- Joined
- Mar 5, 2019
In most sane lawsuits, the defendant would almost immediately file anti-SLAPP, before the majority of discovery and definitely before depositions. Sam Johnson getting to grill Vic prior to the TCPA filings was extremely unusual. And yeah, it helped Marchi, since Vic admitted to touching her hair, even if Vic immediately denied the abusive elements of the incident.So here's my issue with it. Including Marchi allowed Marchi's lawyer to question Vic in depo. Ty didn't depo Marchi. He has to run up a bill not just sitting through the time Marchi's lawyer questioned Vic but in filing a response to her TCPA in the hope of her not getting it. If it's granted what good did suing Marchi do? They didn't get any discovery from her whatsoever, they didn't get to crosscheck her answers with Monica's in deposition, it served no purpose but to lose them money, Now, it would be unfortunate if that's what happens, but I don't see how Ty could look at that possible path and say "We need to sue Marchi", knowing they didn't have enough to keep her in the party when TCPA hit presuming her TCPA was at all competent (which was the assumption until Monica and Ron's insanity).
In the end though, I'm sure Ty went into the lawsuit assuming he wouldn't be able to