Snowflake Nethilia / Tasha Campbell - Doll-sperg with a social-justice twist

New blog post: https://americangirloutsider.blogspot.com/2018/01/rambled-opinions-and-general-snarkiness.html

She gave her thoughts on the Farms:
Screen Shot 2018-01-03 at 11.54.52 AM.png

I like how the person who sexualizes children thinks anyone who calls her out is the disappointment to the world.
 
I kind of agree that it's dumb for AG to put boys in their American Girl line. Maybe start a branch-off company, American Boy or Brothers of America or something like that?

But I'm not going to rage about it and throw in stupid Tumblr catchphrases like "cause a pirate is free" or "I'm too gay for this shit".
 
  • Agree
Reactions: Mrs Paul
My favorite part of the post is where she spergs about how makerspace (3D printers I guess) being male coded then proceeds to rant paragraph after paragraph about how good she is at making yarn and sewing and how that makes her soooo talented and special and better than you.

But I make things. I make my things of cloth and needle and thread, of wool and sticks, of spin and twist, with paintbrushes and inks. I can turn raw sheep hair into viable yarn and can precisely tangle that into a sweater of any size, given the dimensions of the wearer and some basic math, and if I get any further back on the "making cloth" diagram I'm gonna be living on a lesbian farm full of sheep and alpaca. I know what colors to mix together and what concentration of acid and the time frames to make the chemical reaction that makes dye color stick to wool or cotton or other things and stay there without running out. Then I can take my newly made colored string--or other colored string of the same general thickness--and make socks or hats or sweaters or anything, and then write down how I turned it into a pair of socks or hat or whatever. If I use the right codes for how I made my thing, someone can follow my code, and make the same thing I made. I know color theory and balance, so that things look good together.

I got bored while thinking of the next part of my book, popped the cape off my stuffed Pikachu, figured out how to put it back on, and put it back on--all in an hour, the same way someone would take apart a vacuum and put it back together. I used to gut my stuffies and disassemble clothes to fix broken seams the same ways children are encouraged to know the inner workings of a small motor or find the error in lines of code that make a bug.

spweh.jpg


My makerspace has rulers, fluff, stacks of patterns and books, three sewing machines (even if only one ever likes to behave), fistfuls of knitting needles and crochet hooks, four drop spindles (just got a turkish, that bitch spins like a dream) tons of art supplies, and a spinning wheel. Someday, I'll have a dressmaker dummy and a proper home embroidery machine. I made a whole quilt, bigger than a king sized bed.

Congrats. You made a quilt way too big to be useful. Have fun washing that thing and getting it to dry. I have a king size bed and it is monstrous. I can't imagine a quilt bigger than the type for a king size bed. What the hell was the point of making a quilt that you can tarp an SUV with?

I can look at an outfit, and my brain figures out how to take it apart into pattern parts and I can make those pattern pieces and then make them go together and then write to another person how to put the pieces together and they can get the same thing I made! I can take something from 3D to 2D and then back to 3D again--or an illustration to a 3D representation, for those many of us that turn AG's old illustrations to outfits--and I can do it well, for all that bullshit about women not knowing how to think in 3D proper because I personally can't think about what a box might look like flat or the other side of a shape figure. I am starting to study puppet making and want to, when it's viable, make a decent working puppet and self perform with it, even if it's just for fun..

Lord help us all! Neth wants to become a puppeteer!

Anyone who brags this much about how talented they is either far less skilled than they claim in real life so they just brag online or is so smug about what they can actually do that they are absolutely insufferable to be around in any sort of professional or casual setting. She's probably the type that would look at the sweater you are knitting and start giving you "friendly" advice on how to fix it.

But according to STEM, I'm not a "maker", I'm a "crafter", because the shit I do is heavily feminine coded. And the fuck outta here with that shit. I am disgusted at how how "maker" culture is considered making "proper" techy things using 3-D printers and electronics and wires and LEGO and spark components with oil and dirt and wires and engines, and not that "silly girly" shit of using cloth and string, or string and one or two sticks, and making a shirt. I will die on the fucking hill of "don't you dare tell me my makework of putting together a dress from cloth and paper diagrams is less cool than making a blueprint for a 3D printer to form a figurine." Plus when the power goes out I can still put a dress together, so hah.

Making is to crafting as action figure is to doll. If you're going to devalue my makercraft because it's not coded masculine enough, then I expect you in the apocalypse not to ask folk to make you anything to wear. Go turn your computer into a suit.

But sewing and knitting is crafting Neth. It has always been crafting. How is it even remotely the same as 3D printing? No one's saying that sewing is less cool than making 3D printed action figures, programming and making elaborate Lego models. We all need clothes Neth. It's just that sewing did not start out as a hobby. For thousands of years, before the industrial revolution started us on the road to mass produced clothing being readily available, if you didn't want to be naked you had to be able to sew, knit and weave. It was a necessary life skill and women had to learn it to prepare themselves for marriage. Because you couldn't just go to Walmart and buy your family new clothes. You had to make them yourself.

3D printing, despite some really useful applications, is still pretty much a hobby. No one is saying that you as a woman cannot use a 3D printer. Women, like men, are free to craft whatever they want to using the tools available. No one is stopping you. By the way, there are plenty of men who knit and sew. And here they are doing this female coded hobby without sperging out about how unfair life is because STEM is about technology and not sewing a quilt the size of a circus tent.

Neth is back to bashing Tenney again. I do actually think that Tenney may have been the original pick for 2017 Girl of the Year unless Neth is lying about accessories for Gabby being thin. But when people cry foul nonstop about dolls of color you end up with a half assed launch because the company wanted to please people quickly. I do think they have a problem with doll diversity. But it probably really does reflect their demographics and what dolls actually sell.

that bird on the shirt just confirms that Gabby's earrings were supposed to be for Tenney and AG cut her short.

I do actually believe this. The designs don't lie.

I actually really like the Luciana doll and would be all over this if it came out when I was a kid. Of course we wouldn't be able to buy it. But I'd still drool.

I think that Neth crying foul over Maker culture in a post featuring a STEM themed doll who has a "Maker Station" accessory available is completely and utterly without self awareness if I ever saw it. Here's a very positive toy for girls but all Neth can do is whine about how much cooler her ability to make doll clothes is compared to those icky boys and their custom made action figures.

If you look at the pictures Neth took you'll see overweight middle aged ladies about. No kids. Maybe Neth just tries to keep kids out of the shots. But I'm thinking when you go to an American Girl store the norm tends to be doll obsessed adult fatties.
 
Here she is once again whining about boy dolls: https://americangirloutsider.blogspot.com/2018/01/rambled-opinions-and-general-snarkiness_3.html

They have expanded the boy doll line beyond Logan (or Nogan as Neth likes to call him). They are from the Truly Me line and feature white, Asian, Hispanic (or ambiguously brown as Neth says) and black. You'd think someone as #woke as Neth would finally realise that this is a step in the right direction for the lack of AG diversity she's always complaining about. But no. she still hates boy dolls for some bizarre reason.

She starts out oddly positive and I thought at first that meant she changed her tune.
AG Boys: Let's start with what everyone noticed recently so I can get this out of the way. Truly Me showed up to their new year's party with something no one needed for any more than we needed Nogan: boys. That's right, AG has more boys now. Four of them. I understand the idea of expand the line to draw boys in, and boy dolls are apparently a thing on IG and among other collectors. I did see a couple boys in the store saying "oh this is cool, there's dolls like me!" Yes, boys should learn to like dolls as much as girls, instead of toys being hard gendered so that boys can't have creative doll play and growing up to become shitty ass men whe resent anyone over the age of nine who has dolls and enjoys their hobbies instead of being into what they think people should be. Boys playing with dolls doesn't make boys gay, and if you think they do you should go eat a bowl of glass. And other lines have stared doing boys, so AG is just getting in on a thing that's been happening for some time.

She then goes on to bash the face sculpts and I could not see how they were manly.
One of the weird things about the boys is that they were modified from the face molds to have closed mouths and slightly "firmer" jawlines. Which is. Uh. Ahem. Time for another rant!

Boy dolls in the prepubescent age rage shouldn't have firm manly jaws. Carpatina was one of the first lines to do boys, and when you look at Adam and Carter they--uh. They don't look right at all. They look like old man heads on young boy bodies. Dissonance! Later dolls by the brand look better, but it still occasionally has the issue and part of the problem is very quick to articulate. The manufacturers don't want the boys to look girly or feminine, and one of the major differences in men and women's face shapes (stylistically/artistically, not always) is the jawline. Ladies are portrayed with soft jawlines, and men are portrayed with a sharper, more emphasized jawline. So designers lean towards giving their boy dolls a severely strong jaw, like a teenage boy might have, so that they look less "girly." Some also make the eyes smaller.

Now maybe it's just me or the fact that I haven't seen the dolls in person. But they have round, chubby baby faces to me. I think they look pretty young. When I think of a strong jaw I think more square not so round.
IMG_8771.JPG

They look like three year olds to me. Nice Chris Chan shirts BTW.

And the dolls all have the same bodies. So Neth can just make a troon. After all, she's in to sexualizing effigies of eight year old children. Diversity Neth! Diversity!

In trying to make a male doll appear less feminine, companies make their boys look too "old," and it's uncanny valley and off enough to be uncomfortable when paired with what's supposed to be an eight to ten year old girl. It's as uncanny as it is to take a Bitty Baby Head and put it on an 18" body because that head's too "young." AG didn't go as severe as some companies--just look at Carpatina again and fear everything--but they still added some thickness to the jaw, as well as thicker eyebrows which is also a thing little boys don't have. Also the closed mouth only hurts the whole idea that "Kaya has a boyish face" because of her closed mouth, and I might have to kick someone if they keep implying that Native people are boyish.

All of this is to say I just don't like boy dolls. Hell I despise 90% of boy dolls. I rarely had Kens growing up, I ignored all but one of my male Monster High Dolls,2 and I only enjoy boy ponies in limited styles and generally only Gen 1 where they have the fuzzy feets. To me AG boys are just 18 inches of Ken. I'm too gay for this shit and I'm too gay for boys. At least they popped in quietly, instead of being everywhere and hyped and getting the focus. There was no one hovering over the boys on Luciana's day, even. They just slid in with all the other new stuff.

But it's ok for Neth to pair herself with an eight year old girl doll/use her as a proxy for her adult sexuality. And surprise! It's a white doll she does that with despite constantly going on and on about the blackness of Abby and Gabby. Internalized racism much, Neth?

I don't think that Kaya looks boyish. I actually prefer the closed mouth. But I can understand why her mold was used for Logan. She was ambiguous looking enough if you gave her boy's clothes and hair. If she wasn't a DOC you would not be complaining as much about "Nogan the face stealer". But you's still complain Neth. And I do agree that it's cheap. However, companies reuse molds all the time. It would have been nice to give the first boy doll his own original face. But maybe it was a time issue or someone wanted to save a few bucks.

Who actually says Native people are boyish? Is this a thing? I always hear that Native women are fetisized and overly sexualized. That doesn't sound like being viewed as boyish to me.

No one cares what you personally prefer Neth. Anyone can buy any doll they choose or buy or make any clothing they choose. If they want Logan to wear Addy's dress, hey they can even do that. You can't stop them. Yet you seem to think you are the boss of AG and they must cater to your personal needs and feelings.

Also:
IMG_8788.JPG

Come on Neth, the store is full of people and employees and you are pulling down doll pants to take pics of doll panties? What the hell is wrong with you?
 
No one cares what you personally prefer Neth. Anyone can buy any doll they choose or buy or make any clothing they choose. If they want Logan to wear Addy's dress, hey they can even do that. You can't stop them. Yet you seem to think you are the boss of AG and they must cater to your personal needs and feelings.
No!!!!!!!!! You cannot put any other doll in Addy's dresses except Addy!!!!!!!!!!! And you cannot put any other doll's dress on Addy!!!!!!!!!!!!!! REE WHITEWASHING YOU RACIST
 
Come on Neth, the store is full of people and employees and you are pulling down doll pants to take pics of doll panties? What the hell is wrong with you?
Imagine working at that store and seeing this shit.

I also like how she calls the black doll "Black Dude" but the other non-white ones are "Generic Asian" and "Ambiguously Brown" Much progressive. Very social justice. wow

A commenter brought up that the jaws weren't changed:
Screen Shot 2018-01-15 at 1.01.10 PM.png
Screen Shot 2018-01-15 at 1.02.27 PM.png

Also:
Screen Shot 2018-01-15 at 1.02.46 PM.png
:horrifying:
 
Last edited:
Screen Shot 2018-01-17 at 11.25.17 AM.png


If it wasn't about not judging people for the color of their skin, then what was it?
 
How the FUCK does she afford all of this shit? It makes what Chris spends on Lego look like pennies. AG stuff is seriously expensive.

Somewhere in the first few pages of the thread, there is a post about how she found a doll at a thrift store and the wording implies it wasn't the first time and there was another about finding a Wellie Wisher for about a third of the full price at some fair, so not everything was purchased for full price. Some posts on her blog talk about being gifted AG stuff and she also makes clothes for them as well. But she still buys new stuff, though since I have only skimmed her blog and instagram I don't know how often that happens. Though even if less than half her horde was purchased new/full price, that is some serious dough to drop on toys. Not to mention she has duplicates in her stash, which is just a waste of any amount of money. She also has other toy related interests, so there is even more money being spent on toys.
 
The ego on this woman astounds me. I recently got a used AG doll with slightly jacked hair and wound up looking up braid spray for dolls today and one of the things on the first page is her post about how ungrateful the AG fandom is and how she totally came up with the idea of using braid spray on doll hair. Aside from it being doubtful that she was the first ever to think of it, trading tips kind of works like a game of telephone. It only takes one person to forget to credit her and with how fast things can move online, it ends with no one really knowing who came up with the idea.

And she calls all the other Truly Me 26 dolls 'Fauxtters', because apparently Otters the Pagan is the One True Doll and the others are cheap imitations. It's so pathetic that it loops around to funny. They're dolls, they're all created equal. Her life must be so empty if she needs to make her dolls the Grand Supreme.

Also, even with her coupon, she still paid nearly a hundred bucks for the doll alone and would have dropped over a hundred bucks for the outfits that are backordered. You need to be a rewards member to get the space suit, but that seems to be a free thing. Though I do wonder what membership tier she's on.
 
"Otters" seems like a rather ridiculous nickname and tbh it's always bugged me. Why the extra S on the end? It does not sound like the name of a person.

Reminds me of when my younger brother, as a toddler, wanted to name a stuffed sheep "Grass'd" because it liked to eat grass.
 
Back