TCPA Hearing 9/6/19 - Marchi ran from the Law, TI crumbles, conspiracy still on the table, and collective autism from all sides.

[ES 195]

2 is Bingo! http://bbfpics.blogspot.com/?view=classic

View attachment 926277


View attachment 926278

It's interesting but I want to see a version without omissions. The way it is this means nothing.

 

[wickedlilium]

To be fair, you can conduct limited discovery of it's relevant to the TCPA itself.

That could be an admonishment of Chupp to Ty about why Ty didn't subpoena some of the convention owners that dropped Vic.

True, but at the same time Ty indirectly show'd that they never had enough time to do anything besides go through what, like 1.5K-2K pages of doc's.
Personally (based on Chupps handling prior and now) it showed that Chupp wanted a higher standard when you realize that many points of TCPA the defendants filed shouldn't even be there, and that he only stuck 1 filing (Ty's) September 2nd.
Even if Ty realized that Chupp wouldn't be following Statue rule's, he would've only realized that last minute leaving him little to no room to adjust.
The other issue comes from the fact that the defendants where constantly adding, arguing, or trying to prevent Ty from focusing on the TCPA dockets at hand, and Chupp did nothing about it. Not a judge, nor lawyer, but it just seems like the judge didn't even bother presiding over the baby factory and just allowed them to do w/e they wanted.


I am curious if Ty's supplement filings was even allowed, Funi is trying to argue it's not, but is it?
Also is the first set of affidavits even a thing legally anymore?

 

[RogerSmith77]

2 is Bingo! http://bbfpics.blogspot.com/?view=classic

View attachment 926277


View attachment 926278

About what I thought: Chuppy boy is a joke. No, I take that back. This is much worse than I thought. That "maybe, yeah" clinches it for me. This doesn't take away from Ty royally fucking up on the deadline, since that would have contributed a lot more to clinching a reverse and remand on appeal. But it does appear to confirm that this judge is pathetic.

 

[X Prime]

2 is Bingo! http://bbfpics.blogspot.com/?view=classic

If this is even remotely accurate, it is really looking like Beard got railroaded.

 

[murdered meat bag]

The worst thing about this is the KV arrogance running rampant now. And within a month, we could see Vic on the road to a Stalin job. Here’s hoping the Funimation shit isn’t forgotten like most internet drama. But it will.

who buys more anime stuff? kv or iswv? I assume iswv seeing how much spergin is going on.

 

[DuckzillA]

2 is Bingo! http://bbfpics.blogspot.com/?view=classic

View attachment 926277


View attachment 926278

I swear to God I hope ty goes scorched earth on this motherfucker. God damn that pisses me off that this fucking judge isn't even interested in this case and instead of using the law to decide it. Fuck this guy.

 

[Markorian]

2 is Bingo! http://bbfpics.blogspot.com/?view=classic

View attachment 926277


View attachment 926278

Good fucking god, let me revise this
Scenario 2a: Chupp really doesn't want to deal with this case anymore and is making it incredibly easy for Ty to just appeal and stick some other judge with it, Christ almighty

 

[Zero Day Defense]

The way I see it, there are 3 scenarios as to what the fuck happened today
1: Chupp is just a moron, and simply doesn't understand the TCPA and the difference between "clear and specific" and "preponderance"
2: Chupp decided that he was going to throw the case out before today even rolled around, struck everything as soon as it came up, got to defamation and realized it was more solid than he anticipated, and is taking his time to strike it within the 30 days but make it harder to appeal
3: Chupp is striking parts while planning to let defamation go through so that neither side can appeal it until after it all finishes

And this guy was elected, you say?

2 is Bingo! http://bbfpics.blogspot.com/?view=classic

View attachment 926277


View attachment 926278

Why does Chupp sound like got out of bed only to realize that someone broke into his house and replaced his flooring with Lego?

This is some serious "taxation really is theft" kind of stuff... now I'm curious as to what Chupp's reputation was before this lawsuit was assigned to him.

 

[Pham]

What the hell are you talking about? Nick and Ty were both clear about how they couldn't say for certain how Chupp would be, or how the case would go in general. They gave palpable odds for Marchi's TCPA actually succeeding-- much more than ISVW and even much of KF would. Nick just happened to be consistently right about everything important up until now, and even up until now, he was right to worry about Ty's recent mess ups-- which Ty acknowledged.

I don't care how many times he said he wasn't sure of this or that in order to cover his boomer shorts wearing ass because he also constantly said how the opposite side was reading the judge wrong. I've heard him say "If you think Chupp..." this and that so many times that its burned into memory. That's all I'm pointing out. I just think it's funny he read him wrong too despite talking about the others doing it wrong so often.

 

[UnKillFill]

Jesus fucking Christ... They sure went out of their way to find the absolute worst picture of Vic for their shitty hit piece, didn't they?

Spoiler: I'm sure this has been posted by now, I'm not claiming it's news, but it's still bullshit.

In anime’s #MeToo moment, Vic Mignogna a no-show at Tarrant County hearing and his case is mostly an unholy mess

State District Judge John Chupp must come from a family of firefighters because Friday he managed a hearing in his Tarrant County courtroom that...

www.dallasnews.com

Of course they used a sympathetic pic for Rial and Marchi.

Once again we see why journalism is dead.

 

[LawTwitter is Dumb]

So if you can get more then 20 people to sit behind a plaintiff in a lawsuit they become a LPPF, yea that doesn't work in any reality.

Guess you can just march tons of people in to win a hearing.

 

[Random Internet Person]

Yeah, that makes Chupp come off really poorly and prejudiced. He must be so much fun at parties

Can’t you get slapped by some oversight board for that?

 

[A_throwaway_name62919]

2 is Bingo! http://bbfpics.blogspot.com/?view=classic

View attachment 926277

Well that's a rather ridiculous way to determine it. By that reasoning, any politician or corporation which is major within it's niche could defame a private citizen; and when the court had a bunch of people there because it was a politician or a corporation major within it's niche being sued, the private citizen would somehow be a limited purpose public figure because a bunch of people familiar with their defamers showed up.

 

[Immaculate Ape]

Can’t you get slapped by some oversight board for that?

At this point, I'm thinking that he's trying to fast-track this case into appeals simply to get another Judge to take it over.

 

[Sheryl Nome]

Well that's a rather ridiculous way to determine it. By that reasoning, any politician or corporation which is major within it's niche could defame a private citizen; and when the court had a bunch of people there because it was a politician or a corporation major within it's niche being sued, the private citizen would somehow be a limited purpose public figure because a bunch of people familiar with their defamers showed up.

Yes, its the most appeal-able thing he's done, thats obviously crap. Vic hasn't thrust himself into a public controversy, and definitely hadn't done so before the defamation began.

 

[GenericReviewerDraco]

So Chupp couldn't handle the absurd filings of Ty and Fuhrer Lemwah, so he tries to cancel the case out of malice/force appeals.

That makes Ty look less exceptional at least.

 

[RogerSmith77]

I don't care how many times he said he wasn't sure of this or that in order to cover his boomer shorts wearing ass because he also constantly said how the opposite side was reading the judge wrong. I've heard him say "If you think Chupp..." this and that so many times that its burned into memory. That's all I'm pointing out. I just think it's funny he read him wrong too despite talking about the others doing it wrong so often.

In Nick's recent streams leading up to this, it felt like he was trying to distance himself from his past opinions about how royally fucked the defendants were (i.e. comments like "even if Vic loses the TCPA, we were still able to get these leaks out and bring the truth about Funimation to light.") He probably saw the writing on the wall the minute Ty fucked up on the deadline.

 

[ItalianMobStripper]

I'll peace out for today Kiwis, got stuff to do.

Stay fresh, and book some consluts. I'll expect this thread to be flooded by tomorrow morning.

Peace

 

[Sheryl Nome]

In Nick's recent streams leading up to this, it felt like he was trying to distance himself from his past opinions about how royally fucked the defendants were (i.e. comments like "even if Vic loses the TCPA, we were still able to get these leaks out and bring the truth about Funimation to light.") He probably saw the writing on the wall the minute Ty fucked up on the deadline.

I think he was just managing expectations ahead of judgement day, Nick has always said this lawsuit is not a sure thing

 

[murdered meat bag]

I swear to God I hope ty goes scorched earth on this motherfucker. God damn that pisses me off that this fucking judge isn't even interested in this case and instead of using the law to decide it. Fuck this guy.

have to wait for the transcript but oh man, ty saying "we’ve met the prima facie minimum," and Chupp saying no is pretty embarrassing.