Debate the ethics of making fun of Andrew “Charlotte” Fosgate’s suicide - Long way down

[DoNotFeedTheSneed]

Niggas writing books on why it's okay to make fun of trannies on KF.

Obviously it's okay, dumbasses. That's what the site is for. Quit shitting up threads with "uwu my personal opinion is" that shit is gay. Go make a mass debates or something instead

Because of the recent feature, the Tranny Sideshows on Social Media thread has been flooded with people debating the ethics of making fun of the bridge jump. Both sides of the argument - the pearl clutchers and the nay sayers - have derailed the thread’s original purpose of making fun of tranny sideshows. As such, I am creating this mass debates thread as a containment zone. Do you think making fun of the suicide is distasteful? Do you think the people pearl clutching over this are faggots? Litigate it to your heart’s content here instead of over there.

 

[gagabobo1997]

people dying can be funny and moralfagging about it on the stalking website makes you a retard

 

[Unyielding Stupidity]

Reminder to all of the people moralfagging for the tranny that said tranny unironically supported white genocide. If this tranny was still alive, they'd be fantasizing about your death at the hands of a pack of feral Bantus.

 

[wobinbobin]

Reminder to all of the people moralfagging for the tranny that said tranny unironically supported white genocide. If this tranny was still alive, they'd be fantasizing about your death at the hands of a pack of feral Bantus.

Wasn't he white?

 

[Figger Nucker]

Distasteful? Yes.
Funny? Yes.
I don't know what you expect, no one cares when a literal who jumps off a bridge and if you didn't want people to make fun of you, you wouldn't have posted it for everyone to see.

 

[GotFriedBy]

Debating the ethics of mocking a tranny's death while simultaneously posting on the tranny stalking forum is sort of hysterical

 

[San Marino]

Reminder to all of the people moralfagging for the tranny that said tranny unironically supported white genocide. If this tranny was still alive, they'd be fantasizing about your death at the hands of a pack of feral Bantus.

Are we sure it was unironic? It seems like the only evidence for this claim was one throwaway comment he made that could easily be interpreted as a joke. I think its much more likely that he is just making a dumb joke to be contrarian.

 

[Wodanaz]

https://x.com/XJosh/status/1929017723075318084


"The existence of a person whose identity forces me to lie is repugnant to my morals."
-Adolf Hitler, Mein Kampf

 

[BinaricHate]

https://x.com/XJosh/status/1929017723075318084
View attachment 7440087

"The existence of a person whose identity forces me to lie is repugnant to my morals."
-Adolf Hitler, Mein Kampf

this is actually fake.

 

[User names must be unique]

Don't you dare make fun of him, he was an hero.

 

[Wodanaz]

this is actually fake.
View attachment 7440091

falsely attributing based quotes to respected historical figures is so fucking kino

 

[GunCar Gary]

women in stinkditch and simping for degenerate faggots. name a more iconic duo

 

[Fuck Fags I'm A Homophobe]

17 year old autistic man kills himself.

Suicide is the pussy way out.

Ideally, he shouldn't have needed so many pills and estrogen, etc, in order to live, but alas, the trannies got to him.

It's sad but.. damn. We really need to do something about this transgender issue.

 

[Gremperor]

My favorite is this one.

I am so saddened that communities like this lead people to stuff like this...and then these same sites mock them...
You'd be so much better off if you viewed this not as a "haha funny a man killed himself because nobody went along with his delusions" but instead "Why does this keep happening? Why do so many young trans people end up committing suicide?" and treat her suicide with respect she deserves.
All people deserve respect and care. It doesn't matter if they're trans, "illegals", "aliens", criminals, ect. They are all humans after all. You cannot judge a group of people via a few individuals (unless they're nazis), and even if all of them were somehow evil, mocking them like this is making you look even worse.
I feel awful associating with this site, but it IS the best place to find info on several individuals which have legitimate reasons for criticism. Like Chris Chan, who can pull shit off that no troll could make him do all on his own. Or Pizzacake, who cannot separate her porn from her family content. Or Keffals, who spent all of her legal funds on drugs and vacations, as well as being a part of several communist organisations.
Do better.

I thought it was a joke at first because of how embarrassing it is but he's on the CWCki for being a sperg so who knows.

Link (Archive)

 

[Preacher ✝]

It is possible to disapprove of suicide from a moral standpoint and still mock it.

It is also possible to think it is generally wrong to mock suicide and still find this particular suicide funny.

Especially considering that this was his last post, ~3hours before the bridge picture:

 

[Hellwalker]

I don't really care, much like with a lot of shit that gets people up and arms on the site, but all I'll say is...

A dead troon is a good troon.

 

[Sparkletor 2.0]

Just like school shooters, people who commit a very public suicide are trying to get as much visibility as they can through horrible methods. His suicide was trying to send a message. Instead of validation, I say give him humiliation. He wanted attention, he can have attention. If we look at the truth of the matter, this man could not accept life as an adult. Needing to get a job, man up, and be a productive member of society. He wanted to remain a child forever and live in a fantasy land where he could be a pretty princess. He wanted to shirk all responsibilities and to just play and have fun with no consequences. When reality finally hit him in the face his only logical conclusion was to kill himself rather than grow up.

He was a loser. Now he's a dead loser.

Ha ha.

 

[RuPaul’s Drag Racist]

“When your enemy kills xirself, you win”
-Fidel Castro

 

[Mound Dweller]

The man is dead, whatever he was is passed onto memory, we should all be so lucky to exist after our mortal demise in the thoughts of so many.

 

[Lammy]

In a cycle of abuse, victims tend to become the next abusers.

Is the suffering of a victim unjust? Of course.
Is justice against an abuser right? Of course.

The question is, at what point does the victim become the next abuser?
And did this person cross that threshold? And perhaps could they have later in life walked away from their troonism instead of becoming another abuser?

I don't think there's a clear cut answer.

However, the jokes are funny and I don't think humor is necessarily bound to the constraints of morality.

The real tragedy was this person's grooming and enabling, moreso than their suicide. I see people talking about "empathy for the family that lost their child", but I have very little for a family that personally enabled it to the degree of literally injecting the troonshine needles into their child with their own hands.