshit that goes on at that level of art but just in general the art world makes my brain hurt and none of it makes sense to me.
Pretending to like things that are objectively bad is a form of virtue signaling. It's saying "I'm so enlightened that things like physical attributes don't affect me at all - I see past the mundane and directly into the artist's soul, where true beauty is found".

It's bullshit, but the act has become so pervasive that I honestly don't think they could turn it off even if they were trapped on a desert island for ten years. They've been lying to themselves for so long the lie has warped their view of reality.
 
A drawing by famed Nunavut artist the late Annie Pootoogook has been named one of the best artworks of the 21st century by ARTNews, a magazine based in New York City.
1747836006198.webp
Her art is no different from what 10 year old abuse victims draw. "Powerful" but calling it "one of the best artworks of the 21st century" is such fucking bullshit fart sniffing.
 
The art world has always been very strange to me. Art is something basically anyone can do with enough practice and motivation and basic tools that can be purchased very easily worldwide. It's even more accessible than music which has a bit of the weirdness of the art world but a lot less of the strange circle jerking exclusivity bullshit the art world has. I've met a fuckload of artists over the years. A ton of them have been really talented at what they do and produce some really great art. Then I see news stories like this or just see examples of what's considered high quality professional art or whatever the fuck and it's just fucking garbage. I understand there's a lot of money laundering and bullshit that goes on at that level of art but just in general the art world makes my brain hurt and none of it makes sense to me.
It comes down to low art and high art. The vast majority of skilled artists are stuck doing low art, e.g. working for corporations for a paycheck, trying to make their products look more appealing. They have no creative control of these projects so none of them are anything they'd be proud of — it's stuff like the Google landing page or whatever. These types are tortured by working on garbage, they have no long-term security in our economy, and especially with AI they are going to be a dying breed, because no money comes to these people. Some of these will become true "outsider artists" when the economy just excludes them entirely.

High art, gallery and private collection bullshit, having no functional purpose, is a different scene and doesn't have much connection to actual skill. It's more about filling a social role. Being the right kind of person, knowing the right kind of people. Money flows freely to people in the high art game, and when they have no skill people say they're doing "outsider art," although really anyone involved in this stuff is insider by definition.
 
The art world has always been very strange to me. Art is something basically anyone can do with enough practice and motivation and basic tools that can be purchased very easily worldwide. It's even more accessible than music which has a bit of the weirdness of the art world but a lot less of the strange circle jerking exclusivity bullshit the art world has. I've met a fuckload of artists over the years. A ton of them have been really talented at what they do and produce some really great art. Then I see news stories like this or just see examples of what's considered high quality professional art or whatever the fuck and it's just fucking garbage. I understand there's a lot of money laundering and bullshit that goes on at that level of art but just in general the art world makes my brain hurt and none of it makes sense to me.
A lot of it is money laundering, yeah. At least on the economic level - when you hear "Pootoogook's Eskimo Disalives Self sold at Sotheby's for 50 bajillion dollars", it's because a bajillionaire needed a plausible spot to park 50 bajillion in assets. But there's also cultural and philosophical levels, which since the 20th century can be summed up as "make everything as Marxist and hellish as possible, because 8000 pages of critical theory "

It helps to remember that art, and "The Art World", are two different beasts. "The Art World" - that is, educated establishment types and the service industry that caters to them- is, ironically, pretty hostile to art in general, and represents only a small fraction of the art market (albeit the ones with the loudest voices and deepest pockets), and champions only a small fraction of the global art output.

Art World is to Art what Reddit is to Internet, basically.
 
The art world has always been very strange to me. Art is something basically anyone can do with enough practice and motivation and basic tools that can be purchased very easily worldwide. It's even more accessible than music which has a bit of the weirdness of the art world but a lot less of the strange circle jerking exclusivity bullshit the art world has. I've met a fuckload of artists over the years. A ton of them have been really talented at what they do and produce some really great art. Then I see news stories like this or just see examples of what's considered high quality professional art or whatever the fuck and it's just fucking garbage. I understand there's a lot of money laundering and bullshit that goes on at that level of art but just in general the art world makes my brain hurt and none of it makes sense to me.
Art is not necessarily about talent. What you've made is not the "art", "art" is the process through which you convince other people what you've made IS art. This is much easier to do when you have the technical skill of someone like Michelangelo or whatever, because a layperson will look at the mural and say "yes this is beautiful, this is art".

And then you have faggots like Marshal Duchamp and his retarded urinals that he didn't make just plopping one down and saying "this is art", or the idiot who taped a banana to the wall. Esoteric no talent shit like this isn't art to most people, but to culturally stunted "intellectual " types they rally around this shit because hailing someone like the artist on the OP who has all the drawing skill of Napoleon fucking Dynamite is a big middle finger to all the legitimate artists they are envious of because they themselves do not have the innate talent nor are they willing to put in the long hours of practice to refine their skills to the point of someone who painted The Last Supper.
 
Last edited:
The art world has always been very strange to me. Art is something basically anyone can do with enough practice and motivation and basic tools that can be purchased very easily worldwide. It's even more accessible than music which has a bit of the weirdness of the art world but a lot less of the strange circle jerking exclusivity bullshit the art world has.

The problem in a certain section of the "art world" is the politics/bad taste of the people who buy the art. Art is produced and sold based on the tastes and interests of the people who have lots of money and buy expensive art. Meeting and talking to the people who buy the art tends to explain everything.

The other thing about the high end of the art market is that what is being sold is usually NOT the art itself. Its the "artist" in terms of their story and their personality that is being sold. Usually social and party skills are of far more value in the high end art market than actual artistic skill.

If we had better rich people, we would have better art.
 
The art world has always been very strange to me. Art is something basically anyone can do with enough practice and motivation and basic tools that can be purchased very easily worldwide. It's even more accessible than music which has a bit of the weirdness of the art world but a lot less of the strange circle jerking exclusivity bullshit the art world has. I've met a fuckload of artists over the years. A ton of them have been really talented at what they do and produce some really great art. Then I see news stories like this or just see examples of what's considered high quality professional art or whatever the fuck and it's just fucking garbage. I understand there's a lot of money laundering and bullshit that goes on at that level of art but just in general the art world makes my brain hurt and none of it makes sense to me.
The art world is entirely captured by ideology and finance. The quality of art is determined by pricing models and the likelihood that it will appeal to political agents. Somehow, it's still less fucked up than what happens in architecture.

this for sure. and I would also add that Art as an industry and image tends to attract the most annoying midwit faggots who love to put on an air of culture and erudition for themselves and others. I once went to a Matisse exhibit and watched a man choke up as he was overcome by the sheer beauty and genius of this painting:

1747836212791.webp
 
Somehow, it's still less fucked up than what happens in architecture.
I just can't get over how fucked modern buildings are ever since I read about how basically all modern buildings exist because literally one guy was a miserable prick who believed humanity should be miserable and depressed while living in cities and this one guy basically came up with all of modern architecture.
It's bullshit, but the act has become so pervasive that I honestly don't think they could turn it off even if they were trapped on a desert island for ten years. They've been lying to themselves for so long the lie has warped their view of reality.
I think it gets to the point where they actually believe the bullshit. I know someone that paints some pretty godawful shit. Like, they're a good painter, but the art they make sucks a lot. Nobody I know who's seen it thinks it looks good. Yet this person tries to sell their art for thousands of dollars and legitimately thinks it's worth that much and is constantly surprised when people won't pay that much for paintings of roadkill and dirty ashtrays.
Art World is to Art what Reddit is to Internet, basically.
After reading everybody's long detailed answers, this really sums it up the best I think. I like this analogy.

Also, I kind of regret commenting on this. Holy fuck everybody's got something to say about art.
 
one guy was a miserable prick who believed humanity should be miserable and depressed while living in cities and this one guy basically came up with all of modern architecture.
Le Corbusier? The funniest part is he even has the Reddit article baked into his name.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Vecr
Wow, that's worse than I was expecting. "Put-on primitivism" is definitely the best way to describe it.

West Baffin Eskimo Co-Operative in Kinngait
I thought Eskimo was supposed to be a slur?

I heard of Annie Pootoogook and the saddest part of her works is that they are extremely derivative of her mother's. An entire generation of artists and zero development to speak of. Not like the art is impressive on its own, but still, I would expect at least some originality or minor improvement upon the work of your parents. Inuit and Abbo art really is hopeless.

Her mother's art at least has a folksy stylism to it. Annie was just performing "dumb indian" for the fart-sniffing whites. I love how no one, white or native, can say anything about the obvious insult.
 
Back