Well lets mosey through this list...
Night of the Living Dead (196
- One of my all time favourite movies, and is in a very select club of films that genuinely creeped me out as a kid that still manage to bring back warm memories of fear even now. Out of the original Dead Trilogy, this one is the finest "Horror" movie with the black and white cinematography and orchestral horror soundtrack perfectly complimenting the story and character work.
Dawn of the Dead/Zombi (197
- The one. The only. The ultimate zombie film of not just the trilogy, but the genre as a whole. There is little I can really say about this movie that has not been said a thousand times before by others. Between the masterful use of zombies as an ever growing threat despite how individually weak they are, and the timeless portrayal of society ripping itself apart in fear, coupled with the eventual setting of one giant mall playground for the protagonists, this shit is aped by everyone for very good reason.
Day of the Dead (1985) - Honestly, its probably my favourite of the three original Dead Trilogy movies, even if I recognise the other two as technically superior. The atmosphere is so deliciously grim and joyless, and out of all the original trilogy movies it is IMO the most genuinely post-apocalyptic feeling, as the initial fear of Night and the madness and absurdity of Dawn has passed, leaving only bleak realisation that its basically game over for humanity
Return of the Living Dead (1985) - A horror comedy take on the zombie genre, that unlike its successors is far more tilted towards horror than comedy and it works beautifully, and manages to escape the Romero paradigm with its invincible brain obsessed and fully intelligent zombies which would go on to spawn its own wave of imitators in the two decades to come, and would indeed become largely seen by normies as the basic standard for zombies until Romero style zombies once again became the norm in the late 00s
Return of the Living Dead Part II (198
- Not worth watching. Duller, tamer, and with more emphasis on goofy comedy, its just an uninteresting and defanged rehash of what came before
Return of the Living Dead 3 (1993) - Erm....yeah. Technically the second best Return of the Living Dead movie because of how shit the other entries other than the first were, and not exactly terrible in its own right but boy howdy was someone whackin off behind the camera at every moment of this literal fetish film. Still it had good gore, a somewhat unique spin on the franchise, and even something resembling a heart. A skeevy, S&M fetishist heart sure, but a heart nonetheless.
Zombi 2/Zombie Flesh Eaters (1979) - Hooboy some good shit. I have sperged at length before about how this is one of my all time favourite non-romero zombie movies, and to cut my textwall down to size, I will simply say that aside from fantastical sound design with the memorable tropical flavoured score and the nasty ass sounds of tearing flesh, the beautiful jungle setting which goes from paradise to hell over the course of the movie, the fantastic gore effects which have earned this movie a spot in splatter history for moments like the eye scene, and shit like a literal "zombie vs shark" scene, this movie has in my opinion the absolute finest zombies ever put to screen, both with the sickening makeup and the sinister as fuck sleepwalking portrayal. These things looked like they had just been dug out the ground and they looked like they wanted to rip you apart. The only tradeoff is that the characters are dull and it takes a longass time to get going, but once it does then shit gets great fast
Hell of the Living Dead (1980) - Eh....if you like bruno mattai films you will probably enjoy this. If not, then you will find it yet another generic and barely watchable collection of scenes and ideas and visuals and music ripped off from better films...sometimes literally in the case of this movies soundtrack being directly lifted from Dawn of the Dead.
Night of the Living Dead (1990 Remake) - Visually I love it, and it is easily the best of the Romero Remakes. In terms of acting....yeah sadly everyone seems to be overacting the shit out of their parts to the point where they lose all relatability and become parodies of their original characters, with the partial exception of Tony Todd who aside from a few overblown moments was the only one who halfway understood the idea of subtlety. All in all its a perfectly serviceable remake that doesn't particularly annoy me and I would happily watch again.
Dawn of the Dead (2004 Remake) - While I have been really harsh on this in the past, I will grant this movie a limited degree of respect for having some of the absolute finest "worldbuilding" in its portrayal of the initial stages of the zombie outbreak which even to this day have only been rarely matched. After this initial stage is over though, everything gets real generic and forgettable real fast with masses of barely fleshed out characters doing contrived shit to push the plot along, though the zombie baby scene manages to be atleast somewhat interesting for the time.
Day of the Dead (2008 Remake) - Yeah....this is absolute fucking roadtrash. Its literally a shitty asylum level movie with the most generic "zombie outbreak" plot imaginable and the names of characters in the original slapped on people with absolutely zero similarity or link. The zombies
Land of the Dead (2005) - First of the "ok who gave grandpa romero a camera?" trilogy. On paper the concept is great, and is what he originally wanted to do for Day of the Dead. In practice though, the mix of overacting, heavy handed and entirely unsubtle political metaphor that completely burns through any suspension of disbelief, stupid CGI, and the inexplicable decision to have the majority of the action/gore scenes shot in the dark make this a complete disappointment and a sad waste of potential.
Diary of the Dead (200
- A shallow as hell and obnoxiously filmed attempt to do "found footage" horror which falls flat on its face within the first few minutes, and Romero seems to have been actively trying to be even less subtle than his previous entry.
Survival of the Dead (2010) - Havent actually seen it yet. Never saw the need, though I might watch it eventually should curiosity take me
Day of the Dead 2: Contagium (2005) - Asylum tier trash thats even worse than the remake. Skip
Return of the Living Dead: Necropolis (2005) - IIRC this movie and the sequel completely neuter the zombies into generic romero style zombies, and they filmed a bunch of it in chernobyl to try and get attention. I definitely watched it but it was so fucking worthless I dont remember anything about it
Return of the Living Dead: Rave to the Grave (2005) - Same as above but with added dumb teen comedy elements.