Jerry Peet / Lily Orchard / Lily Peet / Valkyrstudios / Bhaalspawn / Tara Callie / "Mod Ebara" - Sociopath writer of pedophile fanfiction and cartoon reviews, faked getting raped to force a divorce, then mobbed and gaslit their ex off Tumblr, satanist neoliberal of the MovieSlob variety, also wants to fuck dogs and/or pokemon

[X-Shaped Weeaboo]

Part way through the SU video he claimed about white boy Steven being a messianic special who is the arbiter of the show's objective morality among all these supposed strong female characters. And then later he went on to call the actually female show runner of a pretty acclaimed cartoon a stupid piece of shit and implied he could do better than her.

He doesn't outright imply it, he swears by it on his Tumblr with his stupid as shit WoW fanfic.

Hilarious that he call Steven a messianic archtype give that his favorite self-insert, Lord Ryder, is exactly that. Complete with the "Surrounded by strong female characters" shtick too.

 

[Piga Dgrifm]

I will never ever fucking get over how pasty-ass, pale-ass Jerry Peet who seems to live in a place with no natural light constantly commissions drawings of himself as a fucking brown-ass woman.

Fucking hilarious, the delusions here.

Surprised the rest of the SocJus clan hasn't called him out on this. Isn't this "digital blackface" in their world?

 

[X-Shaped Weeaboo]

Surprised the rest of the SocJus clan hasn't called him out on this. Isn't this "digital blackface" in their world?

I'd imagine they wouldn't be familiar with his reputation in the YouTube community, especially since posting his work in places like GamerGhazi and Tumblr. They probably have no idea who he actually is and because they're pants on head stupid, they probably wouldn't care and call it progressive for someone to "so vehemently identify with their Native heritage" or whatever.

 

[Neil]

Holy shit, I just skimmed through that Steven Universe video, and WOW is it bad.

How does someone within this show's target demographic miss the point THIS bad? SU has a lot of issues, but this video didn't even hit ANY of them. It's literally two hours of some sweaty manchild with a female cartoon avatar screeching about how Rebecca Sugar isn't pandering enough to her political and moral sensibilities.

Spoiler: Rant expanded

This dumbass lacks taste so much that they had the fucking audacity to say that the Diamond battle after Ruby and Sapphire's wedding "ruined" the episode, as if children want to have an entire episode of two of the show's most obnoxious characters with no motivation other than their desperate longing to fuck each other after each and every break up they go through finally having it confirmed that they'll be able to stay fused for the next 70 episodes of filler before breaking up again.

From one moment to another, he jumps from "RUBY AND SAPPHIRE ARE THE BEST CHARACTERS IN THE SHOW UWU I LOVE MY GAY BABIESSSS" to "REEE NOT ENOUGH GAY, 'BLINK AND YOU'LL MISS ITTT!!' REBECCA SUGAR IS BURYING THE GAAAAAAAYSSS"(despite Ruby and Sapphire having 3 kissing scenes in the show, each uncensored and blatant).

He complains about the plot not moving anywhere, yet applauds pointless shit like Ruby and Sapphire's repetitive relationship struggles, then proceeding to complain about the Diamonds' appearance (muh space fascistssss!!!1) and any of the story's twists and turns. Sure, the show is meant to have a huge moral message behind it, but do we really need to waste a billion episodes worth of screentime with characters doing shit unrelated to the plot? Oh wait, it's only okay when it strokes his political ego.

Oh, and on the "MUH EVIL FASCISTSSSS!!" topic, it also amazes me how he thinks that having the Diamonds show a sympathetic side is somehow bad, because all bad guys (especially those mean evil bully jerk fascists) are supposed to be 100% black-and-white evil with no other traits.

It's also hilarious how when he bitches about the "bad animation quality", he only shows clips from season one.

Really, a lot of this moron's issues with the show seem to stem from his own personal grief. This video is projection, after projection, after projection. This guy really seems to hate any pretense of forgiveness in any way shape or form.

Mr. Enter back in 2013 wasn't even this bad when it came to criticizing a show. The most he ever did was insult Zeus Cervas directly. Jerry here seems to actually legitimately hate Rebecca Sugar and think she's an awful person who's responsible for everything wrong in his life this children's show.

Actual quote from the video: "I don't think animation is a critical priority for this show"
Another thing from the video: >Calling Rebecca Sugar a clueless moron on the topic of fascism despite the fact that she's the descendant of a Holocaust Survivor
I'm done here. Jerry Peet, go to hell.

 

[The Iconoclast]

Calling Rebecca Sugar a clueless moron on the topic of fascism despite the fact that she's the descendant of a Holocaust Survivor

Is that an exact quote? Because if so...
~~Devil's advocacy alert~~
...It's not inherently wrong. That's like saying that it's absurd to claim that some kid knows nothing about war despite the fact that his father was a soldier.

I don't think that's his view though.

 

[Campbell-Duo]

"Another thing from the video: >Calling Rebecca Sugar a clueless moron on the topic of fascism despite the fact that she's the descendant of a Holocaust Survivor"


Imagine saying this in a serious rant video that is meant to be taken seriously, this and the fucking "The su staff stole fan theories to fuel the show"

IF YOUR THEORY WAS RIGHT YOU GUESSED RIGHT BE HAPPY YOU TOOL

 

[Piga Dgrifm]

How does someone within this show's target demographic miss the point THIS bad? SU has a lot of issues, but this video didn't even hit ANY of them.

The only legitimate issue he talked about was how the show gets off model a whole lot. That's it.

Is that an exact quote? Because if so...
~~Devil's advocacy alert~~
...It's not inherently wrong. That's like saying that it's absurd to claim that some kid knows nothing about war despite the fact that his father was a soldier.

I don't think that's his view though.

I mean, his only reason for thinking she's clueless on the topic is that she made the diamonds characters with their own development instead of just cookie cutter villains who do nothing but look sinister and have no depth.

 

[The Iconoclast]

I mean, his only reason for thinking she's clueless on the topic is that she made the diamonds characters with their own development instead of just cookie cutter villains who do nothing but look sinister and have no depth.

Right, what I was saying was that it's not a wrong point to say that she's clueless on fascism despite being a holocaust survivor's descendant. But Jerry's point was that she's a Nazi sympathizer for making us want to feel anything but contempt for a fascist villain, which is fucking retarded for reasons I've explained.

 

[Grand Lunar]

Right, what I was saying was that it's not a wrong point to say that she's clueless on fascism despite being a holocaust survivor's descendant. But Jerry's point was that she's a Nazi sympathizer for making us want to feel anything but contempt for a fascist villain, which is fucking exceptional for reasons I've explained.

To be completely fair on this, it is kind of grating that the show is so casual in its portrayal of the diamonds despite them having destroyed dozens of planets and killed millions of their own species. The Bismuth episode forcing a "killing is always wrong" message despite the fact that they were in an all out war and being killed by the millions was actually pretty eyerollworthy as well.

 

[Lurk Jurk]

Right, what I was saying was that it's not a wrong point to say that she's clueless on fascism despite being a holocaust survivor's descendant. But Jerry's point was that she's a Nazi sympathizer for making us want to feel anything but contempt for a fascist villain, which is fucking exceptional for reasons I've explained.

He also assumes we're meant to feel sorry for Blue just because she cries all the time despite her depression powers being presented as downright terrifying and her grief making her unstable and dangerous. Oh we saw one song that shows what motivates two villains and that means they're "woobified" and we're supposed to forget everything bad they did and the show will too? Even though the show isn't even close to addressing it yet? The two literally crashed a wedding and then Steven showed them what their attack did to the gems on Earth and then they were off to Homeworld again to talk to White Diamond. I mean, sure, the show has godawful pacing issues. But again that's nothing people don't know.

I don't think the show is even passing the buck to White Diamond. Blue and Yellow talk about her like she's a senile parent with a temper you have to be very careful what you say to. Everything about her makes them uncomfortable. They seem to be running things without much input from her so their disregard for the lives of their servant gems is all on them. Honestly the glimpses of this totalitarian caste system the gems have is pretty much the most worthwhile thing in the show. And it's interesting because they're NOT human, they're literally all AI super computers made for specific roles and some even take more resources to create than others. It's hard to argue "everyone is equal" to a species where everyone quantifiably isn't and if the show actually explores that it'd be cool.

I mean, there's a chance it won't and the Diamonds will immediately change their minds and be redeemed with the power of friendship cause anime, but when the show pulls its head out of its ass and is good it tends to be really interesting, which is what keeps people watching it.

(Redeeming terrible people cause they're fun characters is very anime too. Oh hey Vegeta you blew up planets, murdered scores of people and killed half our friends? Nah you're cool now.)


I have to agree with his bitching about Lars tho. He's a brat that Sugar seems to especially like and then the writers gave up and basically killed him and replaced him with the end point of character development that never happened.

 

[Ironic Impact]

Wait a second, in Jerry's Legend of Korra review, he lambasted Bryke for making the spirit lore black and white and making Vaatu into satan, but now he's harping on SU for not being black and white enough and not making the diamonds into satan.

 

[Totentanz]

Is he aware that the entire character arc of Luke Skywalker and the original Star Wars trilogy is that of redeeming what many would consider an irredeemable fascist and war criminal?

 

[chadmuska]

Is he aware that the entire character arc of Luke Skywalker and the original Star Wars trilogy is that of redeeming what many would consider an irredeemable fascist and war criminal?

It's not the prequel trilogy so it lacks enough choreographed lightsaber fights to care about or remember silly little plot details like the entire arc and motiviations of the main character

 

[Durenduren]

He likes to reference obscure twitter and interview quotes from Sugar everywhere else in the video except for the really famous one where she outright says "Rose was a terrible person" as he's accusing her of not understanding that Pearl and Rose's relationship is unhealthy and not understanding she "ruined the hero" when it was revealed Rose was a member of the ruling class slumming it and orchestrating an entire revolution of people she didn't really see as her equals to get out of her own responsibilities. Which as far as I can see is the point cause shit suddenly makes more sense after that.

He's right about some of the writing being unbalanced and some of it being a direct retconned response to criticism and some of it having unfortunate implications (like the one character who is an explicit representative of a black woman being characterized as too violent and unreasonable by the viewpoint of the show for wanting to bring revolution to her oppressed people and it turns out her leader who jailed her for it was secretly a member of the ruling class oppressing them and yeah), but that's shit people already knew.

He's also right about Steven turning into a sanctimonious little shit and that becoming how he solves every conflict, but do you also expect a 14 year old boy to start tearing down the ideology of the space fascists the moment he meets them? Also in a show where they try to cram all this world building, character development and plot into 11 minute chunks (seriously 20 minute episodes would solve so many of the show's goddamn problems.)

But then the last half hour of the video is just a confused tangent about barely anything.

:late: everyone and their great grandma knows that this show is flawed as fuck, but people looked up at Jerry as if he's the voice of reason and acted like he's the first person to talk shit about SU when there's countless of videos people talking about it, if not, way better than Jerry put out.:late:

 

[Campbell-Duo]

The Bismuth episode forcing a "killing is always wrong" message despite the fact that they were in an all out war and being killed by the millions was actually pretty eyerollworthy as well.

The bismuth episode tried to do what batman says. "if i kill i become just as bad as them." The main gems dont want to shatter or harm any other gems which is why we see them bubble every gem from the monster of the week part of season 1. Bismuth only existed at that time to show that shattering was wrong (for some reason the cluster didn't already make that point mute) and that even allies could be on par with the bad guys.

 

[Grand Lunar]

The bismuth episode tried to do what batman says. "if i kill i become just as bad as them." The main gems dont want to shatter or harm any other gems which is why we see them bubble every gem from the monster of the week part of season 1. Bismuth only existed at that time to show that shattering was wrong (for some reason the cluster didn't already make that point mute) and that even allies could be on par with the bad guys.

That isn't comparable. The bubbled corrupted gems are from the post-war era, and due to being corrupted appear completely at random. Bubbling them in this case is sufficient to neutralize the threat.

In the context of the gem war, this makes no sense. It would be like if the Allied Powers handed Europe over to the Nazis in WWII because "killing is wrong" and it would be immoral to fight back. Homeworld was shattering crystal gems by the millions, and based on what was said here the crystal gems apparently continued to show restraint and only poofed homeworld gems, allowing them to continually regenerate and come back to shatter more of their own. This really is a silly and obnoxiously naive message.

 

[Chapter Master Tu'Shan]

That isn't comparable. The bubbled corrupted gems are from the post-war era, and due to being corrupted appear completely at random. Bubbling them in this case is sufficient to neutralize the threat.

In the context of the gem war, this makes no sense. It would be like if the Allied Powers handed Europe over to the Nazis in WWII because "killing is wrong" and it would be immoral to fight back. Homeworld was shattering crystal gems by the millions, and based on what was said here the crystal gems apparently continued to show restraint and only poofed homeworld gems, allowing them to continually regenerate and come back to shatter more of their own. This really is a silly and obnoxiously naive message.

Double so because it's not even like Bismuth's said that she wanted to shatter all of the Homeworld Gems to win the war. She always talked specifically about the "Elites" and "Upper Crusts", so her plan clearly was to take out the leadership of Homeworld in order to free the common Gems.

 

[dag1984]

You know what? For all the time Lily spends bitching about the redemption of villains or bigots I have never seen him offer an alternative. Like with Starlight Glimmer (since Lily hates her so much) HOW is Twilight going to punish her without pushing the show's G-rating? In terms of power Starlight is nearly equal to Twilight, HOW will Twilight punish her in any meaningful way? It's the same deal with the Diamonds, they are immensely powerful and difficult to beat. Hell Yellow Diamond showed they can instantly poof a gem in one blow.

 

[Chapter Master Tu'Shan]

You know what? For all the time Lily spends bitching about the redemption of villains or bigots I have never seen him offer an alternative. Like with Starlight Glimmer (since Lily hates her so much) HOW is Twilight going to punish her without pushing the show's G-rating? In terms of power Starlight is nearly equal to Twilight, HOW will Twilight punish her in any meaningful way? It's the same deal with the Diamonds, they are immensely powerful and difficult to beat. Hell Yellow Diamond showed they can instantly poof a gem in one blow.

Which is yet another example of her being a hypocrite. I distinctly remember her talking in one of her old videos about how good critics should offer alternative solutions, instead of just bitching and saying that an idea doesn't work. But we all know how Lily feels about having to practice what she preaches.

And in these specific cases it wouldn't even be hard, the main characters got at least two deus ex machina abilities to depower Starlight with, could asspull some anti-magic restraining bolt for her magic, or just literally throw her into Hell.
And for the Diamonds, they could've gone with having the Cluster kill them. Seeing all those millions of mutilated, half-dead Gems take revenge on the ones who did this to them, would've been a satisfying resolution and easy enough to justify, since the Cluster is stated to be powerful enough to destroy a planet all on it's own.

 

[George Beorge]

You know I literally had no idea who the fuck this was and watched his shitty Steven Universe video because Youtube recommendations kept shoving it down my throat.
I thought it was bizarre and strange that he kept talking about the objectification and sexualization of Stevonnie, pointing to pretty mundane shots as "evidence that the writers were pedos". The entire segment just seemed really hamfisted and it gave me the impression of someone who themselves was a self-loathing pedophile attempting to talk to themselves rather than critique the show.
Low and behold, I find he has a thread here and I read it. To no one's surprise, he's a kiddie diddler.