Pulling the Enperor out of a hat just from a narrative standpoint is an issue since they were planning a sequential trilogy. Which means each movie is the beginning, the middle and the end.
Compare to the original trilogy. The bad guy Darth Vader is introduced and he kills a whole bunch of people. We later learn he is part of something called "the Empire". Since he was subordinate to Tarkin in the film its shown Vader is not ultimately in charge. The heroes spend most of the movie running from Vader, including the final sequence where he is shooting down fighters left and right.
In the second movie Vader has overall field command, but now we are introduced to the true big bad. The Emperor. Luke ends the movie getting his shit wrecked by Vader. Then in the third movie the Emperor shows up in the flesh at last and we have the final throne room showdown.
At no point in the original trilogy is the Empire played for laughs. They were an ominous, competent force that the Rebels manage to beat by the skin of their teeth in the first movie and wrecks their shit in the second. Which makes the battle of Endor a satisfying payoff. You dont see The Emperor losing his temper and yelling, you dont see Vader getting thrown around a bridge.
Compare that to Disney star wars. They introduce their big bad right off the bat, have the lead charachter effortlessly defeat him, while in the process the first order is shown as bumbling incompetent morons with the emotional range of 4 year old boys. All in the first movie. Then in the second movie they...do the same thing, only this time kill the final boss like a bitch and then fight a pointless ground battle.
So now their narrative is completely borked. They need to build to the climax but they've already blown their load. Twice! Worse we STILL dont know what the first order is, how they "reign" or why we should root for the heroes to beat then. Telling people to "read the books" is pointless. If your movie is only explainable if people have a written compendium then it's a bad story. Tolkien had an entire bible's worth of back story and lore for Lord of the Rings but you dont need to read any of it to be able to understand and get invested in that story. Both the books and the films.
What they have is Kylo Ren, who Rey has bested TWICE now, his scooby doo gang called the first order, and a ridiculously over powered protagonist who "came from nothing". What do you do with that? You cant just use deus ex machina and wave it all away and say "it was the emperor all along!" In the original trilogy there was a progression towards the face off with Palpatine. Where is the progression here? There is none.
Main issue is that there are no stakes, so to speak. There are things "at stake" (ie: peace of the galaxy, the good guys prevailing and defeating the baddies), but since the ST has channeled Sonichu's writing to a point of absurdity, Rey always has the correct power (to a ridiculous degree) that she needs to handily solve any pickle she finds herself in.
The power and capabilities of every character and organization shift massively with whatever the plot demands at the moment, so you never have a feeling that anything is really "at stake", the suspension of disbelief is utterly broken. You know Rey will win and you don't even humor the thought that she could just be slightly inconvenienced. When Snoke bonked her on the head with Anakin's lightsabre, that was literally the worst thing that has happened to her throughout the entire fucking ST this far.
So of course we don't feel any kind of tension. When someone loses, we know this only serves the plot. When someone has to overcome something, we know they will. If someone is caught in an escapeless situation, we know something will save them.
We know that for most protagonists of most shows and movies, but we still experience tension. In nuWars, the movies just lamely go through the motions and it mystifies me, why so many people don't see through this.
Oh no. Rey has been caught. Oh well, she escaped thanks to her newly found powers of [whatever the fuck it was that she needed to escape].
Top notch writing.
I mean....nobody thought disney would be that fucking stupid to just have him be some random irrelevent fucking nobody who had zero importance to anyone despite wiping out the jedi and corrupting the skywalkers again
Best part (or worst part, depending on your perspective) is that Ruin put
a lot of effort into insulting fans for actually being invested in any of this shit.
It's not often we see a producer mock people for caring about their franchise. Then again, that behaviour has been on the rise...
This is Jack Scalfani tier of laziness and incompetence
Dude. If you gave me a choice of either eating something made by Jack Scalfani or that GE kid's menu garbage, I would honestly have trouble picking, that's how bad it is.
I'm not gonna lie and say "It looks so shitty, I would even choose Jack Scalfani's stuff over it!", but I have to say, it would not be an easy decision and that scares me.