Victor Mignogna v. Funimation Productions, LLC, et al. (2019) - Vic's lawsuit against Funimation, VAs, and others, for over a million dollars.

[Carcinogenesis]

This is the exact reason why you don't parade a lawsuit around as some sort of pay-per-view event, the defendant(s) will just claim you're suing them for personal gain. Ty Beard shouldn't have been a part of Nick's livestreams, it was irresponsible and could very well jeopardize this case.

 

[Punished Brent]

We can conjecture all day but really the person that decides if something is a valid argument or not is the judge. A person with their own views and beliefs that has shown to take the “guilty until proven innocent” approach with this because #believeallwomen

 

[I can't imagine]

We can conjecture all day but really the person that decides if something is a valid argument or not is the judge. A person with their own views and beliefs that has shown to take the “guilty until proven innocent” approach with this because #believeallwomen

In fairness, this will be the appellate court that would be deciding on it, and that would require the plaintiff's counsel to actually use the argument (which they probably won't). This is all fun speculation, but there's probably more effective strategies that Vic's lawyers will be using.

 

[Sheryl Nome]

Yeah, its a speculative argument and a pretty ballsy one, I wouldn't do it in Vic's case because... There's better arguments, like the fact that there was absolutely a prima facie case for TI

 

[A.Shitposter]

These death threat notes are so laughably fake.

 

[FGO-Professor-P2PBTW]

The only way that TI gets dismissed is if the second amended petition gets dropped, and the only way that happens is because of technicalities. How common is it for things to be dropped because of mere technicalities, considering how rigid yet flexible the law seems to be?

 

[Felonious Monk]

Co

Now we know where Firecrotch gets her funding from. No need for money from Vic.

The collateral source doctrine bars evidence that a party has already been compensated through another source, so this isn't an argument Vic can make.

 

[Sheryl Nome]

The only way that TI gets dismissed is if the second amended petition gets dropped, and the only way that happens is because of technicalities. How common is it for things to be dropped because of mere technicalities, considering how rigid yet flexible the law seems to be?

i don't even think you need the 2ap to get TI past TCPA

 

[secondclass]

i don't even think you need the 2ap to get TI past TCPA

What was the underlying tort that Toye/Rial committed?

 

[Felonious Monk]

The only way that TI gets dismissed is if the second amended petition gets dropped, and the only way that happens is because of technicalities. How common is it for things to be dropped because of mere technicalities, considering how rigid yet flexible the law seems to be?

Extremely, extremely common. This is why lawyers are such sticklers for rules of civil procedure and evidence.

Also, the Court of Appeals will consider the TCPA de novo, they won't consider the decision to exclude the 2AP de novo. They will review for abuse of discretion, which is a substantially more deferential standard.

 

[Imperial Agent]

TIME'S UP Legal Defense Fund on Twitter

“The TIME’S UP Legal Defense Fund is proud to support Jamie Marchi and Dina Lee Almeida in their fight for justice.”

twitter.com

TIME'S UP Legal Defense Fund on Twitter

““In most instances, money is a big barrier to suing… many people such as paramedics, housekeepers and waitresses simply don't make enough for a lawyer to take their case,” said @TIMESUPLDF director @SharynTejani to @NPR https://t.co/BdaSDcYIaQ”

web.archive.org

So... doesn’t this make any complaints about Vic being funded by outside sources moot?

 

[Sheryl Nome]

What was the underlying tort that Toye/Rial committed?

TI w/ contract in texas doesn't require an underlying tort.

Extremely, extremely common. This is why lawyers are such sticklers for rules of civil procedure and evidence.

Also, the Court of Appeals will consider the TCPA de novo, they won't consider the decision to exclude the 2AP de novo. They will review for abuse of discretion, which is a substantially more deferential standard.

The good news here is that there's a lot of lack of clarity around the TCPA and in the past texas courts have been unwilling to apply rule 63 to Motions to Dismiss, meaning there's much more latitude to argue

 

[theworstkindofeurofag]

Well, in the end, we can say we saved Vic from killing himself over the false allegations ruining his life. He's probably going to kill himself now over the sanctions and fees ruining his life.

No, I'm not serious, just cynical.

 

[mindlessobserver]

Lemwah got you bro! He got you! The proof is the fact that your opinion is similar to Nick! 100% truth. He linked to your main-post. It's done, you lost the case Nick!!
View attachment 999737

Senpai noticed me, and he says I offer legal analysis. I am touched

 

[I can't imagine]

Well, in the end, we can say we saved Vic from killing himself over the false allegations ruining his life. He's probably going to kill himself now over the sanctions and fees ruining his life.

No, I'm not serious, just cynical.

I mean, I'd certainly hope that someone at BHBH explained to him that this could potentially bankrupt him. It's something you really should know before this sort of thing.

 

[TexOffender]

Senpai noticed me, and he says I offer legal analysis. I am touched

Did you give consent to be touched?

 

[In Heaven]

Did you give consent to be touched?

No one wants Lemoine touching them.

 

[mindlessobserver]

Did you give consent to be touched?

No but it's not rape if I like it.

 

[JohnDoe]

I'm annoyed that the furfaggotry of my AV was not immortalized in a legal document.

 

[mindlessobserver]

What's funny to me is he is claiming the weeb wars OP is "legal analysis", but it's not. I think out of that huge wall of text there are maybe a few sentences where I give my (non lawyer) opinion on what it could be. I use links to Nick's videos for the actual legal analysis. Funny that he thinks me and Nick are the same person though. I will take that as a compliment and wish him luck in spending Moronicas money to prove otherwise. I know I have said it elsewhere but bears repeating that I just find legal cases fun and read them as a hobby. It's actually what brought me to the farms in the first place.