- Joined
- Sep 18, 2019
Just gonna throw my hat into the ring.
Worse than TLJ from a technical standpoint and equally bad (if not worse) because of the whole Palpatine business. There, I said it.
- Klaud has no introduction, does nothing, and has maybe one whole line? Clearly a victim of reshoots, and I'm almost narcistic enough to bet our memeing of him contributed to him being all but slashed from the movie
- Daisy Ridley is still a plank of wood - four years since TFA and she still can't act
- Neither can Boyega, actually - I don't understand the praise he gets. Even when he isn't wooping like the Falcon just pulled into the KFC drive-thru, he brings nothing to the table.
- Maz Kanata aka Yellow Yoda awkwardly shows up because her actress probably still had a contract - she does nothing of importance
- Neither does Leia - her inclusion is brutal in how awkward it is. There's a clear reason why it went unused for TFA, and it's on full display here.
- Some actor JJ worked with on Lost keeps showing up - as does Snap 'Fart Wedding' Wexley, who also previously worked with JJ
- The movie really moves at a breakneck speed, as noted before, but this is not TLJ's fault - it is squarely on JJ and Chris Terrio. They could have cut so much pointless garbage to give things like Based Sheev returning a sliver of a chance of not going completely unexplained
- Passaana is pointless and full of ugly nu-aliens
- The quicksand and gay ass sand worm (did KK come up with this thing? I bet she did) are too contrived and convenient to be taken seriously.
- The Knights of Ren land on Passaana and feature in a number of shots that made me think I was looking at a 90's boy band music video. Seriously.
- Chewie gets a fake-out death to give us one single hint that Rey maybe has some Sith in her (force lightning).
- The MacGuffin is found and promptly lost to the First Order
- Rey, Finn, and Pie pretend to bond throughout the movie, but it all falls flat. At the end of its runtime, even the movie itself drops the pretense; the trio have a hug, then Poe and Finn are nowhere to be seen and Rey hogs the spotlight on Tatooine. Remember how the OT ended with the gang together? Yeah, none of that shit - so a fat load of good all this 'banter' did us.
- Kijimi is utterly pointless and could have been bypassed completely
- It also got blown up completely by a Death Star Destroyer. Did we really need another planet blown to bits? Fake-out deaths for Sorry Bitch (or whatever she's called) and the infantile Babu Frik
- Sorry Bitch is pointless
- DIO, the new robot, is pointless
- Chewbacca ain't dead and thus has to be rescued - again wasting more runtime.
- Hux is the mole and gets killed by General Pryde. No one cares.
- Dagger, which remains horribly toyetic in its looks, is retrieved.
- Rey uses some exceptional logic to match the dagger to the Death Star ruins - it would appear that the Death Star did not crumble at all over the course of 30+ years in a stormy ocean
- Jannah, who could fit a thermal detonator between her front teeth, shows up with a background that is conveniently similar to Finn's
- Rey finds the Goddamn stupid Wayfinder MacGuffin that the Dagger MacGuffin pointed towards and Kylo Ren promptly destroys it
- So the whole movie up to this point was pointless.
- Rey fights Kylo Ren, Leia kills herself to distract Ren, Rey then skewers the guy and heals him, flies off in his TIE to exile herself on Luke's Island
- On the island, Rey tosses away her saber, only for Force Ghost Luke to catch it (he quips about it deserving more respect, Rian confirmed seething). Rey wants to give up but Luke reminds her that there's a Wayfinder in Kylo's TIE
- Rey takes Leia's lightsaber, conveniently hidden away by Luke, and his X-Wing and iconic helmet, and flies off to meet Palps
- Poe and Finn return to base, find out Leia died, Chewie has a heartfelt cry and makes you feel bad for all the shit he's been put through by Disney
- Rey sends them the location of Exogol, Poe is now General following Leia's death and promotes Finn to General in what I find to be a very un-self-aware reflection of how most people at Disney and Bad Robot seem to have gotten their undeserved jobs.
- The Rebels/Resistance/Diversity Squadron set off for Exogol with an exceptional plan; all those super sekrit Star Destroyers Palps built? They can't leave Exogol without a signal from a navigation station, so they vow to blow it up.
HUGE FUCKING PLOTHOLE
- Diversity Squadron attacks the navigation terminal, bringing along Jannah and her slightly less horse-like mounts for an exceptional ground assault
- Pryde sees through this, and rerouts the terminal's signal to his own Star Destroyer
- Diversity Squadron and the horses call off their assault before landing and instead attack the Star Destroyer
- The horses are unloaded on the Star Destroyer, because they are seemingly the only way to deactivate the signal.... somehow.
- Pryde and the Tard Order promptly forget that they can reroute the signal - so instead of routing it back to the navigation terminal, or a different Star Destroyer - which would leave the horse cavalry with nothing to attack - the Sith Troopers get to attack
- In order for this stupid, contrived ground assault to work, the First Order forgets to use a tactic they just used 30 seconds ago
At this point I was done with the movie. Completely done. My evening wasted.
- Rey meets up with Palps, who wants her to kill him because reasons. Not clear why - possibly for him to then take control of her body? Why does Palps expect her to go along with this?
- Kylo arrives in a regular ol' TIE, parking it next to Rey/Luke's X-Wing. The camera dwells on this shot for a bit too long to not be on purpose - 'member these two ships always fought in those movies you liked?
- The Knights of Ren, fresh off their 30 minute career as a boyband, show up to stop Kylo - they immediately job to him.
- Kylo gets to Rey, and Sheev saps the life force straight out of them - so why was having Rey strike him down necessary previously?
- Rey watches Diversity Squadron get shot out of the sky ('member Luke seeing his friends die on the 2nd Death Star? JJ 'members) and Kylo gets yeeted off a cliff
- Suddenly she hears all the old Jedi call out to her, gets up, and kills Palps - then she dies. Finally a happy end for us all.
- Except Kylo gets back up, heals her, kisses her, and dies instead. I liked it better when both were presumed dead.
- Back on the Star Destroyer, Finn and Jannah succeed in blowing up the navigation terminal - this kills the Wyte Pryde
- Lando saves their asses
- Rey escapes from Sheev's chambers, and joins Poe and Finn and the gang at the obligatory jungle planet party ('MEMBER RETURN OF THE JEDI?)
- Short montage of Star Destroyers falling out of the sky over Endor, Cloud City, and Jakku (DO YOU 'MEMBER?!)
- Lesbian kiss is thankfully not done by Billie Lourd (Carrie FIsher's IRL daughter), but by the middle-aged lady with the huge hooknose from TLJ and a diversity hire
- Poe makes a pass at Sorry Bitch, gets rejected
- Maz Kanata aka Yellow Yoda gives Chewbacca a medal ('MEMBER CHEWIE NOT GETTING ONE?) - no one else gets one though.
- Lando and Jannah share a moment and seemingly set out to uncover the latter's past - very on-the-nose in terms of leaving open the possibility of a Disney+ series.
- Rey, Poe, and Finn share a hug, Rey fucks off to Tatooine to piss on the Skywalkers one last time, and this shitshow finally ends.
FINAL VERDICT
+ Lando is cool, Billy Dee Williams is based
+ The movie ends
- Everything else
Rating; massive terminal brain cancer/10
Worse than TLJ from a technical standpoint and equally bad (if not worse) because of the whole Palpatine business. There, I said it.
- Klaud has no introduction, does nothing, and has maybe one whole line? Clearly a victim of reshoots, and I'm almost narcistic enough to bet our memeing of him contributed to him being all but slashed from the movie
- Daisy Ridley is still a plank of wood - four years since TFA and she still can't act
- Neither can Boyega, actually - I don't understand the praise he gets. Even when he isn't wooping like the Falcon just pulled into the KFC drive-thru, he brings nothing to the table.
- Maz Kanata aka Yellow Yoda awkwardly shows up because her actress probably still had a contract - she does nothing of importance
- Neither does Leia - her inclusion is brutal in how awkward it is. There's a clear reason why it went unused for TFA, and it's on full display here.
- Some actor JJ worked with on Lost keeps showing up - as does Snap 'Fart Wedding' Wexley, who also previously worked with JJ
- The movie really moves at a breakneck speed, as noted before, but this is not TLJ's fault - it is squarely on JJ and Chris Terrio. They could have cut so much pointless garbage to give things like Based Sheev returning a sliver of a chance of not going completely unexplained
- Passaana is pointless and full of ugly nu-aliens
- The quicksand and gay ass sand worm (did KK come up with this thing? I bet she did) are too contrived and convenient to be taken seriously.
- The Knights of Ren land on Passaana and feature in a number of shots that made me think I was looking at a 90's boy band music video. Seriously.
- Chewie gets a fake-out death to give us one single hint that Rey maybe has some Sith in her (force lightning).
- The MacGuffin is found and promptly lost to the First Order
- Rey, Finn, and Pie pretend to bond throughout the movie, but it all falls flat. At the end of its runtime, even the movie itself drops the pretense; the trio have a hug, then Poe and Finn are nowhere to be seen and Rey hogs the spotlight on Tatooine. Remember how the OT ended with the gang together? Yeah, none of that shit - so a fat load of good all this 'banter' did us.
- Kijimi is utterly pointless and could have been bypassed completely
- It also got blown up completely by a Death Star Destroyer. Did we really need another planet blown to bits? Fake-out deaths for Sorry Bitch (or whatever she's called) and the infantile Babu Frik
- Sorry Bitch is pointless
- DIO, the new robot, is pointless
- Chewbacca ain't dead and thus has to be rescued - again wasting more runtime.
- Hux is the mole and gets killed by General Pryde. No one cares.
- Dagger, which remains horribly toyetic in its looks, is retrieved.
- Rey uses some exceptional logic to match the dagger to the Death Star ruins - it would appear that the Death Star did not crumble at all over the course of 30+ years in a stormy ocean
- Jannah, who could fit a thermal detonator between her front teeth, shows up with a background that is conveniently similar to Finn's
- Rey finds the Goddamn stupid Wayfinder MacGuffin that the Dagger MacGuffin pointed towards and Kylo Ren promptly destroys it
- So the whole movie up to this point was pointless.
- Rey fights Kylo Ren, Leia kills herself to distract Ren, Rey then skewers the guy and heals him, flies off in his TIE to exile herself on Luke's Island
- On the island, Rey tosses away her saber, only for Force Ghost Luke to catch it (he quips about it deserving more respect, Rian confirmed seething). Rey wants to give up but Luke reminds her that there's a Wayfinder in Kylo's TIE
- Rey takes Leia's lightsaber, conveniently hidden away by Luke, and his X-Wing and iconic helmet, and flies off to meet Palps
- Poe and Finn return to base, find out Leia died, Chewie has a heartfelt cry and makes you feel bad for all the shit he's been put through by Disney
- Rey sends them the location of Exogol, Poe is now General following Leia's death and promotes Finn to General in what I find to be a very un-self-aware reflection of how most people at Disney and Bad Robot seem to have gotten their undeserved jobs.
- The Rebels/Resistance/Diversity Squadron set off for Exogol with an exceptional plan; all those super sekrit Star Destroyers Palps built? They can't leave Exogol without a signal from a navigation station, so they vow to blow it up.
HUGE FUCKING PLOTHOLE
- Diversity Squadron attacks the navigation terminal, bringing along Jannah and her slightly less horse-like mounts for an exceptional ground assault
- Pryde sees through this, and rerouts the terminal's signal to his own Star Destroyer
- Diversity Squadron and the horses call off their assault before landing and instead attack the Star Destroyer
- The horses are unloaded on the Star Destroyer, because they are seemingly the only way to deactivate the signal.... somehow.
- Pryde and the Tard Order promptly forget that they can reroute the signal - so instead of routing it back to the navigation terminal, or a different Star Destroyer - which would leave the horse cavalry with nothing to attack - the Sith Troopers get to attack
- In order for this stupid, contrived ground assault to work, the First Order forgets to use a tactic they just used 30 seconds ago
At this point I was done with the movie. Completely done. My evening wasted.
- Rey meets up with Palps, who wants her to kill him because reasons. Not clear why - possibly for him to then take control of her body? Why does Palps expect her to go along with this?
- Kylo arrives in a regular ol' TIE, parking it next to Rey/Luke's X-Wing. The camera dwells on this shot for a bit too long to not be on purpose - 'member these two ships always fought in those movies you liked?
- The Knights of Ren, fresh off their 30 minute career as a boyband, show up to stop Kylo - they immediately job to him.
- Kylo gets to Rey, and Sheev saps the life force straight out of them - so why was having Rey strike him down necessary previously?
- Rey watches Diversity Squadron get shot out of the sky ('member Luke seeing his friends die on the 2nd Death Star? JJ 'members) and Kylo gets yeeted off a cliff
- Suddenly she hears all the old Jedi call out to her, gets up, and kills Palps - then she dies. Finally a happy end for us all.
- Except Kylo gets back up, heals her, kisses her, and dies instead. I liked it better when both were presumed dead.
- Back on the Star Destroyer, Finn and Jannah succeed in blowing up the navigation terminal - this kills the Wyte Pryde
- Lando saves their asses
- Rey escapes from Sheev's chambers, and joins Poe and Finn and the gang at the obligatory jungle planet party ('MEMBER RETURN OF THE JEDI?)
- Short montage of Star Destroyers falling out of the sky over Endor, Cloud City, and Jakku (DO YOU 'MEMBER?!)
- Lesbian kiss is thankfully not done by Billie Lourd (Carrie FIsher's IRL daughter), but by the middle-aged lady with the huge hooknose from TLJ and a diversity hire
- Poe makes a pass at Sorry Bitch, gets rejected
- Maz Kanata aka Yellow Yoda gives Chewbacca a medal ('MEMBER CHEWIE NOT GETTING ONE?) - no one else gets one though.
- Lando and Jannah share a moment and seemingly set out to uncover the latter's past - very on-the-nose in terms of leaving open the possibility of a Disney+ series.
- Rey, Poe, and Finn share a hug, Rey fucks off to Tatooine to piss on the Skywalkers one last time, and this shitshow finally ends.
FINAL VERDICT
+ Lando is cool, Billy Dee Williams is based
+ The movie ends
- Everything else
Rating; massive terminal brain cancer/10