Opinion no one wants to have children anymore, and as a mom, I understand why

Link (Archive)

no one wants to have children anymore, and as a mom, I understand why​

My experience with motherhood started in a cold hospital room filled with fluorescent lights and beeping machines. I was isolated from my daughter’s dad for reasons I can’t even fully remember, probably some fucked-up COVID protocol. While trying to concentrate on the breathing exercises I picked up from my Hypnobirthing book, the nurses and doctors surrounding me did absolutely nothing to support me emotionally, aside from offering one medication after another and getting increasingly impatient when I refused them.

After approximately 30 hours of desperately trying to cope with the most excruciating pain I’ve ever known, I gave in and let them inject the longest needle I’ve ever seen into my spine. I fell asleep. The next thing I remember was being woken up by the nurses, telling me I needed to push. Fast.

Just minutes after they woke me up and forced me to push, they placed my daughter on my chest. After the brief relief of knowing she was alive and well, I felt immense confusion about how I would ever catch up on that sleep. I never did.

Little did I know that the humiliation and isolation I experienced in that labor room were just the trailer for everything that was about to unfold. I walked into that hospital needing women to hold me through the most sacred experience of my life, but instead, I was treated like a problem to be managed— ideally as quickly and efficiently as humanly possible.

And if my birth story isn’t the perfect metaphor for what motherhood feels like in a capitalist, patriarchal society, I don’t know what is. Efficiency. Isolation. Gaslighting. Medication. Unsurprisingly, the system didn’t just fail me during labor. It kept failing me relentlessly in all the moments that came after, and it continues to do so, as if it once made a silent vow to keep punishing me for daring to expect more.

Since I’m not the only woman on this planet who damn well understands the underlying motivation to opt for a child-free life after experiencing the soul crushing reality of motherhood in the system we’re forced to mother in, I decided to include the voice of the fabulous Briana, along with insights from hundreds of mothers I polled on Instagram, in this essay.

The voices of women choosing to live a childfree life are getting louder and louder — and rightfully so. I think we can all agree that, much to the dismay of many men in the comment sections beneath those posts, women are done subscribing to the bullshit narrative we were fed as little girls. It took many of us a few messed-up relationships, abuse, and a whole lot of therapy to understand that this narrative wasn’t designed to serve us, merely to contain us.

Children’s books and Disney movies did an excellent job in convincing us that our highest calling was to become wives and mothers. That our value peaked when a man chose us and a baby ultimately completed us. But what we weren’t told is what happens after the fairytale ends. When your handsome prince suddenly wants to get blackout drunk with his boys instead of taking care of his child. When your pretty dresses aren’t possibly big enough to cover the isolating pain in your chest.
We weren’t told that motherhood can feel like a beautiful prison.

Personally, I gaslit myself for long enough into believing that it’s not actually that bad, but I’m done subscribing to the glamorous image of motherhood that has been sold to us for decades by the media. Motherhood doesn’t look like a blonde, white woman with shiny hair blissfully breastfeeding her baby. Cinderella isn’t the blueprint. I bet that bitch has bills to pay, too.

So why are so many moms disappointed by motherhood, when we’ve always got told that it’s the most beautiful event to ever possibly happen to a woman?

Sarah: Ever since I’m a mom, I feel like I’ve discovered the biggest scam of our society. I feel incredibly naive for buying into the belief that motherhood would be the most beautiful thing to ever happen to me.

I believe what’s the most disappointing for me is the lack of support from wider society. During my pregnancy, everyone showered me with congratulations like I’ve never experienced with any other milestone in my life, but once the baby was there it’s like society expects you to be at home and don’t bother anyone else with your screaming baby and your leaking boobs. I was shocked by how isolating it all felt.

Everyone wants to come and see the baby, but no one actually wants to help raise it, and to be fair, having people visiting the baby doesn’t help a new mom AT ALL. In contrast, it even puts another workload on us.

I also find it incredibly frustrating to witness how the life of the dad doesn’t change at all. My daughter’s dad was able to go clubbing with his friends like nothing ever happened, although our daughter was just 5 days old and I can barely get dressed.

And the worst part is we’re still told to be grateful. We’re still told that venting about motherhood is dangerous, that it makes us sound ungrateful, or worse—like we don’t love our kids. Love isn’t the issue. The issue is that the second we become mothers, the world expects us to disappear into that role and never ask for more. In fact, it’s because we love our children that we demand something better. I would even go as far as saying, better won’t cut it. We need a fucking revolution.

Briana: I never dreamed of becoming a mother, nor did I fantasize about marriage or whatever else is shoved down the throats of young girls to distract us from ourselves. So you’d think the harsh reality of modern motherhood wouldn’t be as devastating — IT IS.

First, nothing could have prepared me for the rage I’d feel for the continued and unearned praise my daughter’s father receives for simply being seen with her. It’s not specific to him; each boyfriend says the same, “people are really nice to me when it’s just the two of us.”

Meanwhile, I am offered little beyond critique, judgment, and sharp shame whenever I don’t perform motherhood perfectly. We all know “perfection” is a moving target, so it’s a lose-lose game.

I often tell people motherhood sucks, but mostly because of societal expectations, the destruction of robust community in a digital-first world, and the general intolerance of children and their parents (re: mothers) in public spaces. Women are disappointed with motherhood because it’s an unnecessarily isolating experience. Raising children is a community effort - period. The degradation of proper third places (not overly curated events rebranded as third places with a $40 entry fee) combined with the accepted norm that children should only exist in child-specific spaces, it’s simply too much work.
Especially because women do the overwhelming majority of labor associated with childcare.

Why are so many women opting for a child-free life?

Sarah: I think there are so many reasons to live a child-free life, but I guess the main dominator is that these women have simply educated themselves enough to discover the scam before having children on their own. I spoke to some women who told me they decided to never have children, after they’ve seen what their friends with children are going through. I spoke to women who told me they don’t want to have children in this economy. I spoke to women who told me they would want to have children, but the state of the world makes it impossible. I spoke to women who said that they realized having children was never a wish they had, but a societal expectation they carried. Also, I believe what plays into this today, very few women have the privilege to ‘just’ be a mother. Most of us are mothers, girl bosses, emotional caretakers and unpaid domestic workers. I think many women have come to realize that by choosing motherhood, they’re signing up for yet another unpaid full-time job — in an economy where you already need two just to survive.

What we need to understand is that the image of motherhood has been created by the media, which, in turn, has been shaped by men. Yes, the part of our society that doesn’t have a uterus, will never experience the pain of childbirth, and the social isolation that comes with it, sold us the idea that it’s the best part of our lives. And ironically, they’re also the ones benefiting from our unpaid domestic labor. They glorify sacrifice, romanticize exhaustion, and call it love when, in reality, it's often just unpaid, unrecognized labor.

Motherhood is painted as a noble duty, a woman’s highest calling, yet the systems in place do little to support mothers once they step into that role. From the moment a woman becomes a mother, she is expected to put herself last—her ambitions, her health, her identity all taking a backseat to the needs of her family. And when she dares to voice the struggles, the exhaustion, or the resentment, she’s met with guilt. Society tells her to be grateful, to cherish every moment, to smile through the sleepless nights and the endless demands because "one day she’ll miss this."

But why is it that the burden falls so disproportionately on women? Why is a father "babysitting" his own child while a mother is simply doing what’s expected? Why is childcare her responsibility, her career the one to suffer, and her body the one to bear the irreversible changes?

We are we told that motherhood is the biggest gift, but for too many women, it feels like an unnecessary trap—a role that consumes their identity, limits their freedom, and leaves them invisible in a world that heavily depends on their labor but refuses to value it.

Briana: It only takes one good video of a mother bawling her eyes out about being crushed by the endlessness of motherhood before you start to question if the risk is worth the reward. Whether it’s a result of the cost of living crisis, political instability, lack of desire, or the growing anti-child sentiment, fewer people are choosing a life alongside children, but not just of their own. As a millennial, the girl-boss era absolutely burnt us out. We were taught to collapse our existence into the endless pursuit of career success while maintaining the delusion belief that we can “have it all.” Girl-bossery left no room for living, much less dating, gestation, birth, and raising a child. We were so down bad we showed up to the club in blazers and pencil skirts, y’all!

After the collective crash of grind culture, women started caring for their mental health by going to therapy in droves. With women outpacing men educationally and emotionally, what we see today is a cultural divide between men and women as we’ve adopted different philosophies on life, in my opinion. This, of course, communicates a major privilege as distance means financial freedom outside of men. Proximity to a man also doesn’t carry the same social capital it once did. So the question becomes: why attach yourself to a man and child when parenthood has fallen out of fashion? It’s economically, socially, and emotionally challenging, what’s the point if it isn’t a burning desire?
‘The lack of support and nourishment of the mother who is holding it all.’
‘Having to do everything quickly (let me take a quick shower/ let me quickly eat etc)

’The mental load of ‘unseen’ small tasks that keep life going. Cooking, cleaning, laundry etc.’
‘The people who just don’t show up that you thought would. Especially your own mom.’
‘We were sold an idea of equality with our (male) partners, but kids show you how unequal it really is’
‘Women romanticising birth, postpartum, raising a child and therefore trapping each other.’
‘Being responsible for my daughters. I miss being reckless and doing whatever.’
‘Being trapped with a man you don’t want anymore, financial dependence’
‘The father’
‘The world’

I think what’s ironic is that growing up, I never heard a mom complain about motherhood. The only message that seemed to stick was that the love I’d feel for my daughter would somehow fix everything. I wish even one mom had sat me down to prepare me for what was coming. I wish we could all agree—as mothers—to stop romanticizing motherhood. That way, women who are unsure about having kids could make an informed decision instead of buying into decades of propaganda. And moms who feel crushed by the reality of it wouldn’t feel even worse comparing their journey to some mom on Instagram, perpetuating that same propaganda bullshit just to brand herself as the perfect mom.

I wish we would realize this: Perfect mom. Good mom. Bad mom. Hot mom. Cool mom. MILF. None of these labels trying so hard to box us in actually matter — because the benchmark was set by men. Built to make us manageable.

Palatable. Non-threatening. Easy to praise when we conform, easy to shame when we don’t. Motherhood isn’t the problem. The way motherhood has been policed, judged, and commodified through a male lens is.

And even though you’d think we’d know better by now, we all carry parts of ourselves that are still trapped in the socialization of the “good girl” who eventually gets rewarded with her perfect happy ending. Deep down, we’re still performing for approval — still trying to outperform other women to earn validation from a system that never wanted to validate us in the first place. We need to collectively unsubscribe from this shit show.

I’ll never forget when I asked moms on Instagram to privately share something they’d never say out loud, one mom said, “Sometimes I dream about being hospitalized just so I can get a break from my kids without feeling guilty.”

This is how bad it is y’all. A mother so burnt out she wants to get hospitalized should be proof enough of how ridiculously non-existent the support we receive as mothers is. We need to break the silence, stop pretending motherhood is the equivalent of a Disney movie, and start demanding real support—emotional, practical, and systemic. We won’t win this game by perpetuating a false image of motherhood just for the quick dopamine hit of being praised for our burnout. We will, however, create a different world for our daughters if we stop romanticizing the bare minimum treatment and start asking for the place in society we deserve.

That means not clapping for men who babysit their own kids. Not calling it “help” when a dad changes a diaper. Burning the idea that exhaustion is a badge of honor and replacing it with a demand for actual support. Structural change. Community care. Paid leave. Affordable childcare. Respect for mothering as labor.

Like dating a dude who wants to go 50/50 but still expects girlfriend treatment — we should be the ones covering the whole fucking bill and then leaving the table, instead of thanking him for offering to pay for his own meal. Maybe we have to be uncomfortable for some time to change the narrative, but maybe that’s the only way we can build a world where our daughters don’t have to recover from the lives they were told to dream about.

Thank you so much for reading this piece. If you want to support my work, it would mean the world to me if you donated to my fundraiser. I’m raising money to produce my own geo-docu series, where I share the raw, unfiltered stories of mothers from all around the world. It’s about damn time people finally listen.

If you want to read more from Briana, click here.
 
Last edited:
I walked into that hospital needing women to hold me through the most sacred experience of my life, but instead, I was treated like a problem to be managed— ideally as quickly and efficiently as humanly possible.

And if my birth story isn’t the perfect metaphor for what motherhood feels like in a capitalist, patriarchal society, I don’t know what is.
It's women who came up with those retarded protocols, you simpering sow.

The voices of women choosing to live a childfree life are getting louder and louder — and rightfully so.
Because they replaced their husbands and family with the government, all the way to who will take care of them when they are old.

First, nothing could have prepared me for the rage I’d feel for the continued and unearned praise my daughter’s father receives for simply being seen with her.
Woman is self centered, film at 11.

But why is it that the burden falls so disproportionately on women? Why is a father "babysitting" his own child while a mother is simply doing what’s expected? Why is childcare her responsibility, her career the one to suffer, and her body the one to bear the irreversible changes?
Oh goody, I was waiting for this one.

Well, you sniveling quim, there's a reason. You see, the father goes out and breaks his fucking back for 8-12 hours a day to pay for your lifestyle.

But see, you bitches fucked up.

More and more men have been house-husbands over the last few decades, and we all discovered something.

Housework and taking care of 1-4 kids is NOTHING compared to a fucking job. Fucking NOTHING.

Most men are done with their housework by 9AM, 10AM at the latest. Even when the kids are at home because it's summer or a school break or the child is too young, it's NOTHING.

Kids are easy to handle. You change a fucking diaper with one goddamn hand. You can clean the whole house in a few hours, scrub the floors with a brush and goddamn heavy duty detergent every Mon and Friday.

When we found that out, you bitches lost your fucking minds.

And there is NOTHING a woman hates more than to see a guy who is obviously the house-husband. Getting groceries in the middle of the day with three kids? These bitches will ask if there's something wrong with you that your wife has to work.

No. It falls disproportionately on women because for the most part you earn jack and shit, your best jobs are basically playing with stickers and glitter pens, and do nothing. Your "job" takes more money out of the household in babysitting, car payments, insurance, and other expenses than it puts in, and even then you act like doing the dishes is a big fucking deal.

You aren't banging the laundry on a rock. Even color separating, pre-rinse, bleach bullshit in the washer and tumble dry with folding takes no time at all. Most women don't know how to use a fucking dishwasher or how to remove the burners to clean under the fucking burner. Open the fridge and you'll see 'attack of the brown fluid' in the drawers.

So, hit the bricks. You bitches don't do shit any more and STILL demand that the man do half the housework while you can't be bothered to fold the laundry or suck a dick.
 
I felt genuinely sick when she wrote how much the child, who has seemingly not stayed in one place for 3 months at a time at this point "really enjoyed daycare."
what's wrong with daycare. it's a modern antisocial phenomenon to act like only the mother can care for her child. historically grandma, aunts, neighbors, random old ladies, would help a new mother out.
 
Every parent I've spoken to says some version of the following: that their child is the greatest thing in their life, that they wish they had kids sooner, and that everything in life takes on a new glow because they're seeing things for the first time again through the eyes of their child.
I think that's the normal response and people like this author have some kind of personality disorder.
 
what's wrong with daycare
I don't think that poster was criticizing daycare. The comment says that the kid is being raised in an environment so unstable that he moves every few months. Mom had a series of boyfriends over a two year period, etc.

He might love daycare so much because it's the most stable, dependable thing in his life. That's sad.
 
She’s almost got it. Why is it so hard? Because we’ve atomised society - previously you’d have had extended family around you. You’d have caught up on that sleep because a sister or aunt or friend would have held the baby for a few hours and you’d do the same for them. You’d not be expected to go back to an office four weeks postpartum either . Women worked more around the home
But a few clues in here:
1. Hypbobirthing book = I thought I’d breathe the baby out. Alas, you get the birth you get. Breathing excercises work to a point, but there’s a point by which medical intervention is needed
2. I get the medical trauma stuff. Giving birth can be shockingly violent and the attitude of medical staff can be terrible.
I’m done subscribing to the glamorous image of motherhood that has been sold to us for decades by the media.
What glamorous image? Motherhood has always been tiring, I don’t think I ever got told it was glamour.
I never heard a mom complain about motherhood.
No of course you didn’t. Now think about why and what’s changed in society? But you won’t
Why is a father "babysitting" his own child
This does piss me off. When we’ve needed to wfh due to sick kids he gets ‘oh you’re so involved’ and I get ‘why dont you have a nanny?’ Despite all work being done.
‘You don’t pay me enough to hire one, would it be better if I took this week off?’ No? Ok
My daughter’s dad was able to go clubbing with his friends like nothing ever happened, although our daughter was just 5 days old and I can barely get dressed.
Other problem is she’s married someone who doesn’t help. Men, if the wife doesn’t have a massive extended family, that need to help is even more important. She’s just given birth. Your job is to do everything else for a bit so she can feed the baby and recover. Not go fucking clubbing.
 
It's pretty easy to complain about and make it womens fault when the entirety of society is currently rewarding hooker behavior instead of mother behavior.

Having some arab sheikh shit in you shouldn't be a career choice. But alas

Also @Otterly. I need to ask if this jugdement comes from people who do not have kids themselves. Massive lack of empathy seems to be general rule, them people always know how to do everything better. Huh, like vegans.
 
Last edited:
I wish the lady who wrote this article was less of a self-centered cunt and didn't try to shovel in a bunch of feminist buzzwords, because she does make a few good points.

Child rearing and having a career are incompatible goals. Once a 2-income household became a requirement to survive, motherhood took a huge hit. It's absolutely insane to have women working a job into the 9th month of pregnancy, then returning to work 2 weeks after the birth. This is not good for anybody; not the mothers, not the fathers, not the employers, and especially not the babies. Motherhood for working mothers with children under 6 years old is just a misery for everyone involved and completely retarded. This is an economic, societal issue.

I do believe that there is some romanticization of motherhood by Hollywood, and society in general. There's the 1950s sitcoms like Donna Reed and Leave It to Beaver that made motherhood looks so easy that you can do it in high heels, pearls, and a crisply ironed dress. Then there's the daytime soaps that show an attention-filled, dramatic birth (in full makeup, with beautifully styled hair) but then they rarely actually show the child again, unless it's whisked out, scrubbed and beautifully dressed, to lisp out a quick line and be whisked away again.

In modern sitcoms, there are very few depictions of how difficult child-rearing really is. Mostly the kids are just cute and sassy, and need a talking to in that one special episode, but you rarely saw any of the true difficulties involved in raising them. The only shows I can recall really addressing the problems were Good Times and Malcolm in the Middle. Both of those shows did make an attempt to show how much expense there was in having children, and how much grind work went into raising them with the constant cleaning, laundry, and cooking. Malcolm in the Middle even touched on behavioral issues in the children a few times, although it was a glancing blow. Most media depicts children as cute little angels, not living, breathing human beings who will destroy your house and run your life unless they're taught otherwise. You never saw one of the Brady kids having a full-on nuclear tantrum. A little homily from their gay dad and a cookie from Alice and it was all good again by the end of the episode. They really make it look so simple.

For a very long time, "the innocence of a child" has been highly lauded in society, as if the default setting for humanity is perfection, and children must be taught to sin, but it's the opposite. Children are born completely amoral and selfish and must be taught how to behave, and to care about others. I don't think the current media about childhood and motherhood prepares women for this.

The older women in the family used to let the younger ones in on certain realities about motherhood, but now women are stuck with trying to look it up on Wikihow. Mothering forums are the worst for perpetuating the "innocence of a child" folderol, because nobody wants to admit that their child acts like a savage in front of all the other mothers who won't admit that their children act like savages too. That saying that nobody hates women more than other women is true, because they'll absolutely pile on any women who makes a mistake in mothering and admits it on those forums. Nobody knows how to parent any more, and there's nowhere safe to learn.

She's wrong about Disney promoting motherhood though. Disney promotes (an unrealistic view of) marriage, which obviously turned out to be a huge disappointment to this woman. Rather, Disney features a number of dead mothers and orphans in its stories if you think about it, which is not romantic at all.

I think motherhood would be a lot more appealing to modern women if it were possible to go back to single-income households, but I'm afraid that we just can't stuff that cat back into the bag, and a lot of this feminist bullcrap would make many modern women unwilling to go back to unpaid labor. I really don't see much of a solution, I'm afraid. Time to warm up the fiddles, because modern society is about to burn.
 
I think many women have come to realize that by choosing motherhood, they’re signing up for yet another unpaid full-time job — in an economy where you already need two just to survive.
That’s it. That’s the problem right there. you can throw away the rest of the article.

We have the Rothschilds, Rockefellers, and Kissinger to thank for this. They rather explicitly wanted to flood the workforce with women in order to shore up the tax base, drive down wages, and reduce population growth. If you read the Jaffe Memo and the New Order of Barbarians transcripts, they lay it out explicitly.

“Exponential population growth is bad. We have to do literally everything in our power to stop reproductive incontinence, from promoting homosexuality to forcing women into the workforce, otherwise, the planet will be swarmed and consumed by human locusts.”

This has been the unironic policy of the West for five fucking decades.
 
what's wrong with daycare. it's a modern antisocial phenomenon to act like only the mother can care for her child. historically grandma, aunts, neighbors, random old ladies, would help a new mother out.
@Clotso Coof already answered and covered most of it. The child is secondary to this new mother, of lesser importance than her wonderful holiday which they are too young to participate in, enjoy or experience as anything other than a massive disruption to a life they have only just started.

You are right that expecting a mother or even a two parent household to manage anything solo is something that traditionally was not so common. Family was often a major support function there too, which of course for this parent who left all of that behind to travel the world will not be present.
 
what's wrong with daycare. it's a modern antisocial phenomenon to act like only the mother can care for her child. historically grandma, aunts, neighbors, random old ladies, would help a new mother out.
It depends who is doing it. Being with an aunt or the nice family next door you’ve known for twenty years is fine. We have a variety of other people’s kids traipsing through and an unspoken pact that puts get to go round theirs as well. Putting a tiny baby on a daycare staffed by uncaring and possibly abusive strangers is not great.
We’ve been pretty lucky in that I saved up and took a decent long maternity each time and then they had nice rural nursery where they just mucked around in the woods and drank out of puddles with the local kids all day but they’re not all like that.
@Dumbledore's Onlyfans is spot on.
There ARE a lot of hard things about motherhood and every single one of them bar the medical likelihood of survival is worse than it used to be because of modern society. Even the medical care was more caring back in the day - you used to be in for several days and taken care of, now you’re drained of half your blood volume on a loud ward with strange foreign men peeking through the curtains while you try to breastfeed, and given zero pain relief after c sections. Maybe you live a long way from family because you had to move for a job and can’t afford a house near them.
The years where they are small and you’re working too are exhausting. The bit where you’re pregnant, feel sick, have a toddler just into nursery which gives them a fresh cold each week, and school aged kids who need you too, and you’re at work and they want you to be on calls with Japan at 3 am and then with the American teams at 9pm because they can’t figure out time zones while simultaneously bitching about how we get ‘extended holidays’? Yeah that bit is tiring.
Single income household loss has been a disaster. I don’t know how to fix it
 
Single income household loss has been a disaster. I don’t know how to fix it
Sorry, but as a non-American, it's difficult for me to understand this idea that it's impossible to combine motherhood and work, since I live in a country where extended family taking care of children is more normalized.
Will PL that my mother worked yet she was very present through my whole life in spite of that and didn't seem burned out by both, so maybe it's due to anecdotal experience.
 
Sorry, but as a non-American, it's difficult for me to understand this idea that it's impossible to combine motherhood and work, since I live in a country where extended family taking care of children is more normalized.
Will PL that my mother worked yet she was very present through my whole life in spite of that and didn't seem burned out by both, so maybe it's due to anecdotal experience.
It’s not impossible, it’s just hard. School days ends mid afternoon and someone has to go and get them from school. Someone has to take them to school. That curtails your work day. Our work has a habit of sending us off to stupid international meetings on short notice. I need to coordinate that with my other half. Which means instead of half the pickups and drop offs we are now doing all of them while the other is away. Which again means missing meetings. Our work is multinational so there are calls at odd times and I’ve seen their calendars in the USA - they start early and all leave at 3-4pm, it I’m expected to manage Asia and still be available for America after Europe hours.
Kids get sick, they need to be off school. Ow you need a wfh day - will work grant it? Of not you need to take a day off work.
It all adds up, and it makes it very hard to work like modern corporates demand. Of you’ve got extended family to help with drop offs and pickups and sick days you’re winning. And of course work make you feel guilty for not being at work and then you feel guilty at work for not being with the kids. It’s not easy.
My mum didn’t work until we were all at junior school then she got a part time job. We didn’t have much money, but we couldn’t manage to survive now on the jobs my parents had then. Things have changed
 
We didn’t have much money, but we couldn’t manage to survive now on the jobs my parents had then. Things have changed
Can someone who actually knows explain to me what exactly changed? What changed such that the economy just doesn't work that way anymore? Do immigration and female labor force participation just devalue labor that much?
 
And if my birth story isn’t the perfect metaphor for what motherhood feels like in a capitalist, patriarchal society, I don’t know what is.
I stopped reading at this point. I was sympathetic to her critique of hospitals, but we don't live in a patriarchal society and this isn't men's fault, and anyone who uses that language isn't someone I need to hear from.
 
Can someone who actually knows explain to me what exactly changed? What changed such that the economy just doesn't work that way anymore? Do immigration and female labor force participation just devalue labor that much?
Yes. House prices are so high you need two incomes. Professional jobs require you 24/7. That means you need two parents working. My parents managed a small house and a small car on one income. We can’t.
 
House prices are so high you need two incomes.
This is a piece I was thinking about. Even if we're all wealthier by an amount that offsets labor market shifts in favor of employers, you still have to live somewhere, and immigration also doesn't help with that side of things (plus housing is fucked for so many other reasons).
Professional jobs require you 24/7.
This is another aspect where I think the overall shape of the labor market leads to consequences for how people experience work that's decoupled somewhat from their wealth. If it's just hard to find a new job, people will put up with more and allow employers to demand more of them, and that's for jobs all through the spectrum. Fair enough, for some jobs it makes zero sense to imagine you being able to just come in and put in a shift at will then leave when you feel like it and still be of any value to the company, but when the balance is at least shifted to where it's employers who scramble to find people and feel like they have to put in effort to keep them, that's where workers can get the flexibility to fit work in with demanding life situations like raising young children. I don't think maternity leave is even feminist as implemented, like yeah when you are massively pregnant or actively squeezing out a child it is impossible for you to come in, thanks for noticing. How about something like they let you only work until the early afternoon on the presumption you need to pick up your kids, say until they're all 12 or so?

I don't think the answer is to go and cry to the government about what people should and should not be allowed to do, some of the shit is how it is from overregulation, especially shortsighted regulation that has unintended consequences (e.g. companies avoiding giving people full time employment to avoid having to also give them mandated benefits). Just recognize there's two sides to the equation and things might look better for the average person when the market favors labor. Getting there isn't all fun stuff like being racist and deporting brownos either. I like watching highlight reels of fat black women crying over getting fired from their government jobs as much as the next psychopath, but unless they're all going straight on welfare and staying there, they'll now be in the market for a real job right along with you. It's not that it's always right to pay a bunch of people to dig and fill in holes, but you've got to be clear-eyed about what consequences you get from the policy you choose.

Maybe it's just too late; technology can make us all "wealthier", but it's just going to accelerate cratering the value of a man-hour until the actual valuable work to be done is the tiniest fraction of the available labor. I guess a future where everyone is unemployed still gives mothers a lot more time with their children...

I wasn't hoping to write this much bullshit. I'm gay.
 
Back