What are your thoughts on this reddit comic about a Sikhs who fought in WW1 managing to argue he is White/Caucasion to attain US citizenship?

The racial distinction between high- and low-caste Indians is more historical than anything, saying that you're a TRVE PVREBLQQD BHARATIYA ARYAN because you're a "Brahmin" doesn't hold water outside of Hindustan
Also even the Irish weren't considered "white" in the early 20th century, what makes you think that your brown ass would be?
 
Last edited:
  • Agree
  • Like
  • Dumb
Reactions: Justsomecicada, Helvítis Túristi, Markass the Worst and 1 other person
DJ Grelle said:
The US handled correctly, he isn't white no matter how much he tries to twist and turn about it.
It's just jealousy and resentment all the way down.
Click to expand...
Should the US have forbidden him from serving in the army or at least set up something similar to the French Foreign Legion?
 
Last edited:
foreman 89 said:
Should the US have forbidden him from serving in the army or atheist set up something to the French Foreign Legion?
Click to expand...
Forbidden from service, the FFL automatically confers citizenship on completion of a tour of duty.
The US doesn't have enough sikhs to set up a gurkha regiment so it really does not matter.
 
Catgirl Tyranid said:
I'm not going to go to reddit fuck tard.
Click to expand...
Daddy's Little Kitten said:
You really think I'm gonna click on a reddit link?
Click to expand...
The basic cliffnotes so you don't have to look at ugly reddit tier 'artwork'
- Stinky brown turban wearing Sikh wants to become a US citizen
- Joins American army to fight in WW1
- US passes 'naturalization act' allowing alien members of the military to become US citizens for serving
- Stinky brown turban man gets citizenship
- Citizenship revoked 4 days later because he was not classified as a "free white person" which is a requirement for the naturalization act
- Stinky brown turban man appeals
- Denied
- Takes it to supreme court
- Tries to claim he is actually a white boi because he's a "aryan indian" of high caste that should be regarded as white despite being visibly brown and stinky
- Claims a japaneese was given citizenship and so too should he
- Court tells brown stinky man the nip was living in 'merica for over 20 years and already assimilated well thus allowing him citizenship, while the brown stinky man is too brown and stinky to be given citizenship
- Court says he's not white and therefore doesn't qualify for citizenship
- Visibly brown and presumably still stinky turban man goes "nuh uh I'm still white on technicalities bro"
- Court says he may be technically caucasian if you do enough mental gymnastics but the court states he is still in fact both brown and stinky
- Many years later congress passes an act allowing brown and stinky foreigners to get US citizenship if they were part of the US army in WW1
- Brown stinky turban man now has citizenship
 
  • Informative
  • TMI
  • Agree
Reactions: Rapesputin, Catgirl Tyranid and Daddy's Little Kitten
What thoughts are you looking for? He failed in his pursuit of getting recognized as a free white man, it took the abolishment of that requirement for him to achieve naturalization.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Rapesputin
Blue Gem Kosher Queen said:
I'm obviously not the target audience for this thread but he deserved his citizenship. This guy is what all migrants should be.
Click to expand...
>"prolly going to get downvoted for this"
>reacts are exclusively positive

Thank you for your thematic post. It's like I'm still on Reddit.

Anyway, my thoughts are that this comic is anti white propaganda using autistic early 20th century judges as "proof", and somehow the moral of the story is that we shouldn't have borders even though the entire reason Thind's story is compelling is because he was fully assimilated, which approximately zero percent of illegal immigrants are.

My personal opinion on his case is that he should have been granted citizenship, but only because he was assimilated. Only people willing to become Americans, not hyphenated Americans, should be allowed to live here.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Rapesputin and LilShotaBoy
Megaton Punch said:
>"prolly going to get downvoted for this"
>reacts are exclusively positive

Thank you for your thematic post. It's like I'm still on Reddit.
Click to expand...
I meant it for this part.
foreman 89 said:
A lot of the users on this site are White nationalists or even further with racial science being one of the core parts of your ideology.
Click to expand...
I'm a fucking mutt kike, what ya want me to do? And yes, this is edgy Reddit. You can't call people out for thirstposting anymore.
 
Last edited:
the supreme court made the right decision because brown people are not human and animals do not get to become citizens of the US
 
DJ Grelle said:
The US handled correctly, he isn't white no matter how much he tries to twist and turn about it.
It's just jealousy and resentment all the way down.
Click to expand...
It's jealousy and resentment to think that you should be able to become a citizen of the country you legally reside in and served for? Are you fucking retarded?
 
Soyjak Enjoyer said:
It's jealousy and resentment to think that you should be able to become a citizen of the country you legally reside in and served for? Are you fucking retarded?
Click to expand...
It's about him being white, he was desperate to be seen as one of the "civilized" even though the sikhs are little better than the rest of the subcontinentals.

You lack reading comprehension
 
  • Agree
Reactions: Rapesputin
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back